New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

Posts

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#2

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Excellent piece of work, Kees.

I have emailed you separately.

One of the items that I do not recall seeing in the research was whether you varied the angle at the leading edge of the chipbreaker. This will have a similar effect to the distance of the chipbreaker from the edge of the blade, as demonstrated in the Kato video. How did you account for this in your research? Or was it not a factor of relevance?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#3

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Kees

Thanks Derek,

As you know, Kato and Kawai allready researched the influence of the angle of the leading edge of the capiron. No need to repeat that, I completely trust them.

Interesting to see is how a higher cutting angle also increases the effect of the capiron. You had allready mentioned this some time ago, and I also have felt this in a subjective way with my Ulmia smoother. It is nice to see that confirmed. For people making their own planes this is a nice way to make the capiron setting a little bit less sensitive, while you can still get away with a medium bevel on the capiron.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#4

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Steve Voigt

Hi Kees,

I just saw the last two blog posts yesterday and really enjoyed reading through them. Nice work!

Of particular interest to me was the 50 degree stuff. Purely through dumb trial and error, I found that 50 degrees with a double iron was my preferred configuration for making planes. I've noticed that setting the cap iron (for tearout-free planing) was a little easier compared to my Stanleys, but until I read your results, it didn't "click" that the reason was that 50 gives you a little more leeway in terms of how you set the distance. Anyway…thanks and good work.

Steve

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#5

Setting up for tear out free planing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

I think that the settings for the chipbreaker, and the decision for other choices such as high angle planes, can be easily understood once a basic feature common to all is recognised. This is based on information from the Kato video, experiments and observations by others and myself, and confirmed by Kees' research results here ..

In a nutshell, tearout is reduced or eliminated by creating a Type II chip. This occurs when the chip/shaving is bent at the mouth before it is allowed to tear down the wood surface. Type I chips are prone to tearout because they allow the chip to begin splitting far from the mouth.

There are a number of ways to get the chip to bend as sharply as possible:

1. Because bending at the mouth is where the sharpest bend occurs, closing the mouth down forces this to occur at this point - however this is only effective with thin shavings (a point make by Kees). I suspect that it is dependent on the flex of the wood - the harder or stiffer (and more interlocked) the wood, the less it can flex. Consequently, only thinner shavings stand a chance of bending sharply.

2. A high cutting angle, whether BU or BD (without a chipbreaker), in the range of 55 - 60 degrees will force the chip to bend sharply.

3. The chipbreaker will bend the chip, as long as it is close enough to the edge to force the chip to contact the shaving. The chipbreaker is acting as a deflector, which indicates that there are two factors for adjustment in this method:

(a) there is an optimum range from the blade's edge where the chipbreaker has an effect on the shaving. Kees' research nicely demonstrates the effect of distance.

(b) the angle at the leading edge of the chipbreaker. This was one of the features to come out of the Kato video. They were recommending 80 degrees however their cutting angle was 40 degrees. Depending on the cutting angle of your plane, anything from 50 degrees will work. Warren and others (Dave and Kees, especially) have reported 45 degrees to be fine, which appears to be the angle of the Stanley chipbreaker. (For reference, the LN and LV chipbreakers arrive with a 25 degree leading edge).

What remains anecdotal is the interaction between distance of the leading edge of the chipbreaker to the edge of the blade, the angle of the leading edge, and the angle of the bed (cutting angle). My observation is that this is additive (but also may be used in combinations). For example, I have used the chipbreaker effect to good effect on LN planes with 50- and 55 degree frogs. The leading edge of their chipbreakers were steepened between 45 - 80 degrees (with microbevels).

Kees, you asked the question why the mouth size does not appear to be important with the chipbreaker effect. My explanation would be that the chipbreaker effectively adds about 10 - 15 degrees to the cutting angle, that is, in converting the chip from a Type I to a Type II. It has been well known for many years that a plane with a 60 degree cutting angle (whether BU or BD) is not dependent on a small mouth but can plane tear-free with it wide open. I first heard this from Terry Gordon.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#6

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing *LINK*

Kees

Actually when Steve Elliott's describes his quest in trying to get a type I chip, he found that almost all plane shavings are type II (see link). I would like to add that as soon as you get tearout, you have a type I chip. Otherwise it is type II. (And in scraping planes you get type III.)

