New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

Posts

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#26

Type 2 and tight mouth

David Charlesworth

If Professor Hoadley is right, his diagram of the failure of type 2 "chip", makes it clear why mouth width has no effect and can be wide. He also specifies a thin chip.

I have a favorite Stanley plane with a 0.004" mouth, Hock blade and L-N C/B, with front edge at 45 degrees.

For many years I set the C/B close but not KK close. Perhaps about 10 to 12 thou".

With a fine shaving, about 0.001", it will plane most things without tearout but not the real difficult stuff. So I disagree with the notion that a smoother always takes Type 2 shavings with a fine setting.

The KK recipe with C/B front edge at 75 degrees works amazingly well with the "wood from hell", interlocked Indian Laurel !

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#27

Re: Here's the issue, though..

david weaver

..the question often comes up on forums that have a lot more beginners about "what plane to buy to plane curly maple". Usually the person asking the question already has a plane that's perfectly capable of doing it, and they are quite sure that you are trolling them when you tell them that.

When you start to look to 60 degree planes and such things, you get out of the running for coarse work in any quantity, and you have:

* an iron that has substantially less edge life

* no ability plane a softwood and get anything but fuzz

* the requirement to have another plane for softwood (and that plane probably could do the same thing the 60 degree plane is doing)

* a plane that leaves a duller surface in wood than the high angle plane

So it's not necessarily a question of whether or not you can put together a pile of planes (often at a much higher price per plane) and do the same thing learning to do the cap iron brings (and that also brings in the ability to do heavy coarse work without generating huge tearout).

The question becomes whether or not someone can describe why a high angle plane, especially one with a tight mouth, is a better plane to have around. If someone can use a common pitch plane with a cap iron, the answer is that someone can't.

Most folks who master the use of both will be able to quickly see the difference in finish level in something like cherry. Does it matter, especially if you're going to sand or scrape? likely not, but there's no great reason to have a more expensive one-trick plane in the first place (and I still have several from when I believed that a shelf full of thought free plane was ideal).

This is an area where we aren't professionals, but as an otherwise professional in something else, there are situations where we literally describe the value of professional judgement over a completely paramaterized solution because the solution from professional judgment is literally better, cheaper and relies only on another professional having decent judgment to confirm it rather than parameterization of some things that don't lend themselves well to it.

This is one of those cases, especially when there are gloms of folks attempting to step in and use something very intermittently and describe their parameters and state a definitive conclusion - often one that disagrees with warren, which is dangerous territory. I've been there.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#28

Re: Type 2 and tight mouth

Kees

Hoadley explains type I chip very well. The edge lifts up a beam of wood, which slides over the face of the blade, splitting from the substrate before the blade's edge, until the beamstrength fails and the shaving breaks. This bending and breaking repeats.

For type II it becomes a little vague. The blade compresses the shaving by pushing it forward. This leads to a diagonal line of shear inside the shaving. But what this line exactly is, isn't described. I think that the layers of woodcels are sliding along each other. They fail in shear. This allows the shaving to change shape and become compressed.

But that is the normal way the shaving fails in a type II shaving. That is not yet tear out. So it doesn't explain why tearout isn't regulated so well with a tight mouth. I am at a loss what exactly happens there.

On the curly wallnut I could get a 0.05 mm shaving with a 0.05 mm mouth and got a smooth surface, but extending the iron a little deeper I could squeeze a 0.07mm shaving through the gap and get a rough surface. So there was no place for the wood to go, and still it teared. The only logical conclusion would be that the plane was lifted slightly to allow the wood to tear.

All the while I could plane that same wood smoothly with the capiron set at 0.1 mm until I couldn't take a thicker shaving (0.12 mm) with the mouth wide open. That exceeded also the capabilities of the 60 degree plane. In other words, the compression of the capiron on the woodshaving in this scenario is very strong.

The picture from Hoadley about how the capiron works is complete nonsence.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#29

Re: Here's the issue, though..

Kees

This is something I agree 100% with you. The adjustablility of the double iron plane is one of its major assets.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#30

Re: apologies for..

david weaver

..being so insistent about making a general judgment about it rather than attempting to make 50 parameterized judgments. I deal with it professionally, same thing. There are a lot of professionals who still can't deal with a judgment call that is rooted in experience and subtlety unless someone will parameterize it.

I was guilty of it with the sharpening stuff too, with warren. I remember saying to him that his comments about edges and harshness of some abrasives were something I wasn't inclined to believe without measuring it. I'm pretty sure I couldn't measure what diamonds do to japanese tools, but I'm also pretty sure that all of my carbon steel tools appreciate natural abrasives a little more than they do the harsher abrasives that are more appropriate for complex tools. that's my judgment of it, I'd have trouble parameterizing it.

With the beginners who will undoubtedly be hounding you about cap irons given the article that will be in print soon, and is in digital print, there will be gloms of people desiring that paramaterized magic trick answer. One single thing that relieves them from thinking or having to accumulate experience.

You could be totally offensive like all of the obnoxious ads we have over here on our internet and say "Use one cheap plane and save yourself hundreds with this one weird trick"

:b

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#31

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Kees

Indeed, but I can make no promisses about the luster of the resulting surface. :D