New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

mortise issues

Posts

Re: mortise issues

#26

Re: mortise issues - delayed response

Warren in Lancaster, PA

- I checked your assumptions and they seemed questionable - so I challenged them - with quantified specifics anyone can check for accuracy.

I don't see what assumptions you challenged. You correctly calculated a time of four minutes for making a little 1x1 mortise and stub tenon, the largest size available from the $900 machine you quoted. Your own analysis of $.35 savings per joint puts the break-even point over 2500 joints, even higher than the "maybe 2000 joints" I suggested.

You made the distracting argument that I should limit the number of saws, chisels and planes I owned in order to be able to make a cost analysis. Would it be safe to assume that these are the only handtools you own - not counting perhaps a brace and set of bits? I hope you were not trained to question analysis by making spurious arguments.

Re: mortise issues

#27

Re: mortise issues

charlie belden

I suggested the Glenn Drake Tite-Makr marking gauge - which IS a handtool - though a modern one that uses more modern techology - steel, brass and carbide. It solves the beam deflection issue, has a single bevel wheel cutter (or two) that can be oriented facing the "fence" or facing away from the "fence" whihc addressed the second issue he noted - wandering. The carbide cuts cleanly and stays sharp quite a long time. And with two cutters mounted on it - flat bevel facing "out" for mortises and "in" for tenons you can scribe both lines for a mortise at one time. And because it has "micro adjustment" you can set it to an existing mortise width if you've already got the tenoned piece - or the the tenon width if you already have the mortised piece.

Because the cutters are single beveled you get a small vertical wall on one side of the scribed line - easier to register a chisel agains for a vertical cut than if the scribed line is V shaped.

Hopefully this illustration will convey the latter ideas more clearly than words.


Re: mortise issues

#28

Re: mortise issues - delayed response

Bruce, a MN Galoot

how did those chairs hold together for you, William? I've fixed a bunch of rickety chairs (antiques, says the owner, actually just old), by drilling out the old dowels and replacing them with slightly larger, better dowels. In a couple spots, even those were questionable and the only thing that could fix those were loose tenons.

Re: mortise issues

#29

Re: mortise issues - delayed response

William Duffield

They have held up fine. None of the joints has loosened at all. My son has used them for two or three years, and recently sold them. He's much heavier than I am (and I'm 15 stone), and he likes to tilt back in chairs (I wonder where he learned that?). Note that these particular chairs are not period reproductions or even period mockeries (they are modern Levitz products), but I have since mostly adopted this method for most repairs of later reproductions with dowel joinery. I don't use the Domino, or any loose tenon machine for repair of furniture that was originally built by hand, even if the new joinery will be totally invisible. That would be just wrong, and wouldn't respect the spirit of the person who built it originally. Dowel joinery is different. Due to the nature of the dowel joint, after a few decades, there is almost always a gap in the joint where the shoulders have separated, and through which the dowels can be seen. (Do they keep growing? I don't think so. There's nothing deader than a doornail.)

Of course, the critical difference between dowels and loose tenons is that dowels have an insignificant long grain to long grain glue surface area. The other factor is the precision (and repeatability) of the Domino system. You end up with a very precisely fitting joint that is evenly and thoroughly wetted with glue every time.

I used the largest tenons that the smaller Domino would accommodate, because that was all that was available to me at the time. For those particular chairs, whose structural members, IIRC, were 1" x 1-7/8" thick, I would probably choose a fatter and longer tenon, since I now have the larger machine.

Re: mortise issues

#30

Yes Wiley, but

Ron Harper

Yes Wiley, some occasionally talk about ither things here, but I do resent those who feel thsy need to tell us that they have " found a better way" in power tools. Let em talk about it on the other side of the pond.

Re: mortise issues

#31

Re: Yes Wiley, but

Tom

I don't buy that. I think I have as much on the go with handtools over 40 years plus as anyone here, but I don't know where it says this is a Hand Tool only place. If it was a lot power, I probably wouldn't be here. But there are all kinds of hand tool discussions. The idea that a discussion approach that is tightly limited is more hand tool that one that isn't doesn't cut it with me. Only looking at part of the picture is not while denying mane uses of HTs is not representative.

I'm pretty sceptical that the Domino is the ultimate machine, the ultimate machine is probably more like a vibratory mortiser that is a little heavier. I would own a Domino if I could justify the expense (or didn't have to). But I don't spend like that any more. I'm super OK with the idea that Domino is milking the cow on their product until the patent runs out, but they shouldn't expect any Olympian efforts in adoption, understanding, or applications if they want to wall off their product.