I always wonder about the difference in shavings between high angle planes and planes with a chipbreaker. The first have a shape with many tight waves. The latter is much straighter. I wonder why that is.

For me it was a surprise that the tight mouth wasn't nearly as effective as the high angle and the chip breaker settings. When I look at it with a mechanics eye, I could understand how the tight mouth should be very effective. It really holds down the fibers until they get cut. But I am an electronics engineer, so that might explain my confusion. On my blog I have explained my trials and tribulations with the sole of my plane to make the mouth more effective.

seekelot.blogspot.com


http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/shaving_formation.html

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#7

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is no high angle equivalent to a double iron plane. A high angle plane will control tear out, but at the cost of surface quality, smoothness and clarity. If you are getting comparable results, it suggests the double iron is not set up the best.

As Samuel Carruthers stated in early March, 1767, double iron'd planes far exceed any uprights or toothing planes whatsoever for cross-grained or curled stuff.

I went to a Lie Nielsen event last year where a fellow brought in some quarter sawn cherry. The representatives planed it many times with a 55 degree plane, but were unable to completely eliminate the tearing in small patches. Even more telling, however, was the low quality of those areas that were not at all affected by tearing.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#8

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Kees

Goodie .. a discussion. Hopefully. Not many of these for some time.

Actually when Steve Elliott's describes his quest in trying to get a type I chip, he found that almost all plane shavings are type II (see link). I would like to add that as soon as you get tearout, you have a type I chip. Otherwise it is type II. (And in scraping planes you get type III.)

Ahha ... but Steve also goes on to write ..

"Type I shavings are typical only when a plane is making a thick cut. As shaving thickness decreases, the cutting action changes to Type II, which is typical for most smooth planing.

Areas of tear-out are clearly the result of Type I cutting. A plane that takes a Type II shaving in areas of favorable grain direction can switch to Type I cutting in patches of wood with grain reversals."

Regardless of the terminology - in past discussions there has been much confusion how to define a Type I and Type II chip - Steve also believes that tearout occurs with shavings that break ahead of the mouth.

I always wonder about the difference in shavings between high angle planes and planes with a chipbreaker. The first have a shape with many tight waves. The latter is much straighter. I wonder why that is.

This is an interesting factor. I think it has to do with shaving thickness.

Has anyone done any research on the shaving thickness for the chipbreaker to begin having an effect? Logic says that the chip needs to be thicker to bend in a way to shoot up and create a straight shaving. Since the bevel is between 25 - 30 degrees, a BD plane with a set chipbreaker is better able to penetrate the wood more deeply than a BU plane with a higher angle bevel (such as 50 degrees). The BU plane is better suited to thinner shavings. These lack the rigidity to straighten.

That is just my logic, so feel free to disagree (if you have another theory).

For me it was a surprise that the tight mouth wasn't nearly as effective as the high angle and the chip breaker settings. ...On my blog I have explained my trials and tribulations with the sole of my plane to make the mouth more effective.

My theory is that a tight mouth only works with very thin shavings. As I mentioned earlier, it is unnecessary with a high cutting angle. I did look at your Blog for any descriptions of your experiments, but did not found anything. Consequently, if you have been experimenting with it with a chipbreaker of a high cutting angle, it is unlikely that you will see any change in planing performance.

One thought did occur to me. The chipbreaker will extend into the mouth, unlike the single bevel plane with a high cutting angle (either BU or BD). As a result the mouth does need to be open with a closed up chipbreaker, while for the high angle plane one can do as one prefers.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#9

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

wilbur

“My theory is that a tight mouth only works with very thin shavings.”

Actually, it may be the other way around. A tight mouth somewhat forces you to take a thin shaving. One of the guys in my woodworking club has a plane with such a fine mouth that it only takes a shaving if the blade is set at a particular point. If the blade is in back of that point, it doesn’t cut, and if it is forward of that point, then the shaving clogs the mouth.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#10

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, yes, Wilbur. You cannot have one without the other. That is the point - a tight mouth ensures that the surface of the wood is held down at the edge of the blade. One can only take a thin shaving in this set up otherwise the blade extends past the mouth.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#11

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Kees

The only thing I hav etested in this experiment is the tearout reduction (or lack thereof). I agree that my title "surface quality" could be misleading in this regard.

