New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Laminating Strips

Posts

Laminating Strips

#1

Laminating Strips

James Blandford-Baker

I'm making some slats for the backs of a set of dining chairs. They are bent slats so I'm laminating them from 5 pieces of 3mm oak strips (17mm wide). The process involves producing one planed face, cutting the 3mm strip on the bandsaw and then replaning and cutting the next strip. I would really like to be able to get a nice flat surface on the bandsawn side so that all the strips glue together with an almost invisible line (I've been numbering the strips as they are produced to make sure they go back in the same order as they were cut).

I discussed a similar process with James Ryan from the Edward Barnsley workshop recently. He explained that they smooth the cut face on a thickness sanding machine and get excellent results. I don't have a thickness sanding machine!! Does anyone have a good process, or a jig that would be possible to produce in a home workshop to do this? It needs to be controllable. I've tried scraping (very difficult with the 3mm thin strips) and hand sanding (not controllable enough).

Any ideas would be most welcome!

Thanks

James

Re: Laminating Strips

#2

Re: Laminating Strips

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello James,

Welcome! You can thickness plane your strips with a bench plane. Various ways to arrange this. For example, let's say you have a No. 5 plane which is 2-7/16" total width, with a 2" blade. With plywood, cause it'll be pretty flat, make a channel consisting of a base which is 2-7/16"+ wide, and a foot longer than your strips. Glue low sides to this base plate, so that they corral the plane but don't get in the way otherwise. Then you need a pair of the 3mm strips which are the length of the channel. Glue these strips along the edges of the channel, such that the plane will ride on them. You can either make these riding strips 1/4" wide so they're outside the blade of the plane, or just use the ones you're bandsawing and make a couple of passes until the plane bottoms out.

Glue down a cross strip 6" in from the far end of the channel; this cross strip should be lower than 3mm, doesn't matter by how much as long as the strip will catch the lamination, but let the plane pass over.

To use, butt the lamination against the cross strip and plane the band sawn side. Should be about right. If you need to plane a smidgen lower, set your shoulder plane for a fine cut, and make one pass down each side strip, lowering the planing height by one fine shaving. Repeat if need be.

You have now made a thickness planing jig for your No. 5. Of course, about any bench plane will do, with the appropriate modification in channel width.

There are other ways to implement this concept, including temporarily gluing running strips on either side of the plane itself, but one advantage of the channel is that you can use it again with the same plane, plus you don't have to make a search for reversible glue etc etc.

Wiley

Re: Laminating Strips

#3

Re: Laminating Strips

James Blandford-Baker

Thanks Wiley. That makes perfect sense! Sounds like a very good strategy. Thanks for taking the time to explain it so fully.

James

Re: Laminating Strips

#4

Ellis Walentine

Wonderful post, Wiley

Ellis Walentine

For all the laminating I've done, I never thicknessed the strips with a hand plane. Your jig makes excellent sense. Thanks.

Ellis

Re: Laminating Strips

#5

Might have mentioned that

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

if there is any issue of the ply for the channel bottom being a little bowed in the length, one can rebate the side pieces to positively lock it up straight during glue-up.

Wiley

Re: Laminating Strips

#6

Re: Laminating Strips

William Duffield

First, a rhetorical question:

Why do you need to control precisely for thickness on each of your laminating strips? It seems that, since you are working glue surfaces, two smooth surfaces would be the only critical criteria. A bench plane without the thicknessing jig should be sufficient, as long as you are careful to keep the strips reasonably close to the same thickness. After glue up, you can work the two remaining surfaces for thickness and finishing properties with a spokeshave or with rasps and files and scrapers.

Like Ellis, I've also used several methods to do bent laminations. The easiest, quickest way, is to just rip them on a table saw, as long as you don't mind the dust and noise and the sacrificial push stick. I've also used the jointer/bandsaw/drum sander method. If you like that method, you don't need an expensive thicknessing drum sander for narrow strips. A sanding drum and fence on your drill press (or oscillating spindle sander, or even a hand cranked post drill, if you prefer :) ) works well. If you make a mistake and feed the strips in the wrong direction, you probably wont make the same mistake twice. If, after glue-up, you need to work the final surfaces for fairness and thickness, the sanding drum works for those purposes, as well, but for final thicknessing, you need to replace the flat fence with a single point fence like you would use on your bandsaw for resawing.

There are lots of different ways to do it, which one works best for you will depend on what tools you have in your shop, which ones are tuned up to your satisfaction, and how comfortable you are with using each of them.

Re: Laminating Strips

#7

Ellis Walentine

I'm wary of sanding drums

Ellis Walentine

Sandpaper, whether on a drum or a block or whatever has always tended to dub over the edges of whatever I've sanded. I like the idea of using a plane, which would leave a surface that is flat across. As for uniform thickness, I agree that it isn't necessary or probably even noticeable, but it would still be nice to have. And taking just the bandsaw ridges off with a plane wastes a lot less material than a tablesaw kerf. That pays off in appearance, at least on woods where the interruptions in grain betray the laminations.

