New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

first spoon and a related gouge question

Posts

first spoon and a related gouge question

#1

first spoon and a related gouge question

vamatt

I made my first two spoons in the past two weeks. Not entirely created with hand tools as I didn't realize how hard it is to carve dry cherry and maple. I have a couple of Del Stubbs knives, but it was quite slow carving out the bowl.

Since I do not have any green wood now, but plenty of dry wood I was thinking of buying a couple of carving tools to rough out and shape the hollow portion of the bowl. any suggestion on a gouge that I can use a mallet on in dry cherry and maple? Bent gouge #7 and #9 at 1/2" maybe? Also are these hard to sharpen?

also can't figure out how to post a photo from my computer. oh well.

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#2

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question *LINK*

Hank Knight

Take a look at these:


Bent Knives

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#3

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

vamatt

Thanks they look like good knives. I was thinking something more like these:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=31111&cat=1,130,43701

the henry taylor's look like i could use a mallet on them. Hand pulling the knife made only tiny cuts on the dry wood and I'll really like to rough out the material faster.

matt

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#4

Photos *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'll defer to others on the gouge question - although I'm with you on the trickiness of carving out the bowl on a spoon without the right tools. I made some birch salad spoons for my bride some years back, and the bowls were 50% of the project; the rest was simple.

On photos: Wood Central is an "open entry" site, in that you can, as you did, post without registering. However, for security reasons, you have to establish a profile before you get access to all the neat features, like posting photos from your computer. To establish a profile, go to http://www.woodcentral.com/faq/profiles.html and follow the directions. Note that, because you've posted already, you have to clear the Wood Central cookies from your computer before you start this process.

Once you've established your profile, your "post a new message/reply" window will look more or less like this (I really need to do a cleaner version of this picture):


Right above the text box, it says, "upload embedded file." The little symbol to the left of that will show the photo types/sizes permitted. Click on the "browse" box to the right; that will take you to a window where you can track down the photo on your computer and load it. There are, of course, limits and rules on photos; have a look in the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs link in the box at the top of the screen there) for information*.

Note that you place the photo where you want it. If you need to post several photos to ask a question or show off your spoons or other work, you can intersperse text and photos:"Here's the spoon overall [photo of spoon]. Now, here, you can see the problem I'm having with the bowl [photo of bowl]."

If you're having trouble with any of that, contact me. I've sent you an e-mail, so you'll have my e-mail address (which you can't see here on the forum right now, because you don't have a profile; once you do, you'll be able to see e-mail addresses for me and others who choose to put theirs up, helpful for side conversations).

Let me encourage you, as your skills progress, to post photos of your completed work. We don't get nearly enough show and tell here. They don't have to be award-winning projects; it's good to see folks developing their skills.

Bill Houghton

a Wood Central moderator

*In fact, it's a good idea to read through the FAQs in general, just to avoid surprises.


http://www.woodcentral.com/faq/profiles.html

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#5

original poster here with photos

mreagan


and

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#6

thanks Bill


Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#7

Re: original poster here with photos

Hank Knight

Nice spoons, but I think that first one could be a little bigger. ;>)

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#8

Nice work!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Great first spoons: good shapes. Thanks for showing them.

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#9

Darrell in Oakville

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

Darrell in Oakville

Roughing out spoons is best done with a hatchet. Check out the APT website for lots of greenwood information, and youtube for carving videos. Some of those guys do 90% of the spoon with their hatchet, and just the finishing work with the knives.

And you really do need to start with green wood. So much easier to carve. But I know your pain, having carved a number of spoons from dry birch, maple, and cherry.

The book on swedish spoon carving has recently been reprinted, you should see about picking one up: "Swedish Carving Techniques" by Wille Sundqvist

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#10

wife requested a "large" spoon for canning


Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#11

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

mreagan

Darrell,

Thanks! I'll check out the book. I'm really trying to find a better way to rough out the inside of the bowl on dry wood. Using the hook knife (on dry wood) made me want to give up the project...

matt

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#12

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question *LINK*

Larry Barrett

Here is a link to Country Workshops. Drew Langsner does a lot of bowl carving and carries bowl and spoon carving tools. He also has the Wille Sundqvist book and the just released DVD.

Check the store for books and tools (gouges).


http://www.countryworkshops.org/

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#13

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Matt,

I've made several spoons and ladles, and even sold some of them, all of them from seasoned hardwoods, but none recently.

Sleuthing from your posts, I deduce that you may be Matt Reagan, from Virginia. If you are located near the largest population center of that state, you might be interested in some tools imminently applicable to the carving of spoon bowls that are being offered at an old tools auction in Damascus, MD in a couple of weeks.

The organization is PATINA. www.patinatools.org

The auction announcement is here: http://www.patinatools.org/auctioninfo.asp

The auction item list is here: http://www.patinatools.org/auction_2014/2014_WebList_Sorted.html

The lot number is 169.

