New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

Posts

Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

#1

Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A question recently came up, "how can you stop the LV small router plane blade from twisting?". The problem is the shaft of the blade is round and set in a triangular-shaped mortice, and only friction prevents it from twisting or rotating. Some find this occurs frequently, while others rarely so. My own Small Router Plane fell into the latter category. Nevertheless and blade movement was undesirable.

The recommendation to date has been to rough of the shaft with sandpaper to increase friction. This works for some, does not work for others. There is a better, more permanent way.

I completed these mods some time ago, and did not take photos of the actual method, but this is simple enough to do. Basically, you will need to grind the rear of the shaft into a right angle triangle. This will match the angle of the triangulated mortice in which the shaft runs.

The result looks like this ...




The blade is locked squarely ...


For reference, blade sharpening is made so much easier if you first hollow grind it ..


There is a tutorial on the jig to do this here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/SharpeningRouterPlaneBlades.html

In use the blade is solid ...


I gather that Lee Valley have a depth stop out and that all will be receiving one!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

#2

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

roger lance

Derek.....thanks for this review/pictorial.....sometime ago, you showed your small wooden router plane and I made one of my own clumsy design.....I made that small router plane partly because of the problems people were reporting with the small LV router and the round blade shafts twisting in use and I felt that LV should improve its design but I assumed that LV was faced with significant costs to change their molds/castings to a square opening for blades like LN.....I had never seen the LV small router in person.....your photos show that LV could simply solve this issue by producing their blades as you have modified yours.....this should be accomplished at a reasonable cost and involve no alteration of the plane body.

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

#3

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Roger, you said, "...your photos show that LV could simply solve this issue by producing their blades as you have modified yours.....this should be accomplished at a reasonable cost..."

Lee Valley's offering its little router plane at roughly 2/3 the price of Lie-Nielsen's. I doubt either company is making much of its annual profit from these tools. At that price point, what seems like a trivial extra production step could exceed the profit margin.

I suspect that Rob Lee wouldn't see much, if any, drop in sales if the price moved up by, say, $5 to accommodate the fix Derek shows; but I'm no kinda retail marketing expert, so this is idle speculation on my part.

I've experienced some frustration with the twistiness of this tool's cutter; I'll be putting Derek's fix on my list of round tuits, although the list is already long enough to keep me busy for years.

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

#4

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

roger lance

Bill....I quite agree that LV is offering their small router plane at a very reasonable cost....and now they intend to give to their customers of record a free depth stop which only adds to their reputation of being a truly remarkable company.....and I also agree that we customers can only engage in some form of speculation about cost and difficulty of manufacture which sometimes is way off and overly presumptive of us telling Rob Lee how to run his affairs given that he seems to be doing a pretty good job of that on his own.....but, in this case, it seems LV could eliminate the one major criticism of this tool with what appears to be an easy correction at the manufacturing level.

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

#5

It would be good to hear from Rob Lee on this one

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

although I suspect he and his family are in the shop, helping the staff deal with post-Christmas workload or celebrating with the staff getting through the season yet again, or both.

I've had some e-mail back and forth with Rob on this very subject, and he's indicated that the engineers have looked at this. Given the attention to detail Lee Valley gives its tools, I'd be surprised if they haven't looked at this possibility.

Re: Modifying the LV Small Router Plane

#6

Re: It would be good to hear from Rob Lee on this

Tom

Assuming people aren't asking too much of a tool that maybe shouldn't be expected to do much more than whisker off wood. Maybe chalk would solve the problem, or creating a sticky piece like AL that would fit into the slot, and increase the bearing. Anyone who has received the free rebuilds from LV, probably knows they won't be satisfied with this. There will always be the critical eye, the dull bit, and the monstrous hands to take into consideration.