New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Custom Tasai Chisels

Posts

Custom Tasai Chisels

#1

Custom Tasai Chisels

Allen Fulmer

Hey everyone, I browse here frequently but Im new to posting. I know there are a bunch of Japanese tool specialists on this forum and Im looking for some insight. First, I found these custom Tasai push chisels online, and im trying to get the specifics of them. I really like their aesthetic features, a lot. its possibleObviously they're Mokume, are the sockets a dark blue? Or are they black and the lighting is weird? This may seem like a strange question but im very curious.

http://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/gallery_nomi/20070224_tasai_mokume_push_chisels/pics/IMG_0498.JPGhttp://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/gallery_nomi/20070224_tasai_mokume_push_chisels/pics/IMG_0515.JPGhttp://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/gallery_nomi/20070224_tasai_mokume_push_chisels/pics/IMG_0516.JPG

Also, Ive got a set of Koyamaichi Bench chisels as well as a set of Koyamaichi Dovetail chisels(hooped) but I find myself being able to use bench chisels for most of my larger dovetails, and just needing to clean out the very corners. I know this isnt news but I guess Im curious if I have a set of bench chisels, are push "dovetail" chisels useful rather than hooped ones? I guess im curious what some of your japanese chisel collections consist of.

Answers to these questions would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#2

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

Allen Fulmer

For some reason it cut off the other two pictures I had

http://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/gallery_nomi/20070224_tasai_mokume_push_chisels/pics/IMG_0515.JPGhttp://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/gallery_nomi/20070224_tasai_mokume_push_chisels/pics/IMG_0516.JPG

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#3

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Allen,

There is a ferrule style in deep blue, so the photo may well be rendering accurately. I have Funahiro slicks with that style (dark blue) ferrule. Handling is a separate trade, and the chisel is being made to someone's order, so the ferrule could be specified by the smith, or the broker, or the retailer, or in this case the owner. For your own purposes, if it matters to you, you will need to get an understanding with the vendor at the time of ordering.

At the time I got into hand tools, I started with Japanese (mostly), and a friend kept after me to get a couple of slicks. I procrastinated, not immediately seeing the sense in them, but one day just went and did it. I was hooked.

But it all depends on how you like to work. For example, I like to saw out dovetail waste, or the waste between multiple tenons, and then pare to the line. I like slicks for this. The length gives a good sense of vertical or other angle, and the length also is useful if you're paring with a 45 degree or 90 degree paring block. For dovetail or multiple tenon paring, take the end of the handle in one hand and put that hand right under your jaw, and just lean your weight down to make the cut--it's very controlled (very little muscle exertion), and you can see your angle very well. For this task, I bought a series of 'smalls', from 1/8" through 1/2" by sixteenths, or equivalently, 3mm, 4.5mm, 6mm, 7.5mm, 9mm, 10.5mm, 12mm. I still like this set of smalls, and a 30mm or 36mm is also useful to have for surface paring, like into a corner, with the bevel down. Or across a tenon cheek, with the bevel up.

But if you like to chop dovetails, then very little of the above applies--it's all about how you like to work.

Customization is something to think about. For example, for dovetails, I find it's nice to have the sidewalls angled at about 10 degrees off vertical. Chutaro Imai, who is now close to retired, would provide this angle with his high-end chisels, and would also make the in-between sizes to order (such as 4.5mm, 7.5mm). If you're interested in this kind of customization, ask the vendor if it can be arranged. I find the ability to obtain custom features more important than the maker's name--others might disagree.

Suggestion: Get in touch with Stu Tierney, or go to the LV site, and buy a 1/4" slick, Koyamaichi for example, and see what you think.

Wiley

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#4

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

Allen Fulmer

Thanks for the response Wiley, I appreciate it. Typically when I do hand cut dove tails, i use a marking wheel gauge and then saw to the line and saw out just about up to the marked line. I also pare to the finished line however since I have "chopping" DT chisels i usually just set the chisel tip in the line and cut half way through, flip over and repeat. So its kind of a mix of both. But in my original post, I mentioned that i can use my bench chisels to chop to the line and use a paring DT chisel to clean out the corners. I feel like my "chopping" dt chisels are a little redundant. But Im relatively new to hand cut joined, so advice is very welcome.