Back to spoon generalities: Carve the bowl first, since that operation puts the most stress on the wood stock. (There's nothing more frustrating than separating the handle from the bowl while hollowing. After you've done it once, you will understand.) If you want to use a gouge with a mallet, it is most efficient to remove the abundance of the stock across the grain, where a gouge with a larger sweep is more efficient than the smaller sweep you would use for finish shaping, with the grain.. A mallet helps a lot. Mallets do not transfer forces efficiently to bent gouges, because the gouge's handle tends to flex, a lot. You would be better off using straight gouges, especially for the rough stock removal.

For finishing the bowl, inside and out, a selection of curved card scrapers of various radii are very useful.

For help in spoon carving techniques and inspiration, check out Barry Gordon, , e.g., this page on his web site: http://barrygordon.com/making-spoons-guide/

For advise on sharpening gouges, you can't find a better instructor than Mary May, and Chris Pye's books and videos on the subject are also very useful.

If your philosophies do not limit you to hand tools, my preferences for roughing in the bowl are Kutzall burrs. Of course, use of a bandsaw for rough shaping is de regueur.

For example, http://www.ebay.com/itm/like/281266661119?lpid=82 and http://www.artcotools.com/kutzall-bur-3-4-dia.-bn34.html

To drive these, I use a 4" Makita GA4530 4-1/2" angle grinder and a pneumatic Grex AR368, followed by a Grex AOS368 angle die grinder/random orbital sander for sanding.

http://www.amazon.com/Grex-MR368-Air-Powered-Inline-Grinder/dp/B000HHRL80

Note that I am providing the links to these products only to illustrate the types of tools I use, and I DO NOT endorse any of these particular merchants. They just happend to be the first examples that Google found for me. I bought the tools I use at the Orange Borg and at a woodworking retailer where I used to work.

If you go this route, wear your eye protection, hearing protection, breathing protection, and heavy gloves.

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#14

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

Patrick Gibbons

Check out Paul Sellers' blog. Many entries on spoon carving. http://paulsellers.com/2013/08/spoon-making-carving-out-the-bowl/

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#15

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

Paul in NJ

Knives, both straight and bent work best with green wood. The difference in effort between working green and dry is like night and day. I would recomend a 7 or 8 gouge 9 (6 or 7 English) sweep about an inch wide. A cabinetmakers gouge like the one pictured below works fine too. You can clean up with one of those curved scrapers that look like a french curve. You can use spokeshaves to good effect for the handle and outside of the bowls. The trick is holding the spoon while you shape. If you leave the handle long it helps a little holdig it in a vise or shave horse.

Paul



Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#16

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

This is a salad serving set I made a couple years ago as Christmas stocking stuffers. (The women-folk in my family get to pick what they want and I get to pick style and everything else) The wood is seasoned walnut. The gouge is a 8/13 Swiss Made from Woodcraft. I just walked in, told the guy what I was doing, and he said this is what most people were using for making spoons. It worked pretty well. I think I might like one with a little less sweep.

Anyway, the gouge took care of almost all the heavy stock removal and even the finer work, but the final smoothing was done with a gooseneck scraper and sandpaper.

I've never worked with green wood, so I can't comment on bent knives, although they're next on my list of stuff to get.


Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#17

Thank you and follow on question

mreagan

Wow, what a great number of responses. Thanks to everybody who chimed in. I really enjoyed watching the Paul Sellers video and seeing each individuals means and methods. I'm waiting on a couple of carving chisels to arrive.

One follow on question. I'd like to pick up a spokeshave but have no experience with one. I can pick up a new spokeshave now, or sell some of my work and get the veritas set of three hopefully by years ends. So the question is are the concave/convex spokeshaves ever used in spoon making? Or will these two be relegated to the tool cabinet never to see the light of day? I love the idea of antique but I really don't have a lot of shop time to figure out how to renovate and make it work. Anyway just looking to see if the veritas set (as there is a good cost savings as buying the set) is worth it the wait. FWIW, I'll be making spoons and ladles that have curved handles...

thanks again.

matt

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#18

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

mreagan

William,

I'd love to go. Unfortunately, I have reserve duty that weekend. how many sellers show up?

Matt

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

#19

Re: first spoon and a related gouge question

William Duffield

It depends on how you're counting. :) I'm not very good at counting, but I would guess there are often 30 to 60 cars, trucks and tables (and lots of cardboard boxes on the ground) in the parking lot with "tailgaters" selling things, about that many more sellers with one or more paid-for tables inside, and all of the people who offer "lots" for auction. Since these sellers are anonymous, it's difficult to tell how many of the auction lots are offered by the same person. Unless you need to add five hundred Stanley #5s to your collection :) , you wouldn't be disappointed.

I'm sure someone here would have better estimates than mine.