New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

prepping glue joint

Posts

prepping glue joint

#1

prepping glue joint

Jerry Gibbs

In the latest issue of WoodenBoat, no. 240, Richard Jagels responded to a glue problem. Professor Jagels wrote in part: Another quick test is to put a drop of water on the wood surface after it is prepped for gluing. If the water droplet spreads out within 30 seconds, gluing should proceed without any problem. If the droplet remains oval and does not spread out [see photo], the glue joint will remain weak."

The original question involved original Titebond. Has anybody heard of or used this test?

Jerry Gibbs

Re: prepping glue joint

#2

Re: prepping glue joint

don stephan

Just read a description of this an hour ago in vol 1 Traditional Bowyer's Bible. The theory was that if a drop of water won't soak into the wood because of oxidation, white/yellow/hide glue won't bond well. Suggested solution was to use plane or spokeshave on the wood to expose a bit of fresh wood. Sanding was strongly discouraged, although I remember suggestion in an issue of Popular Woodworking to always sand wood lightly with I think 150 just before gluing, to expose some fresh wood.

Re: prepping glue joint

#3

needless fretting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The only events that will prevent a good bond are a rough, torn or otherwise damaged surface, or greasy contamination. All that has to happen to get a good bond is for one layer of glue molecules to wet each surface and then in turn wet one another. In detail, "wet" means the long glue molecules mingle amongst one another and become attracted(bonded) to the wood molecules.

Indeed, if water beads up on a joint to be joined there is some contamination present (oil, wax ?) that is preventing the glue from bonding to the wood molecules. A rough surface will prevent intimate contact. A torn or otherwise damaged surface will have weakened wood below the glue line and this weaned wood can fail under stress.

Each year millions of successful joints are prepared using Titebond type adhesives and machined wood surfaces.

Accurately machine your surfaces to be joined, apply glue and clamp to get intimate contact (about 200 psi recommended for hardwood). Get the joint assembled before glue begins to dry. That is all there is to it. Further diddling with joint or testing with water is proven to be unnecessary. Hand planing can be useful for fixing damaged or inaccurately machined surfaces ( presuming you are better with a hand plane than adjusting your machinery) but this step provides no further benefit to wetting.

Re: prepping glue joint

#4

Re: needless fretting

chuck

Just to be clear in my own mind...

You're saying that surfaces accurately prepared with hand planes do not need to be degraded to provide some "tooth" for stronger glue joints? Thank you.

chuck

Re: prepping glue joint

#5

Re: needless fretting

Sgian Dubh

"Accurately machine your surfaces to be joined, apply glue and clamp to get intimate contact (about 200 psi recommended for hardwood).

Bill, nothing wrong with your advice, except to say the recommendation to apply about 200 lbs psi can only be the case in limited circumstances. Specifically such pressure is only possible when it can be applied perpendicular to the faces being joined, e.g., edge gluing boards to make up a wider panel.

This is not possible with something like a mortice and tenon joint or in the case of many joints (not all) where a male part fits into a female recess of some sort. Once the shoulder line of an M&T is snug there is nothing you can do to tighten the cheeks of the mortice to the faces of the tenon, and their intimacy to one another is determined by how well the two parts are cut. Slainte.

Re: prepping glue joint

#6

Adhesive theory

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The following applies to edge joining.

Precisely prepare two optically flat surfaces on two pieces of 3" diameter steel bar stock (the 3" is from long ago memory but the number is about right). Hook one to a crane and the other to a convertible with the co-inventor of cyanoacrylate adhesive along for the ride. Add drop of Eastman 910 adhesive (equivalent to current cyanoacrylate adhesive) and join the surfaces. Allow a few minutes to cure and then lift the car. Note that in this experiment no "tooth" was employed for if the adhesive wets both surfaces "tooth" only degrades the joinery. Tooth is never a beneficial addition to a joint prepared with a proper adhesive that will wet (bond to) the surfaces.

Wood adhesives are formulated to wet wood. End of story.

I had the opportunity to ask an adhesives expert at VA Tech whether wood adhesives worked as described above or whether the adhesive needed to penetrate the wood surface to "lock" the joint mechanically. He replied that wood is so porous that it is impossible to not penetrate the cellular structure and for a mechanical as well as an adhesive bond to result.

I conclude that roughening the surfaces to be glued would only weaken the underlying wood and thereby weaken the bond. I have never seen anyone messing with a machined surface before joining in a commercial shop or factory.

