New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Hand/Bench Chisels

Posts

Hand/Bench Chisels

#1

Hand/Bench Chisels

Don Emmerling

I am usually over on the woodturning side, but I need some help from the handtool guys. I am looking for some good bench chisels that have good steel and will hold an edge and last me for the remainder of my time. I always hear that the Japanese chisels are of good steel and hold an edge, however on the Japan Woodworks site they have so many different types to choose from that I am lost on making the correct choice. I thought I would consult with the experts here for some guidance. I can afford to spend a little money on them, say more than one might spend on some more common types like Stanley etc. Any help would be appreciated, as I am trying to work more hand tools into my efforts at woodworking.

Thanks

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#2

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

Hank Knight

Don,

You will probably get as many different opinions as there are replies to your inquiry. Chisels are a constant subject of discussion and debate as to which are the "best." As you might imagine, preferences are very subjective, just as I imagine the opinions about the best turning chisels are among you lathe guys.

Having said that, here are some thoughts. My favorite chisels are the blue steel cabinet makers chisels by Matsumura on the Japan Woodworker site. They take a fine edge and hold it well. They have beveled edges that are good for getting into tight places, like dovetail corners. They are light weight and easy to handle. The downside is that they might seem a little delicate for someone looking for a general purpose chisel.

Many people like the Lie-Nielsen bench chisels. They are modeled on the old Stanley #750s that were as good an all-round bench chisel as you can find. The Lie-Nielsens afford a choice between 01 steel and A2. A2 is more wear-resistant than O1, but I can never seem to get it as shap as O1. I do not own any of the Lie-Nielsens, but if I were going to buy some, I would choose the O1 option and plan on sharpening a little more frequently. I do own some old Stanley 750s and they are nice chisels that feel good in the hand.

Lee alley has a new line of bench chisel out made of a new steel alloy that is supposed to sharpen well and hold an edge too. I don't recall the name of the alloy, but I'm sure you can find it on their catalog site. Peoplewho have used the chisels speak highly of them. Again, I don't own these chisels; I'm just repeating what I've heard about them.

There are many other makers out there - Blue Spruce, Ahley Isles and Barr to name a few. All of them make nice tools. I have tried to describe my preference along with the the brands that seem to get the most comment and praise. It will be interesting to see what everybody else has to say.

Good luck with your selection.

Hank

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#3

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

William Duffield

One excellent choice you should consider are the Veritas PM-V11 bench chisels.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=69847&cat=1,41504

What is your preferred sharpening medium? If it's not diamond, these might be a bit frustrating. However, as far as hardness and durability, these will hold their own against the best the

OTOH, if you have to have Japanese chisels, wait for a reply from Wilbur Pan. Unlike a lot of what you read about Japanese chisels. which IMHO is fanaticism, Wilbur approaches Japanese tools in a logical manner, and his recommendations are based on his experience and facts.

Here I go, recommending tools I don't use. What I do use is Lie-Nielsen bench chisels and antique Sheffield cast steel chisels (Witherby, James Swan, L & I J White, Buck, Butcher, etc.). If my Lie-Nielsens (cryogenically hardened A2) had the durability of the Veritas or the best Japanese, they would be perfect, because everything else about them could not be improved upon.

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#4

Sharpening considerations

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Don,

Just like with turning tools, it's useful to think about chisels and sharpening setup together. Do you already have a sharpening procedure and equipment in place? Do you have a preference already for sharpening media?

It's not that big of a deal, but for example if you prefer oil stones, they tend to go better with the cleaner steels. At the other extreme, if you like diamond, then you're unconstrained pretty much.

Do you like dry or wet grinding or no motorized grinding? That preference can have some influence on chisel choice, esp. if you're considering Japanese.

Wiley

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#5

I like these *LINK*

John in NM

Somehow I never end up buying the fancy chisels :D

The two of these I have are as good as the Sandvik's I picked up in a junk store years ago.


Narex

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#6

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

Tom

The first thing to figure out is what you want to get out of the purchase, or what goal you are starting towards. When I bought my first Japanese chisels back around '79, I was taken by the idea of the mastery of Japanese Carpenters, and would have been frustrated with many of the tool offerings of other nations. It may be hard to believe today, but there were long periods back then when none of the tool catalogs LV GW, etc... actually sold a base range professional grade western tools, even to a low standard. Magazines were full of articles on how to convert inappropriate tools into dovetail saws, one guy even had a book in which he cut his joints with a hacksaw, which works. So part of the Japanese thing was that they were the only serious range of joinery tools on offer. The next best thing were antique tools.

