New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

Posts

The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#1

The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As promised some months ago, here is the full review of the KC Birdcage fretsaw. There is some - heh -passion and intrigue here in possibly the last article of the year.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/KnewConceptsBirdcageFretsaw.html

Please read the first review if you have not yet done so. The current article assumes basic knowledge of the Birdcage fresaw.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/KnewConceptsFretsaw.html

Best wishes from Perth for the festive season!

Derek

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#2

Fretwork

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Have you tried the saw for fretwork?

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#3

Re: Fretwork

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Warren

I have not done any fretwork, so I cannot comment how they work in this regard. This saw came about for removing the waste of dovetails. It derived from saws used for fretwork, which are deeper. This one has a 5" frame. There is another with a 3" frame. The 8" - 12" versions are likely to be better in this regard.

Warren, I assume that you do have experience in this area. A question - when sawing fretwork, do you predominantly use the saw with the blade in the vertical?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#4

Re: Fretwork

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have a 3" fretsaw and an 8" fretsaw that are used sitting down, vertical, pull stroke. For dovetails I use a coping saw push stroke. I use the coping saw pull stroke when sitting down.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#5

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical l

William Duffield

Has Lee sent you a prototype Black Widow yet, for your analysis?

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#6

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical l

Lars Parrington

Interesting write-up

I use an coping saw to saw out dovetail waste and find it's really no problem to make the cut in a single pass. Just a standard olson saw with a normal blade.


img

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#7

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical l

Michael Brady

I generally like my KC aluminum saw, but it was my first fret saw, so I have no real basis for comparison. I am wondering why your critical look at the new saw mentioned the stiffness of the frame with the blade in parallel with frame and not angled as it is designed to do while cutting wider boards. To me, that would be where I would want to see comparison done, as did the You Tube reviewer. You show several photos of the saw in use in that configuration, but don't refer to that. Perhaps I missed that.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#8

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical l

Tony Wilkins

Very timely Derek. A coping/fret saw had worked it's way to the top of my list (to cut curves on the top and base of a Roubo bookstand). I was looking at the 8 inch or the coping variety of KC saw. In looking at your testing and your recommendation, it does seem that the 3 inch would be best for cutting out dovetail waste.

However, for the job I have it hand, it would seem that more 'room' under the frame would be helpful. Am I thinking correctly?

If so, maybe it's time for me to build that turning bow saw ala Bill Anderson :)

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#9

Re: Fretwork

John Pappas

"For dovetails I use a coping saw push stroke."

Warren, I am curious...what would be the pros/cons to using a push stroke vs a pull stroke. I am not skilled at all in the use of a coping saw. I've tried using a coping saw on some test dovetails, but with little success.

Thanks.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#10

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical l

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

An 8" deep fretsaw - that saws at 45 degrees - is totally overkill for dovetails. Here you can see it will cut to a depth of about 5 1/2" - do we really need to go more than 1"? In addition, the longer arms will increase its vulnerability to flex.


Even a 5" fretsaw is unnecessary. This cuts to a depth of 3 1/2".


Consequently my recommendation is to get the 3" model, which can cut to a depth of 2", which is more than sufficient for the task of dovetail waste removal.


If, on the other hand, you plan to use the fretsaw for other purposes, then this recommendation does not stand. This information here is more meaningful if you view a fretsaw as you would a dovetail saw, that is, a tool for forming dovetail joints.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#11

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical l

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Lars

Which just goes to demonstrate that there are many ways to skin a cat.

My reviews should never be seen as a recommendation to buy the tool, or that they represent the only or best way to work.

(I posted the following comment on SMC). One of the thoughts I have carried with me from the beginning of writing reviews has been "if I demonstrate how I used the tool, then those who know more than I will see the limitations of my technique, and recognise whether the tool has something to offer them. For those with less technique, there is an opportunity to see what can be done".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#12

Re: Fretwork

Tom

John if one assumes the baseline woodworker today is ambi-directional in being able to use either push or pull saws, and has no prejudices on the mater, then the pull strokes are going to be more efficient since the blade is anchored in the handle. Of course the better saws we have today make than pretty much moot. Some people prefer to push the saw since there is no onside tear-out, to obscure the line. Of course that can be moot also, depending on the blade, and the layout for a dovetail is pretty easy to follow. Myself, if there is going to be any tear out, I want to know right away. Another reason for the direction of cut can be holding work, and what direction will press it to a surface, though that does not seem to be an issue with this kind of stuff.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#13

push stroke

Warren in Lancaster, PA

John, I am used to looking at the cleaner side of the kerf as I saw. When I do dovetails I am looking at the handle side of the board and I push; when I do fretwork I am looking at the side away from the handle and cut on the pull. I have seen some coping saws that buckle when cutting on the push stroke, but mine does not.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#14

Re: New KC Concepts?

William Duffield

Isn't anyone curious enough to ask about what Lee Marshall is working on now?

