New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Winding sticks and bad eyes

Posts

Winding sticks and bad eyes

#1

Winding sticks and bad eyes

ray

I just began flattening my old Chappelle bench. Since I have very little experience with this task, I thought I had better acquire a set of winding sticks. I am rated at 20-200 in one eye, 20-400 in the other and very near sighted.

I have progressive lenses and thought that there might be a sweet spot that would allow me to see these sticks well enough to be useful. So far, nothing has worked. Everything is too fuzzy to make an accurate judgement.

Does anyone have any suggestions from your similar experiences?

Thanks,

Ray

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#2

craigd

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

craigd

I'm not sure this is actually viable, but photos [of the winding sticks] do work. With a smart phone, the small sensor will foreshorten the image (ie make the winding sticks appear closer together); that, together with instant image and pan/zoom might be fast enough to be usable. High contrast winding sticks (I use a yellow Stabila level as one of the winding sticks) help.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#3

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

David Charlesworth

Ray,

If your sticks are three feet apart, you need to be about 9 feet away from first stick.

Eyes cannot focus on both if you are too close.

David Charlesworth

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#4

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

ray

Thanks for the camera idea, it may be my only option.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#5

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

ray

It appears as if my shop may be too small for the successful use of Winding sticks to flatten my bench. I still may be able to use them for shorter surfaces, placed nearer to one end of the bench.Thanks for the important information.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#6

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

JasonInOC

One of Schwarz's blogs recently mentioned this. He improvises a pinhole camera by making a peephole with his hands/fingers somehow. A pinhole in card stock would also work.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#7

4-foot level

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I find that a level, especially a 4-foot milled edge level, is a most valuable tool in the shop. For example, when edge jointing or face flattening, you can rotate the level around its center and develop a very close feel for where it's grabbing--high centered or high ended.

You could flatten, level, and untwist your bench top with one, in combination with a jointer.

Wiley

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#8

Re: 4-foot level

Curt Putnam

Because of damage to my foot and the resultant "cast" I must wear prevent me from bending down to see winding sticks, I have become pretty good at twirling a level or even a straight edge to determine high spots. I suspect the method is every bit as good as winding sticks.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#9

Your main job is flattening your bench.....

roger lance

Ray.....if your eyes don't allow the use of winding sticks then just concentrate on determining the areas on your bench that are out of flat.....and the amount those areas are out.....a level would be a good tool to use in this effort.....use a pencil to mark the areas.....take your time to get an accurate idea of what you are facing.....use a #7 if you have it and take very thin cuts.....concentrate on one area at a time.....check often with your level to gage progress.....work the worst area down first but not all the way.....recheck with that level....move on to the next area....same slow process....more checking.....and so on.....then reassess your top....this is not a race....work slow....work comfortably.....at some point you might want to work with a #4 or even a hand scraper.....the top does not have to be perfect.....just improved over its current condition.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#10

Re: Mirror mirror.

Tom

Those are some interesting ideas on getting a view of the sticks. If your sole problem is that you can't get off to one side far enough to sight the sticks, just place a mirror so that you can stand in some place in the room and see the view.

Winding sticks are designed to find wind, but they are hardly the gold standard. If you spend a few minutes studying the wiki of metrology, you can come up with all kinds of el cheapo ways to make dead nuts measurement devices to dial in your table, and you don't need to have a reference surface.

If the bench isn't too big you may be able to dial it in off the jointer plane alone. If one isn't used to doing that it can vary in difficulty just by the terrain you are lucky enough to encounter. Meaning certain shapes are easier to read, and require less work to set right.

If the surface is bad, and you aren't too proud, another option is a router sled. Tack/clamp two straight plywood edges to the surface, and check for level. Then build a router sled/gantry and run it over the whole surface till it is level. Do the clean-up with a plane. I hate routers, but if you have to compensate for your particular tool set, who cares. By the way, with an indicator, and a stiff enough gantry, you could indicate in the whole surface. I don't think the trend to buy some speciality tool that was blogged on the internet, rather than have a way to use what you have, is necessarily producing better craftsmen.

By the way, are your sticks high contrast.

They sell lasers at the dollar store for 2 bucks that throw out a line around the whole room. Can't say how well they work, mine is still in the blister pack.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#11

Lasers

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have a $70 laser level from the big orange store. It's not self-leveling, and I found that getting it level is a delicate business. It's also hard to read if there's any other light sources, like windows. They offered some hip red glasses to wear, which help; but even with those, it's useless outside or in similarly well-lit situations.

It paid for itself on the first job, but not without some effort.

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#12

Re: Mirror mirror.

David Charlesworth

Two four foot levels, a pinhole and a mirror, sound like the answer to me.

Detecting twist with one straightedge, does not seem viable to me.

Some incarnation of winding sticks, is after all the age old solution.

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#13

Spirit levels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ray

Try using two long spirit levels (I have 2 X 18"). Leave one at the far end - as you would a winding stick - and move the other progressively backwards. The bubbles will show you what is happening, and you can gauge how much to remove by packing shavings under an end of one side.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Winding sticks and bad eyes

#14

Winding sticks are useless

Mark Hennebury

A straight edge is all you need.

Get or make a straight edge long enough to cross diagonally across the surface that you are checking.

There are five reference points that define a flat surface; the four corners and the center.

If you place the straight edge diagonally across your surface and it hits the the corners and the center then place it diagonally across the other diagonal and it hits the corners and the center then your table is not twisted but flat at the reference points.

You will have to learn how to read and adjust your bench surface in most cases to bring it into a flat plane; for instance If your straight edge can rock on the center point in one direction then the center is high and needs to be lowered, if the straight edge sits on the two corners but has a gap in the center then the two edges need to be lowered. Sometimes it will do a combination of readings and you will have to plane away the high spots until you get it to hit the three points in both diagonals.

You need to bring the bench top into a flat by hand planing away the high spots until the straight edge sits flat across both diagonals then along the sides and across the ends and all over. The diagonals will tell you if you have any wind or twist in the surface.

This is by far the most accurate and easiest way to create a flat surface that i know of. I would never even consider using winding sticks.