New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

Posts

Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#1

Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

Kees

Mechanics of chipbreakers and high cutting angles in woodworking planes.

Kees van der Heiden, The Netherlands, 2014.

Abstract.

When using handplanes, tearout is a typical problem. Two methods to prevent tearout are high cutting angles and chipbreakers set very close to the cutting edge. In previous work it was found that a cutting angle of 60° is equivalent to a chipbreaker setting of 0.1 mm behind the edge when the chipbreaker edge is beveled at 45°. Likewise an angle of 55° is equal to a 0.2 mm setting of the chipbreaker. To compare the two methods a planing machine is used with force transducers to measure the cutting force Fc and the force perpendicular to the wood surface, the normal force Fn. Fc proved to be 30% higher for the plane setups with a high cutting angle, compared to the equivalent chipbreaker settings. Fn is normally negative, pulling the edge into the wood in a standard 45° plane without the chipbreaker. When setting the chipbreaker close to the edge this negative force is slightly reduced, but in high angle planes this is reduced much more and tends towards 0 around a 60° cutting angle, under the circumstances of this experiment. A second experiment has been conducted to measure the forces after a planing distance of 100 meters. The rate of change of Fc is about equal for both methods. The rate of change of Fn is twice as fast for the high cutting angles. The conclusion is that the plane with a chipbreaker is technically more advanced then the plane with a high cutting angle. A hypothesis about how the two methods prevent tearout is proposed in this article too.

The complete article will be published on Steve Elliott's website http://planetuning.infillplane.com/, hopefully this weekend. As soon as I have a link I will post it here.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#2

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

TomD

Cool, only thing I see that could be there is a some kind of qualification of the circumstances in which this is a relevant concept. 99% of planing can still be undertaken without chipbreakers, and is more efficient as such. That would be 99% in terms of plane type, or wood type, or angle of attack. Of course for some people, like say planers of bamboo flyrods that would be 100% of work, and for others, say those who use a mechanical plane only for pre-sanding finishing, it would be 100% in the opposite direction with all their planing using chip breakers. This is no assault on the concepts under discussion just not to extend beyond the practical/actual their application.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#3

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

david weaver

Figured wood doesn't always allow planing downhill, nor does some glue-ups.

Also, if you have a board corner that's a hundredth high or whatever when you're planing to a mark, sometimes it's easier to bring the corner of the board or panel down planing from the center of said board or pane, against the grain.

And if you like to plane Xs on something like a glued panel that you're leveling (so that you don't have to change where you're standing, same thing - some part of the X pattern is going to be going against the grain.

In those cases, you don't need a plane that will take a coarse shaving with minimal tearout, but it is awfully convenient, and it makes the shavings that are against the grain much more comfortable because the plane remains smooth in the cut.

I agree that it's nice to plane down grain instead of back into it, but sometimes a routine planing partly into the grain is much faster.

Also, when you're planing downhill with a common pitch plane with a cap iron, you can back it off some and have an easy cut. With a high angle plane, you can't. Even if you just back the cap iron off so that it's reducing tearout but not eliminating it (thus not adding much push resistance), it's nice.

I think, however....well, I don't know what kees's motivation is, but we often hear "there's not much more push resistance" or "I don't notice it being any harder to push a high angle plane" or "it stays sharp just as long", and kees is putting actual numbers to those things. Often we can trust our hands and eyes, and those of us who have used both high angle planes and cap iron laden common pitch planes know that it takes less force to push the plane (which just for me translates into taking a coarser shaving, because I'll take the coarsest comfortable shaving that I can take), and that the plane has a desire to stay in the cut more with the cap iron laden plane than does a high angle plane.

We can trust our hands and eyes. It's too bad that a lot of people don't, otherwise. Having pushed high angle planes, it also didn't ring true to me that dimensioning with a high angle plane was similar in resistance, especially as the cut gets heavier. I'm glad kees is quantifying it, not because it changes my mind, but because there are some people who just won't believe anything, including what they see and feel, unless someone takes a machine and measures it.

I get a chuckle out of the last comment that kees made, I'm sure that will draw some heat, just like a heel pro wrestler :)

Points made above only in friendly argument, not in a peeing contest way. Some folks who never dimension with planes won't care about any of this, as you can pretty much smooth with anything if all you have to do is remove tablesaw marks and machine planer chatter. for dimensioning from rough, it's a revelation in productivity, and a few side things stick out in my mind, like a $600 spiers pattern infill kit that I have that did just OK with the cap iron set off (a panel plane where something like an X pattern followed by through strokes is idea for flattening a face), but with the cap iron set properly is a complete joy to use as long as the shavings stay heavy (it's a bit of a pig to take thin shavings with).