I think there are probably more serious HT woodworkers in Japan that here, and one of the evidences of that is the huge number of power tools designed to assist specific HT tasks, that one rarely sees over here, including many different machines to cut mortises. To me this spills a bit on both sides, there should be both more HTs, and more machines in many cases.

Re: mortise issues

#32

Re: Why Domino sucks like a plate joiner

Tom

For the most part if one can afford one, which is an issue at this price point, I can't see any major reason not to own one. Plate joiners are fabulous, and I would prefer a Domino to a plate joiner (PJ).

So how do they suck like a PJ?

- They are based on the same overall operational format of a hand held device that uses cheap fences and clever but imprecise strategies to quickly hack out "morises". They use floating tenons, that are not always the best choice. And of course the results are mostly such that one hides them, which directs joinery choices in certain directions. Of course given that tenons are so good, any machines that broadens the scope of their use has to be viewed favourably.

- So in looking at the videos the tenon fit is loose, and depends on expansion of the insert. This takes control out of the hands of the craftsman, except as regards certain gross adjustments.

- The joint is largely based on fit in only one axis, just like biscuits. This is said to facilitate various fanciful things, like "wood movement", but is in fact mostly there to make the sloppy set-ups possible.

- The Joint is largely dependent on bonding, not engagement. Which is fine for the most part. PJs are like that and they can do striking things as far as loads are concerned. But it isn't as good as the range one gets with hand cut joints. Happily the junk they are shown building with these joiners is stuff one wouldn't care if it took early retirement, for health reasons, anyway.

- The floating tenons have rounded edges. As they point out, dowels comparatively suck. This thing is part dowel.

- The machine is inaccurate in a sense. It obviously cuts precise pockets, and the tenons do the rest, but the offsets are just fudged, as one can see by uncentered pockets in the demo video. 4:00 ish.

- There are a limited, not infinite set of size options. In my use of the PJ, I go even further, and for the most part try to build around just one size, which makes sense, but reduces even further the ability to fit joints to uses.

- There is wood fiber discontinuity, because like PJs it is a floating system.

- joint tolerances do not create initial stability. So you parts wobble around, need clamps. etc...

- The video does show a lot of pretty poor practices, like gluing laminate, use of particle board, bizarre face frames, undersized joinery parts, and the sloppy gluing of the joints themselves. Sadly these machines tend to encourage this kind of junk. Iit is also built in because if you try to do stuff well, the reliance on tolerances from compressed elements means one often does not have the time to carefully apply glue, because while the joints have no helpful initial structure, they soon grab far to fast.

- There are some things that are worse about the D. The cutter geometry of PJs is better. Circular cutters create less dust, vibration, and wear less quickly (of course the hole you get with the D is more what one would want). There are an annoying number of cutters and floaters to stock, and switch around. Yet one still has minimal geometry. In one section near the end of the video, there are a ludicrous number of joints holding some slats in place, while the frame is under joined. This kind of hackmanship is typical of these systems.

- The D uses a weird method of cutting this kind of mortise that may exist largely to satisfy the patentability requirements of the device.

- The tool is more something to step up from a worse system to, than something to step down from a classical form to. Of course if one had all the tools, and the wisdom to use them, that would be ideal, and I would certainly own one.

Re: mortise issues

#33

Re: mortise issues - delayed response

Tom

" The point I was trying to make is that even "traditional" makers used new technology - or invented it - if it did the job better and more efficiently."

At the one end of that, I would say they were all using current technology, some of what was current then is now regarded as obsolete.

Overall though, your assertion that efficiency was key, which is seemingly true over the long haul, is far from true at the time. Spinning is an interesting situation where vastly inefficient technology persisted because owners didn't care how suckish it was for their spinners even though improvements would have been cheap. We today have several things going for us. We don't care hardly at all about quality in the sense of refined goods, and labour costs are a big part of it. In the past people had many weird ideas, like that pointless work was good for people, or that it was wrong to eliminate jobs. etc... And their main customers were actually demanding, and wanted quality goods of great refinement and complexity, such as people don't even know to ask for today, no mater how rich they might be.

After WWII, which drove a scientific approach to production that revolutionized the world, machinery makers intentionally started making ugly machines. Not because it was cheaper, or nicer, or worked better, but because it fit the politics of an era based on efficiency. If you were applying these new principles you didn't want to be surrounded by pretty machines. So our ideas on efficiency are relatively recent, and relatively fanciful at the same time. But there was an obvious feedback loop, and it had been at work before the war too, that if everything needed to look like a machine, for political reasons, then it could probably be made more cheaply also.