In regards to the chisels, I did think they were dark blue ferrules, but I wasnt sure. I have some chisels with black hoops that dont look like these under any lighting conditions,so I figured they couldnt be black. I really like the look of the above Tasai chisels. Customizing my chisels is important to me, as is the maker.

I actually have ordered all of my chisels through Stu. Hes been fantastic, and his homepage is at the top of my favorites list. Its rather unfortunate for my bank account(haha)

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#5

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

wilbur

In most cases, a Japanese “dovetail” chisel is not exactly the same as a western dovetail chisel. The Japanese dovetail chisel is so named because the shape of the top of the chisel comes up to a triangular profile. But there still are side walls that make a 90º angle with the back of the chisel. Here’s a standard Japanese chisel next to a Japanese dovetail chisel. You can see that the side wall makes it so that the Japanese dovetail chisel really won’t have an advantage over a regular Japanese chisel in terms of getting into the corner of a dovetail.


Just to push this point home, here are a series of 1/4” Japanese chisels. The first is a standard Japanese chisel profile, the second is a Japanese “dovetail” chisel, and the last is a Japanese mortise chisel. Again, you’ll see that both the standard and dovetail chisels have those vertical sidewalls that make them essentially equivalent in terms of getting into the corner of a dovetail.


For me, I have standard profile Japanese bench chisels, and the Japanese paring chisels that I have are of the dovetail variety. The different shapes don’t provide any functional advantage, but I like the way that they look. In terms of dovetails, I tend to chop most of the waste, and either chop or pare to the baseline depending on how things are going. For me, I use a narrow enough chisel so that I can skew the chisel to get into the corner, rather than having a “real" dovetail chisel. With a narrow enough chisel, you can get in there, even on dovetail joints with real skinny pins.


And if you go this route, you’ll have, say, a 1/4” chisel and a 1/8” chisel, which overall is more useful than having a 1/4” chisel and a 1/4” dovetail chisel. You’ll use that 1/8” chisel for a lot more than just getting into the corner of a dovetail.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#6

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

Allen Fulmer

I understand what you guys are saying. I also really appreciate the input thus far. As I'm just starting to build my chisel collection, it's nice to hear which chisels others find useful and which ones might have been necessary.

I'm considering picking up a few shinogi push chisels of smaller sizes, say 3,6,9mm?(Is there a benefit to having multiple small sizes? The chopping I can do with my bench chisels. I was aware of the sidewalls on Japanese shinogi chisels, but I've read that Tasai's "very thin" chisels have a very minuscule flat on the sides. Does anyone have any experience with any of these chisels?

I was also considering getting a true dovetail chisel for cleaning up half blind dovetail sockets.

I also found this picture of a Tasai mortise chisel, which has a dark blue socket on it. Maybe this is the socket on the Tasai push chisels I posted?

http://www.thebestthings.com/newtools/tasai_japanese_bench_chisels.htm

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#7

Re: The real story

Tom

1) Are you a collector or a user? Both are totally legitimate, but if you are a user, in my opinion there is a reason to keep it simple. I have a hundred or more Japanese chisels, about half of the very highest order. I don't even want to go into how few of them I actually use. The more you have the more time you spend on fettling and maintenance, and as you have already found out, there are duplicates. I think if the chisels really do something different, that is fine.

2) I am wary of tourist chisels. Eye candy sets for punters. When I bought my Tasai push chisels I had a chance to hold and look at a bunch of them. I had long since learned that the ones you are going to hit are probably better in white oak, but here was a chance to go wild again, and get whatever handles I wanted since it obviously wouldn't mater since I wouldn't be hitting them. But what I found was that the quality of the fancy sets was terrible, they weren't assembled straight, and ever the forging was off. I ended up with a slightly touristy set, white oak handles, but raw forged, which I assume is another eye candy trick. Still there was something workmanlike about them, and they have turned out to be the best chisels I own.