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#4

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

TomD

I'm thinking more broadly and obviously than that, the sort of thing the person who knows nothing about planing might might need directions on. Even in the modern kit, the majority of planes don't have breakers, or they don't need them. Even in finishing there are woods that cut fine regardless, and shavings too fine to set for. What remains is important but narrow ground.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#5

a thoughtful reply

bill tindall

Thank you for the thoughtful reply complete with actual experience to support it

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#6

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

david weaver

The penultimate step is the one where cap irons are most useful. I think if you get your shavings thin enough, you can do whatever you want.

What's interesting is the number of planes that had cap irons when planes were used professionally vs. the number that have them now. It leads me to believe that most people use planes for little more than smoothing, and if a fitting situation comes up, they get sanders out to level joints, etc.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#7

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

TomD

Yeah, that is the case of what makes this important information, because it is relavent to the reality of how it seems that people use planes, or at least experiment with them, which seems to be a major form of recreational use. And it is relevant to the huge mass of lying around there planes that remain to be rediscovered.

But even that said, the likes of LV are always bringing out new planes, and most of them seem to be single blades: router planes; shoulder planes; plow planes; chisel planes; block planes; toothing planes; scrub planes; hinge install planes... Not to mention the work they did with low angle bench planes, now seemingly scorned, though my jointer still works as well as it did before the world caught up.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#8

The link! *LINK*

Kees

Here is the link to the article. Steve did a great job. Many thanks also to Bill Tindall, the "professor" of the project and Wiley Horne for the support, critisism and feedback. Thanks also to the Popular Woodworking staff, because the revenue of the chipbreaker article in februari allowed me to invest some money into this project.

http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/mechanics_of_chipbreakers.html


http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/mechanics_of_chipbreakers.html

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#9

Re: I don't know if ...

david weaver

..the whole cap iron thing has made much of a dent on LV's stuff. Figure that the internet is still a fraction of their total sales, and the simple fact is that a high angle BU plane is easier for someone to get initial satisfaction from. I'd imagine they'll sell them for a while without any problem, maybe indefinitely.

LN has pushed the idea of the high angle frog for quite some time when it is immediately apparent they weren't aware of the use of the cap iron because some of their planes couldn't be adjusted far enough forward for the cap iron to be used close to the edge. Their position now (at least last i heard) is that using a double iron is too fiddly and they suggest high angle frogs. (Of course. )

LV now has a nice batch of options BU or BD and you can really burger king your BD (or as john goodman said in the big lebowski, "have it your way, dude")

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#10

Ellis Walentine

Very convincing, Kees

Ellis Walentine

Your results seem intuitive to experienced users, speaking for myself, but it's interesting to see the quantitative proof as well. Thanks for a great article.

Ellis Walentine

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#11

Perseverance

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I had the good luck to see how much uncompromising work Kees dedicated to his apparatus and his results. What he has shown us is the result of months and months of rework, adding transducers, getting better transducers, redoing the sled--all until he could consider his results stable and reproducible.

In short, he is a meticulous worker, much as Steve Elliott has also been in his own work.

This is all to congratulate Kees on a very strong piece of work, getting beyond the anecdotal phase, and doing his work with integrity.

Wiley

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#12

Re: I don't know if ...

TomD

I don't disagree, I am just saying that as a snapshot of the planes people want, if their catalog is representative of that, outside of the bench planes (average person needs two), they have a large variety of planes that are not now, nor generally ever, chip breaker planes. Therefore chipbreaker planes are a subset, say a third, of planes that represent a fraction of planes that are in the craft. So the research shouldn't be presented outside of the limits of what it is.

By the way, not sure what the likes of LV sell is representative of what they know. Anymore than what McDonalds sells is representative of what they know to be nutritious food. You sell what the customer needs and wants, not what you know. If the customer knew what LV knows they would be running a competitive LV, not trying to figure out how to take a shaving by the most linear method possible.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#13

Re: Perseverance

Kees

Thanks guys!

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#14

Anecdotal

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think it is kind of annoying to hear our perception that a double iron plane requires less force than a high angle plane called anecdotal. Was it anecdotal to suggest that the sun was brighter than the moon (or Jupiter brighter than Saturn) before these were actually measured? Am I on shaky ground for suggesting the sun is brighter without seeing actual figures? If a farmer says that a bushel of apples is heavier than a bushel of beets, is that anecdotal?