Ellis

Re: Laminating Strips

#8

Re: I'm wary of sanding drums *LINK*

William Duffield

You're right, grain mismatches can be a lot more noticeable that minor thickness irregularities. There is a tablesaw blade, the Micro-Kerf 40, made by Total Saw Solutions, that wastes a lot less wood than a standard kerf or a thin kerf blade, but is a lot quicker than bandsawing and planing every surface flat. But, at $185 per blade, you'd have to do your homework to decide if you were making enough bent laminations to pay for it. It's kerf it less than 1/16", so your grain mismatch could be better than all but the best bandsaw blades and the best planing technique.


http://www.totalsawsolutions.com/index.htm

Re: Laminating Strips

#9

Re: I'm wary of sanding drums

James Blandford-Baker

Thanks for further contributions. I want accurate thickness in order to avoid have to thickness them later by scraping, spokeshave or sanding. I have 6 chairs to make each with five laminations; scraping and sanding each to thickness would be a pain. I much prefer planing anyway to sanding (I'm a devotee of David Charlesworth's approach to precise use of the plane) and it is much easier to plane a flat strip with the Wiley's method than a curved lamination with a spokeshave.

Wonderful to have so much expertise and views! Thank you.

James

Re: Laminating Strips

#10

Re: Laminating Strips

Joe shelton

Would you drar a line sketch of that jig, in section or elevation view? It sounds great, but I'm not visiblizing it.

Joe

Re: Laminating Strips

#11

Re: Laminating Strips

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

Plan and section tomorrow or late tonight :) .

Wiley

Re: Laminating Strips

#12

Re: Laminating Strips - flag for Article!

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Attn: Bill T, (Article-Meister),

When you get a chance.

Wiley's jig description would make a good WC Article.

Bob in NJ

Re: Laminating Strips

#13

Ellis Walentine

Sounds good to me


Re: Laminating Strips

#14

Re: Laminating Strips

Tom

The jig I use is a shoji screen plane jig. It consist of a strip of wood tacked to either side of the plane. My plane is wood, so that is easy, but double sided tape would probably work with metal. What this does is make the plane cut exactly a 1/4" strip. To cut a taper, I just apply to the bench a strip with the taper I want. Then I plane the project piece to "1/4"" and it comes out with a perfect taper every time.

This is a bit like mine, it doesn't have to be a japanese plane:


This is how my strips are on:


Fancy version with adjustable height strips:


Re: Laminating Strips

#15

Re: Laminating Strips

Patrick Gibbons

Of course you could just steam bend and forget laminating completely.

Re: Laminating Strips

#16

Thicknesser--sketch

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe and all,

The thicknesser is a simple jig, with just a couple points to be made about it. Here is a crude plan and section:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/10056459843/lightbox/

I am showing the rebated version here. The main points to be made are,

1. Flatness. The bottom plate of the jig has to be flatter than the flatness you're trying to achieve in the slat you're making. For that reason, plywood, esp. Baltic birch ply is a good choice. In principle, you'd rather not mill it, because the factory thickness and edges are references themselves. So rebating may not be desirable. However, if the pieces you're going to use have been sitting around a while, you may want to rebate the side/bottom join before gluing, to be sure that the bottom plate is cinched up flat against reference edges.

2. Hardness of the stop. The stop takes a beating. Pick the hardest, toughest wood you own. A piece of tropical or one of the world's ironwoods is perfect; failing that, hard maple or hickory. As a fine point, the edge facing the work might be given a little 'rake' so that it leans into the load slightly. Think 'bench stop'.

Readers should take a look at Tom's shoji thicknessers in this thread--they give the idea very elegantly and clearly.

Wiley

Re: Laminating Strips

#17

Thanks, Wiley

Joe shelton

That clarifies it for me, and I appreciate your taking the time to do that.

Joe

Re: Laminating Strips

#18

Re: Laminating Strips

James Blandford-Baker

So I made the thicknesser as Wiley described (pretty much). Brilliant, works a treat. Not sure how to upload multiple photos but here's one from dropbox.

Excellent results. When I get close to thickness (3mm) the strips lose enough stiffness that one has to careful pushing the plane at the beginning of a pass as the strip is liable to bend upwards and if you keep pushing would snap. Might work better with my number 6 (since the distance from toe to blade is longer and would keep more of the strip flatter). Anyway glue up is now in progress so I will post results in due course.

Many thanks for the help Wiley!

James


img

Re: Laminating Strips

#19

Ellis Walentine

Excellent post, thanks


Re: Laminating Strips

#20

Re: Excellent post, thanks

James Blandford-Baker

And here's the cleaned up article. You can just see the laminations (though there is no sign of a glueline as such…I used Cascamite) but I don't think they intrude. One was actually glued up out of sequence by accident so still room for improvement.

Thanks to all.

James


img

Re: Laminating Strips

#21

Re: Excellent post, thanks

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Great job, James! Do you clamp those to a form during glue-up? And if so, do you deal with springback, or is there any?

Wiley

Re: Laminating Strips

#22

Re: Excellent post, thanks

James Blandford-Baker

Thanks, Wiley. Yes, I did use a form (see the pic below). Springback was really minimal (say 0.5mm over the length) so not really a problem.

The next issue is cutting the tenons (the shoulders of which are angled relative to each other…you can just about see them marked on the form in the picture). I did half of one tonight using a tenoning jig built from plans in Jeff Miller's book. Worked pretty well.


img