3) So as you know the oxidation spectrum goes through the blues to the blacks. If it is a real heat thing, then to get to forging, temps you are going to get well into a heavy black end of things, but to do the tempering, you are not going to get anywhere near there. And of course the finish can be chemical, or japan black. All that said it is likely to be black with any secondary tinge being blue. I would not expect the blue part to be heavy.

Since you are dealing with a mokune finish, I am guessing it would be ground clean, polished, pickled to bring out the pattern, and then chemical blued or something. It is hard to know since there are all kinds of ways of playing with the pattern.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#8

Re: The real story

Allen Fulmer

Tom,

I'm absolutely a user. But at the same time i want to own a few eye candy chisels. Most of my chisels are/will be "working" chisels.

I don't know a ton about the tempering process and such, but are you saying there's a good chance that the socket is black with a blue hue due to hear during the processes? I'm trying to understand as best I can.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#9

Dovetail Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There were no dovetail chisels when I started making dovetails. And lots of guys made dovetails before I came around. Decades ago, when they started marketing the triangular section Japanese chisels (like umeki sumi nomi and shinogi nomi), the catalogue writers had to say what to do with them and said "for tight places like dovetails". Later they started calling them dovetail chisels.

Now American tool makers are selling dovetail chisels. This is a great example of catalogue copy writers creating a market and a need that has no basis in reality.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#10

Re: The real story

david weaver

Those chisels are regarded as good chisels. If they are $400 per, probably less than half of the cost is for functionality, though, stan covington mentioned that a lot of craftsmen in japan wouldn't be caught dead with showy chisels like that.

Since the rings/patterning are made of (apparently from their description) layers of steel (instead of mokume that is made from wrought which is very easy to sharpen), there is no practical benefit of them over any other soft iron or mild steel backing, both of which appear in inexpensive chisel across the board. It may be that wrought isn't used on those chisels because it would threaten their ability to be as thin.

If you want the quality of Tasai's work, but with your money spent toward the parts of his trade that he plies that will help you do your work, and not hundreds of dollars spent toward adornment, you can probably check with thebestthings, or Stu Tierney or Tomohito Iida and get a plainer version of the same thing.

As a vote for practicality, if you already chop your dovetails, you'd probably use your push dovetail chisels about as much as I use mine (though mine aren't tasais) - which is never.

There are excellent makers of less expensive but equally functional chisels (though they may not quite have the amount of hand work in them the tasai does, and for academic purposes might not hold an edge quite as long) from makers like tasai and ouchi. their chisels are utilitarian and inexpensive in comparison, but are a delight to work with.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#11

Re: Dovetail Chisels

Allen Fulmer

If you're implying I do not need triangular shaped Japanese paring/bench chisels(aka dovetail chisels) I'm aware of that. However I enjoy re-investing the money I make building fine furniture and custom cabinetmaking. At this point in my life, I have a relatively low overhead so now is the best time to feed this addiction. I don't have a house yet, or any kids yet, although I will be getting married soon. So splurging for "chisels that are not necessary" is acceptable for now.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#12

Re: The real story

Allen Fulmer

I'm all for functional chisels, like I said my chisels are "working" chisels. However having two or three paring chisels that are a pleasure to glance at(that are also of an exception working quality) is okay in my book. I was looking for details of the sockets/ferrules on the Tasai chisels because I really like them. Other than those particular chisels the rest of my collection will consist of function over form chisels.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#13

Re: The real story

david weaver

Well, you could get them for jewelry if you'd like. $100 would also get you an extremely nice patternmaker's vintage parer with a forged bolster.

There are places where you'll have to spend a lot of money with almost no other choice (on wood, and on carving tools if you get into carving and don't want to spend your life looking for carving tools). I'd save the difference for that.