Can a craftsman not trust his own perceptions? I can't imagine that anyone with

real experience would have any question which required more force. Or that a good mechanical engineer would not give an opinion without testing. I can't imagine that Kees would have devoted the time and expense to this project without confidence in the outcome.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#15

the flat earth soceity

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The reaction to the cap iron information recently (past year or two) revealed has been curious. Those that knew and used it wonder what the fuss is about. Those that had already found the solution to tear-out through high angles and close mouths dismiss the thought that there is any need to diddle with the cap iron. Most importantly, new to planing woodworkers seeking a solution to tear-out are confused by these reactions.

Both of the modern plane manufacturers dismiss the benefit or advantage of a close set cap iron. In their product literature each fails to offer information on setting it to mitigate tear-out. Rather high angles and close mouths are advocated and offered.

Yes, those that have experienced the brightness of the sun believe it, but those still in the darkness may need data to encourage them to peek out. A way of approaching Kees work is to see it as another way to get the close mouth and high angle advocates, as well as the confused inexperienced, to consider that there is another simpler, and cheaper, effective way to the goal of lessened tear-out.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#16

Re: the flat earth soceity

david weaver

Anecdotal issue aside, I had made the same comment to kees about a week or two ago, that it's too bad he has to go through all of this work just because people often refuse to believe their hands or eyes (or the statements made by people like warren who have the sense and experience to make a definitive practical statement).

The work kees did is in line what what my experience is with the two types of planes, not surprisingly (as warren implies, it's pretty easy to figure out, though the less perceptive may need to take a piece of timber and do equivalent work and use a clock to find out which goes faster).

As soon as a test comes out like this, it becomes definitive to the folks who either refuse to try, or refuse to believe their senses when they do try. I guess that's just the way it goes.

(we're still hearing people describe the degradation stropping does to an edge based on brent beach's advice, so sometimes these things don't work out quite so well as kees' conclusion has).

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#17

Re: Anecdotal

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Definition of "anecdotal":

__________

ADJECTIVE

1(Of an account) not necessarily true or reliable, because based on personal accounts rather than facts or research:

Example: 'while there was much anecdotal evidence there was little hard fact.'

_________

Warren, you're absolutely right and I apologize for the choice of words. I was using 'anecdotal' to mean a qualitative account (no data), but did not intend to imply unreliable, as given in the actual dictionary definition.

A doctor takes your pulse-- it's high, he knows that instantly and for a fact. Then maybe he counts beats for 10 seconds, multiplies by 6, and write down 84 on your chart. It was 72 or so last time. The qualitative data--'it's high'--is actually more certain and reliable than '84', which though measured in some way, is an approximation. But still, doctor writes down 84, because if he wrote down 'high', then he wouldn't know when he saw you again next time if high was in the ballpark of 85 or 100. The measurement is a benchmark of 'how high', just as Kees' work provides a benchmark of 'how much more' a lower attack angle (with cap iron) pulls itself into the work, compared to a 60 degree attack (no cap iron).

The measurement augments the original finding, but doesn't change it from unreliable to reliable, as you very convincingly point out.

So. Bad choice of words on my point. Can't edit at this point, so will just leave it at an apology and explanation.

I always consider your personal accounts of great value, and reliable.

Wiley

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#18

Re: the flat earth soceity

Patrick Gibbons

I've been using planes for about fifteen years. I tried bevel up planes with higher bevel angles and rejected them, not liking their overall performance. I've used thicker after-market blades and cap irons and A2 steel. I've closed up the mouth on my planes. I tried cap iron adjustment after reading about it here. Before I read about this, I thought I was placing my cap iron close to the edge. Turns out it wasn't close enough. Using original thin blades with a properly tuned cap iron gives me great results and, because they are thinner and made from simple high carbon steel, are easier to sharpen and put back to work. I'm glad this info was made available here on Woodcentral. Otherwise I would still think 1/16" was close enough.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#19

Re: the flat earth soceity

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Bevel up planes are a lot less complicated, and therefore can be manufactured and sold for less than the bevel down planes. They may also be less intimidating to inexperienced plane users. If the bevel up plane makers emphasized the utility and advantages of the chip breaker, they might sell fewer big block planes. The big block planes work fine for many tasks and timbers.

