New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, late again this month, we need your thoughts on yet another vexing woodworking question. This time it's regarding the future, and maybe the essence, of woodworking. Specifically, CNC vs craftsmanship.

The Museum of Art & Design in Manhattan has an exhibit this Fall of computer-assisted production, not only in wood, but across a range of decorative and functional objects. Also, a major highlight of this year's AWFS in Las Vegas was the introduction of new CNC equipment at more affordable prices for smaller shops. The question is whether this still qualifies as woodworking or is it just computer programming? Are consumers even aware of how things are made? Do they care, or are they just interested in utility and/or aesthetics? And, does the concept of "craftsmanship" apply to CNC-produced furniture and other wood objects?

What do you think?

As usual, we'll publish a digest of your opinions in the next issue of Woodworker West magazine. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#2

Wow

Ron Harper

Where to start? If you are interested primarily in the product, then you really do not care much about how something was made. You care about the look and utility of the product.

I go to my shop for other reasons. Yes, I am often interested in the end result, but always I am interested in the process and especially the material.

I do not consider CNC prodoction to be woodworking. It can be manufacturing of a very high order, but it is not woodworking.

Ron

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

roger lance

I think that "the average" furniture consumer, when making a purchase, may pride himself on knowing to check the drawers to see if they were dovetailed as this is a sign of quality. However, that consumer will probably not know the difference between machine made/hand made dovetails and probably doesn't care. The same thing will happen for CNC generated pieces.....they will be accepted by the majority of consumers with only a select few knowing or caring about the difference. For small furniture makers, if your competition is using CNC, you will feel the pressure to also use CNC machines to stay in the game.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ellis and all,

I can imagine the same question being asked at the advent of the table saw, the electric router/shaper, the electric jointer/planer, and so on. Like these machines we are all familiar with, I would venture that CNC, and laser cutting for fancy inlay, and even 3D printing of certain parts--all will turn out to be tools among other tools. A means to an end. If it looks half-way convincing, and can hit the right price-point, it will succeed in the market.

That said, there will always be a market for true hand-crafted. Why? Because people with the money to pay for it will want something more special than mass production. They will want and be willing to pay for a personal relationship with the maker and for the knowledge that their high-boy was hand-made and can't be bought at Target. Indeed, the expanded availability of CNC-made period furniture (to take an example) could well enhance the saleability of hand-crafted to the wealthy, many of whom will take the advice of their architects and interior designers (who in turn make it their business to know CNC from hand-crafted).

I see CNC, laser and the like creating greater availability, and paradoxically, greater choice, diversity, and hand-craft opportunity

Wiley

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The tools you use to carry out an idea both empower and limit the outcome. If your primary tools are tablesaw and jointer, your work will tend to be rectilinear, without much in the way of curves, because that's what those tools do best.

CNC work will be limited by the decisions made by the people who write the programs and then by the ability of the designer to overcome the limitations built into the programs. Designers will have to learn how to project their ideas into the program - like drawing, but more difficult. I suspect that a lot of designs will be simplified, subtle features lost, because they'll be too darned hard to put in place.

It will be further limited by the fact that the work is being shaped at a remove from the designer. Even with machines, the woodworker can recognize that a particular piece of wood will work in the design or not as s/he moves it over the machine. The CNC machine will just do what the instructions are, without regard to finesse, because it can't sense the wood except as something to shape.

Might as well use plastic as wood.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#6

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hmmm,

Interesting to think about.

Not woodworking that I would be much interested in, but then I spend time in the shop for fun, not profit.

If I was doing it for a living and wanted to crank out 10,000 pieces of a particular furniture design, then CNC would be a no-brainer.

On a smaller scale turning out a few or custom one off designs, I think that CNC machining, coupled with good design via 3D cad models, and then skilled stock selection could also work.

There would probably still be a guy at the assembly table with a block plane a knife and a chisel, easing the joints together at glue up.

Not for me, but the bottom line is CNC is just another tool in the box.

Bob (in NJ)

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#7

craigd

What if ...

craigd

Not woodworking that I would be much interested in, but then I spend time in the shop for fun, not profit.

There seem to be more and more SketchUp drawings out there. I think it would be nice if I could find, say, a dresser I liked and CNC the carcass parts so I could concentrate on the fun stuff - veneer, cock beading, hand plane-ing, finish, carved details, etc. Those of us who make stuff because we like to make stuff are usually limited time wise so one of those CNC power tool thingies could be a new fangled table saw to do grunt work.

PRS guitars look pretty nice (to my untrained eye) and are CNC/machine made.

If you look at the metal side, there are some truly gifted designers/machinists doing amazing work with CNC. Wood seems to be uniquely suited for CNC production work, on the metal side it seems like CNC is used mostly for prototype/small production work, somewhat akin to the commercial high end low output furniture shops now.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#8

A better question...

Tom

would be: Does the average guy who responds here care if the tools he currently buys are made better because LV used CNC to make the bottoms straight, or to create various swirly profiles. Or would they prefer to go back to the days when the bottom of each plane had a lot of character? And the answer is that no threads are more popular when it comes to hand tool discussions than those about the latest CNCd hand tool.

Obviously working wood with CNC is woodworking, but not of the type the hand tool board commonly talks about. CNC allows greater creativity in certain areas. Particularly branding. Making custom logos, as on guitars; Making custom molds for boats; making stamps. This allows predominantly hand work to compete with factory work in those areas were it is least appropriate and to allow hand work to be used in those situations where it makes an actual difference.

In some ways CNCs are like super power tools, a lot more of the same. But the way I look at it they are also a lot like hand tools in that they respond exactly, sometimes moreso, sometimes less so, to our specific commands and designs. They aren't just table saws that process endless lines of stock. You can write your name with them, or draw your face.

Ultimately we have ideas, and the tools we use are just a means for instantiating those ideas. Some of those ideas are more effectively executed in CNC. Even if one uses the measure of workmanship of risk vs workmanship of certainty, there isn't any risk in many things hand tools do. They are programmed to take a fine shaving or cut a certain width. If one knows what one is doing one connects the various dots and the results are to some degree determined.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#9

If it's made by CNC

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

... then it shouldn't be called woodworking (or pottery, or whatever other craft), because the maker has not had a physical hand in the making of the item.

Then again, some would object at the using of a powered jointer as being called woodworking, since a machine does "all the work", as opposed to using hand tools for the task. I would argue that the use of a powered jointer requires a degree of skill in its operation, same yet different as hand tools. Again, there are degrees of proficiency needed in operating various powered tools, and in some cases it might matter.

As for consumers, I would say 99.X percent do not have a clue as to what workmanship is, how to distinguish man- from machine-made, and the worst part for us woodworkers is that they mostly don't care.

Woodworking isn't the only craft in this boat.

DC