I haven't tested for luster or other surface quality parameters. I actually wonder how you could setup a test like that. A blind test would be my best guess. Maybe this would be a nice way to spend a day for a woodworking club? Prepare a couple of boards from several different woodtypes, one example each with a 60 degree plane, the other with a 45 degree capiron and several settings of the capiron. Freshly sharpened irons of course. Then the other half of the club could examine and score the quality of the boards without knowledge of which is which.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#12

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Kees

The tight mouth test has been done with a 45 degree plane and the capiron far away from the edge.

How tight is practical in a user plane? I think in a Bailey type it gets increasingly difficult to go tighter then 0.1 mm. Setting the frog is not a very precise business.

I found that even when the shaving squeezes through the mouth, so tight that you could lift up the plane with the shaving, you could still get tearout if the wood was difficult enough.

Regarding the curl in a high angle shaving. A capiron plane makes a bit of curl too when the shaving is very thin, and it starts to straighten indeed when it gets thicker (I haven't remembered exact numbers). The high angle plane always makes these curly shavings, also with much thicker shavings like 0.1 to 0.2 mm thick.

And regarding chiptype. Looking at the Kato video, I really only see breaking at regular intervals of the shaving and splitting ahead of the cutter when tearout occurs. I think the shaving breaks on the late to early wood boundary. I suppose you can also get type I shavings when you take very thick shavings with the grain, because the forces involved are much higher.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#13

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

david weaver

If you have a good camera and decent light, plane something like curly cherry. The difference is instantly noticed.

Actually, even plain cherry with no figure shows it easily.

Pictures on a tripod alternating back and forth between a high angle plane and a common pitch plane will do the trick.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#14

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Steve Voigt

I think that the settings for the chipbreaker, and the decision for other choices such as high angle planes, can be easily understood once a basic feature common to all is recognised. This is based on information from the Kato video, experiments and observations by others and myself, and confirmed by Kees' research results here ..

Hi Derek,

Thanks for your comments. Yes, I'm quite familiar with the mechanics, having followed the discussion rather closely for the past year.

My point, perhaps poorly expressed, was that I've found I can get the same results I get on a Stanley with a 50* plane, but with the cap iron a bit further away. What was interesting to me about Kees' latest post was his confirmation of this. Specifically, that a 50* plane with the cap iron .2 mm from the edge gave the same results as a 45* plane with the cap iron .1 mm from the edge. This seems to describe my own experience perfectly, though I've never attempted to measure precisely. So, it wasn't really new information, but it's always nice to get confirmation, and some numbers.

Best,

Steve

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#15

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've found I can get the same results I get on a Stanley with a 50* plane, but with the cap iron a bit further away. What was interesting to me about Kees' latest post was his confirmation of this. Specifically, that a 50* plane with the cap iron .2 mm from the edge gave the same results as a 45* plane with the cap iron .1 mm from the edge. This seems to describe my own experience perfectly, though I've never attempted to measure precisely. So, it wasn't really new information, but it's always nice to get confirmation, and some numbers.

Hi Steve

My own reply was a bit long winded (as usual!) and I missed emphasising the point I was trying to make.

Your observations above are similar to my own, and I have experimented a little in this regard. The long and short of it is that the chipbreaker deflects the chip and the angle at which it bends the chip serves to restrict the amount it can tear. If bending is what it is all about, then there are parts that interact to achieve this: the distance the chipbreaker is from the edge of the blade can vary according to the angle at the leading edge of the chipbreaker. The angle at the leading edge can vary according to the angle of the bed of the plane.

There seems to be a wide range of permutations available. What this means is that there is no single setting that one can recommend. At this stage it is a trial-and-error process.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#16

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Kees

That's a pitty, I used up all my curly cherry.


I'll send out for some more.

To do it honestly, you should compare a capiron setting to a high angle plane with similar tear out reduction capabilities. Comparing a 0.3 mm capiron setting with a 60 degree plane is aples to oranges. That's where my measurements could be usefull.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#17

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

david weaver

You would want to do both. There's no reason to handicap the common pitch plane's finish when it doesn't need to be handicapped. I've never measured my planes, but I'd say a relatively close set (rather than a scorched earth against the grain lignum vitae) setting is a good comparison - something you would use in curly soft maple.

