New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Dovetails - a little confused

Posts

Dovetails - a little confused

#1

Dovetails - a little confused

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Yesterday I started to make a till for the few handsaws I have.

I haven't put much thought into it, just started to put it together with scrap pine 1x12's.

It's going to hang on a wall and the sides are going to be dovetailed to the top and bottom boards. So I wanted the side boards to be the tail boards and the top & bottom the pin boards. That makes sense right?

I am no DT expert, far from it. I do fine DT'ing drawers. Normally with drawers they are half blind and start with 1/2 pins.

Yesterday when I looked at the tail board and started to lay out the tails, I got completely confused. How do I begin laying out the tail board with, I guess, 1/2 tails at both ends or sides of the boards.

How do I lay out the tails? I just can't get my head around it. I know many of you do this stuff without even having to think about it...

BTW, I am doing tails first.

Thanks for any help/suggestions.

Joe

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#2

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

William Duffield

Your tails should be in the sides; pins in the top and bottom. This will keep gravity from pulling it apart. (If you were going to set the cabinet on the floor and slide things bak and forthon shelves, then it might be wiser to reverse the locations of the pins and tails.

I don't like to make half tails, because they act like wedges and can split a narrow piece out the edge of the tail boards if you cut the dovetails too tight, or if the case is racked. Lay them out with half pins instead.

This video, by Megan Fitzpatrick of Popular Woodworking should help: You will need two sets of dividers.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MUiPJF_jNEA

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#3

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Your tails should be in the sides"

Understood and that 's what I was planning on doing. If the side board begins with half pins, then the side board doesn't extend to the bottom visually.

That's why I wanted to begin with half tails so that the side board appears to be full length - probably not explaining that well.

I'm probably not making much sense....

I've watched Megan's video a number of times, maybe I'll just do it that way.

I was wanting it to look like this as viewed from the front.


Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#4

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

William Duffield

Yes, I do understand. It took a while; I'm a bit slow this morning. I think that's why, in the 18th Century, they hid them all with mouldings. :D In this case, I think the structural considerations trump the aesthetics. If you do split the tail board, it's easy to fix with one expletive deleted, a little glue and a clamp, and is invisible, unless you llike to point out your errors to people.

There are lots of different methods for laying them out. The first one that comes to mind is Frank Klaus's (pins first) method, but he just does them. I guess you could say he lays them out with the saw--no measuring or marking tools needed (except the base line, of course). I recommend the method Megan shows because I find it easy to remember, even if I'm in the shop and all my references are back in the house, or if I haven't laid any out in a while.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#5

Couple ways

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

You can do it the way you envisioned. There are a zillion ways to do the layout, but you can simplify everything by deciding up front that your half-tails will have the same width at the scribe line as the full tails. For example, all along the scribe line--the baseline--the half tails will all measure, say, 1".

The next step is to decide how many pins you want. Because after the baseline, the first marks you're going to make are the pin centers. The way I do this is just take a 1H or HB pencil and start playing with a drawing, first on paper and then right on the end of the board, or a board scrap of the right width. While you're doing this, you're also deciding 1:5, 1:6 or whatever looks best to you, and also the approx. visual weight of the pins compared to the tails.

Now mark the pin centers. Let's say your sides are 10" wide, and you've decided after playing with it for a while that you want 6 pins. And therefore there will be 7 tails and half-tails. The 6 pins will divide the 10" into 7 equal parts--again, we're simplifying so the pins are equally spaced. So pin spacing is 10/7 inches, or 1.428". Which is just about 1-7/16' (minus 1/100").

You can mark either the board end or the scribe line. Either way, lay ruler across the board, and make 6 marks, 1-7/16" apart. Those are the pin centers. Make vertical marks to see the pin centers on board end and scribe line.

Now balance the pin and tail weight. The next marks you make are going to set the pin weight and tail weight, which you've already been mulling over. Look at the first pin mark at 1-7/16" in from either edge. Let's say you want your tails and half-tails to be 1" wide at the scribe line. Then the pin at the scribe line is established by marking 7/16" either side of the pin center, so you will have tails that are 1" wide along the scribe line, and pins that are 2 x 7/16" = 7/8" wide.

