Re: Word of warning - The Art of Joinery 2nd editi
Old Baleine
No one has touched this comment for two days, so I will.
Thanks to Zeb for pointing out this change in construction and for contacting John Hoffman for information. I haven't yet received my copy, so I am commenting on information I have taken from Zeb's comment and from the Lost Art Press website.
The Lost Art Press bookstore describes the new edition as "notched and casebound", and as having "rough exterior edges".
"Notched and casebound" means that the sheets on which the pages are printed are gathered into signatures, but rather than each signature being bound together by thread, the folded edge of each signature is notched by cutting out small squares along the folded edge. Think of a box joint. This is done mainly to increase the gluing surface of the edge. All of the signatures are then gathered together, forming the text block, and the notched edges of the text block are glued together before being bound into the case of the book (the "covers"), pretty much the same way their books have always been bound. The main difference is that the signatures are glued, not sewn.
While I agree that this is a departure for Lost Art Press from every other book they have published, it does not necessarily mean that it is "cheap and shoddy". Assuming LAP are as fastidious with their paper choices as they have always been, the critical component of this type of binding is, of course, the adhesive. If LAP or their binder specified a UV-stabilized polyurethane reactive adhesive for the binding, then this edition should open easily, rest open and flat, and last a long time.
Given the choice between a smythe-sewn binding with trimmed edges, and a glued binding with deckled edges, I prefer the smythe-sewn, but I am a stick-in-the-mud. I doubt that there is a significant cost difference between the smythe-sewn and a high quality notched and glued binding. The deckled edge, which LAP describes as "a feature like early books", is merely a design conceit. It is incongruous with several of the other editorial emendations of the new edition that are surely not a feature of books in Moxon's time, such as the inclusion of photographs. When paper was made by hand, the paper fibers were cast on a frame called a deckle. The edges of the sheet were irregular ("deckled") until trimmed. In modern papers, the deckled edge is an anachronism, sort of like stone quoins on the edges of modern buildings.
I think that what is most difficult for LAP is that this change was never mentioned in the roll-out to this new edition. It is a significant departure in construction from their previous publications, and Christopher Schwarz should have drawn attention to it, rather than waiting for his subscribers to discover it. However, depending on the binder's choice of adhesive and its proper application, it is unfair to characterise the binding as "cheap and shoddy".
I hope this helps address any concerns that might have been raised by Zeb's posting. For the record, other than being a customer, I have no connection to Lost Art Press.