"M&T vs Loose Tenon M&T joinery - in terms of joint strength - is an issue that's been flogged to death"

Only because most people either don't seem to know what they are talking about; aren't telling the truth; or are talking at cross purposes where vastly different objectives are present. All of which is abetted by the fact that there is nothing much to be lost, like falling out of the sky, should something go wrong.

"There doesn't seem to be any real world difference in terms of strength. Loose tenon M&T joinery does require less wood - that will be visible - since the true integral tenon isn't necessary. Makes for easier " figuring" since you don't need to work out the "visisble lengnth" PLUS ""2 x tenon lengths. And if you make a mistake cutting a true tenon in the wrong place - it's either shorten everything related - or make new parts. With LOOSE TENON M&T - if you blow the location of a mortise - plug it with a loose tenon and some glue - wait a while, cut off the plug - and try again. It's like having an UNDO button ; )"

Yeah, here we see the truth, if you have stupid; innumerate; unskilled workers (probably by choice), and are doing cookie cutter work where offcuts are driven by the need for a simple plan, and maximizing wood yield, then floating tenons are exactly as good as integral ones, except where they aren't.

"But discussions on Real M&T vs Loose Tenon M&T do point out a limitation of working exclusively with handtools. Yes, end grain CAN be mortised. But if you were to do that for table leg to apron joints and stretchers to leg joints as well - in order to use loose tenons - you'd be an old man by your 5th table with stretchers ; )"

Fair point, but it doesn't work like that. Unfairly, new stuff either blazes it's own build vocabulary, or it tends to ape the old, imprecisely. So the onus is on mister floating tenon to make his work look like it is traditional, never on the repro maker of the old stuff, or the best maker to make his work look like it was clapped together with every machine age shortcut. Occasionally one sees a sweatshirt printed to look like a tux, one rarely sees a tux printed over to look like a sweatshirt, sort of thing.

At the end of the day, the hand tool worker can make a domino joint, I have hand cut biscuits in the case where I had to do it to get it onto the place I wanted it, and the machine couldn't reach. The domino can't do much of anything other than it's one trick, though smart users will find a lot of ways of using that.

Also, ideas like the amount of wood in a tenon are important because the piece is so cheap. There is little added value. I don't doubt that there is furniture that could have lots of added value made with these things, but if that were the case the cost of the tenons would not be the issue. There are cases where floating tenons make sense, but the cost of tiny scrap of wood is not really the issue.

"The router made loose tenon joinery far more practical and doeable - even by an intermediate woodworker. And combined with purpose built or adjustable router jigs even a relative newbie can cut and use loose tenon M&Ts. With the DOMINO - and absolute newbie can do and use loose tenon M&T joinery."

This is good, the more people with an oar in the water the better, but sadly, each step is a little worse. It is easier to use a domino, but it isn't floating tenon at it's best either. I do like your term "loose" tenon, that gets right to the truth of the mater.

Re: mortise issues

#34

Re: mortise issues - delayed response

Tom

"Let's check the math. At $0.67 per Mortise AND Tenon - at $10 an hour - you'd need to make 15 mortises and 15 tenons each hour for close to three hours to do 42 M&T joints. That's 2 minutes per mortise and 2 minutes per tenon - including the layout?. If you want to make $20 and hour, cut those times in half - a minute per - and work at that pace for close to three hours. AND - if you make the M&T joints right - NOBODY WILL EVER KNOW - except you."

Of course while it isn't what is being argued here, one can use machines to make real mortises, and easily do it as cheaply as a domino, but without the shortcuts. It is an oddity of american classic work that they just won't cosy up to mortising machines, even in production setting (often), and in places that use many machines.

"It takes about 10 seconds to cut a mortise and move to the next one - so 20 second per pair of mortises. That's 6 per MINUTE as opposed to your 0.25 mortise or tenons per minute. The DOMINO is therefore 24 TIMES faster."

But only because we are arguing on the Domino battle field, whatever the dubious merits of this device, what can't be argued is how limited it is. This is proven alone by the fact there are now two of them. If there were 5 it would only help a little. At some point one should just cut the faffing around and get a real machine.

"Now if you make furniture because you enjoy the making, especially the tedious repetative stuff, and the end result is icing on the cake - and don't make a living making furniture - Neander Away - and more power to you, assuming the power doesn't come from a wall outlet."