As many KC saws, and pictures thereof, as I've seen on benches, in tool boxes, hanging on workshop walls*, in magazines, videos, blogs, forums, etc., I figured there would be enough interest here to at least ask me what I'm talking about. Maybe everyone out there is chopping out their dovetails, or sawing their veneer on an Excalibur scroll saw, or building their own chevalet de marquetrie? Maybe everyone out there also attended WIA and has already seen the Black Widows, but didn't walk up and introduce themselves when they passed me? OK, if you were there, you were probably too busy talking with some really important woodworkers, tool makers and authors to bother with me. I know you didn't take one of these saws home with you, because there had only been three constructed at that point, and Lee had already decided who was getting each of those for further evaluation. All I have is a photo, and a bit of very tentative design and feature analysis.

Nota bene, Someone over on Pitsaw Swamp :) , or wherever, in response to another parallel review notice of la tour Eiffel, asked about the latest advances in fretsaw materials technology, and this just might answer his question in the affirmative.

* In the spirit of full disclosure, I have a 5" KC fretsaw hanging on my shop wall, for which I paid retail price. I also have, on the same wall, several other fretsaws and coping saws that I am not at all pleased with, and my "go to" coping saw that I built myself.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#15

Re: New KC Concepts?

Larry Barrett

OK, you have my attention now. Can you expand on your tentative analysis and provide a pix?

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#16

Same here.  What's Black Widow?


Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#17

Re: Same here.  What's Black Widow?

William Duffield

These are the new experimental saws KC brought to WIA. They are shown in the photo with KC's production aluminum frame 3" and 5" fret saws. For lightness and stiffness, the frames are made from aluminum and carbon fiber tubes.


Note that the smaller diameter frame components are pinned at each end. Using the same set of components, by simply cutting the carbon tubes to the appropriate lengths, they can manufacture these in a wide range of arbitrary throat depths and even blade lengths.

Also, note that the fretsaw blade holders can rotate 360° (with stops every 45°). As Derek notes, the holders on their production fret saws, due to interference with the frame, can only rotate 270°.

When the guys working on the Space Elevator figure out how to manufacture buckytubes to arbitrary length, diameter and thickness, these saws will be ready, reducing their weight considerably, while also increasing their stiffness. :D

As I note above, these are first generation prototypes. I cannot speculate on what modifications might be made before they reach production, or when or even if they will ever reach production. I also cannot say what their most appropriate applications should be. I suspect it will not be sawing out dovetail waste in particularly difficult hardwoods. KC have already cornered the high end of that niche market. I did not get to try out the saws, and I am not skilled enough at marquetry or other potential applications to give a fair evaluation anyway.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#18

Knew concepts is becoming a steampunk outfit!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My poor little no-name, perfectly serviceable coping saw is going to be demanding dress-up clothes.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#19

Re: Knew concepts is becoming a steampunk outfit!

William Duffield

…and a different outfit for every occasion. :D There are lots of occasions which might demand a different outfit, and thus a different saw.

I found a post by Lee Marshall on another forum, in which he stated (before WIA) that he expected the new saws to come in at around 9 oz., which is quite a bit more than KC's AL-handled fretsaws, so I don't expect they will be weapon of choice for those who plan to use them mainly for sawing out gnarly Antipodean dovetail waste. This is about the same weight as the inexpensive, deep throat fretsaw the Lee Valley sells, and I suspect quite a bit less than their inexpensive coping saw, or my home-made coping saw for that matter.

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#20

...deep-throat fretsaw from LV...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Sir Wm and all,

How does that German-made saw--the one whose hoop has a round cross-section--compare with the Knew Concepts aluminum fretsaw for rigidity? The ones with rectangular sections give ground by deflecting out of plane, if tensioned enough, including my 8" KC. But the round cross-section would tend to resist this kind of deflection (in theory).

Can anyone compare the two?

Wiley

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#21

Re: ...deep-throat fretsaw from LV...

William Duffield

I should be able to do a comparison, as I have one of each. Would tests following the lines of the tests Derek found useful be appropriate and sufficient, or should I pretend I can't saw straight and also repeat the testing regimen of the guy Derek generously calls the "Poster"? :D

Are there any other measurements you would find valuable, e.g., varying the type of saw blade? A related concern is that these saws have very different blade tensioning mechanisms, and the additional stress to failure might therefore be very different. In any case, I'll see what I can do. I have another way of measuring lateral forces on the blades and handles that might tell us something useful.

I'll get some pics of my testbed if I can make it work and get any meaningful numbers from it. Calibration is the major issue here. :)

Re: The Knew Concepts Birdcage Fretsaw: critical look

#22

Re: ...deep-throat fretsaw from LV...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Sir Wm and all,

I really am interested in your subjective impression, the kind we get when we use a tool to saw a typical piece of wood. Just a total anecdote. For example, if you take the KC saw and tension it til just before it deflects, and do the same for the LV tubular frame. And then use each saw to saw a tail in the first stick of wood you pick up off the shop floor, can you tell which saw blade is is forming the least catenary (I think that's a word) bow?

Derek has set the bar so high, that anecdotes are sometimes afraid to show their face. But I like anecdotes--they're really real doncha know :) .

Wiley