New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

Posts

A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#1

A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

roger lance

Well, its time to take advantage of LV's free shipping period which I did to get one of the new LV's diminutive router planes. A year or so ago, I voiced a number of criticisms of the LV small router.....and I even made a small router which addressed some of these concerns. My effort came in a distant second based on looks to the small wood router made by Derek Cohen.....and mine received the love given your average red headed step child.....little, if any.

Now comes LV with the release of their "medium" router and they have addressed a number of the concerns people were stating:

First, the blades are not round.....and blade stability should be markedly better.

Second, the re-design allows the use of the extensive plane blade offerings that LV already has for its large router plane. Gone is the need to self fashion a blade from a hex wrench which some people were doing.

Third, I find the "medium" to be very ergonomic.....feels good in my hand.....has a nice mass.....very controllable.....and the size is right.

I have to give some "props" to LV.....Rob never gave a hint (that I know of) about this tool being developed.....maybe, the guy can play poker !?.....and LV was miraculously able to bring this tool to market $1 less than the LN tool with depth stop.....what planning.

In short, this is the tool LV should have made all along.

Some pics including my clumsy effort.....




Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#2

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When would it be beneficial to own this plane if one already had the larger version (which I have and adore)?

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#3

Speculated answer.....

roger lance

Bill.....just got it and have not really used it much more than a test spin.....but speculate that it will come in handy in small work pieces and possibly with something that you can talk about.....line work where you were using a small chisel maybe this tool with a thin blade would work....both hands on the tool....good control....good selection of small blades....what do you think??....I'm interested to know your opinion.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#4

Thanks for the Review, and a Bonus

William Duffield

The bonus is a depth stop for the Small Router Plane. I already have one of those, and received a letter a couple weeks ago that Rob would be enclosing a depth stop for it with my next order. I assume that everyone who has the small router will be receiving the letter, if they haven't all ready.

A note on the new Medium Router Plane. Sometimes people (mostly patternmakers) have need to span a wider depression than the width of their router will accommodate. For that reason, Stanley, Veritas, etc. have put two countersunk holes in the base of their large routers for screws to attach a wide sub-base. The sub-base can also be used to attach a fence. I noted immediately that the new tool doesn't have this feature, but when I saw the enlarged pictures, I saw a pair of small indents at the appropriate places. You could drill these out for that purpose. Usually, if you are doing that sort of thing, you already have a large router plane, but I sure like Rob's thinking on this one.

Also, optionally getting it sans blades immediately occurred to me as well. Again, Veritas' attention to design details and customer satisfaction is more than impressive.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#5

Re: Speculated answer.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

lines in line and berry are 1/32" wide. Maybe small hinges like jewelry boxes, but I am not yet seeing a reason to own two.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#6

Re: Speculated answer.....

roger lance

It appears that the thinest blade offered by LV is 1/16" wide.....could be modified smaller I suppose.....there have been a number of new tool offerings in recent times and I did not see a viable reason to buy as you are seeing this offering....guess we are all vulnerable at times.....hope the more experienced hand tool users will weigh-in here and give their insights as to whether this tool has real purpose or not.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#7

Re: question

Patrick Gibbons

I own the two Stanley routers, the large and small. I find the small to be useful being more appropriate in certain circumstances. It would be even better with more sizes of cutters available. This new router offers that with better cutters too and better ergonomics.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#8

Re: Speculated answer.....

TomD

The obvious reason to have more than one would be if you regularly did work that required two + settings that were used intermingled. Can't think of an obvious example, but like the idea of having a ton of bevels to do a windsor chair. Maybe something involving trimming tenons where the 90 deg axes are at different depths. For a job like that you could use the med or large on the same job, so why not.

This kind of question is why we have wooden tools. The moment you dispense with the idea that you are going to need to adjust them, then planes and routers do not need complex adjustment mechanism, then they can be made in a few minutes, and you can make them for a given purpose, and they work better in wood anyway. Once they cost 100 bucks so that you can use them efficiently, inefficiently, then the question comes up as to why they are needed as a mater of economics.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#9

Re: question

JDK

I own the two LN routers, and find uses for both. Mine are closed-mouthed, and under some circumstances i could see owning both closed-mouth and open-mouthed versions of each plane. However, I don't presently find myself under those circumstances.

:)

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#10

Answer to Speculated answer.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Making a 1/16" wide line is not an issue ... if you utilise the Inlay Cutter.


This was designed for the Large Router Plane, however it should work just as well in the Medium (I have the inlay cutter but not the Medium router plane so I cannot say that is does work).