For mortise and tenon joinery, and similar joints, penetration of the irregular wood surfaces is likely important to the joint strength. These surfaces just don't get close enough together over their entire surface to get a good adhesive bond.

Tip: The next step after panel gluing is to size the panel. The cut off ends are a readi-made test piece for your gluing technique. Attempt to break the joints and observe wood vs glue line failure. The failure should be mostly wood. If you are getting glue line failure it is most likely a result of poor surface mating, inadequate wetting of both surfaces with glue, or the glue surface dried before joining.

Re: prepping glue joint

#7

the various functions of glue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In a butt jointed panel the only thing holding the panel together is the strength of the glue. Hence, the adhesive must be applied and the joint machined optimally. The desired result is a glue line stronger than the yield strength of the wood. High pressure is recommended to bring the mating parts together and squeeze out excess glue to achieve maximum strength. It is a myth that a joint can be "starved" by excessive clamping pressure.(Reference: Franklin Adhesive technical staff as well as my experiments) The glue is too viscous to be thoroughly squeezed out by clamp pressure.

In mortise and tenon, dovetails, and similar joinery the strength of the joint comes from the interlocking construction of the joint. The only function of the glue should be to hold the assembly together and stiffen the assembly. Holding the joint together requires little strength from the glue. If the parts don't mate perfectly and excess glue is not squeezed out the joint will still function adequately if the wood parts are well fitted so that stress is on the wood and not the glue.

In veneering the only function of the glue is to hold the veneer onto the substrate. The assembly will typically encounter little stress pulling the veneer off the substrate. Hence, the glue does not need to stick the veneer to the substrate with the maximum strength available. Pressure only sufficient to level the applied glue is required. Fifteen to 20 psi is recommended and adequate for this task (Ref: Franklin technical manuals).

Re: prepping glue joint

#8

Re: needless fretting

don stephan

Using discrete hand tightened bar clamps on an edge to edge joint, say for a tabletop, how does one get 200 psi along the entire joint? Has anyone measured the pressure per square inch that can be generated using a Bessey K bar clamp?

Re: prepping glue joint

#9

Re: needless fretting

TomD

I don't believe it happens. In some cases you are using only a few clams because the width of the board precludes the need for more clamps, or maybe they can't be attached. So say it is 48 inches long you have 9600 pounds of pressure in there, and only 3 clamps, or 3200 per. The best glue joints need no pressure whatever with Franklin Titebond 1.

Re: prepping glue joint

#10

Re: Bulletin footnotes

TomD

Possibly you could quote the sections in Franklin's literature that you relied on and that refer to the use of Titebond 1 to assemble parts to be used in a marine environment. I'd like to get that literature.

Re: prepping glue joint

#11

Re: Bulletin footnotes

Sgian Dubh

Tom, you can find their recommendations for pressure at their website, or at least you used to be able to. I imagine it's still there. Slainte.

Re: prepping glue joint

#12

Re: needless fretting

Sgian Dubh

"Using discrete hand tightened bar clamps on an edge to edge joint, say for a tabletop, how does one get 200 psi along the entire joint?"

You probably don't. Generally I aim to space sash clamps over and under the panel roughly 150 - 200 mm (6" - 8") apart, with the last one at either end about 50 mm short of the end. After that I just suck them up tight, but not so tight that veins start bulging in the forehead. Another limitation is pressure applied might cause the panel to cup, so pressure may need to be backed off a bit to eliminate that.

As to meeting the recommended pressure given by Franklin, well that's maybe achievable in a laboratory, but probably not very likely in a busy general purpose furniture or joinery type workshop. I've even stuck boards together successfully with nothing much more than a sprung joint, a bit of PVA (or aliphatic resin), a swift rub and a single clamp at the centre of the panel's length. Half an hour to an hour after glue up the panel's gone over a surface planer and through a thicknesser. I wouldn't recommend it as normal practice ... but if needs must, sometimes you've got to take a bit of a risk, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: prepping glue joint

#13

Re: Bulletin footnotes

David Charlesworth

Bruce Hoadley's book "Understanding wood" gives some approximate forces applied by different types of clamps.

He says that since the small workshop is unlikely to achieve optimal pressure, a good joint can be obtained by paying attention to the other factors.

Chemical cleanliness, recently worked surfaces cut with sharrp tools, i.e. not clapped out router cutters, good flatness, good glue spreading and perhaps double spreading to ensure both surfaces are wetted.

