Setting up for tear out free planing
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Steve
I think that the settings for the chipbreaker, and the decision for other choices such as high angle planes, can be easily understood once a basic feature common to all is recognised. This is based on information from the Kato video, experiments and observations by others and myself, and confirmed by Kees' research results here ..
In a nutshell, tearout is reduced or eliminated by creating a Type II chip. This occurs when the chip/shaving is bent at the mouth before it is allowed to tear down the wood surface. Type I chips are prone to tearout because they allow the chip to begin splitting far from the mouth.
There are a number of ways to get the chip to bend as sharply as possible:
1. Because bending at the mouth is where the sharpest bend occurs, closing the mouth down forces this to occur at this point - however this is only effective with thin shavings (a point make by Kees). I suspect that it is dependent on the flex of the wood - the harder or stiffer (and more interlocked) the wood, the less it can flex. Consequently, only thinner shavings stand a chance of bending sharply.
2. A high cutting angle, whether BU or BD (without a chipbreaker), in the range of 55 - 60 degrees will force the chip to bend sharply.
3. The chipbreaker will bend the chip, as long as it is close enough to the edge to force the chip to contact the shaving. The chipbreaker is acting as a deflector, which indicates that there are two factors for adjustment in this method:
(a) there is an optimum range from the blade's edge where the chipbreaker has an effect on the shaving. Kees' research nicely demonstrates the effect of distance.
(b) the angle at the leading edge of the chipbreaker. This was one of the features to come out of the Kato video. They were recommending 80 degrees however their cutting angle was 40 degrees. Depending on the cutting angle of your plane, anything from 50 degrees will work. Warren and others (Dave and Kees, especially) have reported 45 degrees to be fine, which appears to be the angle of the Stanley chipbreaker. (For reference, the LN and LV chipbreakers arrive with a 25 degree leading edge).
What remains anecdotal is the interaction between distance of the leading edge of the chipbreaker to the edge of the blade, the angle of the leading edge, and the angle of the bed (cutting angle). My observation is that this is additive (but also may be used in combinations). For example, I have used the chipbreaker effect to good effect on LN planes with 50- and 55 degree frogs. The leading edge of their chipbreakers were steepened between 45 - 80 degrees (with microbevels).
Kees, you asked the question why the mouth size does not appear to be important with the chipbreaker effect. My explanation would be that the chipbreaker effectively adds about 10 - 15 degrees to the cutting angle, that is, in converting the chip from a Type I to a Type II. It has been well known for many years that a plane with a 60 degree cutting angle (whether BU or BD) is not dependent on a small mouth but can plane tear-free with it wide open. I first heard this from Terry Gordon.
Regards from Perth
Derek