New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Dovetails - a little confused

Posts

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#26

Re: Where to start?

TomD

"people starting wood based businesses without know what tools are? Doctors practicing with no practice? None of that is real, and none of it is relevant."

You may not have gotten out enough. I had a friend who started a business and immediately sold a pile of furniture and he did not know anything, really about building furniture. It all unfolded as a disaster. That kind of thing is more common than not. Mikke Holmes up here had a popular crusading show against the contractor side of that, but it is just as common in carpentry and cabinet work.

I gave a seminar attended by some very nice employees of a cabinetmaking company, they were having trouble getting tight joints with the Leigh jig. One might wonder how that is even possible... The same seminar was attended by a lady who had her own TV show up here. I don't see a complete lack of skills as much of a barrier to entry.

"Dovetails are stronger joints, or more durable in use if you prefer - I don't get why you would think increasing the dimensions is here or there. It's as if I were saying that steel is stronger than aluminum and you come back with "not if you make the aluminum thicker". That is precisely my point.... the stronger joint allows you to do more with less, that is why it is an advantage when needed."

Well you are now qualifying stronger, you didn't initially, I think. Much of the dovetail work I see in modern stuff, including stuff I make, I will confess, is strong enough to be assembled with nails. The first dovetails I made back in the 70s were in a cabinet my dad and I were building for our kitchen. I dovetailed together the carcass, using red oak, 3/4s, with dovetailed corners. It replaced 3/4 pine nailed together that was partly a face frame design, overall using a lot less wood. It never showed the slightest strain, and would probably still be there where it not for our renovation. Indeed, Frank Loyd Wright configured the walls in some of his hoses to be built out of 3/4 wood, that was it, no studs or posts, in those walls. Of course they were nailed but that isn't really comparable since in housing nails are mostly in shear, which is harder to arrange with boxes. My point is that cabinets we build today are often as strong as houses, and on top of that we wag our fingers an say we do it because they need to be stronger.

Are dovetails really stronger than metal hardware; is solid wood really more effective than plywood. A typical panel choice in the bottom of a drawer would be 1/4 inch something or other. I am currently making a skiff that is largely 1/4 inch ply that will hold my considerable bulk, a motor, all fmy gear, and even another person, though the design was not friendly to that use. Are cabinetmaker really more concerned with strength, is that really the controlling idea. I don't buy it. There are a number of reasons why we promote, or like dovetails strength is really never near the top. There is virtually no strength testing that is done in any serious way.

"I am not saying who should use them when in a finished product. I'm just saying that if one wishes to practice and get good at them, that person should use them whenever they can and not sweat the finer points of how they look."

I do agree that hand skills should be used as often as possible. I think it is pretty much a fact that learning occurs better in situations where practice is separate from execution. Unless the lesson is all about how to handle the pressure of executing in some real world environment. Pros can often draw on their deep skills to do a job correctly the first time, and this can be a type of fun. I don't always eat my own cooking, I like the struggle of pushing myself, but if it turns out to be something very difficult, I break it down and practice individual pieces.

As far as whether one should sweat making them look good, what does that mean? Should you punish yourself if they don't turn out. Sounds like a bad idea. Sweat in this context is a judgement term. It implies there is something inherently unpleasant or futile about the process. But if by "sweat" one means pay attention to details that might make the joints better, I think that is a very good idea. One may get better if one just keeps repeating the same mistakes until they magically disappear, but sometimes paying attention to details pays off. There are people into details, promoting the idea that they should hold off on what they enjoy until making enough mistakes coalesces in perfection, is probably not going to make them happy. Isn't there an assumption that people will be put off by sweating the details, that they would prefer to wait till some client time can be burned up leaning how to do something. There are folks who can't wait to get better.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#27

Ridiculous....

John in NM

Sure, anyone can start a business they know nothing about and fail miserably fairly quickly, which is more or less what all your examples are about. I don't see the relevance of such failures to the discussion at hand, people can fail in school as well, or in an apprenticeship, it has nothing to do with the practice of a craft.

Qualifying stronger? Are you for real? That is what you did pal, by specifying that other joints were stronger if one simply increases dimensions. Of course they are.

Sweat making them look good just means that when doing a practice project, like a toolbox that will be painted and knocked around, make the joint as well as possible without doing anything over.

You're really over thinking this, it is a simple subject.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#28

Your suggestion worked for me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have dovetailed some bizarre structures to get practice. Perhaps the most unusual is an "elevation extender" to raise the height of the Victorio tomato juicer so a large catching pot will sit under it. The extender gets C-clamped to the work surface and the juicer to it. BTW, this juicer will turn a half bushel of Italian juice tomatoes into pulp and rejected seeds and skin in minutes. Ebay is your friend when searching for one, or a farm store for a new one.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#29

Re: Unqualified

Rum

No skin in the dovetails vs no dovetails issue, I like them in some places not in others and it seems that most folks feel the same way :b There is something to be said about a mechanically sound joint that doesn't need anything else to hold it together from several perspectives that I think calls to some of us.

Incompetence or at least ignorance is not necessarily synonymous with failure either though (witness my survival thus far :D).

A rather distressing example was a co-worker had bought a VERY expensive "gaming table" and matching set of chairs. Despite there being a rather long and tiresome diatribe about "heirloom quality" (hair loom? maybe?) there were serious design and implementation flaws in some part of the package. Some of which I would rather have burned than shown anyone (except maybe as a how-not-to-do-this).

In particular the conspicuously machine cut dovetails on the (many) drawers were poorly setup and had a solid 1/8" gap around the pins gummed full of kind-of-matched wood putty (maybe these were the same folks who couldn't figure out the leigh jig?). Given that there were a good solid dozen identical drawers in this one table I found it rather unforgivable that they couldn't have taken the time to properly set it up ahead of time.

The chairs were suffering a rather high failure rate as well (2 of ?8 or 10?). The fit & finish was pretty good but they were backed chairs with inadequate bracing/no stringers so everytime anyone leaned back in them the, now rather heavily leveraged, seat would pull free of the back legs.

This same company has orders stacked up for months and has gotten at least one fairly lucrative funding round (they were on one of the populist "shark blah blah" type shows).

Also Bill, +1 on the tomato pulper doodad - those do indeed rock!