It is also a great book generally.

best wishes

David

Re: prepping glue joint

#14

Poor test

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think it is a poor test. I tried the test this morning with a number of woods. I found that the species of wood was a much bigger factor than freshness of cut in how the droplet behaved on the surface. For some woods, the droplet just sat on the surface whether the surface was planed more than a year ago or just seconds before. For other woods, the droplet was absorbed whether the wood was freshly planed or was planed years ago.

Jerry, I don't know what you actually mean by "prepped for gluing". I have glued only hand planed surfaces for the last forty years. I have apparently successfully glued many woods that would fail Mr. Jagels test.

Re: prepping glue joint

#15

Re: needless fretting

Tony - Memphis

Seems like there was an article in FWW that tested various clamps and their clamping ability. Of course, that is subject to the abuser/applier! Not sure how one could test with the different handle styles and screw sizes/types. I guess you could use the same person and tell them to give it al they had every time. Or perhaps one could measure the torque applied and keep that consistent? Not a trivial test realy. Not sure it would be worth doing, but....

Tony

Re: prepping glue joint

#16

Re: needless fretting

Tony - Memphis

Fine Woodworking Tools and Shops 2010. The article reports that the parallel clamps they tested were able to apply between 325 to 700 lbs of force (NOT pressure!). Besseys were able to apply 650lbs. I'd have to do some noodling to translate that into psi, but my experience is that they apply more than I need! Being a bit heavy handed has resulted in some less than desired results! Oops.

Tony

Re: prepping glue joint

#17

Amen to those recommendations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Franklin recommendations are for production gluing on clamp racks. These clamps are tightened with a torque limiting air driven wrench. One presumes that if Franklin recommends 200 psi that these clamps deliver it. They employ an acme thread like the traditional, but now old fashioned Hargrave clamps, which have a similar hand cranked acme screw. Hence, I suppose the Hargrave clamp, ubiquitous in shops 50 years ago and mine, is similarly able to deliver this pressure. A clamp that can deliver 600 pounds of force can exert 200 psi over an area of 3 square inches (600 pounds divided by 3 square inches equals 200 pounds/square inches. ) (Note, divide both the numbers and the units and you get the resulting number with the correct units) To continue the calculations- 600 pound clamps spaced 8" can not deliver 200 psi to a panel composed of 3/4" boards. I'll check when I get a chance but I think these clamps are capable of greatly more than 600 pounds of force.) I'm off the IWF Atlanta in a few minutes where this information is available in abundance at the clamp vendors).

Recall that the function of the clamp is to bring the surfaces together and squeeze out excess glue. If the surfaces are perfectly prepared, the glue is applied uniformly and the glue has not started to dry and thicken, then a force well short of the maximum that Franklin recommends will be adequate.

The main point of all this discussion is that you can't apply too much force as far as the glue is concerned. Clamp or panel flexing, etc. can limit the amount one can tighten the clamps, but don't fret the glue.

Re: prepping glue joint

#18

Aged wood surfaces not detrimental

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Any chemistry that may occur on a wood surface simply exposed to air and light will only increase the ability of the surface to be wet by a water based glue. Contamination by oil or other hydrophobic substances during storage is another issue. If such contamination is suspected then the surface for gluing should be redone.

Panel preparation is trivial and should not be complicated by myths and unnecessary diddling- accurate machining by hand and or machine, wet both surfaces with glue, assemble before the glue surface begins to dry, apply adequate clamp pressure to bring the surfaces together and squeeze out excess glue. Done.

Why the necessity to squeeze out the excess glue? Typical glue is mostly water. If a thick layer of glue dries, the dried mass is mostly air, which has no strength. The joint will be held together by a glue line resembling styrofoam. The glue part will be strong, the air part will not be. It is the same problem as gluing end grain except in this case the end grain is mostly air.

Re: prepping glue joint

#19

Re: the various functions of glue

William Duffield

I was going to ask two, perhaps rhetorical, questions about veneering, but your last paragraph basically answers the first one, which addresses the disparity between the recommended 200 psi and the 15 psi maximum that can be applied by a vacuum bagging.

In veneering the only function of the glue is to hold the veneer onto the substrate. The assembly will typically encounter little stress pulling the veneer off the substrate. Hence, the glue does not need to stick the veneer to the substrate with the maximum strength available. Pressure only sufficient to level the applied glue is required. Fifteen to 20 psi is recommended and adequate for this task.