Then mark the rest of the pins, and use your bevel to bring the pins down to the board end (their short end). Shade in the pins. What's left is your tails. Extend all lines across the end grain. NOTE: If you're going tails first, you only need to mark the one board on its face, showing the pattern. You can gang the two sides, and saw them both at the same time, where the 'off side' need only have its scribe lines marked, and of course the end grain marks carried across both boards, once they're ganged in the vise.

There is of course a quicker method: after playing around with drawings and getting comfortable with what you want, just mark one side by eye, gang the sides, mark the end grain, and start sawing. If using molding, this is a no-brainer, but even without molding you'll come close enough by eye that no one will see the minor irregularities in the layout.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#6

agree with the paper first approach; layout tool

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are just making a "drawer" to hang on the wall. It is a must learned skill.

When I was learning to lay these things out I found that it was best to do the full sized layout on a piece of paper first. Paper is even cheaper than shelving pine :) Draw the board representing the side of the cabinet. Make a dotted line representing the thickness of the "box" bottom on the end of the drawing. Freehand draw in pins, for it will be these pins that show on the side. Shade them to make them stand out. When it looks the way you want it to then transfer the concept to the lumber using what ever means of sizing and spacing the pins you prefer.

I see no problem starting with a half tail on the side. It is something I do frequently.

Alternatively, precisely lay out on paper and precisely transfer from paper to lumber.

Hint. One's eye is not sensitive to pin spacing differences but quite sensitive to pin size differences. Develop a way to ensure consistent sized pins. The home made tool pictured below ensures pin sizes are consistent.








Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#7

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thank you all for the suggestions.

I was over thinking things a bit...

I used a little bit of everybody's suggestions and just went at it. It'll work out fine. It's just something to put my saws in, not a piece of furniture. Spending too much time on it. :)

Still needs work, but this is what I am doing:


Thanks again all.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#8

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

TomD

Presumably the different size end tails are there to deal with the back of the cabinet. At any rate, that is something else one needs to do.

Visually, I think the half tails look out of balance. When I do halves, they are actually just the size of my normal spacing, but one side minus the bevel, so it is more than a half. The small one in your picture looks a little undercut, and the larger one looks like a square. It will be a nice project, and I would spend the time required on it. It will stand out as your workmanship in your shop, almost like an advertisement, even if you aren't selling anything. It is faster to do a neat job than a bad job, so one might as well do it all the time. Nails would hold this piece together, so dovetails are more decorative than anything else.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#9

gaining confidence

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The best way to learn to make a dovetailed drawer (or case) is to find excuses to dovetail other stuff where the main purpose is to hold something together.

In your case at hand- an outstanding example for a practice session. Were it a drawer, you could have gotten by with a tail or two less.

Some people seem to prefer busy dovetails. Enough of them and they begin to look machine made. Personally, I like the more economical look one finds on old pieces where the objective was to use the minimum number to hold something together.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#10

Re: gaining confidence

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I guess that's the point of this exercise - "a practice session"

I'm just messing around with hand tools using some scrap to make a saw till. I've used hand saws to rip and crosscut the boards to size, a saw, chisel, and router plane to cut a stopped dado for a shelf and so on. I'll use hand tools for the drawer as well that will go between the shelf and bottom board.

If the DT's look too silly, I'll have some more scrap for the fire pit... in the end I will have gotten some more hand tool practice. :)

Once I get this thing put together, I can get the saws off my work bench that are laying in the way and start to teach myself how to sharpen them. I'm tired of reading how to sharpen and watching (and re-watching) the videos I bought, I'm ready to try it! That's the plan anyway...

Thanks again all for the input.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#11

The metric isn't looks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"If the DT's look too silly, I'll have some more scrap for the fire pit"

The proper metric for success is whether the box is sufficiently held together.

When I quite worrying about what others would think of my dovetails an amazing thing happened....I used dovetailes more and they became easier to make.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#12

That is it exactly...

John in NM

This cannot be stressed enough - while the joint is taken as a mark of skill, the point of it's use is not aesthetic. An awful looking dovetail is stronger than a tidy nailed butt joint.

If one doesn't like the look of the practice dovetail projects - saw tills, storage boxes, etc, then give them a nice coat of paint. Dovetail everything you possibly can, don't worry about the appearance, and you'll get good at it without much angst.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#13

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

Sgian Dubh

"How do I begin laying out the tail board with, I guess, 1/2 tails at both ends or sides of the boards."