If it costs you a lot to get cherry, certainly no reason to send for me. It grows here everywhere, thus it's cheap here.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#18

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Kees

I'll dig in my stack of scraps to see what I've got.

I think a reasonable aproach would be to first determine what capiron setting produces the best finish, then measure the capiron setting and then choose a high angle that has similar characteristics.

BTW, when you have a very sharp blade it is sometimes difficult to find a piece of wood that even wants to tearout. These are the kind of practical problems facing you when you are trying to research something.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#19

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I would suggest that you use a selection of timbers, ranging to very hard, and closed to open grain (obviously all interlocked grain). Further, apply an oil (or other non-film) finish after you are done and then see if you can determine any difference at this stage as well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#20

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Kees

:D

You're all very good at using my sparetime. But you will all have to wait a while because I have my right hand in a brace. Strained my wrist and the doctor prescribed rest.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#21

Testing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I did a lot of tests with high angle and double iron in 1976 when I had time on my hands. High angle planing just does not give the best surface.

Planing wood is an art. Finishing wood is an art. Finishing wood to take advantage of the fine planed surface takes experience and techniques that require skill. It is not something you can do after reading a tutorial or taking a workshop. We don't go up to a Japanese blacksmith and ask for a tutorial on chisel making. We don't go to Joshua Bell and ask for a tutorial on violin playing. If some craft can be laid out in a few pages of text, it is not an art. In a limited setting like a forum, we can do no more than give hints and nibble around the edges of an art.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#22

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

david weaver

I think the intention that folks have to be able to prescribe a set of parameters for you and quantify the cap iron and how it works vs. other planes, specifically at X or Y wood with AA or BZ shaving thickness and N1 or N2 cap iron setting don't really do anything.

When we wrote the original article for this site, I don't know if I put it specifically in the article, but my thought at the time was that a user questioning whether or not the cap iron works to someone's advantage, beyond literally having a single smoother that does absolutely everything, and a single jointer that does absolutely everhting etc.....anyway, my thought was that people are not going to usually be able to get a grasp on what it's like to work with a plane with a cap iron unless they dedicate themselves a couple of weeks to literally pick up no scrapers, no high angle planes, etc, and figure out:

* what it takes to get a smooth surface when you're doing more than taking a thousandth shaving

* what the surface looks like coming off of the double iron plane

* how heavy of a shaving you can get away with and still have only a very minimal amount of tearout or fuzz that can be removed with a couple of smoother passes

These are things that are not that easily quantified into a silo of parameters because they involve judgement and actual work of projects.

That's one of the reasons I lost interest in the discussions pretty quickly, aside from reinforcing that it works and there really isn't a need to try to come up with parameters where it doesn't if you (not you specifically, but the cadre of members coming up with straw scenarios) can't find them in practical work.

It's been more than two years now, and I haven't used high angle planes for anything since then, I've dimensioned more wood by hand than I ever have before, literally a couple of hundred board feet of mostly cherry, but also beech, maple, etc, and I have not overshot a thickness mark or a line, nor have I had to creep slowly up to those lines like I used to.

I think what you're doing is good, there are people who will read a study of a few scenarios on the internet, make a very certain (of their conclusion) determination and state it as fact. They will read anything you do, come up with other scenarios that they try to think of where your analysis won't fit and describe a need for something there is no need for.

It's nice to be able to fit everything into a conclusion from a four parameter model and say "it's dominant, covers all scenarios", but it's not really a substitute for experience for folks who want everything to be parameterized so they can store a notebook with bullet points and do something without having any experience.

The experience is what people really need. To learn the skill and set aside some of their notions of being able to keep a whole bunch of bookmarks of various sites and draw conclusion from tests and substitute those conclusions for experience.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#23

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Steve Voigt

The long and short of it is that the chipbreaker deflects the chip and the angle at which it bends the chip serves to restrict the amount it can tear. If bending is what it is all about, then there are parts that interact to achieve this: the distance the chipbreaker is from the edge of the blade can vary according to the angle at the leading edge of the chipbreaker. The angle at the leading edge can vary according to the angle of the bed of the plane.

Hi Derek,

Thanks for following up.

