New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Yep, and actually on time for a change...

This month I'd like to pursue a question that was sent in by one of the readers of our bimonthly "News & Views" column in Woodworker West magazine.

USED WOODWORKING MACHINERY

What to look for, what to look out for, and the pros, cons and relative merits of new and used machinery.

I'm sure there is plenty of experience out there on all sides of this issue, and, as usual, we want to hear what you think. We'll distill your replies and include them in the next column, due out in mid October.

Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Woodworker West magazine

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#2

Ellis Walentine

Hmm. No takers here.

Ellis Walentine

You guys just don't want to admit you have machines lurking behind all those racks of hand tools. Maybe we should call this survey "Used Tools" instead of "Used Machinery."

We'll do a hand tool survey next time. :)

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#3

I've been taken before.....

roger lance

I've got scads of power tools.....and a couple of hand tools.....and the first thing I believe an individual should do before buying a used tool is to do an honest self assessment of their ability, knowledge, and patience in working with a used machine that maybe needs some TLC. If you don't have the necessary characteristics to successfully repair a used machine, buy new. If you do have those attributes, then assess the machine to determine what will be involved and if it is worth the effort.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#4

Re: I've been taken before.....

Doug Trembath

Very good points regarding used equipment, Roger, but as a counterpoint, almost all of the many new power tools I have purchased (bigger than a hand drill), required me to do almost as much work for initial setup, which required just about the same knowledge and capability as you list for the used stuff.

Getting a new jointer square and in plane, adjusting a new Unisaw, cyclone dust collectors, shapers, drum sanders, heck, the list goes on and on...

I guess what I'm saying is that buying new doesn't alleviate the need for capability in my own experience. I have, by the way, bought more used than new. Sometimes the used is better, because someone already did the setup.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#5

Re: Hmm. No takers here.

TomD

The primary question, sadly not elucidated in the OP is why one would want to buy used machinery. This really is the nub of the issue. For instance, if you want to recapture what it was like working with your dad as a kid in his shop; or want to use pedal power 19th century tools; or want tools that are no longer made; or want tools that look nice rather than like a central air conditioner; then you pretty much have to buy used tools. That cuts down on the possible objections that might otherwise be raised about their purchase. I have done all these, sometimes more than one on the same day. I once went and visited a guy who had assembled a lot of tools, enough for his intended second shop. Unfortunately he had had to drop his plans, and was selling his machines. He sold me a foot powered mortise machine (pretty, no longer made). At the same time he sold me a really nice Rockwell table saw, 9 inch, just like the one my dad had, and that I still have at the farm. Except we had the contractors version, this one was a mint version in cabinet format. It had a really elegant cast base (pretty, Dad's shop category, cheap [$50]).

The most common reason for buying second hand might be the price. A 50 dollar saw they couldn't make today for 2K is pretty persuasive. My experience along those lines is:

1) I never found the secret to getting tools cheap, but over time they started flooding in. I have had this experience on a number of things, and the problem is that ridiculous situations show up at fabulous prices, normally around the time you have already bought everything. Which is no longer as useful as it might be. I could go into the biz now, but I don't want to.

2) Online sales fall into commodity stuff, you can pick up anywhere. So you have the tablesaw for virtually free. Easy to learn these markets lots of ads. You have the entry level tools that people switch out of. I needed one of those entry level drill presses for CNC parts, but you could buy them just to get the motor, or to fixture a drill press. There was literally one every highway exit.

At the other extreme there are the speciality things people want like say Inca tools that are easy to find in my area because there are few things (looms and Inca nick nacks) to clog the listings. You will probably find more Inca in affluent parts of the country, or areas around Garrett Wade or Lee Valley stores because they sold the lines. Maybe tough in Alabama, but then there were rocket engineers in some places there also.

Other than mastering Boolean search tools, I find a critical thing in finding listings whether selling or buying is to figure out a key word that cuts through irrelevant listings. Some listing are just nightmares to sort. Even better is to figure out the words people miss-list deals under. There is nothing like checking constantly. A few of my best deals came from reading a lot of ads and spotting something the person selling didn't want to sell. I never did this intentionally by say looking for "and I also have", but on two occasions I got my most prized tools from "and I also have" listings. I never asked about say a tool in the background, to see if it was for sale, though I guess it could happen. The "and I also have" listings, are afterthoughts so to boot you can sometimes get them cheaply.

