New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Fishtail chisels

Posts

Fishtail chisels

#1

Fishtail chisels

Joe shelton

I think I need some fishtail chisels, and don't know how to choose between the Blue Spruce, which may not even be available right now, and LN. Looks to me as though the LN could be used with a mallet, but the Blue Spruce could not. Anyone know?

Thanks.

Joe

Re: Fishtail chisels

#2

Re: Fishtail chisels

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I made a fishtail chisel from an old 1/2" Stanley #60. It works well. I doubt it's any thicker than the Blue Spruce and I can use a mallet on it. In making half-blind dovetails, the only time I use it, there's not much pounding involved anyway. It doesn't take much persuasion to clean out those back corners.

Dave Jeske demonstrated his chisels at the HandWorks show in Iowa. He beat the living daylights out of it, demonstrating both chisel and mallet, and neither was any worse for the wear.

Re: Fishtail chisels

#3

Re: Fishtail chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

First of all, you do not use a mallet on a fishtail chisel. They are a paring chisel, used for clearing out corners, such as in dovetail pins. They require some delicacy in use, not force.

Secondly, I have used the Blue Spruce for some years and can recommend them wholeheartedly. They take and hold a terrific edge. Their handles are the best in the business.

About a year ago Stu (Tools from Japan) sent me a prototype Koyamaichi fishtail. The main difference is in the handle and shaft, which is typical of those used on a Japanese slick (paring chisel). This does offer a little more solid feel.

Both are excellent. Here they are alongside a Japanese slick.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fishtail chisels

#4

Roger the delicacy, but

Joe shelton

You can't have Work without force. I don't have your wrists or mitts, but I do have a lil ole mallet that can be very judicious.

Would you expound on your comment that the handles on Blue Spruce chisels are the best?

Joe

Re: Fishtail chisels

#5

Re: Fishtail chisels

Lloyd Robins

I like my LN fishtail. I have both the long and short handle for it. It is nice to have the option.

Re: Fishtail chisels

#6

A couple of points ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

There are similarities between the Blue Spruce and the Veritas. I don't have photos of the Blue Spruce being held, so I will use the Veritas to demonstrate a few factors.

Here is the Veritas and the Lie-Nielsen (since you singled out this along with the BS) ...


In my hand the Veritas looks like this ..


... and the Stanley 750 (aka LN) looks like this ..


Here are the BS alongside the Stanley ..


What I am trying to show you is that the Veritas and the Blue Spruce have handles that are longer than the LN/Stanley. This creates a better balance for paring. The strength of the LN/Stanley lies in the shorter handle being better suited to use with a mallet.

The Veritas and the Blue Spruce handles are quite similar in shape and feel. The BP is superlatively shaped and finished and for this reason gets my nod.

Keep in mind that this is my personal experience and your mileage may vary.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fishtail chisels

#7

Re: Fishtail chisels

William Duffield

The long run issue with fish tails is that as you sharpen them, the tail gets smaller and smaller. A pair of skew chisels will do the same job as one fish tail on full blind or half blind dovetails, etc. but you have to swap tools more often. If you're very concerned about expense, you can buy two straight paring chisels and easily grind opposite skews into them. It's a bit more difficult to start with a wider straight paring chisel and grind it into a fishtail, because you have to remove a lot more metal, and you probably don't have a grinding jig that makes it easy to control the geometry.

Re: Fishtail chisels

#8

Re: Fishtail chisels and such

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe and all,

The Blue Spruce will take at least light hammering. With a steel hammer, so I'm sure a mallet would be fine. Here's the business end of three 3/8" chisels:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/10087112024/lightbox/

Blue Spruce dovetail chisel at top; then an Imai fishtail; then an Imai shinogi (triangular section) slick at bottom.

Derek has covered the handles very well, and I find myself not even thinking about handles as long as it has one, so am not a good source on comparing them.

I like fishtail chisels--gouges too--but not especially because you need them to get into corners. The thing that differentiates fishtails for me is that, with the blade taper and the low bevel angle appropriate to a paring chisel, you have great line of sight to exactly where the tip of the chisel is cutting. I'm not guessing, I really can see that last fiber next to the wall getting sliced.

For dovetails, I ordinarily use what I have in my hand, a 1/4" or 3/16", even though there are skews and fishtails within reach. But I'd just as soon use what's in my hand already. In a dovetail socket corner, like the ones you have on drawer fronts, there are three approaches into the corner--vertically down from the top, vertically in along the side wall, and horizontally along the floor and side wall. Now the last of these three is where people want fishtails. But you have three entries, and the first two entries are square to the chisel, and a small chisel can be wiggled or stabbed into a back corner horizontally to get very nearly the last little bit, and you can easily rake out the remainder from the other two directions. So I use the one in my hand. That's just me, though, every one enjoy your skews in good health; there's room for everyone and every preference :) .

Anyway, I find the fishtails are ones-you-reach-for detail chisels because of the clear line of sight they offer.

Yes, the Blue Spruce can be struck, though maybe it's a question of how much. i've used the one in the photo recently, at times giving it light to moderate taps with a steel hammer, and it didn't mind that. I find it entirely believable that Dave Jeske was malleting away on his. I don't think of a hammer so much as a bashing tool, as a controlled force tool. You can apply a very light sharp hit with a hammer that is hard to replicate with progressive hand force.

One reason I showed the longer slick is that it offers a way to apply controlled force, by putting the gripping hand under your jaw and leaning on the chisel--there's more control using body weight than straight arm force. Very useful paring end grain at the scribe line.

Wiley

Re: Fishtail chisels

#9

Re: Fishtail chisels and such

Joe shelton

Wiley, you're more articulate than I about the use of a hammer for controlled force. Thanks, that's what I meant to say.

Joe

Re: Fishtail chisels

#10

wrong impression - my bad!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Dave J demonstrated his mallet and a regular bench chisel in Iowa, not beating on a fishtail chisel. Sorry, didn't mean to give the wrong impression.

Re: Fishtail chisels

#11

No, you're good!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Joe was asking whether the handle would take a lick, if I understood him. Apparently it will.

Wiley