If I have interpreted the above correctly, you are saying that

1) The optimum CB distance varies according to the total included angle (where total included angle = bed angle + CB leading edge angle);

2) Bed angle is important only insofar as it contributes to the total included angle.

(I am sure you do not mean this as literally as I have put it, but your emphasis in a number of posts does seem to be strongly on the total included angle.)

In any case, Kees' research seems to directly contradict this supposition. He states that:

The effect of the capiron can be increased when the bedding angle is higher. In the Ulmia[49* bed--SV] plane, a capiron set at 0.2 mm from the edge had the same effect as a 0.1 mm setting in the Stanley plane. Remarkable is that both planes present the same perpendicular wall to the shaving. The Ulmia plane has a capiron with a 40 degree bevel, the Stanley plane has 43 degrees. The total included angle is 89 and 88 degrees respectively (A + B in figure 1). This means that the better performance of the Ulmia plane is due to the higher cutting angle only. (emphases mine)

This makes sense to me. Even set very close, the CB is too far away for the chip to make a single bend. There are two bends, and it stands to reason that the first bend has a more immediate effect.

Of course, one can increase the bed angle until the needed CB angle = 0 and the optimum CB distance = infinity. In other words, a high single iron. :D But that raises a whole host of other issues with which you are familiar (pushing resistance, surface quality, etc.). So, my own interest lies in the narrow band between 45* and 50*. My own work suggests, to me at least, that 50* is preferable, and Kees' latest seems to support this, but it's still all anecdotal and personal.

It would be interesting for someone to expand this research and compare a range ways of achieving the same "total included angle." I'm not the one to do it though; I'd rather get back to my shop, make some planes, and put them to use! Still, it's fun to speculate about!

- Steve

PS if I've misinterpreted you from the get go, my apologies and please let me know.

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#24

Re: Setting up for tear out free planing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

If I have interpreted the above correctly, you are saying that

1) The optimum CB distance varies according to the total included angle (where total included angle = bed angle + CB leading edge angle);

2) Bed angle is important only insofar as it contributes to the total included angle.

Hi Steve

No, that was not my interpretation (if I have understood you - but we may be splitting hairs). I attempted to say that all the parts contribute to the whole: the CB distance, the angle of the leading edge, and the bed angle. And that the sum may be reached by varying the value of individual parts.

In any case, Kees' research seems to directly contradict this supposition. He states that:

The effect of the capiron can be increased when the bedding angle is higher. In the Ulmia[49* bed--SV] plane, a capiron set at 0.2 mm from the edge had the same effect as a 0.1 mm setting in the Stanley plane. Remarkable is that both planes present the same perpendicular wall to the shaving. The Ulmia plane has a capiron with a 40 degree bevel, the Stanley plane has 43 degrees. The total included angle is 89 and 88 degrees respectively (A + B in figure 1). This means that the better performance of the Ulmia plane is due to the higher cutting angle only...

Kees' findings are not a surprise - that is, they are in keeping with my comments. He has managed to demonstrate them so well and this is a testament to the good work he has done. What you see here is how parts may vary in individual value, but their combination results in a similar performance.

I think what is also happening (and the reason why the higher bed reduces tearout more effectively) is that the chip is bent closer to the blade edge with the higher cutting angle than with the chipbreaker (where the chip must flow back and against its leading edge). Just surmising.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods *LINK*

#25

Re: Comparing anti tearout methods

Kees

Lots of things to think about. It's good that I am out of the running for while...

I am not sure if and how you can compare the perfectness of the handplaned surface. Point is, a high angle plane can produce quite an acceptable surface too. So, when you are going to compare planes which put a similar amount of pressure on the wood, I am not sure if you are going to see much difference.

When I am confronted with a difficult piece of wood, something curly, or interlocked or with knots, then the first thing on my mind is avoiding tearout. So I guess for a comparison like this, tearout resistance is a good start. Like I said before I don't think it is honest to compare a plane with a mild capiron effect just enough to avoid tearout, with an agressively high pitched plane which has the potential to tame much worser types of wood. It wouldn't be a surprise at all if the latter doesn't produces as nice a surface.

I guess the experience is neccessary to find the position of the capiron that gives just enough anti tearout effect, without putting undue pressure on the woodfibers.