When you want to buy something my strategy on getting the deal, assuming I really want it, is to say I will pay cash, and it is sold assuming the condition is as listed. You can get price concessions later if you need to. I think part of the reason I do well is because I like old people, enjoy their stories, am straight but serious with money, and am willing to take a risk, don't cry or call the lawyers when I end up with the short end. It is hard to characterize the approach, it will be different for everyone. Most sellers of woodworking stuff are pretty nice people and you are in their homes. If you treat them as you would expect to be treated, they will show you the stuff behind the curtains, and maybe later ask you to liquidate their shop (mixed blessing).

Safety. Use common sense when entering situations where you could be walking into John Wayne Gacy's basement voluntarily. You will be indoors, in a situation were easily weaponized stuff is lying around everywhere. Be polite and cordial to everyone, but formulate a plan to kill them, as the saying goes. This cuts both ways, when ladies come to visit I always have them met by my wife. That may set them at ease, though it shouldn't in the Province where Karla plied her trade.

What should you buy?

Obviously on price, there are opportunities to get a lower price on recognizable catalog items. These are just straight forward bargain hunting. You obviously have to have a clue on the financial depreciation of various types of gear; which ones are more likely to have motor or bearing problems. With the internet all this stuff is out there. Then you just go after the deals that make sense to you.

Buying actual old, possibly antique tools is more of a mixed bag. What should you buy. I like saws and drill presses. Particularly table saws. The US market design wise is way behind on saws. If it had progressed as in the EU, buying a 1950s table saw would be ridiculous. But it has retained the basic flawed architecture and attached expensive stop gaps like fences, and sawstop. On that basis, the beautifully machined, and particularly the smaller saws of an earlier period are super buys and tolerably safe. Many of these old saw used round bars for the fence, and may have minor mounting challenges for the newer fences. Old saws may be more accurately machined. Motors are normally easily detached and serviced or replaced,

Bandsaws. The newer ones are basically euro, and for general work and resawing are preferable. The old ones like a 15" general can be extremely high quality at the right price. The rangy Victorian ones can be great for cut out work. Usually will require addition of safety stand-off gear.

Planers are complex and hard to fix, and parts may be missing. I generally avoid them, but when you come across the only driven on sunday type planers, and they can be a good deal. They are a classic example of tools that may be a nightmare to dust extract. Extraction can be a major problem when buying older stuff, keep it in mind.

Around this point it is time to talk about moving stuff. Don't lift it, or ask your friends to lift it. The cheapest way to move really heavy stuff on ground level is with an engine hoist, it also comes in handy for pulling small trees out of the garden. Moving is a whole other subject...

Jointers. Three things here: Materials and machining matter here, you have a cantied structure that is heavily loaded, you have few major parts, that is a plus for old stuff well made. You have some very real dangers, as in badly designed guards, excessive gaps, square heads, and your back while moving this stuff. You have some issues around how tools are designed to be used. You might want to buy a huge wide planer to face plane your Krenov style cabinets, but it may have been designed to plane timbers, and so the gap might be really dangerous around you short little pieces of bookmatched wood.

Drill presses. Good area for oldish ones, though it can get ridiculous with exposed wide belts, etc... However, these machines can be killers, if you buy one for 50 bucks that has a 5 horse 3 phase motor, be aware it can wring you out like the wash. Size the motors for the work you are doing, not the size of the machine. A gravity switch is a good idea.

I could go on, but I am going to hop to something other than the tools.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#6

Re: The Big Take-Aways, And Big Ideas

TomD

Bundles. When you buy second hand or old machines, you usually do not pay extra for stuff. So you will find that similar machines price at the same dollar amount while one has a few missing parts, and the other has a chest of hundreds of items that each has an average price of $100 each. Seriously. People want money for the machine, pretty much the same money. I bought a shaper that was almost out of the box mint, another serious person tried to sell me the Road Warrior version of rusty parts for more money than I paid, I think he wanted 900, and I had paid 600. But these were rage, and at one level they are good value as to what you get at almost any price compared to what they make today, but wait for the mint "kit" if you have the time. Having time and some extra cash to front, even though you probably can get the cash back, is key.