This is no longer the case. There are 20 versions of every tool you might ever want. There can still be certain problems, but getting bare functionality is no longer one of them.

I have tried hundred of chisels over the years, and my basic cut is that Japanese tools are still the best edges, but not necessarily designed for the style of western work. To take full advantage of them you are probably best off as a hand sharpener; a cutter not a prier; and they work best for certain types of work, which by and large are not western work. So they are always a good choice, but it would be crazy to see them as necessary, and they certainly will not yield better results in the hands of most workers.

If my shop burned down, after 35 years with Japanese tools, I probably wouldn't replace them, since I have taken the whole thing as far as I am likely to. Japanese tools today, are more a negative than a positive as far as getting work done. It is a wonderful discipline I am glad I went through, and they are out there, so buy what you want, but they are like learning Karate at a time when concealed carry permits are widely available. In other words a whole other hobby.

Contrary to current thinking, I think the chisels are the best of the Japanese tools, followed next by the planes, and then the saws. As what they were intended for, they are pretty perfect, but as to what they can bring to the average western purchaser, that is my rating.

Once you drop out of the rarefied heights of Japanese tools, you pretty much don't find another support level until you get to a point where everything else of good quality is fairly equal. There are different degrees of different things, but unlike the Japanese chisels, no outright best over all winner. My personal favourites are antique tools, but I have never had a full set of identical chisels, so I tend to have them for types that are one-off like large slicks, or mortising chisels. These are basically the only pro-quality western tools. Everything else is pretty much made for amateurs. They are also the cheapest option, if you can find them. At the 80 dollar each level, I have O1 tools, and I think they are great, edge holding is not so great, but what maters more is how easily one is consistently at a high performance level, and for woods up to but not including Maple, these tools are as good as anything. At the Maple hardness level they perfectly viable for the amateur, but they might be a bit of a pain for the all day dovetail chopper, of whom there are few.

As a turner, you presumably know how to handle HSS, and if cost was no option, I would search out a set of HSS Japanese chisels. Just use them up. They aren't that expensive, and it is pretty much an unbeatable combo, of efficiency and high end use. HSS tools allow dry grinding, and polishing, and you will get wicked edges at zero upcharge, and almost instantly.

http://www.mehr-als-werkzeug.de/product/718937/HSS-Chisels-for-Cabinetmakers-Blade-Width-30-mm.htm (I may be a little out of touch, but those ones seem pricey)

How many should you buy? 1/4, 3/8, 1/2, 3/4, 1. More is better but really getting them perfect takes a long time, so having a small set in perfect condition, is another option.

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#7

Japanese vs Western chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Don

Ask 10 woodworkers for a recommendation and you will get 10 different answers.

I think that you want a recommendation for Japanese chisels because of the steel. Well you are correct. In the tests I ran (admittedly limited in scope), the Japanese chisel bench chisel came in first. If you want to go down this route, then look for Koyamaichi. They are excellent chisels, with excellent steel, and will not break the bank.

They are the same price as the second-placed chisel, Veritas PM-V11 bench chisels.

These two are standout choices because of their edge holding and ease of sharpening by the steel. In a way the steel is secondary - it is only something you notice when all else is good and the steel is letting you down. So what could you be looking for ...

The two bench chisels above represent two different user groups. The Japanese bench chisel (e.g. Koyamaichi) has a steel hoop and is designed to be used with a steel-headed hammer (a gennou). It is not designed to be pushed by hand, although you can do so - this is not its domain and it is not as comfortable in the hand as a chisel that is designed to be pushed. The use of a gennou permits great precision when the chisel is used. There is no wavering of the hand and a precise amount of force is imparted via the gennou.


The Western chisel (e.g. Veritas) is wooden handled without a steel hoop. It is design as much to be pushed with the hand as hit with a wooden-headed mallet. So how does the mallet/gennou area differ? Not a lot - there is an advantage with the Western chisel as it has greater all round use. The advantage of the Japanese chisel is that it is the more durable (but not by much in this particular example).

Veritas (dark) and Lie-Nielsen (light) ...


