New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

Posts

Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#1

Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

Tony Wilkins

So I've seen a few places that jointing with a bevel blade will help return edges to square. Last night I went back to read Wearing's Essential Woodworker and noticed that he recommends a flat blade and using the lateral adjust to take down the high side. I had a flat blade in my #7 so I decide to try the Wearing method. It worked ok but made the plane a little harder to push and the cuts looked a little more ragged to me.

So has anybody spent time with both methods? What are the pro's and cons of each?

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#2

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Tony and all,

I suggest using a slightly cambered blade in your try plane, and do not angle the blade at any time. Instead, run a small square down the edge, forming a mental picture of where the high spots are--if one side is higher than the other, say, and then the highline crosses over to the other side, center your plane on the highline and follow it down one side and then cross over with it to the other. Then check progress with the square. If there is no particular highline, then go down the center line. While doing this, work from the center of the board out towards the ends, so that every stroke is correcting simultaneously for flat and square.

The process of correcting for square will teach the muscle/eye memory of when the plane is being held vertical.

The shaving itself tells you a lot about how you're doing--watch the shaving come up, and it also will tell you the evolving condition of flat and square.

Wiley

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#3

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

David Charlesworth

Tony, are you sure you are in the right book?

Bob Wearing shows how a cambered blade is used to square an edge.

I believe Hampton may have mentioned the other (heretical) way, which makes no sense at all to me. What does Hampton think we will do with a twisted edge? I don't think we have enough hands for that.

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#4

You're right David

Tony Wilkins

Sorry to impugn Wearing. I went back and read his section on squaring a true edge and it does in fact talk about using the bevel to take down a high side. Now I've got to figure out who I was reading that suggested the other (haven't read Hampton). Well the good news is that the square iron I used was square because it was new so I can go back and bevel it now.

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#5

It is in Wearing after all and I'm confused

Tony Wilkins

I found the reference further on when talking about jointing the top of the table project. I'm a bit confused to be honest about the difference in situation and technique between the two. It is on page 107 (in my iPad version). He recommends a curved blade for surfaces and a flat for jointing - since all of the blade won't be used.

What am I missing here?

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#6

Re: It is in Wearing after all and I'm confused

David Charlesworth

Tony,

You are right, he does mention straight blade and lateral adjust for long edge joints.

I have always used a slightly cambered blade, as this makes for an easily understandable method of correcting squareness and wind.

I could follow up with one shaving from a straight blade, but have never bothered. The minute hollow of width does not seem to have any adverse effect. Much of this is probably straightened out with the clamping force.

One example where straight blade is essential is in "match planing", where the edges of both boards are planed at the same time. Here, errors of squareness will cancel each other out.

best wishes,

David

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#7

So what about match planing?

Tony Wilkins

David et al

So is there a consensus on match planing yay or nay? I've been doing it with some success but is there a downside?

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#8

Re: So what about match planing?

William Duffield

There are always compromises. Match planing may force you to go to a wider, and possibly longer and heavier plane, which can be more difficult to control. Just setting up the boards for match planing is more difficult, and takes longer than planing them individually, since you need to precisely match their heights as you clamp them in your vise. With long boards, supporting the other end on a board jack can also be a problem, since the dog only supports one of the boards, and the narrower board can easily slip under the weight and force of the plane. There are work-arounds, for example using a pair of hand screws on the ends, but that is an extra complication and it takes extra time, which you might better spend mastering the skill of squaring the boards individually. Another work-around uses a second, sliding, removable leg vise to secure the other end.

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#9

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

Michael Brady

I'm confused by the semantics in this thread. Aren't all blades beveled, or have I missed that topic? I can think of only straight bevels and cambered bevels...and how they each may be used in jointing the edges of boards. It sounds like the original poster used the lateral adjuster to skew the blade in an effort to correct incorrect jointing technique. Sorry to be dense about this.

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#10

Terminology drift

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've noticed, too, that people seem to be using the term "beveled" when they mean "cambered."

I've understood the term "bevel" to apply to the angle ground on the edge of the blade/iron that creates a sharp edge; thus present on all plane irons.

"Camber," as used in this context, then refers to whether there's a curve in the edge when viewed with the iron flat on the bench or held straight up for inspection.

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#11

All true, and

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

1. I find myself taking more shavings than I want to, to get the perfect full-width shaving the length of both boards.

2. Match planing doubles--makes a mirror image--of any imperfection in the straightness. For example, any 'sprungness' is doubled--even though you're doing it on purpose, it's easier to fine tune going board by board than when doing both boards in the same pass. I find it more difficult to detail the ends of the board, where I want a stopped semi-final or final cut 1/2" in from both ends to ensure the very ends are in compression.

