Re: I see a difference in our approaches...
TomD
"Granted none of my paying work involves dovetails, and I'm always way behind on it too - but the difference is I don't do anything for practice alone."
This is kinda the American way, you can open a cabinet shop without ever having seen a tool. Traditionally, it was 7 years to get the right to run a shop. The US way is probably why we see stuff like Sam Maloof he was creative, and invented his own way. One can't overstate the value of that, but it will involve a lot of bumping into the furniture trying to find one's way. But I assume we would both prefer the guys doing open heart surgery to have done a dry run at some point. If one doesn't practice then the client is funding the "GI bill" without the maker ever having risked life and limb for his country. I guess a free education is everyone's right today.
"Everything, dovetailed or nailed together, has to have a purpose if I'm going to bother making it. I might dovetail something that does not need it in order to practice but whatever it is will still be a useful item. Anything else is, to me at least, a waste of limited time and materials."
I certainly respect that point of view. But I doubt it is really true for the majority of people. Very few people are purely functional. At the end of a long day of welding pipe, guys are prone to take the check down to the local strip club to watch the dancers. It isn't because they are purely functional in outlook, they are going to have to pay to look, and probably not touch, much. Normally the function argument is just a ploy to divert an unappreciated argument back to an economic argument that has broad appeal. But generally, the bucks in small unit numbers are in selling the sizzle to the rich.
"For a saw till, you are quite right that a nailed butt joint would probably be sufficient. For a box or drawer, the dovetailed one will last longer. That craftsmen in the past didn't bother to dovetail tool boxes just tells me about their priorities, not the intrinsic strength of the various joint options."
Dovetails are stronger for the section or weight, etc... Not in absolute terms, you can always take a piece of wood of a larger dimension, and the nails, biscuits, dowels or screws will hold up just fine. Or use extension slides where the loads are much lower. And since fine furniture these days is just a way point on a route to the dump when tastes change. Unless people appreciate higher values in a piece. and that takes effort. Dovetails are rarely ever going to really mater strength wise. In fact the classic dovetail/drawer constructions we see in many pieces of fine funiture, are actually pretty shoddy. They won't usually last even 100 years.
I would argue that the practical argument "they are stronger", only mater if people take a higher interest in the product. If people don't see anything more than the price of everything and the value of nothing, they won't keep the furniture around long enough for the joinery to mater, so in that sense the functional argument is just a smoke screen for something else.
"I'll grant you that dovetails are often used as ornamentation these days. I don't really find that such obsessive behavior is good for craftsmen in the long run, but it would be naive to deny it's existence"
I think you are right, which is why that school really didn't last that long. I think it was a sincere thing, conceptually, the whole form follows function, and revealed structure thing. And as annoying as that posturing could be, where architecture or furniture was concerned, what has followed has not been better. I don't really feel the need to apologize for Krenov, say, when what followed was a blizzard of mission style computer tables. Or this in architecture:
