New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

prepping glue joint

Posts

Re: prepping glue joint

#26

Re: the various functions of glue

William Duffield

Good points, Tom. The planing of difficult grain to reduce the depth of the tear-out is one we hear all the time, and is emphasized by those who offer toothing blades for sale. The advantage of increased thermal mass to extend the working time of hot hide glue does not come so quickly to mind. It would be especially important in a shop that is not heated, or where the wood itself could not be preheated before the glue-up. I suspect the species of wood would make a difference as well--heat should transfer from the HHG to dense, oily tropicals more quickly than to lighter, more porous woods.

Re: prepping glue joint

#27

Re: On second question, did either Moxon *LINK*

William Duffield

There are many references to the use of toothing planes and irons in Roubo. This is only one of the detailed descriptions and illustrations on both the process and the tools of toothing, from To Make As Perfectly As Possible, Roubo on Marquetry, but it might be the most important to our discussion here today.

"After the appropriate wood veneer has been sawn in the manner that I discussed previously, page 801, one replanes them with a toothing plane as much for giving them an equal thickness as for giving them a grooved texture, so that they are in a better condition to absorb the glue with which one uses to adhere the veneer."

There's a lot more information in this book, but I shouldn't copy any more of it here. This translation of Roubo is copyrighted by Don Williams and Lost Art Press. IMHO, it and the further volumes to come are probably the most important works in English on traditional woodworking techniques.

Of course, Roubo is discussing hot hide glue. He didn't have the advantage of the availability of titebond and their R&D and marketing staff.


To Make As Perfectly As Possible

Re: prepping glue joint

#28

Re: I asked...

david weaver

..george wilson about this once, because he had mentioned to me he never had adhesion problems with glue without scuffing the surface of anything.

He said that he scuffed the veneer with a toothing plane because that's the way it had been done historically, and that was pretty much that. I got the sense that he didn't know if it provided any benefit, but he wasn't going to find out that it didn't.

Re: prepping glue joint

#29

Some logical considerations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is claimed that one must "tooth" veneer to get it to stick yet a crisply planed surface is the goal for edge gluing where maximum mechanical strength is desired.

However, if it is machine cut veneer then toothing is unnecessary. Just sawed veneer needs toothing.

Hide glue sticks tenaciously to glass, the ultimate in smoothness.

A well functioning adhesive does not require a mechanical interlocking to achieve a bond as strong as the material in the adhesive and substrate. Two optically flat surfaces are most ideal.

Sawed veneer may need smoothing. A toothing plane is the only planing device that will plane (smooth) thin stock (AKA sawed veneer) like a crotch.

It seems to me that there is only one valid conclusion based on these facts.

Re: prepping glue joint

#30

Some other considerations (a thought experiment)..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

1. Working with sawn veneer (1/16" to 1/8" thick) that's got saw tracks one side and is not freshly planed on the other side. In other words, it's been stacked on shelves for a while.

Question: To freshen the oxidized planed side, or else to level the sawn side, is it easier and faster to use a normal bench plane, or to use a toothed plane that is cutting on only half its width? Remember, you're having to clamp one end of a likely not-so-flat thin strip, and pull the plane away from the clamping--and then reverse the process to get even coverage of the veneer, going against the grain in one of those two planings. The veneer is delicate, not especially flat, and will require pull planing while clamped (or just held by hand) at the other end. I kinda suspect that the toothed blade would level the sawn side faster and surer, since you're not having to work in 0.001" shavings. And it wouldn't take the edge off your smooth plane, requiring a sooner sharpening.

2. Heat management while veneering with hot hide glue, in 1750 or in your garage. Possibly on a cold day.

Question: Is it faster to get an even spreading of glue on two mating surfaces, if those surfaces are perfectly smooth, or if they are lightly abraded? Which surfaces will wet the fastest--the perfectly smooth or the lightly abraded? And which surfaces will get the fastest surest tack, to avoid a cold join--the smooth or the lightly abraded?

Some More Modern Considerations: In my recent working with 1/8" sawn veneer (satinwood), I didn't tooth either surface. But then I was working in warm weather, without time constraints to speak of, and had access to cold liquid hide, which I used on larger sheets. My main issue was to keep the off-side of the glue-up wet long enough for the bond to set up hard--thin stock with water-based glue on one side will curl like crazy, especially if it's quartered, away from the bond. The off side has to be kept wet, and held down hard from edge to edge for a long time if you're not using hot glue.

This is all in the interest of discussion. I don't know The Truth.

Wiley

Re: prepping glue joint

#31

Re: Some logical considerations

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have limited experience in veneering and repairing veneer, but I take Andre Roubo's words seriously. He says to tooth the substrate on page 813 and to tooth the veneer on page 818. Both times he mentions the glue as a reason.

My guess, Bill is that you also have limited or maybe no experience in veneering with hide glue or restoring old veneered surfaces. Solid wood can weather dents and chips over the years, but veneer is quite vulnerable and most veneered work with any history has had restoration. The use of thin veneers and glues other than hide glue pushes a piece of furniture from a routine restoration job into something we would rather not fool with. Much furniture made today is throw away furniture.

Re: prepping glue joint

#32

Re: Some logical considerations

Rum

It seems that the most obvious advantage is that the toothed surface provides a place for excess glue and air to escape.

An analogy would be the kitchen vacuum sealers where the ribbed bags vacuum a lot easier than a smooth bag does because the air (and in the veneer case glue) can squeeze out through the gaps easier.

This probably matters more with older techniques, obviously with a foam roller and modern slow acting glues you can get a more even smear than you can hurriedly slapping on hot hide glue and a veneer press will push out a lot more air oops than you can as easily with a veneer hammer.

Re: prepping glue joint

#33

Re: Some logical considerations

TomD

"It is claimed that one must "tooth" veneer to get it to stick yet a crisply planed surface is the goal for edge gluing where maximum mechanical strength is desired."

I do sand or roughen these surfaces at times, though that is most often for stuff where I don't want to be outside practices that have been used with low return rates. Lutherie being one area where I tow the line just to be sure I am not going to get results outside of the norm. But the point being that some do joint with sandpaper for some reason. I think you can buy a machine that does that.

One thing that is not the same is that almost by definition, veneering is to a dissimilar material or one with a dissimilar cut. So there could be something about that that is different from the situation where the edge joint is being made.

"However, if it is machine cut veneer then toothing is unnecessary. Just sawed veneer needs toothing."

There are a lot of different veneer types, but rotary cut, which is pretty common is rough already on the glue surface due to micro fracturing as the piece is being unwound, as with a plane shaving in similar circumstances.

"Hide glue sticks tenaciously to glass, the ultimate in smoothness."

Not a comparable material, and the glue used for that purpose is a lot stronger.

"A well functioning adhesive does not require a mechanical interlocking to achieve a bond as strong as the material in the adhesive and substrate. Two optically flat surfaces are most ideal."

That may well be true, though for what. There are different purposes to things, breaking in an adjacent region is not a sufficient test.

"It seems to me that there is only one valid conclusion based on these facts."

That we still don't have enough information. Past practice may be the result of some deep truth, or just how they did stuff.

Re: prepping glue joint

#34

Another potential biggie...

TomD

Another thing that is important when using hide glue, and doing hammer veneering is the ability to get the veneer back down if something causes it to let go. In some cases, even hundreds of years later, the glue can be reactivated. If you have Bill's two optically smooth surfaces being brought together, you do not have much of a well of glue to reactivate if that should be necessary, or if it is necessary during construction. But toothing the surfaces would allow sufficient glue to be preserved even after the extremely high psi hammer application, that the surface can be reglued later in the piece's life.