3. You can't test the boards against each other as you go. This means that if, after dismounting the very carefully clamped sandwich, it isn't perfect for whatever reason, you get to do the whole thing again as though you hadn't done anything--a complete start over, and with width taken out of both boards. With single boards, if there is a minor imperfection, it can be quickly spotted and dealt with on one board or the other.

By the way, more and more, I find myself shooting rather than vertical edge-joining, even though I have always enjoyed the vertical method. Maybe I'm using thinner boards….

Wiley

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#12

Camber was my meaning


Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#13

Eureka

Tony Wilkins

I have found it. Beveled blade and the edge of a beech panel for my Dutch chest = nice square and straight edge!

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#14

Re: Terminology drift

TomD

I think you are right, but I do not know why "curved" which everyone understands failed to suit.

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#15

Re: It is in Wearing after all and I'm confused

TomD

"I have always used a slightly cambered blade, as this makes for an easily understandable method of correcting squareness and wind."

This method must work, and many seem to find it easy to use. That said, it is a hollow edge, not a square one, and as others have said, maybe the time would be better spent, just learning how to make a square one. I fail to see, at a minimum, what would be worse about an edge that is square and true. And given that the curved edge is not in any way necessary to the curved edge method, I don't really see the point.

"I could follow up with one shaving from a straight blade, but have never bothered. The minute hollow of width does not seem to have any adverse effect. Much of this is probably straightened out with the clamping force."

Not sure I buy that. how much force, what species of wood. what consistency of results, you are going to get huge pressure in some areas and less in others. The difference would largely seem to be adhesives that are more forgiving.

"One example where straight blade is essential is in "match planing", where the edges of both boards are planed at the same time. Here, errors of squareness will cancel each other out."

I think this is an essential technique. There is always a suggestion in some quarters that some gross inaccuracies are being covered up by a sloppy technique. The reality can be pretty much perfectly square edges made by someone who is just as good at squaring an edge as anyone, and a lot better at not leaving it hollowed out. Yet outcomes can still be improved by cancelling out any differences with match planing. I use this techique, or shooting, to make panels that require no clamps. Which I prefer to straightening things out with clamps.

Knowing what works in a given situation is what counts to me, and obviously for many the curved blade is that thing. But I doubt very much your edge jointing would suffer one iota if a law prohibited curved edges on planes, it would be just another thing to make work.

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#16

Re: All true, and

TomD

Good points

"1. I find myself taking more shavings than I want to, to get the perfect full-width shaving the length of both boards."

I don't really see that, because the wider footprint, makes getting full width shavings easier or no more difficult. This is basically a difficulty issue, which disappears with practice, becoming a who cares difference in time.

"2. Match planing doubles--makes a mirror image--of any imperfection in the straightness. For example, any 'sprungness' is doubled-"

I am not sure what you are saying here, are you saying there are situations where you would spring only one side, which could make sense. I can dial in any amount of spring I want, so I don't really know why I would need to do it to only one side, but maybe it would be a reasonable way to proceed. I haven't needed it, but now that you mention it... The only problem I have with spring is getting so fine that I am overpolishing wood. There are always ways around that...

"-even though you're doing it on purpose, it's easier to fine tune going board by board than when doing both boards in the same pass. I find it more difficult to detail the ends of the board, where I want a stopped semi-final or final cut 1/2" in from both ends to ensure the very ends are in compression."

Another difficulty argument, I think this would soon pass with minuscule amounts of practice, sorta at the point where you note the need the problem should disappear. I mean we are talking hand planes here. This is as much "hand work" or workmanship of risk as running boards through a table saw, or less.

"3. You can't test the boards against each other as you go. This means that if, after dismounting the very carefully clamped sandwich, it isn't perfect for whatever reason, you get to do the whole thing again as though you hadn't done anything--a complete start over, and with width taken out of both boards. With single boards, if there is a minor imperfection, it can be quickly spotted and dealt with on one board or the other."

Redoing stuff is not a big deal, the processes are so fast, hard to get excited, but one thing I would say is that you should be able to get all the feedback you need from the plane. It is an exquisite straight edge, there is nothing else like it, so why one would need to fit the boards together... I don't pre-fit dovetails, and it isn't because I am so great at it, I just don't see the upside. I sure am not going to fit butt joints.

"By the way, more and more, I find myself shooting rather than vertical edge-joining, even though I have always enjoyed the vertical method. Maybe I'm using thinner boards…."

Both are useful for sure. Not all that sure I believe shooting is more accurate, or faster. Not that you suggested either. There is a lot that can go wrong in those methods, and of course you can shoot and match plane at the same time.

Re: Bevel Blade versus using the lateral adjust

#17

Re: It is in Wearing after all

David Charlesworth

It is important for people to choose techniques which they are comfortable with, and which work.

There are usually several choices.

I am intrigued with the amount of energy that is wasted coming up with theoretical objections to to techniques which have not been tried.

For instance, most of the objections to the ruler trick, have been made by people who have not tried it!

David Charlesworth