There's no pressing need to finish with a half tail Joe. In fact, it's rather unconventional, although technically sound. It's quite normal to put a half pin at both edges, something along the lines that Bill Tindall illustrated in the drawing he included in one of his posts, i.e., as at the front of the drawer box, to the left, although in your case you're doing through dovetails. Saying half pin is a bit of a misnomer really because most people make these half pins something closer to ±two thirds width rather than half, especially if the full pins are very delicate. The extra meat in the half (±2/3) pin makes it more robust. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#14

Re: That is it exactly...

Doug Trembath

I couldn't agree more. I beat myself up continuously on the aesthetics of dovetails until I finally realized that they are simply a structural element. At that point, it all made sense, and my efforts became much more pleasing to the eye.

Let's not forget the lessons learned by virtually every apprentice woodworker since time immemorial, just do it.

Aesthetics come with practice. Be happy with your efforts, after truly and honestly evaluating the results. No one does it absolutely right the first time...

Doug Trembath

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#15

Re: gaining confidence

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Joe,

These are the first dovetails I made (maybe 2001?) that stayed out of the fire.

Big Ugly Functional Dovetails. I went with half(2/3-ish) pins. Half tails would have worked for these big gawky things too. I imagine my thoughts at the time were probably influenced by something I had read about needing to use half pins.

Point is, they work, don't look too bad to my eye, (though others may disagree) and have performed as the designer intended. (were thrilling to me back in 2001 too, I might add.) It might be shop furniture, of little or no consequence, but it's mine and I made it, and it was fun too. (the pine is very forgiving compared to hardwoods)


Bob in NJ

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#16

Re: That is it exactly...

TomD

"This cannot be stressed enough - while the joint is taken as a mark of skill, the point of it's use is not aesthetic. An awful looking dovetail is stronger than a tidy nailed butt joint."

I wouldn't go that far. Many very cheaply done joints are immensely strong, or at least outlast several generations, and are just nailed together. This is shown by the fact that often craftsmen's tool boxes were nailed together. The point in the past may not have been aesthetic, or as a mark of skill. But it clearly is today, to deny it would be to overlook that last 35 years, a good bit of which was obsessed with exposed dovetails. And in the past there was the whole thing about certain dovetails being the mark of different trades. So they may have had some pride in the style they undertook. Skill could not really have been the issue since anyone who can cut one type can cut the others.

"If one doesn't like the look of the practice dovetail projects - saw tills, storage boxes, etc, then give them a nice coat of paint. Dovetail everything you possibly can, don't worry about the appearance, and you'll get good at it without much angst."

Good advice, though I do think one should always worry about the appearance because: A) Some of it is design, and one has to practice that just as one does any other skill. The simplest way is to just start by copying. Google DT joint and when you find one you like, copy it. Figure out why you like it and design your own. B) Appearance is partly workmanship, and if one concentrates on the basics, one will get better, it is all pretty fundamental stuff. There is no way to do it right without trying a little, or to do it really badly if one executes the fundamentals.

I would actually take your good advice one step further. Do practice pieces. Even making a saw till is subject to projectitis. We know this because we are currently in a thread that is covered with it. Practice on the range, execute on the course: Cut samples; warm up with some flowing saw cuts before you do a real piece; don't practice on projects focus not on process or learning new stuff, but on executing. Another reason to do practice pieces is that I think a lot of people are all wound up with the idea that dovetails take so long, or use up wood, or consume emotional energy to the extent that they can't be wasted on practice. These are all attitudes that are part of the problem.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#17

Re: The metric isn't looks

TomD

Perfect looking dovetails will be strong, unless something truly spooky took place. There are cases in work were stuff that looks great falls apart, or self-destructs. Spacing could be an example of something where the look and function aren't in perfect alignment, but even there the idea has generally been functional. If we are only discussing spacing, then why would one even get it wrong. It can be copied, there is next to zero execution skill in spacing and angles.

