New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

The Chair - how would you ...

Posts

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#26

Re: Fishtail splice and bullets

Tom in Toronto

So, to recap, are you trying to get this 100% machine made replica, or 99%? The splice in the original, while arguably more elegant, if one doesn't know what one is looking at, is a machine kludge. The bullet points to the splice are structural mistakes, and the joint would be stronger if it was made with points, which would make it easier to do than manufacturing the bullets.

There are three structural problems with the bullets. One is that buried in the joint they do not recruit the full available fiber; another relatated problem is that the glue bonding is not 100%, though that is not likely to do much damage in this case; FINALLY, it is very important when laying out the joint to ensure that the bullets do not coincide with final surfaces or there will be a SERIOUS REDUCTION IN STRENGTH. However, if you point the fishtails up, then all these problems go away. Can't really recommend how to cut this joint unless I know which way you want to make it.

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#27

Re: 24' jointmaster


Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#28

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Sgian Dubh

I'm not sure what the question may be Derek, but I'm guessing you're looking for ideas to replicate a machine cut joint by hand. My suggestion is not to try and make an exact match. Make it look like a hand cut version of the finger joint or devise one of your own. If you want to keep the finger joint appearance why not retain the essence but don't bother with the rounded corners. Either make them pointed or make them square. I can't decide which would be easier or more likely to be successful by just looking -- I'd probably do a mock-up or three in some scrap to decide.

Basically you need to create two flats on each section that are parallel to each other. These flats are parallel to the orientation of the joint as looked at from above, i.e., treating the joint as approximately (or perhaps exactly) the circumference of a circle you're looking for a tangent line. Then mark the joint out on the flats of one piece, and cut it. Next offer up the cut piece to it's partner. Scribe the lines across as you would do with dovetailing, then cut the other bit to match. Slap it together with glue and do the shaping. Slainte.

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#29

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Tom and Richard

The one deviation from the design will be the finger joint. It will not be rounded at the corners, but pointed.

What I was after were any pointers to joining the arm with the back?

What alternate joint would you consider (although the finger joint, while obviously designed with machines in mind, is synonymous with The Chair)?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#30

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Tom in Toronto

You have the chair to copy, but I assume the joint is at the best place aesthetically, geometry wise, and save the big piece of wood wise. So the one thing I would be trying to do is to optimize the layout so that the joint was as narrow as possible. Maybe they don't do that when they make them in the factory, since having some meat helps with alignment, and blowout. But for handwork, getting the cuts as short as possible will probably be easiest.

The only experience I have with this joint is on bows, and since it ends up glued with epoxy, and inside the grip leather, there is almost no way to do it so badly it won't hold. The only thing I have seen in that case is that it can split the wood if the wedges are off at all.

So in the spirit of inconsistency, if I was doing a pile of these, as you may be. It might be worth making up some tools to make it easier to do the bullet ended ones. The obvious tool would be an edge float with a semi circular cut to it. Then you could lay it out. drill the relief holes, hand saw to the holes, then get the last titch off with the float. Since the holes open up the joint, then you can get in to the flats with a joint making float, all the way down, except for the part the round float handles. Same thing with a rat tail file, but a float would be a very much better tool, and allows you to design to any dimension.

The points style joint I would just mark out and saw. Final refining might be by a wedge with sandpaper on it. I think the marking out could be interesting, but I can't really tackle that without know what the pieces you are going to assemble will look like.

As far as alternative joints, I would mostly be thinking of that in a design that had evolved a little along the way. One version I saw of this chair used a separate back rest piece that opened up the joinery a lot. I can think of a version using Japanese joinery, but it would require the arm being longer, which without having a chair to look at might end up with laminations. While I respect what you are doing, if I was doing this for myself I would probably use machines somewhere; I am not sawing out lams by hand, though I guess I shouldn't say that, I have planed up thousands of feet of strips for boats, by hand. Too much fun.

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#31

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Sgian Dubh

Derek, turn a spigot on the top end of the leg and bore a hole in the underside of the arm. The leg to rail M&Ts lock the leg so that it won't rotate (twist). I realise the bored hole in the underside of the arm will leave more short grain than I would like, but that's the visual form of the joint, deliberately chosen, and I imagine Wegner was aware of the potential and real weakness. If you've already cut the top end of the leg off then bore a hole there too and use a dowel to connect the two holes. Slainte.

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#32

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, turn a spigot on the top end of the leg and bore a hole in the underside of the arm. The leg to rail M&Ts lock the leg so that it won't rotate (twist). I realise the bored hole in the underside of the arm will leave more short grain than I would like, but that's the visual form of the joint, deliberately chosen, and I imagine Wegner was aware of the potential and real weakness. If you've already cut the top end of the leg off then bore a hole there too and use a dowel to connect the two holes. Slainte.

Hi Richard

Sorry, but I obviously was not clear. I have planned for tenons at the top of the legs and will build matching mortices into the arm rests ...


The area I was asking about was the joining of the arms rests to the back rest. Specifically, planning the finger joint. Is there a strategy you would follow to ensure all lines up?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#33

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Sgian Dubh

Derek, I think I covered the strategies I'd use in my previous post, the one where I talked about creating two parallel faces on the outer and inner parts of the arm and backrest using a tangent line derived from a circle. This would give you known reference surfaces from which to do your marking. After that I think you'd need to rely on the accuracy of that marking and your ability to cut to a line to get a good result. I think your hand cut approach is very challenging, but do-able, although I think a more reliable method would be a spindle moulder setup, but even that would require some prototyping and jig making to get right. By the time you'd done all that though you could probably do a one-off by hand! Slainte.

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#34

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I don't think the joint used in your production model of the chair is appropriate for hand tool joinery. However, there are much older and more traditional joints, used in Oriental and Occidental joinery, that are more appropriate. The joint I would use is illlustrated by Gustav Ecke (which I do not have at hand, so I cannot provide a figure number) and also by Roubo, ref. Plate 10, Figures 6, 7 and 11. Roubo's name for this joint might be translated to "Jupiter's Thunderbolts" in English.

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#35

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Andrew F in Australia

Since Richard hasn't answered this one, Derek, Attached is a data point just for opinion.

How I'd do it from the point you're at is to mark of the joint before you round components and essentially build a massive square rail with accurate joinery. Once the joinery is accurate, I'd take it apart and remove the bulk of the excess timber using templates to mark out each rail. Working off the bottom face as a reference, you'll then have the joinery accurate and the rails co-planar and out of wind.

After this, I'd then glue up and use rasps to get the shape close the either spokeshaves or other hand planes to get the final shape (it screams out belt sander but that's outside the remit).

All this is probably what you're planning anyway I'd wager and I've come in late.

Once again, I've typed this up on a tiny screen so I hope there's no typo.

Re: joinery, I'd be guessing that you've got a copy of Joyce close handy (mind's at work) look up tub chair for comment on the top (crest) real to am rail. Might give you alternatives

AF

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

#36

Re: The Chair - how would you ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

How I'd do it from the point you're at is to mark of the joint before you round components and essentially build a massive square rail with accurate joinery. Once the joinery is accurate, I'd take it apart and remove the bulk of the excess timber using templates to mark out each rail. Working off the bottom face as a reference, you'll then have the joinery accurate and the rails co-planar and out of wind.

After this, I'd then glue up and use rasps to get the shape close the either spokeshaves or other hand planes to get the final shape (it screams out belt sander but that's outside the remit).


Thanks again Andrew.

This is almost exactly what I did today (minus the final joint cutting). I will post some pictures in a short while. It's great to get some confirmation!

Regards from Perth

Derek