That is all fair enough, but the only way that machines compete is by selling junk to peasants. I mean, lets be clear on it. Machines don't make hand made best quality shoes, they make Nikes, and even then only with slavery. It is really astonishing how uneven the quality of US stuff is. There is stuff like 1911s that is really pretty amazingly worked out, or AR15s, but the richest person who doesn't wear a suit looks like a hobo, as he gets out of his 100K car, to go to some giant mall and buy more hobo junk.

"For me, it's the working out HOW and selecting and prepping the wood - that's fun. And once I've learned how to do something by hand and get decent at it, if not pretty good at it, the fun level drops off considerably. That said, I really enjoy grinding shellac, disolving it in alcohol and then french polishing - for hours. And beading and cock beading along with carving and shaping are kind of fun to do - but not for hours on end. But then I don't make furniture for a living - and I have time and enough disposable income to Buy & Try - then write up what I've found and share that info with other woodworkers."

That is the way it should be, we are just enjoying ourselves. Apple pie for apple pie eaters, but there really isn't much point in pretending that is as far as cooking goes.

"No, the exteme examples I provided were inspire by Loose Tenon Joinery - which is what the DOMINO does extremely well. The fact that it LOOKS like a biscuit cutter is probably the biggest obstacle the DOMINO has to overcome."

On the first, it dumbs even that down, on the second, it is totally a hand held cheapy, and it is only relevant as a better biscuit joiner, it isn't some huge step up other than that. And what I have seen isn't even that impressive on tool build quality, they are pocketing as much as they can while they can.

"I'm assuming that you think a 1/2 thick, 1 or inches wide tenon that's 2 1/2" long is a "little tenon". And that you assume that you can't use 2 or even 4 smaller tenons to get the same strength."

It is certainly sounding like a too short a tenon, and obviously there are times when one can't use multiples. Situations where one can, but could use bicuits. It is a narrow niche tool. Best to remember, pulling out a number, that 80% of the stuff can already just be nailed, then some can be screwed, then some can only use trad joinery. You are in that exclusive 3% with the domino. Kidding, but only a little. Think Maloof chair, is a domino stronger, there, I really doubt it. And if people are willing to make all kinds of compromises, what is wrong with a few plugs to cover screws?

"And one of the reasons loose tenon joints aren't used in "traditional" work is because it's very difficult to cut mortises - in END GRAIN - but very easy to do with a plunge router, and even easier and quicker and more accurately with the DOMINO."

Domino is way worse that a router, which in my mind is why they don't hold too tight specs on the joint. The bit swings, so you are getting a facet, little bearing is sought there, and there is an arc in the bottom. Another reason loose tenons aren't cut in trad furniture, is because there is no reason to cut that joint other than the needs of the machine. The machine has a lot of bad habits, and encourages more bad habits. But it's needs are paramount to production. You are dealing with a compromise when the need that was satisfied in the delivered form of the object has zero to do with the "needs" of the object or the end user, but the needs of production, or some other externality.

"What the DOMINO does is flatten the learning curve - and bring loose tenon joinery within the reach of newbies and intermediate woodworkers."

For me, if I got one, I would use it for upgrading, on junk, and the one serious role is when one needs to bring something like it to a workpiece, but the piece won't go to it.

"Even the Quakers adopted some modern technology of their time. I believe the bandsaw idea was a Quaker idea - a Quaker woman in fact. Quaker's had no problem making "traditional" furniture using water power either? "

The thing often overlooked about the Shakers is that they were nuts. As woodworkers we like their work, but overall they were very weird people, and so are we.

Re: mortise issues

#35

Profound disagreement but this is America


Re: mortise issues

#36

Re: mortise issues

William Duffield

That's a very insightful and useful analysis, Charlie.

I can find no explanation for why I never bought one, considering I had every opportunity to play with it and could get a discount on it. The micro-adjust is a particularly enticing feature.

When Lee Valley came out with their dual marking gauge, 05N70.01, http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=67466&cat=1,42936, I immediately ordered one, even before they introduced the essential shaft clamp accessory, 05N70.05. I also immediately ordered the shaft clamp when it became available. If you ascribe to the concept of "slaving" tools, I think this gauge makes perfect sense, even if it doesn't have the micro-adjustment feature of the Tite-mark, because you can set the knives directly and precisely from the width of your tools.

