Re: Hand/Bench Chisels
Tom
The first thing to figure out is what you want to get out of the purchase, or what goal you are starting towards. When I bought my first Japanese chisels back around '79, I was taken by the idea of the mastery of Japanese Carpenters, and would have been frustrated with many of the tool offerings of other nations. It may be hard to believe today, but there were long periods back then when none of the tool catalogs LV GW, etc... actually sold a base range professional grade western tools, even to a low standard. Magazines were full of articles on how to convert inappropriate tools into dovetail saws, one guy even had a book in which he cut his joints with a hacksaw, which works. So part of the Japanese thing was that they were the only serious range of joinery tools on offer. The next best thing were antique tools.
This is no longer the case. There are 20 versions of every tool you might ever want. There can still be certain problems, but getting bare functionality is no longer one of them.
I have tried hundred of chisels over the years, and my basic cut is that Japanese tools are still the best edges, but not necessarily designed for the style of western work. To take full advantage of them you are probably best off as a hand sharpener; a cutter not a prier; and they work best for certain types of work, which by and large are not western work. So they are always a good choice, but it would be crazy to see them as necessary, and they certainly will not yield better results in the hands of most workers.
If my shop burned down, after 35 years with Japanese tools, I probably wouldn't replace them, since I have taken the whole thing as far as I am likely to. Japanese tools today, are more a negative than a positive as far as getting work done. It is a wonderful discipline I am glad I went through, and they are out there, so buy what you want, but they are like learning Karate at a time when concealed carry permits are widely available. In other words a whole other hobby.
Contrary to current thinking, I think the chisels are the best of the Japanese tools, followed next by the planes, and then the saws. As what they were intended for, they are pretty perfect, but as to what they can bring to the average western purchaser, that is my rating.
Once you drop out of the rarefied heights of Japanese tools, you pretty much don't find another support level until you get to a point where everything else of good quality is fairly equal. There are different degrees of different things, but unlike the Japanese chisels, no outright best over all winner. My personal favourites are antique tools, but I have never had a full set of identical chisels, so I tend to have them for types that are one-off like large slicks, or mortising chisels. These are basically the only pro-quality western tools. Everything else is pretty much made for amateurs. They are also the cheapest option, if you can find them. At the 80 dollar each level, I have O1 tools, and I think they are great, edge holding is not so great, but what maters more is how easily one is consistently at a high performance level, and for woods up to but not including Maple, these tools are as good as anything. At the Maple hardness level they perfectly viable for the amateur, but they might be a bit of a pain for the all day dovetail chopper, of whom there are few.
As a turner, you presumably know how to handle HSS, and if cost was no option, I would search out a set of HSS Japanese chisels. Just use them up. They aren't that expensive, and it is pretty much an unbeatable combo, of efficiency and high end use. HSS tools allow dry grinding, and polishing, and you will get wicked edges at zero upcharge, and almost instantly.
http://www.mehr-als-werkzeug.de/product/718937/HSS-Chisels-for-Cabinetmakers-Blade-Width-30-mm.htm (I may be a little out of touch, but those ones seem pricey)
How many should you buy? 1/4, 3/8, 1/2, 3/4, 1. More is better but really getting them perfect takes a long time, so having a small set in perfect condition, is another option.