If you plan to go down the Western chisel route, it is important that you try out a few since the handles differ. The Veritas handles are excellent, as are Blue Spruce. Lie-Nielsen offer remakes of the vintage Stanley #750, so you may be familiar with these. You really cannot go wrong with any of these makers.

There are also issues with sharpening that one should consider. The Japanese chisel is laminated steel, and is designed to have the full bevel honed ideally freehand, or a secondary bevel with a guide. One is not supposed to hollow grind these blades (unless using a Tormek wet grinder). The Western chisel is solid steel and may be hollow ground with a high speed grinder, or what you like. It can be honed full bevel, secondary bevel or on a hollow.

I have a few reviews on my website:

Koyamaichi: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/KoyamaichiChisels.html

Veritas O1 steel: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasChiselReview.html

Comparison of chisel steels: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/FourChiselSteelsCompared.html

Hope this helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

The thing is that there is more to choosing a chisel that goin

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#8

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

Patrick Gibbons

I know you asked about Japanese chisels but I will recommend the Ashley Isles chisels which are western. A few years back they redesigned their chisels with thinner blades that have edges that bevel down to nothing. The backs are concave and require very little flattening to set up. Like most chisels, they hold their edge better after a few sharpenings. It is their combination of performance for a moderate price that makes them a good consideration. They are available as cabinetmaker or butt chisels.

There are a lot of good choices available in new chisels. It's tough to make a bad choice. Buy a single chisel of something you think you want to try and see if it works for you.

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#9

Re: Japanese vs Japanese chisels

Tom

By the way, some off the best J. Chisels, or other tools I own were fairly cheap. One of my favourite plane blades was about 13 dollars from LV, back when a Recotd jointer was about 120. I have a catalog of J tools that lists tons of cheap blades, though the stateside importer didn, t seem interested in bringing any ofthem in. They seem harder to find than the tourist tools today.

One of the best sets of J. Chisels I own we special value sets sold by Mahog. Master. At the time I also bought the most expensive Ouchi set sold, they were s little different but no better. Ouchii was top of the line at the time.

I do believe that extra cost shows up in the tools. For instance, the cheaper plane blades had stamped SBs. They work though the breaker was not typical. It is a bit like a table with a F. Polish finish is more costly than Varathane, but neither is better quality, and one might prefer either depending on services

It has also been my experience that fancy chisels with weird wood handles and showboating blacksmithing are often inferior to ueer grade tools. By all means enjoy buying pretty stuff, but check itbout carefully ig you want be a user. Like skowing up at dude camp with then fanciest saddle.

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#10

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

wilbur

I always hear that the Japanese chisels are of good steel and hold an edge, however on the Japan Woodworks site they have so many different types to choose from that I am lost on making the correct choice.

The good news is that these days there are a lot of choices in good quality chisels for woodworking, Japanese or otherwise. Here’s why I like Japanese chisels.

1. Easy sharpening. At some point in getting into hand tools, a lot of people, myself included, think that edge retention is important in a chisel. As I’ve gotten more experience, ease of sharpening has become more important to me. It’s key to have and use a sharp chisel, and if your chisel is easy to sharpen, then you’ll be more likely to do it. Edge retention will delay the next time you have to sharpen your chisel, but often that comes with the price of your chisel being harder to sharpen when that time comes around, which leads to frustration, which leads to letting the chisel get more dull than it should be.

Having said that, Japanese chisels also have excellent edge retention, even though they are easy to sharpen, thanks to their laminated construction, among other things.

2. Weight and balance. Japanese chisels are shorter and lighter than most readily available western chisels. There are some exceptions, such as vintage 18th century chisels with a tang construction (that’s for you, Warren), but those aren’t readily available in many parts of the country, and certainly are not available from Lee Valley or Woodcraft. Some people, like myself, like the shorter length and the decreased weight. Others may not. This is all personal preference.

In terms of which chisel to get, I have and use the Fujihiro brand chisels made by a blacksmith named Imai, and which are available at Hida Tool ( http://www.hidatool.com/woodworking/chisels/fujihiro-bench-chisels-single-hollow-red-oak-handle ). These are made with so-called white steel, which makes them really easy to sharpen, they hold an edge for a good long time, and are reasonably priced as far as Japanese chisels go. The link above leads to the Fujihiro bench chisel page. Other chisels, such as mortise chisels and paring chisels are available as well.

