We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I was given a spokeshave by a friend. It had been his grandfathers'. While it has no markings, I believe it is a Goodell Pratt Patternmaker's shave, a picture of which can be found on catalog page 335 (PDF page 161) in the link below. The cap is not removable. It pivots on a rod that is captive to the body. When I tighten the screw, the cap makes contact with the blade on one side only. The rod may be bent slightly. I'm guessing. I'm going to try to even the tension by gently hammering the high side. I'm then going to use a thin diamond file to get between the cap and the bed to flatten the surfaces. If this doesn't work, I will shim between the cap and bed.
Questions; What should I use for shim material? Any other suggestions for improving performance and tuning up this shave (I will obviously flatten the sole and sharpen the blade)? And no, I haven't tried it out yet to see if it chokes and chatters. I'm assuming it will because of the gap between the blade and cap.
There is more info on the G-P #36 spokeshave in Tom Lamond's book on spokeshaves, pages 176-177. Here are some relevant points:
The G-P shave (36 and 37) were very similar to the Bailey Victor shaves (41 and 43); Bailey manufactured these in the 1870s then Stanley continued until 1884. G-P began manufacturing the 36, 37 around 1900. The G-P 36 has two adjusting thumbscrews, one in the front and one in the back; the G-P logo would be stamped on the adjusting screws. The Bailey 41 has an adjusting screw in the back only. Sears also sold a similar shave (#3661); the thumbscrew on the Sears was sometimes marked 'Dunlap' and is on the small size. Other similar shaves have been observed, almost always unmarked. The adjusting screw on these would likely be only on the top side of the shave .
No useful info on how to tinker with one to apply even pressure to the blade.
Thanks Larry. Mine is not marked anywhere and has one steel screw only. The body casting has some rough spots and the cap is not parallel to the bed. Other Goodell Pratt tools I've seen were better quality. It would not surprise me to find out it was made by some other manufacturer. My ability to fettle this shave is hampered by my diminished vision due to old age.
Aluminium flashing is a little thicker if a can is too thin. Use a leather hole punch or sharpen some steel brake line with the proper ID for a hole punch.
Check for "craft metal" at your hardware store. My Ace store carries aluminum, brass, and maybe steel in various thicknesses, so you could really fine tune this puppy.
Lee Valley, I believe, uses plastic for the shims in its spokeshaves. I don't know what plastic; but you could try cutting up bleach bottles or similar products to see how that would work.
After taking the shave apart and flattening the cap and bed I've determined that the holes that the rod fits in were not aligned properly. The rod is not parallel to the bed and thus the cap isn't either. Surprisingly, the shave worked fairly well on white oak with no chatter though it did choke with shavings. The shave had a lot of chipping on the leading edge of the cap suggesting it had been used a lot. The blade had obviously been adjusted with a hammer but not abused. The cap was too hard for a file to abrade it. I really like how this shave feels in the hand when using it. The design is simple but very comfortable. A shim won't fix this. I could use bondo or epoxy and apply it to the cap, wax the blade and clamp the cap down on the blade and let it set. I could fill a hole on one side somehow and redrill a new hole. I don't know how I would fill the hole. For now, I think I'll buy a new shave. But I really like how this one feels.
I've thought about fixing this shave. I think filling one hole and redrilling a properly positioned hole is my first strategy. The position of the new hole would require the rod to exert pressure against the filler material. I've found two or three things to use. JB Weld is one. Would this take the pressure? Would something else be better?
The only way to really be successful in realigning the holes in that body would involve brazing or welding the holes closed and re-drilling them using a machine tool such as a milling machine. Anything less would risk ruining the body of the shave completely and risk your personal safety as well.
Fillers other than metal are not a proper fix and you will be lucky if they work short term. I`m betting if you use something like epoxy or JD weld it won`t even last long enough to get you through the drilling process.
That's what I was afraid of. I have a Sherline milling machine and I was only having to drill one hole. Filling that one hole is the real problem. The shave works but not optimally. I'd like to fix the problem but it may be more trouble than it's worth.
It`s my understanding that the two holes are drilled in tandem so that they match up with each other and effectively align the pin with the bed. My guess is that the body of this shave slipped in the tooling while being drilled and that has caused both holes to be off. One just shows it more than the other.
Think about how how the pin fits and aligns with these two holes as well as how these holes and the pin placement relate to the body of the tool. If you move one of them in order to bring the pin into better alignment with the bed then the hole you are leaving untouched will be out of alignment with the new hole, the pin and the rest of the tool body. Even if you do manage to drive that pin into both holes the misalignment between holes will, at the very least, cause one end of the pin to not fit fully or bear completely on the bore of one hole. It may also bend the pin slightly if the pin will allow it. Alternately, the misalignment of the holes coupled with a strong and unforgiving pin has the potential to stress the shave body enough to either cause a fracture in the area around the pin holes once you crank the cap iron down enough to capture the blade or tweak the entire body (possibly through the bed area) out of alignment.
Very few rigidly mounted things that show evidence of misalignment during manufacture and don`t allow for follow on alignment can be corrected by way of a single "quick fix". I have found that it always helps to look at the entire assembly and how it relates to the rest of the machine before I undertake any "repairs". Every time I have engaged in a "quick fix" without considering the big picture I have found that I haven`t actually fixed anything. What I have actually done is move the problem on to stress the machine in a different area and caused it to malfunction (or fail) in some new and creative way. Machines (especially deceptively simple machines such as shaves) are wicked smart that way. smart enough to outsmart me on a regular basis if I don`t slow down and fail to listen to what they are actually telling me or hear the message in it`s entirety.
If this shave were mine I would use it as is for a roughing shave and set my intent on finding (or making, with experienced help) a nice, wood body low angle shave or perhaps a scraper shave to serve as a finishing tool. That way you`d get to compare two relatively different tools that perform much the same function.
The need to understand how and why some things work better than others is part of what drew me to hand tools to begin with.
PS- I can offer you a short term loan on an old LA wood shave that functions well on most New England hardwoods if you`d like to test the water before taking the plunge.
Bob, the wisdom of your comments is great. After reading your response above I hit my forehead and exclaimed in my best Homer Simpson voice, "doh!". I was myopic in my approach. You're right, both holes were probably drilled at the same time and, while not aligned with the bed, are aligned with each other. The shave will remain as is. I have other shaves and ordered an LV shave with Xmas money. Thanks for your kind offer. I also have two LV wood shave kits that I now feel an extra impetus to build. I tuned up this shave and a Stanley, made in England 151. I'm amazed how much better the Stanley is. I am anxious to build and use the LV low angle wooden shave.