Note also, that for very narrow mortises, the Tite-mark has a limitation in how close together you can set the knives, since they are both on the same shaft. I think the minimum spacing is around 3/8", as shown in your first diagram. The Veritas does not have any minimum mortise limitation. Another limitation of the Tite-mark is that to set the mortise width from the mortise chisel, the edges of the knives must directly contact the sides of the chisel. The Veritas is set from the opposite ends of the shafts, so there is no risk to the knife edges, and a bit less risk to your fingers, because you never need to touch the blades. When using it with one knife, there is less chance of losing the other knife, because you just retract it into the head. Note, however, that the shaft clamp very easily slides off and drops on the floor.

Further instructions here:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/shopping/Instructions.aspx?p=67530

Illustration of shaft clamp here:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/shopping/AddViews.aspx?p=69304

If someone already has a Tite-Mark, and decides that the Veritas will better suit their needs, don't sell the Tite-Mark. Having two gauges set up at the same time while making mortises and tenons is very useful. One gauge can be used for marking tenon shoulders and checking mortise depths wile the other is set to the mortise chisel width.

Re: mortise issues

#37

Well, I don't get it....

John in NM

Charlie was just trying to be helpful, and got a whole load of crap for his trouble. I'd rather see helpful posts than strict adherence to a "rule" that really does appear to be made up by those who resent mention of power tools here :D

Even most of the purists use electric sharpening tools.... electric lighting.... why make such a fuss over this? Why make a distinction between a Domino and a bench grinder? I just don't get it :D

Re: mortise issues

#38

Chamfer the ends of the tenons a little.

charlie belden

Derek:

AFTER some fun and games getting a bunch of tenons to line up with their mortises for a glue up - before the glue starts going off - I started beveling the ends of the tenons slightly. If you get them close, they self align a bit - and leave a little space at the bottom of the mortise for any excess glue to fit in - rather than squeezing out that'll need clean up.


And on the subject of glue squeeze out clean up - a tip from Michael Fortune - Waxalit. Comes in a small "toothpaste tube" or in a small jar - consistency of thick vaseline - and dries white so you can see where it is. As the name implies, it's a wax - and glue doesn't stick to wax very well. A little wiped around your mortise will make glue squeeze out SO much easier. And because it's white, you can see that you've removed it all BEFORE applying a finish. ( I still cringe when I see Nahmie wipe up glue squeeze out with a damp cloth)

Lee Valley still may carry it - and a small tube will go a long ways.

If you want to read "the rest of the story" about my crazy glue up while making Das Bench - here's the link. (I'm sure I'm the only person this has happened to . . .)

http://www.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/DasBench/CBbench18.html

Re: mortise issues

#39

That's all I was getting at, that

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

many of us partly use machines, and all of use various conveniences like lighting. I've seen people get great machine answers over here. And we don't have so much traffic that we need to exclude stuff.

I really like Ron's viewpoint, and wouldn't quarrel with him for the world.

I also like Charlie's posts, including this one. Something i did not know about, now I have some surface knowledgfe. It's good.

But there are ways around getting into a meaningless row, and that should have happened here IMO.

Wiley

Re: mortise issues

#40

Re: Chamfer the ends of the tenons a little.

Bruce McCrory

I enjoy reading through your own page, Charlie. Thanks for going to the trouble to present it.

Re: mortise issues

#41

Was not clear

Ron Harper

I really do not care if you use power tools. I do care that Charlie tells Warren that power tools are better on a hand tool forum. Believe me, Warren knows that power tools are available. He chooses not to use them. It does say hand tools at the top of this page. Those of us who choose to use them really appreciate a place to talk about them and their use without being told how much better power tools are. If Charlie wants to cut dovetails with a chain saw, that is his business, just don't come over here and tell me it is better than a traditional dovetail saw. There are other audiences for that story.

Please understand, I claim no virtue for the way I work wood. It is a personal choice.

Re: mortise issues

#42

Re: Chamfer the ends of the tenons a little.

charlie belden

A picture is said to be worth a thousand words - if it's a good picture. A decent illustration AND some words? Well, there's something to be said for simple line drawings - and of course - some words to go with it - just to make sure the idea is conveyed.

Glad you find some of this stuff useful, though I do it so I won't forget what I learned the hard way - and repeat mistakes. And I can't lose the stuff if I put it on the web.

Re: mortise issues

#43

Oh you were clear alright...

John in NM

I just don't agree with you :D

I don't think the crux of that discussion was over which tool is "better", it was instigated and continued over the perceived realism of some time and $$$ estimates. Even so, I don't think the discussion veered out of the sphere of relevance, at least not much. I think you and I and Wiley are getting further from the original topic than other posts in this tangent have done.