When I was first looking to pick up a Japanese chisel, all I had were reports on the internet from users and their experience with various Japanese chisel makers. And although there were a lot of reports that Japanese chisels from many different sources were really great, there would be the occasional report that there were issues with chipping, especially with really inexpensive Japanese chisels.

At the other end of the scale, I would read about chisel makers like Tasai and Funahiro, who made what were by all reports phenomenal chisels, although out of my budget. I also read about Imai’s sword steel chisels, which were also not in my budget. But Imai does make a basic style chisel that I could afford. These also happened to be the least expensive Japanese chisels that I could find that had good reviews and no negative reports. So I gave the Imai chisels a try, and have been really pleased with the results.

From what I hear from Derek and others, the Koyamaichi chisels are also really good. I just don’t have personal experience with them.

Finally, at the risk of seeming self-serving, here are some links to some articles I’ve written on Japanese chisels that may help:

White steel vs. blue steel:

http://giantcypress.net/post/609709105/one-steel-two-steel-white-steel-blue-steel

Setting up a Japanese chisel:

http://giantcypress.net/tagged/Japanese%20chisel%20setup/chrono

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#11

Re: An Apology

William Duffield

I really shouldn't call it fanaticism. Tom's explanation is completely valid. I just wasn't doing any appreciable woodworking at the time Tom started to need quality woodworking tools.

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#13

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

Don Emmerling

Wow! Did not think I would get so many responses. I think I will have to do some more research and absorb all the good suggestions I received. There certainly is a lot to think about here. Derek from Perth has to be the chiselmeister there. He sent me a virtual encyclopedia of chisel wisdom. I hope it also helps someone else that may want to know about chisel selection. Thanks again guys, I think I have found another group to hang out with, if you all don't mind.

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#14

We do regard Derek as the.....

roger lance

chiselmeister.....amongst some other meisters..... :D :D

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#15

Re: We do regard Derek as the.....

Don Emmerling

Sorry Roger. Did not mean to offend anyone else here. It was my first trip to Hand Tools and I am not aware of all the fine people that are on this forum. Should I have picked someone else as the chiselmeister?

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#16

Re: We do regard Derek as the.....

roger lance

Don....relax....that was just said in jest....welcome to the forum.....hope you stay around and become a regular.....we all(mostly all) hold Derek in high regard....he is a tremendous asset for those who want to learn about woodworking hand tools.....there are a number of others who post here that are also very knowledgeable.....you'll have to hang around and figure out for yourself who's who.....I'd suggest that you go to Derek's site (InTheWoodshop) to read many fine tool reviews.....I did.

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#17

Re: We do regard Derek as the.....

Don Emmerling

Looks like my bad here Roger. I thought maybe I had stumbled by calling Derek the chiselmeister when there might have been someone much more deserving. I just mentioned Derek because he gave me so much material and effort into answering my question. No harm no fowl as they say. I will visit hand tools much more often in the future because I like the woodworker that puts all his effort into his work and uses the old but good techniques. I tend to feel better about my projects when there is less machinery involved and more of me involved. Will look forward to seeing you in the future.

Don

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#18

My ears are burning ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Don

Thank you for the title. It's richly deserved of course! :) I'm kidding.

What it really reflects is the combination of a high curiosity factor in regard to tools (I'm 6 years old at heart), the tolerance and humoring of my friends here on the forum (who put up with my pedantic style of writing), and the desire to share my thoughts and have a conversation with others equally fixated (since none of my family or friends at home has the slightest interest in woodworking).

The truth is that there are so many more experienced and learned folk on this forum from whom I learn. And continue to look forward to be doing so. Hang around - you'll quickly see what i mean.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#19

Re: My ears are burning ..

Tom

Keep in mind that nothing Derek says is of the least value since in addition to using chisels upside down, he uses them in the woods we have probably mostly not heard of, let alone used, whether we are Japanese or American. Still as Bill Jordan said while writing about murdering migrants on the southern border, there is "No Second Place Winner".

Re: Hand/Bench Chisels

#20

Don't you mean ...

Bruce McCrory

... Didact--, instead of pedantic? Just watch what Derek turns into when he is passionate about an issue. "Pins first, tails first" is one that springs to mind.

On the whole we do love him, and definitely protect him from ourselves, and other thugs.