Models. Similarly, there are often different models, and the models will often sell for the same money, though in the day they might have been very different in price. Some of the models, are way better than others. Say the Toolroom Lathe, VS. a consumer model meant to follow a doctor home. But, sometimes the industrial model is way worn out, and the craptastic home version is a better deal. This can also apply to models with less features on them, could be less desirable, and therefore less worn. Was it born in the time of 24 hr war production. You have to figure these things out. What 4 things should you look at that are the honey traps. Can you recognize the most common things that break, or wear. Google it. Get a good rule and dial indicator, that should set you back 10 bucks. Know the machines that are super accuracy related TSs, jointers, while drill presses (for our work), planers, lathes, bandsaws, may or not require the same level of care.

Investment value. Probably few tools really have it. You are more likely to make a kill on the sale price. That said I try to price stuff so I don't loose more than 10% on resale. You can get killed, or you can kill. I pretty much am happy paying a minor premium for having the experience, or use of the tool. But I have a fair amount of money tied up in these tools. When I went to pick this stuff up, I was buying a lot of it from guys around 75 years of age. I wonder where the replacement people are to buy us out. Is there going to be a point where we hit an age group that is 100% not hands on, and they don't want to buy these tools from us. They don't make them any more, but whether there is a long term market is hard to say.

Materials. One often hears people talking about how bad the new Chinese tools are. It is pretty much all true, particularly on machine tools. Machine tools are more naked, you can almost read the quality of the materials like wood grain. You don't have to be special. When I started to acquire old machine tools it was just obvious. This is not to say that newer tools aren't good. You can write your way out of any corner, and in manufacturing you can do things to make new crap sing. We will get to that.

Relatives. Should you look for situations where the bereaved are getting skinned? Ethics aside I would say no. I normally find that products in the hands of the original owners are in far better condition. Today, a relative can easily search a price on the net, but that won't stop them breaking or loosing parts when they emptied the house, and you probably can't see the stuff running. Exceptions abound, but overall, I prefer to look for quality than price. You can get both if you are patient.

Local. Canada gets very little stuff compared to what the US has, and typically the old second hand market was very expensive, somewhat as a result. So when I started looking I even made distant trips to the US to find stuff. But I learned that I can get almost anything locally. Toronto is big, and the stuff is out there. The internet provides the link, and keeps prices reasonable. But my point to guys in the US who may not have tried the second hand market is that at least at first, I would assume that if you can't find it, it is you, not the lack of availability locally. Give it some time and a chance. Three of my favorite items were ones where I considered going as far as Alabama. Yet ultimately the items were found 1hr, 10 min, and 20 minutes from my home. And I don't network.

Types of machine. Ok, this isn't saw vs jointer. I am talking about the kinds of markets where second hand machines are a lot better, but may or not measure up. I also look for sewing machines, or did at one time. Some old machines are high quality you can pick up for as little as 20 dollars; Singer cast iron machines that were designed to sew 4000 stitches a minute indefinitely. Modern asian machines might as well be made of cheese. So obviously one should only buy old sewing machines, right? Well if you look at a Randall (youtube, kinda cool machine), nobody makes anything like that, as far as I know; Patchers haven't changed; but speciality stuff for hobbyist and crafts like sailmaking, the new stuff is where it is at. Machine tools, the new ones made by say Grizzly, are pretty much patterned after pre-WWII machines, the originals are better and far cheaper. But CNC obviously is new, and modern manual machining requires modern tooling. Spinning, old stuff when people really spun, often were required by law to spin, not useful for modern craft spinning. etc... Pretty obvious, if it is some freaky hybrid, like modern planing, the new stuff may be "better". What about the spiral power planer head with replaceable edges?

Concepts to live by. A pal once told me he had short term, long term, and dream goals. He was a broker so his dream goal back around 1990, was to generate 1 million dollars of retail commission in one day. Same thing here. Be on the lookout for the practical stuff you need, but also keep your eye on the big score. I have had a few on a big scale for me... The biggest I know about was from Oregon, and it was machine tooling. A Doctor, I think, was hoping to take up metal working in his retirement,and built a huge shop, and stocked it with every imaginable tool, a hundred or more lathe sized tools, for all types of work. He never got around to it, and some local guys got called in to find a treasure trove of every imaginable tool, still all in their original crates. It happens.

Is it all worth it. My short take is yes for machine tools, and no for woodworking. Woodworking is specialized I can't think of an Asian, or antique lathe that I would consider. There are also some traps that can affect your productivity. I have stuff in the shop getting in the way, that I plan on reselling. I think that while I am happy with the journey, that I lost more than I gained as far as efficiency is concerned.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#7

Re: The Big Take-Aways, And Big Ideas

Rum

TomD said:

"Woodworking is specialized I can't think of an Asian, or antique lathe that I would consider"

There are definitely some exceptions to that statement imho. This isn't a complete list of counter examples to the "no asian/antique lathes" argument, but I think details the exception.