As sold, the new Veritas planes' chip breakers are ground at a very low angle (It's top is polished smooth from where it meets the iron, all the way back), and therefore does not provide the advantages of one with the front edge ground at a higher angle. Of course, it's easy to fix. The one I tried, set up with a tight mouth and sharp iron, didn't need the action of the chip breaker to perform well on some mildly curly soft maple, but that's not a very demanding test. I didn't note the angle of its frog, but it was not strikingly different from 45°.

I guess an adjustable mouth is less complicated too manufacture than an adjustable Bedrock frog, and it's certainly easier to adjust. An advantage that no one mentions is that it can be removed and the back edge reground when it eventually develops the inevitable wear bevel, which effectively opens it up.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#20

Re: the flat earth soceity

david weaver

Patrick, I came to the exact same conclusions you did. Irons I thought were inadequate were suddenly pleasant to use, and planes I thought that were suitable for coarse work were suddenly suitable for all of my bench planing work - translating to less walking into a different room (where I store my planes) as I always have a jack, try plane and smoother close to my bench now.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#21

Re: thin blades

TomD

That piece was in one of the Krenov books, which was the first book I ever read about woodworking 35 ish years ago.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#22

Re: the flat earth soceity

TomD

"Bevel up planes are a lot less complicated, and therefore can be manufactured and sold for less than the bevel down planes. They may also be less intimidating to inexperienced plane users. If the bevel up plane makers emphasized the utility and advantages of the chip breaker, they might sell fewer big block planes. The big block planes work fine for many tasks and timbers."

I think you have a lot of fair points there. My own view, which is no more than a guess, is that some time ago, pre-breaker, there was a strong customer movement towards single blade planes. This caused problems for the makers of double blades, but eventually they responded with exactly what the craft wanted. Very little thereafter the sentiment moved again. I think we are just getting what we want. If one can get away without a breaker that is a plus, there is no advantage to breakers unless they must be used.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#23

Re: the flat earth soceity

Kees

When I look at the new LV plane, I see two things that make using the capiron more difficult for beginners.

First the angle of the leading front edge looks rather shallow. Hard to see from the pictures but I guess it is sub-40 degrees. That can be made to work, but using the capiron is easier when that angle is a little higher.

Second, the manual advises to set the capiron at 1/64" for tricky wood. We know from Kato who actually measured these things, that a 1/64" (0.4mm) setting is just outside of the working range of the capiron. It won't be completely ineffective, but especially with the shallow capiron bevel angle, it's not good enough. Half that number and you are in Nirvana. Of course I agree that measuring this distance is a pain to begin with and depends a lot on the wood being worked. But when you put a number in the manual, better to get it right.

This example leads me to believe that LV put the capiron in the planes because of market demand, not because they really believe in it. I understand that it is a late addition to the project because some of their pre production testers recommended it.

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#24

A point missed

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As sold, the new Veritas planes' chip breakers are ground at a very low angle (It's top is polished smooth from where it meets the iron, all the way back), and therefore does not provide the advantages of one with the front edge ground at a higher angle. Of course, it's easy to fix. The one I tried, set up with a tight mouth and sharp iron, didn't need the action of the chip breaker to perform well on some mildly curly soft maple, but that's not a very demanding test. I didn't note the angle of its frog, but it was not strikingly different from 45°.


Just as I do not expect a blade to come ready sharpened when I open the box of a new plane, neither do I expect the chip breaker to be ready for use. This would be even more so with these LV planes.

As one hones a blade at the angle preferred by the user, so one prepares the leading edge of a chip breaker. A generic angle for a plane blade may be 25 degrees. For BD planes I prefer 30 degrees.

The generic angle for a chip breaker by LN and LV may be 25 degrees. It is not as simple a matter as just creating a secondary bevel of 45-50 degrees. That would suit a frog/bed of 45-50 degrees. With a 55 degree frog I would therefore create a 35-40 degree secondary bevel, or be prepared to place the chip breaker slightly further back than for a 45 degree frog.

If you are going to tune the combination, then do it properly. One size does not fit all, and a generic chip breaker angle is just that .. generic.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Abstract. Chipbreakers and high angles

#25

Re: A point missed

Kees

They could have made it easier for a more beginning user, or an advanced user who isn't yet aware of this feature. Put a 40 degree bevel on the capiron like Hock does. That at least makes it possible to use the capiron without further fine tuning. Then add some usefull text in the manual that explains how to use it.

Using a high angle frog is easy and well described in the documentation. The capiron needs a bit more education which is lacking now in the manual or on the website.