New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Box joints

Posts

Box joints

#1

Box joints

Randy Johnson

Okay folks, a question from a pretty much hard core Normite.

Did box joints even exist before the industrial revolution, and if so, how were they made? I can see that it might be possible if a really thick special saw was available, but I'm thinking that in absence of a jig and circular dado setup, dovetail joints - even on thinner wood - would have been way easier.

Re: Box joints

#2

Re: Box joints

Patrick Gibbons

It's my understanding that box joints came with mechanization. Before this, boxes, meaning containers, were clinch nailed together. If a joint were made, it would have been a dovetail. The Practical Woodworkerhas a chapter on box making and outlines this. I seem to remember it ascribing an American use to box joints.

Re: Box joints

#3

Re: Box joints

Brian Greene

My understanding is that the box joint came with power saws and the industrial revolution. There were no cardboard boxes and everything was crated. These joints were typically small -- the thickness of the blade -- and were likely made on dedicated machines with multiple blades.

Re: Box joints

#4

Re: Box joints

wilbur

Box joints: as difficult to make as a dovetail, without the mechanical advantage.

Re: Box joints

#5

Re: Box joints--Japan

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Interestingly, box joints are typical for carcase joining in Japanese tansu. The ones I've seen in books are somewhat longish, and traditionally pinned with bamboo so there is some mechanical strength. Many times overlain with metal (iron), further reinforcing the join. They would have been handcut, I would suppose.

Wiley

Re: Box joints

#6

Michael Donaldson

Re: Box joints

Michael Donaldson

I cut box joints the same way I cut dovetails. I personally happen to like the look of box joints better than dovetails, but I hand cut both.

Re: Box joints

#7

Re: Box joints

Randy Johnson

Thanks all, you have confirmed what I was thinking.

The reason I asked in the first place is because I am going to be making up some small boxes that need to be correct for pre-1812 construction and, being the power tool scoundrel that I am, box joints would have been easier.

Oh well.

I have never been very good at hand cutting dovetails but I now have incentive to get better at it. I have the toys for it, I understand the process, but something gets lost in translation between my brain and my hands.

Re: Box joints

#8

Re: Box joints

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Are these utility boxes, or fine boxes? If utility, my impression is that a lot of them were butt joints with nails.

Re: Box joints

#9

Re: Box joints

Randy Johnson

Somewhere in-between.

They will be smaller boxes intended for personal items or maybe shooting supplies. I have one old small carpenter’s box that is made with a mitered wood frame at the top and bottom as is pretty much universal, but the main carcass of the box is dovetailed. Most if not all the wood is ¾ inches thick.

What I want to make will be scaled down by about half and I was planning to make the body of the boxes from 1/4 inch boards. Even using (excuse me folks, I’ve admitted to being a Normite) a jig, dovetails in that thin a piece of wood is a lot more difficult than box joints. While I will be making some for myself, some will be used as shoot prizes as well. They need to have a little class.

I may end up simply using face frame construction. The goal is making the boxes light as possible.

Re: Box joints

#10

Re: Box joints

Patrick Gibbons

1/4" wood is like a drawer. Dovetails are easier than with thicker woods. I'm thinking about using a handsaw, of course. Dovetails provide a mechanical lock while a box joint relies on the glue only. Modern glues are good and reliable. I'd decide which joint based on desired look and how much abuse the boxes would receive. This would be a good project to build your dovetailing skills. You'll be pleased to discover how quickly you improve.

Re: Box joints

#11

Re: Box joints

Tom

With softer woods, maybe up to around mahog, you can cut out the DTs with a single strike of the chisel from either side. Makes making small boxes or drawers very fast.

Re: Box joints

#12

Re: Box joints

Tom

With softer woods, maybe up to around mahog, you can cut out the DTs with a single strike of the chisel from either side. Chisel needs to have a long bevel. Makes making small boxes or drawers very fast.

Re: Box joints

#13

Re: Box joints

Brian Greene

One of the advantages of machine made box joints (router table is best, table saw is fastest) is that the parts can be ganged for efficiency.