If one is discussing execution, then there is an effect on strength. Dovetails are enormously strong, but they also fail at times. A real metric would be a test. Testing is extremely difficult since destructive tests are rarely representative of the failure mode. So there really aren't metrics for the aesthetic part of the equation, and there aren't any established standards for the structural failures. Perfect practice makes perfect still seems like a good plan.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#18

I see a difference in our approaches...

John in NM

Granted none of my paying work involves dovetails, and I'm always way behind on it too - but the difference is I don't do anything for practice alone.

Everything, dovetailed or nailed together, has to have a purpose if I'm going to bother making it. I might dovetail something that does not need it in order to practice but whatever it is will still be a useful item. Anything else is, to me at least, a waste of limited time and materials.

For a saw till, you are quite right that a nailed butt joint would probably be sufficient. For a box or drawer, the dovetailed one will last longer. That craftsmen in the past didn't bother to dovetail tool boxes just tells me about their priorities, not the intrinsic strength of the various joint options.

I'll grant you that dovetails are often used as ornamentation these days. I don't really find that such obsessive behavior is good for craftsmen in the long run, but it would be naive to deny it's existence :D

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#19

Re: A special kind of dovetail failure

david weaver

Last year, I was running around my parents' house taking pictures of their furniture innards. Somewhere along the way, someone clued them in to hand done dovetails (there is gobs of old middle-level furniture where they live in central PA).

To my surprise, every dovetail was handsomely done, and the drawer proportions were very nice. That goes against the advice that everyone gives that dovetails in old furniture are always sloppy looking.

The most surprising of all of them was a drawer on a night stand that was cherry with pine drawers - someone had done something to jerk the drawer open so hard that the pine tails had torn completely loose from the rest of the drawer side and were sitting firmly in the half blind socket, severed roughly along where the tail met the rest of the drawer side.

My parents had never noticed that and described the drawer as "loose" - it was the side facing away from where you'd see if you were in bed and pulled the drawer open.

I'm sure I could find some loose glue on the others.

I've got no clue how old all of this furniture is, but it wouldn't be mistaken for the finest furniture from boston or philadelphia, nor would it be mistaken for junk. It was probably upper middle class furniture from 100 to 200 years ago.

The trouble with all of this is that the camera pictures were of such poor quality that you couldn't see anything. I assumed as I was taking them, they'd turn out, but my parents early 1900s house is too dark and the "flash" on the phone didn't have enough power to make nice with the photos.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#20

Re: English Bob summed it up

TomD

Interesting. Clean is faster than rough. My in-laws have a lot of furniture, and the same applies there, the work was nicely done. The small drawers are a kick. The wood is about the thickness of cigar boxes, but the work is very clean, and it went fast as they could chop out in a single strike, or one from each side.

I used to always argue with Adam that he was wrong about the sloppy part. Haven't heard anything from him since he spent that time in euro. That would be an eye opener.

And as you say the furniture of the US could rise to a wonderful standard, still, as English Bob said:

"English Bob: [discussing the assassination of President Garfield] Well there's a dignity royalty. A majesty that precludes the likelihood of assassination. If you were to point a pistol at a king or a queen your hands would shakes as though palsied.

Barber: Oh I wouldn't point no pistol at nobody sir.

English Bob: Well that's a wise policy, a wise policy. But if you did. I can assure you, if you did, that the sight of royalty would cause you to dismiss all thoughts of bloodshed and you would stand... how shall I put it? In awe. Now, a president... well I mean...

[chuckles]

English Bob: why not shoot a president. "

The best furniture is found in a very different firmament. My cousin got the OBE from the Queen for which one receives a video of the ceremony. She was in some room waiting to meet the Queen, and there was a piece of furniture there, that was more ornate than anything I have ever seen, and I don't think it was anything terribly central to the collection. It was something they could stand to have in proximity to the hoi polloi. Move to Euro, and the ornateness can be even more outrageous.

Presumably the rough work one sees is the work of Jacks of all Trades. And there is something interesting about that also.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#21

Re: I see a difference in our approaches...

TomD

"Granted none of my paying work involves dovetails, and I'm always way behind on it too - but the difference is I don't do anything for practice alone."