The second question is related to the current practice of preparing sawn veneers and the substrate surface with a toothing plane, which is gaining popularity among reproducers of period furniture. Under which veneering conditions would toothing the surface be an advantage, and which conditions would it be of no advantage, or a detriment?

One condition is obviously detrimental: You would not attempt to tooth the back of a modern sliced veneer because toothing it would destroy the veneer. Other cases are open for discussion.

Re: prepping glue joint

#20

data from Franklin manuals`

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These recommendations are for production clamping on a clamping carriage

Clamp spacing- 4" from ends , 12 to 14" between clamps

Pressure- 100-150 for soft woods, 125 to 175 for medium, 175 to 250 for hard (maple)

The clamps used in the clamping carriages are easily capable of over 2000 psi

Re: prepping glue joint

#21

Re: the various functions of glue

TomD

One thing toothing planes are used for is to cut surfaces that can't be planed with other planes. So they are popular with veneer, and stuff like Osage. Keeping in mind that toothing planes have been around longer than certain modern trends in finish plaining.

The other possibility is for veneering with hide glue which was the main game at one time. More glue is good for maintaining heat until the whole mess can be pushed home. More tooth means more glue, could even help hold the piece in place while working it. Some glues are like lubing with grease.

Re: prepping glue joint

#22

Re: needless fretting - what about this

TomD

I just read the article, coincidentally I was sent the issue today. I used to subscribe but gave up after several hundred issues, or something. Strangely you are not at odds. The article is actually about woodworking at -30 degrees, and odd discolorations. You say, Bill, that wetting is key. Jagels, an emeritus prof of forest biology, for what that may be worth, says the same thing, and just provides a test for testing untried species, or samples, or samples that have failed to glue effectively. He is not suggesting that this will add anything to the routine 3000th panel, unless perhaps what has always worked stopped working.

On the mater of hand planing, I would think your points, Bill, support the idea that hand planing provides a superior bond. Rotary cutters often leave a surface that will not be in full contact. Linear cutters, be they power on hand tools will allow planar surfaces to be produced. If you reject the idea that the smoothness of the surfaces is a problem, then are you not for all practical purposes, relative to max bond strength, in the hand tool camp, since surface contact will be maximized, and the smoothness is not a problem?

Of course "practically" for a coffee table it may not mater which preparation method one uses since the joint may not be heavily tested. For today, I am edgy about crap that falls apart, and there are conventional uses for Titebond 1 like guitar bridges that may require better performance. Failure outside the glue line is not alone a sophisticated or meaningful test in many situations.

Re: prepping glue joint

#23

Toothing planes are for smoothing figure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The purpose of a toothng plane is to enable the smoothing of sawed figured thin stock....period. Toothing has no beneficial role in enabling veneer to stick.

Hide glue sticks to glass, so much so that it will fracture it upon shrinking. Why would one imagine needing to roughen a surface to get glue to stick? This issue was settled in some previous discussion here.

Re: prepping glue joint

#24

On second question, did either Moxon

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

or Roubo or other old reference mention toothing planes for veneer? I don't recall any mention of veneer in Moxon (but then my memory is far from perfect :) ), but what about Roubo or other older references?

I like to try to figure out why the old techniques like toothing were used--in the context of their times--as opposed to figuring out whether the ancients had it right or wrong. Time was money for those folks (who weren't slaves or prisoners) and I don't think they would have wasted time on something that didn't pay for itself.

I wonder whether the toothed surface enhanced the visual indication of flatness in a shop where lighting was limited. Or maybe physically worked better, i.e., sawn veneer gripped faster and stayed put better under the veneer hammer, or something like that.

Smith's Key (1816) shows a toothing iron, and references a toothing plane. The Edward Preston catalog (1909) advertises several widths of toothing irons, which are of course uniformly more expensive--half again as expensive--as a regular iron of the same width.

Not arguing with Bill's characterization of what toothing would be used for now, but rather am interested in why our elders used them in veneer practice or for preparing figured wood for smooth planing.

Wiley

Re: prepping glue joint

#25

Re: On second question, did either Moxon

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am not much of a veneer worker, but workers I know do use a toothing plane and I have seen toothing marks on both surfaces of old work. Andre Roubo mentions using a toothing plane on the substrate for veneering for better adhesion. Presumably the substrate was not heavily figured wood. Here is a passage from Section III of Part III, Menuisier ebeniste


Here is a plate from that section showing a marquetry panel in progress, the type of work Roubo was familiar with. Andre himself did the engraving for this plate.