Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I think you're right, Derek. I find my squat, bulbous ones much clumsier for marking with the grain a line to be cut or sawn to. But that brings up deeper rhetorical questions: When do you use a scratch awl for this purpose? It seems that in most cases a marking gauge, or the nicker on a plow or rabbet plane would perform this function. Wouldn't it be more efficient to use a striking knife, with a knife edge on one end and an awl point on the other?
As Stephen noted last night, IIRC, he gets a whole lot more use out of his brad awl, and that mostly for making starter holes for screws. OTOH, I sometimes use my bird cage awl for starting screws, but my weapon of choice is a VIX bit for hinges or a self tapping Kreg pocket hole screw.
He also quipped that he doesn't build bird cages, implying that he found little use for a bird cage awl.
Hi Bill
Both scratch awl and marking knives are marking tools (duh). I use a scratch awl freehand (such as marking a position, either with a dot, or scribing alongside). I use a knife against an edge, and rarely freehand (such as against a square, a rule or a dovetail tail). Unless one uses the point of a knife, it is likely that the position will be inaccurate since the line created then needs to be exactly square, and which it rarely is in my hand. It is so much easier to mark a dot accurately.
I do not have much experience with brad awls. I assume that the name comes from the brad/nail and that, therefore, their original intended use was to create a hole for a brad. A bit rough-and-ready 
Everyone should build bird cages
Then you would discover the beauty of a good bird cage awl. Sharp, defined edges work like chisels to cleanly sever fibres and create a neat, accurate hole for a screw or drill bit.
The picture of my birdcage awl is poor. The shaft has since been ground to a profile more like this one by Czech Edge ..

Indeed, I have just ordered a carbide kit (shaft and ferrule) from Bob at Czech Edge, to which I will add my own handle - I want one that is a simple, wider bulb, that fits my palm, and can be comfortably twisted from side-to-side. A high sided handle may involve using the wrist more and downforce less.
Regards from Perth
Derek