One of the problems with the extremely expensive chisels if you watch how they sell used is that if you change your mind, you will be eating a very large percetnage of the purchase price. You're also subject to currency fluctuation, which could put you into another point of loss, and the unprotected surfaces of the japanese chisels will rust as fast or faster than anything else (depending on what they're made of) and people who would buy those chisels from you in the future will expect them to be perfect - so working with them becomes a tedious routine of following them around to check for rust, too, whereas something old with patina will obtain rust a little less quickly and be devalued less from it if some chances onto a surface.

And the last issue, if you look around at the old chisels online (and perhaps the future will be different), there are not a lot of retired smiths whose chisels bring a lot of money. What brings big money, aside from a few very rare things - like ichichiro or kiyotada - is whatever is being sold for a high price new at the time.

Again, just my opinion.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#14

Tasai very-thin

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Allen,

I bought a Tasai 15mm verithin years ago for getting into tight places--can't remember the specifics of the problem. Anyway, it does have the thin lands you asked about--the land is about 1/32" tall, tapering to disappearance in the honed section. Black ferrule, by the way, and the ferrule is forged, as are all of Tasai's.

It's really a useful chisel. The blade is 1/8" thick, with the shank above increasing slightly to 5/32" or so). Tasai does not mold the shank into the circular ferrule above. The shank remains in rectangular section where it butts into the ferrule, with a discontinuity at the join, with wood showing at the butt end.

The point of this chisel is to get into narrow places. It's strong enough for general paring, despite the thinness. If the utility sounds attractive, I would encourage you to buy one, and see what you think. They are relatively inexpensive IIRC (for Tasai).

You won't go wrong buying Tasai. Couple years from now, you'll have forgotten the money.

Wiley

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#15

Re: Tasai very-thin

Allen Fulmer

Thanks Wiley!

Would you be willing to post a picture or two of your very thin so I could take a look?

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#16

Try to do it by tonight


Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#18

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

wilbur

It appears that Tasai goes back and forth how the ferrule is made. Here’s a picture of two Tasai chisels, one dovetail and one mokume. The mokume chisel clearly has a silver socket/ferrule, whereas the regular dovetail chisel has the darker ferrule.


Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#19

Photos

Allen Fulmer

Thank you Wiley and Wilbur. I really appreciate you guys doing that.

Wiley, what is the color of that ferrule on your very thin? If that's a blackish blue I will know that Tasai could do it.

Also Wilbur, same to you. What's the color of the ferrule on your shinogi chisel. PS is that a chisel from "the best things"?

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#20

Re: Photos

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Allen,

In north light, the ferrule color is black, but on the blue side of black. I looked again at my Funahiro slicks:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8135513179/in/set-72157631881424249/

They have a ferrule, forged like the Tasai one, that is deepest blue. The ferrule is worn slightly at the bottom. There is a dull deep charcoal gray under the blue, so i would say the blue is a coating or chemical treatment. Just a guess.

Suggestion: Ask Stu about the ferrule: Who specifies it? Who forges it? Does the chisel maker supply the ferrule, or does the handling guy have drawers full of them? Is the blue an applied treatment or heating artifact? If you want--or don't want--blue, can you specify it? Can you specify what you want?

Wiley

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#22

Re: Photos

Allen Fulmer

I will definitely do that, thanks so much for posting your pictures and adding your insight.

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#23

Manny Hernandez

Allen Fulmer

The place I found these chisels at, says they belong to Manny Hernandez. Ive noticed in the archives he's posted here/well known here. One of the reasons I posted these on here was in hopes that either A) the owner posted here or B)someone knew him or has seen the chisels in person. It seems that he is a member here. Maybe Ill get lucky and he'll see this but if not, does anyone know how to contact him?

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#24

Re: Tasai very-thin

Allen Fulmer

Im going to pick up one or two very thin since you as well as a few others speak so highly of them. im going to try a 12mm, i was also considering a 6mm. Would you recommend the "usu" style over shinogi regardless of what it will be used for(general work, dovetails, or both) since it has such small lands?

Re: Custom Tasai Chisels

#25

Re: Manny Hernandez

Howard Pollack

You might be able to find him through the diakudojo.org