A PM90 (or even a 45) is a perfectly acceptable lathe for most purposes and is an excellent entry point to the vortex. Even better if you swap out the motor, add riser blocks, etc..

Its not uncommon to see Jet 1642s or PM3520s come up for sale occasionally. Given the amount of use the average owner puts on them, they're probably a decent deal generally. Both of those are Asian machines.

An Oliver 20C pattern makers lathe (or some similar) is an eventual dream quest machine (no place to put such a beast currently!) and I would definitely swap out the motor to three-phase plus VFD for variable speed (being now spoiled!)

If I found a barns treadle lathe in good condition for a reasonable price (including transportation costs) I'd buy it today (preferably a #5, but I'd take a 41/2 if it came along until I found a 5 :D). This would be the eventual "take to saturday market" lathe for attracting interest.

Finally from a collectors perspective if a Holtzapffel ornamental lathe turned up that the owner was somehow wholly ignorant of the value (haha and I found a bag of cash alongside the road!) I think I'd have to get it just because.

I'm pretty sure there are others but that's just a short list ;)

In the general case in large part it depends on your goals and willingness/ability to repair or fix things. If you are a collector that has its own set of rules that are (I believe well outside the scope here). For practical purposes I prefer looking at things with a heavy discount because of the somewhat increased risk (can't just send it back if its a lemon). On the other hand sometimes its worth getting tools for even just the parts (hand saws with bent plates can be worth more for the saw nuts than you pay, even assuming the rest is trash, or I've gotten some tools because the motor was useful even if the tool was a tin can).

My willingness to pay more increases if:

- I can see the tool running/in operation (slightly less relevant to most hand tools of course :D)

- my familiarity with the tool (this also tends to correlate with decreased need since odds are higher I already have it which would of course decrease my willingness to buy at all)

- estimated work/cost required to fix it (for instance if it has bearings over ~20years old odds are starting head towards them needing to be either re-packed or replaced)

- my need for the tool (not at the expense of practicality of getting the tool working - excepting the below :D)

- a certain coolness factor (ooh a snowflake bandsaw close by .. for low money, I will spend some time getting THAT back to functional condition).

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#8

Re: The Big Take-Aways, And Big Ideas

TomD

I'm thinking of modern turning. An ornamental lathe is a definite catch. I have had several chances to buy a barnes, but really couldn't do it other than as a toy, and I have enough of those. I remember people used to like the oliver lathe. I have a union graduate, which is probably technically an antique. But I would unload it at a decent price, but with the internet, there isn't anyone willing to offer me enough money to make a trade up reasonable. However, people that look at it all feel it is old fashioned, even though the basic pillar arrangement is as valid as it ever was. But sorta like bike helmets, there seems to be a sense it is dangerous not to have a realistic arrangement for tail stock support.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#9

Re: The Big Take-Aways, And Big Ideas

Rum

Fair enough, although I'd leave the pm90 on the table for most casual turners and there are a good handful of other lathes in that or somewhat smaller class that would be just dandy for most of the garage market (which is arguably the bulk of the market here) :)

There are some things that one of those monster patternmakers lathes can do that is hard to replicate otherwise, indeed they are one of the hard to replace at all with modern substitutes (a couple of the high end modern lathes come close but lack the compound and sheer mass).

The graduate is a neat looking lathe (I'm guessing you have the bowl turner model from the description?), had to look it up as I hadn't seen them before. The only significant in place upgrade i could see would be conversion to variable speed (have a hard time giving that up now that I have it). It's cultural descendant would appear to be the vb36 (which would appear to have a substantially more robust tailstock setup - of you add that option) or perhaps (less so) the stubby bowl lathes.

One could argue that a 3520 with the extension in the lower position and the headstock slid to the end up isn't that much different functionally from the graduate (and has no tailstock support at all in that configuration) and is definitely somewhat widely used in that setup. Something something perception of risk something... :D

Actually if I had space/time for one there are a good handful of patternmakers lathes that would fit the bill, but they are a specialty machine no doubt (wants, desires and needs weighted appropriately there as the case may be). I can't legitimately argue that the Barnes is a real need either not that there wouldn't likely be better options for most folks, but I like things like that so.. justification enough :)

The short version here is really like any tool purchase know why your buying it first and then figure out what fits that.