This is kinda the American way, you can open a cabinet shop without ever having seen a tool. Traditionally, it was 7 years to get the right to run a shop. The US way is probably why we see stuff like Sam Maloof he was creative, and invented his own way. One can't overstate the value of that, but it will involve a lot of bumping into the furniture trying to find one's way. But I assume we would both prefer the guys doing open heart surgery to have done a dry run at some point. If one doesn't practice then the client is funding the "GI bill" without the maker ever having risked life and limb for his country. I guess a free education is everyone's right today.

"Everything, dovetailed or nailed together, has to have a purpose if I'm going to bother making it. I might dovetail something that does not need it in order to practice but whatever it is will still be a useful item. Anything else is, to me at least, a waste of limited time and materials."

I certainly respect that point of view. But I doubt it is really true for the majority of people. Very few people are purely functional. At the end of a long day of welding pipe, guys are prone to take the check down to the local strip club to watch the dancers. It isn't because they are purely functional in outlook, they are going to have to pay to look, and probably not touch, much. Normally the function argument is just a ploy to divert an unappreciated argument back to an economic argument that has broad appeal. But generally, the bucks in small unit numbers are in selling the sizzle to the rich.

"For a saw till, you are quite right that a nailed butt joint would probably be sufficient. For a box or drawer, the dovetailed one will last longer. That craftsmen in the past didn't bother to dovetail tool boxes just tells me about their priorities, not the intrinsic strength of the various joint options."

Dovetails are stronger for the section or weight, etc... Not in absolute terms, you can always take a piece of wood of a larger dimension, and the nails, biscuits, dowels or screws will hold up just fine. Or use extension slides where the loads are much lower. And since fine furniture these days is just a way point on a route to the dump when tastes change. Unless people appreciate higher values in a piece. and that takes effort. Dovetails are rarely ever going to really mater strength wise. In fact the classic dovetail/drawer constructions we see in many pieces of fine funiture, are actually pretty shoddy. They won't usually last even 100 years.

I would argue that the practical argument "they are stronger", only mater if people take a higher interest in the product. If people don't see anything more than the price of everything and the value of nothing, they won't keep the furniture around long enough for the joinery to mater, so in that sense the functional argument is just a smoke screen for something else.

"I'll grant you that dovetails are often used as ornamentation these days. I don't really find that such obsessive behavior is good for craftsmen in the long run, but it would be naive to deny it's existence"

I think you are right, which is why that school really didn't last that long. I think it was a sincere thing, conceptually, the whole form follows function, and revealed structure thing. And as annoying as that posturing could be, where architecture or furniture was concerned, what has followed has not been better. I don't really feel the need to apologize for Krenov, say, when what followed was a blizzard of mission style computer tables. Or this in architecture:


Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#22

Where to start?

John in NM

I'm not sure why you'd think all the hyperbolic digressions are a good idea, most of them aren't even based on reality.... people starting wood based businesses without know what tools are? Doctors practicing with no practice? None of that is real, and none of it is relevant.

Dovetails are stronger joints, or more durable in use if you prefer - I don't get why you would think increasing the dimensions is here or there. It's as if I were saying that steel is stronger than aluminum and you come back with "not if you make the aluminum thicker". That is precisely my point.... the stronger joint allows you to do more with less, that is why it is an advantage when needed.

I am not saying who should use them when in a finished product. I'm just saying that if one wishes to practice and get good at them, that person should use them whenever they can and not sweat the finer points of how they look.

With the Frank Gehry carp I will certainly agree with you :D

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#23

Shame about that new building falling over

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

right on to the old one.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#24

Re: English Bob summed it up

david weaver

I don't know who had what argument back then, but thought that the cleanliness of the joints was interesting, even on what was very common furniture (I have never inspected super high end furniture).

I also was surprised that the proportions of the tales were very tasteful, with the pins very small and tidy.

I'll try to get pictures again next time....with a real camera.

Re: Dovetails - a little confused

#25

Re: English Bob summed it up

William Duffield

If you want to study lots of dovetails, go to Mark B. Firley's blog, "The Furniture Record".

He has spent years photographing a vast number of the dovetails (and other details) of antique furniture all over the U.S. (and maybe beyond). This record is not particularly selective (except that the furniture has survived), so you get all kinds of spacing and angles and widths.

http://thefurniturerecord.wordpress.com/

Most of the photos are not on the blog itself, but are on flickr, with links from the blog.