Re: Some logical considerations
TomD
"It is claimed that one must "tooth" veneer to get it to stick yet a crisply planed surface is the goal for edge gluing where maximum mechanical strength is desired."
I do sand or roughen these surfaces at times, though that is most often for stuff where I don't want to be outside practices that have been used with low return rates. Lutherie being one area where I tow the line just to be sure I am not going to get results outside of the norm. But the point being that some do joint with sandpaper for some reason. I think you can buy a machine that does that.
One thing that is not the same is that almost by definition, veneering is to a dissimilar material or one with a dissimilar cut. So there could be something about that that is different from the situation where the edge joint is being made.
"However, if it is machine cut veneer then toothing is unnecessary. Just sawed veneer needs toothing."
There are a lot of different veneer types, but rotary cut, which is pretty common is rough already on the glue surface due to micro fracturing as the piece is being unwound, as with a plane shaving in similar circumstances.
"Hide glue sticks tenaciously to glass, the ultimate in smoothness."
Not a comparable material, and the glue used for that purpose is a lot stronger.
"A well functioning adhesive does not require a mechanical interlocking to achieve a bond as strong as the material in the adhesive and substrate. Two optically flat surfaces are most ideal."
That may well be true, though for what. There are different purposes to things, breaking in an adjacent region is not a sufficient test.
"It seems to me that there is only one valid conclusion based on these facts."
That we still don't have enough information. Past practice may be the result of some deep truth, or just how they did stuff.