Re: needless fretting - what about this
TomD
I just read the article, coincidentally I was sent the issue today. I used to subscribe but gave up after several hundred issues, or something. Strangely you are not at odds. The article is actually about woodworking at -30 degrees, and odd discolorations. You say, Bill, that wetting is key. Jagels, an emeritus prof of forest biology, for what that may be worth, says the same thing, and just provides a test for testing untried species, or samples, or samples that have failed to glue effectively. He is not suggesting that this will add anything to the routine 3000th panel, unless perhaps what has always worked stopped working.
On the mater of hand planing, I would think your points, Bill, support the idea that hand planing provides a superior bond. Rotary cutters often leave a surface that will not be in full contact. Linear cutters, be they power on hand tools will allow planar surfaces to be produced. If you reject the idea that the smoothness of the surfaces is a problem, then are you not for all practical purposes, relative to max bond strength, in the hand tool camp, since surface contact will be maximized, and the smoothness is not a problem?
Of course "practically" for a coffee table it may not mater which preparation method one uses since the joint may not be heavily tested. For today, I am edgy about crap that falls apart, and there are conventional uses for Titebond 1 like guitar bridges that may require better performance. Failure outside the glue line is not alone a sophisticated or meaningful test in many situations.