Re: All true, and
TomD
Good points
"1. I find myself taking more shavings than I want to, to get the perfect full-width shaving the length of both boards."
I don't really see that, because the wider footprint, makes getting full width shavings easier or no more difficult. This is basically a difficulty issue, which disappears with practice, becoming a who cares difference in time.
"2. Match planing doubles--makes a mirror image--of any imperfection in the straightness. For example, any 'sprungness' is doubled-"
I am not sure what you are saying here, are you saying there are situations where you would spring only one side, which could make sense. I can dial in any amount of spring I want, so I don't really know why I would need to do it to only one side, but maybe it would be a reasonable way to proceed. I haven't needed it, but now that you mention it... The only problem I have with spring is getting so fine that I am overpolishing wood. There are always ways around that...
"-even though you're doing it on purpose, it's easier to fine tune going board by board than when doing both boards in the same pass. I find it more difficult to detail the ends of the board, where I want a stopped semi-final or final cut 1/2" in from both ends to ensure the very ends are in compression."
Another difficulty argument, I think this would soon pass with minuscule amounts of practice, sorta at the point where you note the need the problem should disappear. I mean we are talking hand planes here. This is as much "hand work" or workmanship of risk as running boards through a table saw, or less.
"3. You can't test the boards against each other as you go. This means that if, after dismounting the very carefully clamped sandwich, it isn't perfect for whatever reason, you get to do the whole thing again as though you hadn't done anything--a complete start over, and with width taken out of both boards. With single boards, if there is a minor imperfection, it can be quickly spotted and dealt with on one board or the other."
Redoing stuff is not a big deal, the processes are so fast, hard to get excited, but one thing I would say is that you should be able to get all the feedback you need from the plane. It is an exquisite straight edge, there is nothing else like it, so why one would need to fit the boards together... I don't pre-fit dovetails, and it isn't because I am so great at it, I just don't see the upside. I sure am not going to fit butt joints.
"By the way, more and more, I find myself shooting rather than vertical edge-joining, even though I have always enjoyed the vertical method. Maybe I'm using thinner boards…."
Both are useful for sure. Not all that sure I believe shooting is more accurate, or faster. Not that you suggested either. There is a lot that can go wrong in those methods, and of course you can shoot and match plane at the same time.