Re: Here's the issue, though..
david weaver
..the question often comes up on forums that have a lot more beginners about "what plane to buy to plane curly maple". Usually the person asking the question already has a plane that's perfectly capable of doing it, and they are quite sure that you are trolling them when you tell them that.
When you start to look to 60 degree planes and such things, you get out of the running for coarse work in any quantity, and you have:
* an iron that has substantially less edge life
* no ability plane a softwood and get anything but fuzz
* the requirement to have another plane for softwood (and that plane probably could do the same thing the 60 degree plane is doing)
* a plane that leaves a duller surface in wood than the high angle plane
So it's not necessarily a question of whether or not you can put together a pile of planes (often at a much higher price per plane) and do the same thing learning to do the cap iron brings (and that also brings in the ability to do heavy coarse work without generating huge tearout).
The question becomes whether or not someone can describe why a high angle plane, especially one with a tight mouth, is a better plane to have around. If someone can use a common pitch plane with a cap iron, the answer is that someone can't.
Most folks who master the use of both will be able to quickly see the difference in finish level in something like cherry. Does it matter, especially if you're going to sand or scrape? likely not, but there's no great reason to have a more expensive one-trick plane in the first place (and I still have several from when I believed that a shelf full of thought free plane was ideal).
This is an area where we aren't professionals, but as an otherwise professional in something else, there are situations where we literally describe the value of professional judgement over a completely paramaterized solution because the solution from professional judgment is literally better, cheaper and relies only on another professional having decent judgment to confirm it rather than parameterization of some things that don't lend themselves well to it.
This is one of those cases, especially when there are gloms of folks attempting to step in and use something very intermittently and describe their parameters and state a definitive conclusion - often one that disagrees with warren, which is dangerous territory. I've been there.