The cutter head holds a pair of included single-bevel slicing blades that score crisply defined groove outlines across, with or diagonal to the grain. By using a chisel or switching to a standard router plane blade matching or smaller than the width of the desired groove, you can quickly hog out the waste between the scored lines.

An included set of shims and spacers lets you set blade spacing to define groove widths from 1/16" to 15/32" (1.5mm to 12mm). Set includes five each of four sizes of plastic shims (0.002", 0.005", 0.01", 0.02") and one each of 0.04", 0.08" and 0.12" steel spacers.

I think that this is the way to go. The inlay cutter works well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#11

It looks slow and awkward.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am not of the proficiency of Steve Latta, although I took a class from him on Federal style inlay, but I did add something in the neighborhood of 100' of it on some recent furniture.

The Federal leg inlay as well as the Chester County "line and berry" is best, and traditionally, done with about 1/32" wide inlay. Don't consider any tool to make the troughs for this style decoration unless it can do a 1/32" trough. The hand made tool that Steve developed, or the Lie Nielsen equivalent, works dandy for the task and one procedure both defines and creates the trough. The tool is easily held and pressed onto and into the work with one hand. The operation is about like hand sanding.

As much as I admire the ergonomics of typical LV stuff this device has not raised the bar over the Latta style tool.

If one does not eschew electricity, the micro fence from Stewart and a Dremel tool is the way to make straight troughs. It has become the choice of Steve and everyone in the class came to prefer its speed and convenience. There is enough fiddling on this style of inlay that you will not feel cheated from hand tool usage by using the Dremel for the straight runs.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#12

Re: Answer to Speculated answer.....

roger lance

Well I'll be.....I actually own a hand tool that Derek does not own (yet).....made my day !!

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#13

Re: Electrons

TomD

The Bishop Cochrane base is great:


I bought one and I am glad I did. Dremels burn out pretty fast. The BC base is adapter based so you can fit any dremel deal to it, allowing one to go Chinese, or go for the tool (sears?) that has lifetime replacement as an option. Or the one that is quietest, or most powerful.

Over time, the smart move is a trim router, or high speed spindle. Trim routers are much sturdier and while the weight might seem like a deterrent, one quickly adapts.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#14

Re: Answer to Speculated answer.....

Patrick Gibbons

The Lee Valley site says it's not compatable with the inlay cutter head.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#15

Best money I ever spent on inlay tools

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

was for this:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=69874&cat=1,43314,69873

And I particularly include LN's Steve Latta offerings in this judgment. I found the sawtooth scorer just about unusable.

The Veritas system cuts 25-, 32-, and 40-thousandth channels, 1/8" deep. The cutter scores in one direction, then scoops out the waste in the other. Channel is clean as a whistle. It works!

I recommend strongly to anyone doing inlay with hand tools.

Wiley

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#16

Re: Small router

edward in vancouver

I've got the small router and use it mostly for hinge mortises. As far as I'm concerned, the only issue with the tool is the round blade shaft rotating. I fixed that problem by clamping the blade in my vice and taking a file down the length of the shaft, forming a mono-buttocked "V" shape on the shaft. Using moderate pressure on the clamping screw, the blade doesn't rotate anymore.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#17

Re: Small router

William Duffield

I haven't gotten a round tuit yet, but I'm going to do that to my small router blades, too. Derek Cohen posted a link to his website, advising the same modification. It would be great if Lee Valley could ship them that way.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#18

Re: Small router

edward in vancouver

Yup, I got that lifesaver from Derek's site, AND his suggestion to file a slot on the depth shoe nut on the LV plough plane--once you tighten it with a screwdriver, it stays put.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#19

Re: Answer to Speculated answer.....

William Duffield

From studying L-V's pictures in their catalog, it appears that the Medium Router Plane's (MRP) hole in the base is too small to provide clearance for the Inlay Cutter Head (ICH). Even if it fit through the hole, I think you would have problems with visibility. I suppose you could use it outboard, but this is all speculation until I get my hands on the new router.

Another potential shortcoming would be using it to lay stringing an even distance from the edge of a drawer or chair leg, since the MRP does not have a fence. An appropriate stringing strategy would be to put the ICH in the LRP to cut the grooves, and a regular cutter of matching width in the MRP for cleaning out the bottoms.

The widths of standard router plane blades is a separate, but easily addressed issue. Cleaning out the bottoms of curved stringing grooves is another issue, perhaps addressed better with some other tools.

Re: A short review of LV Medium Router Plane...

#20

Re: Small router

John S

I have sort of a love / hate relationship with the round shaft on the small router plane. I don't like that the blade sometimes turns when using it. But when I made some small hinge mortises using the small router plane. The round shaft let me skew the blade, so that when I pivoted the router plane in from the side, the blade was going more or less straight in.