New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Posts

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Stephen Shepherd

It is Tuesday and once again we gather to discuss HAND TOOLS and related subjects, tonight's topic is the awl, the brad awl, the scratch awl and the silly little bird cage awl.

The fun and frolic starts promptly at 9:30 o'clock PM Eastern Time and runs for one scheduled hour. Just click on CHAT ROOM on the left and join in.

Awl are welcome, hope to see yawl there.

Stephen Shepherd

Host - Hand Tool Chat

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#2

Re: This one is sure to be a hoot!

William Duffield

One of mine:


and some of Stephen's:



Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#3

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

William Duffield

Here's my current awl arsenal.


Left to right:

New hand forged combo awl and striking knife (SAPFM special);

Combo awl and striking knife made from a spade bit, snakewood handle;

Antique Goodell-Pratt

Chester Tool Works bird cage awl with tulipwood handle;

Loxahatchee Toolworks olive with compression nut ferrule. This is the one in my previous post. In 12 years the olive has lost a lot of its color. Every time I drop it, it gets shorter. Recycled brittle Chinese steel, incorrectly tempered.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#4

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Matt Robinette

I wish I could stay for the chat but 3:30 will be here soon.But here is a pic of the ones I have. They are quite pedestrian but get the job done. I use them for center punch ,caulking gun clearing to scratch awl on aluminum,steel or maybe even wood. The Buck Bros. is maybe the least abused. ;)

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#5

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Bob Entwisle in NJ


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#6

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

For discussion? Are the squat handles on many scratch awls incorrect for their use, or how does one hold this tool in use?

I hold a scratch awl like a pencil or a marking knife ...


Bird cage awls, on the other hand, require down force, and are pushed with the heel of the hand. Therefore the handle is squat.


(Not a good picture of the bevels on the end of the awl)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#7

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

William Duffield

Are your two Craftsman awls (the blue ones) originally screw drivers that you've modified, or did they begin life as awls?

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#8

Re: Brad Awl Question for Stephen *LINK*

William Duffield

Are these brad awls that you show on your website and blog, whose blades are kinked, intended to be cranked, like a really short throw brace?


img

Full Chisel Blog - Hudson Bay Company trade awls

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#9

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Matt Robinette

Awl shucks the top left blue handle is a turned down #1 Phillips I had made to reach something but I don't remember what.It had liquid tape on it so i assumed it was another awl.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#10

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

William Duffield

I think you're right, Derek. I find my squat, bulbous ones much clumsier for marking with the grain a line to be cut or sawn to. But that brings up deeper rhetorical questions: When do you use a scratch awl for this purpose? It seems that in most cases a marking gauge, or the nicker on a plow or rabbet plane would perform this function. Wouldn't it be more efficient to use a striking knife, with a knife edge on one end and an awl point on the other?

As Stephen noted last night, IIRC, he gets a whole lot more use out of his brad awl, and that mostly for making starter holes for screws. OTOH, I sometimes use my bird cage awl for starting screws, but my weapon of choice is a VIX bit for hinges or a self tapping Kreg pocket hole screw.

He also quipped that he doesn't build bird cages, implying that he found little use for a bird cage awl.

…trying to find the answers to life's persistent questions. :D

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#11

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think you're right, Derek. I find my squat, bulbous ones much clumsier for marking with the grain a line to be cut or sawn to. But that brings up deeper rhetorical questions: When do you use a scratch awl for this purpose? It seems that in most cases a marking gauge, or the nicker on a plow or rabbet plane would perform this function. Wouldn't it be more efficient to use a striking knife, with a knife edge on one end and an awl point on the other?

As Stephen noted last night, IIRC, he gets a whole lot more use out of his brad awl, and that mostly for making starter holes for screws. OTOH, I sometimes use my bird cage awl for starting screws, but my weapon of choice is a VIX bit for hinges or a self tapping Kreg pocket hole screw.

He also quipped that he doesn't build bird cages, implying that he found little use for a bird cage awl.

Hi Bill

Both scratch awl and marking knives are marking tools (duh). I use a scratch awl freehand (such as marking a position, either with a dot, or scribing alongside). I use a knife against an edge, and rarely freehand (such as against a square, a rule or a dovetail tail). Unless one uses the point of a knife, it is likely that the position will be inaccurate since the line created then needs to be exactly square, and which it rarely is in my hand. It is so much easier to mark a dot accurately.

I do not have much experience with brad awls. I assume that the name comes from the brad/nail and that, therefore, their original intended use was to create a hole for a brad. A bit rough-and-ready :)

Everyone should build bird cages :) Then you would discover the beauty of a good bird cage awl. Sharp, defined edges work like chisels to cleanly sever fibres and create a neat, accurate hole for a screw or drill bit.

The picture of my birdcage awl is poor. The shaft has since been ground to a profile more like this one by Czech Edge ..


Indeed, I have just ordered a carbide kit (shaft and ferrule) from Bob at Czech Edge, to which I will add my own handle - I want one that is a simple, wider bulb, that fits my palm, and can be comfortably twisted from side-to-side. A high sided handle may involve using the wrist more and downforce less.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#12

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

William Duffield

…to which I will add my own handle - I want one that is a simple, wider bulb, that fits my palm…

Do you mean like the handle that Dave Anderson of Chester Toolworks puts on his birdcage awls? :)

I got mine from Chester (ref. pic in earlier post), but it's only O1 steel, like Czeck Edge's regular awls. I guess you needed to special order your carbide kit, but it's not difficult to estimate how much he would charge for it. Czeck Edge makes really pretty handles, but I've always questioned whether their shape was optimal.

I recommend that you put a flat on one side of your handle, to inhibit it from rolling off your bench, and shattering the carbide tip. I learned that the hard way.

I found an old review and discussion of the Czeck Edge awl on Rob Porcaro's Heartwood blog, with a link to a discussion on another forum, all with positive things to say about it.

http://www.rpwoodwork.com/blog/2009/12/23/ok-tools-and-excellent-tools/

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#13

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Do you mean like the handle that Dave Anderson of Chester Toolworks puts on his birdcage awls? :)

Hi William

No - that is very similar to the one I have already. I have a new design in mind.

I will post it when the kit arrives and the birdcage awl is made.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#14

In praise of brad awls

Patrick Gibbons

I love the little tool handles that were made up through WWII. While these had other handy tools such as screwdrivers and chisels, they were filled with brad awls, leather punch/scratch awl and a birdcage awl. I own three of these and have seen many others. The brad awls always appear to have been well used.

http://i.imgur.com/lghGXxf.jpg

From l to r these are a model from Sargent, L.L. Hull & Co., and a Horace Britton patented tool handle.


img

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#15

Re: In praise of brad awls

Patrick Gibbons

It makes no sense to me these are no longer made. They fit the hand well, are extremely functional and provide a true economy of space. Their larger cousins, while fun to play with, are not nearly as utilitarian as the small awl-sized tools. I need to make some of the missing tools. But my three handles together are missing only about five tools. Brad awls are a quick way to start a screw or nail. They are more precise than a birdcage awl, when that is needed.

Of course multi tools such as these are still made. Just not as elegantly.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

#16

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Awls

William Duffield

I'm looking forward to the results of your experiment, especially if they will help us improve the ergonomics of our tools.

What wood are you planning to use for the handle?