The trouble is, whether it says "Hand Tools" at the top or not, the decisions regarding relevance are not really for you or I to make. One could even reasonably argue that powered hand tools are still hand tools and thus appropriate for discussion here.

Many of us appreciate the wide latitude of discussion and see little if any harm in veering off the typical non-powered subjects now and then. There is lots of good info in this thread for people considering either method, I wouldn't want to stifle any helpful information, regardless of opinions as to "appropriateness".

Re: mortise issues

#44

I'm done


Re: mortise issues

#45

Re: Chamfer tenons, and a little more.

Bruce McCrory

Aahhhh. Now I understand the the 'self-deprecating' posts--that name only because my noodle has poor word recall.

I trust online information storage less than my own offline methods. And, those have an amazingly short history, compared to my overall computer life.

I do hope you confuse your offline backup methods with duplicity. :D At least that is the case for me. Every time I think I have cleaned out doubles, I find a new 'old' backup.

So much for OT.....

BTW, I am initiating a process of wedging dovetail joints. Workmanship is so bad that the wedges are necessary. I already hide my tenons--with wedges--where possible, for the same reason.

Re: mortise issues

#46

Clarifying some history

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Charlie Belden said, up above, "Even the Quakers adopted some modern technology of their time. I believe the bandsaw idea was a Quaker idea - a Quaker woman in fact. Quaker's had no problem making "traditional" furniture using water power either?"

I think Charlie's mixing up several ideas.

As best I can understand the history online, the bandsaw was patented in England by one William Newberry in 1808 (not sure of his religion, but I believe most of the Quakers had moved to the Colonies in the 1600s and 1700s). He was ahead of the technology, though, as no one knew how to make the blade reliably. It remained for a French woman, Anne Paulin Crepin, to figure out how to weld the bandsaw blade, in 1846.

There is a partly true story that the circular saw was invented by a Shaker (not Quaker, see next paragraph) woman in the early 19th century. The evidence is that Tabitha Babbitt, a Shaker woman, was the first to use a circular saw in a sawmill in 1813. There is evidence of circular saws going back into the 1700's, although it's insufficiently definitive to identify the originator of the idea, so it's not clear that she invented the circular saw itself. Still, the history indicates that she invented it independently, extrapolating from the motion of her spinning wheel to a spinning blade; so circular saws must not have been in common use.

(NOTE: I do not intend the following as a discussion of religion; rather, clarification of history). Quakers are not Shakers, nor are Shakers related to the Amish, Mennonites, and others for whom technology has theological ramifications. Both Quakers and Shakers were fairly vigorous adopters of technology, and inventors too. The Amish relationship to technology, which is what I think Charlie's referring to above, is rather more complicated, and going into it would sidle toward a discussion of religion; Google the subject for some interesting reading.

Re: mortise issues

#47

Re: Well, I don't get it....

Tom

I certainly don't resent the mention of power tools, I know that a large part of the reason hand tool purists don't use them is because they can't, or they are re-enactors. This is not a hand tool only forum. And around the time it got started there was less of the purism around. EW's mags always had a mix of techiniques represented in most of the articles. I do consider finding out how it was done at another time is a very interesting topic, though.

"Even most of the purists use electric sharpening tools.... electric lighting.... why make such a fuss over this? Why make a distinction between a Domino and a bench grinder? I just don't get it :D"

I think that is a very weak argument. I doubt that most of the purist use power sharpening, my experience is that there is very little response to comments on power sharpening, presumably therefore little interest in it; By and large the stores do not sell good gear for it; most hand tool WWs seem to prefer jigs and hand methods, but there isn't an information clearing house to prove that one way or another.

Anyway, both sharpening and lighting are externalities that are not going to show up in the piece. A domino is a shortcut that will show up in the piece. Or be present in the piece. As mentioned before, I would take a door prize one in a heartbeat, and find lots of places to use it where it was an upgrade. But for reasons I have already belaboured I do not consider it in the best traditions of the activity, or a universal solution that will meet all situations. If I was in business as a woodworker, I would have to consider it, just as I would any other tool.

What people who aren't skilled may want to consider about skill is that I doesn't cost me anything to substitute a domino, but if they suck at handwork, relying on this stuff will only put off the day when they will have the skills in their hands too. Where I really zoomed ahead on the learning curve was by doing a lot of stuff there was a great machine replacement for, by hand, and some purely practice pieces also. If one hands all that over to the obvious machines when does one acquire the skill. And a domino also costs about as much as a really nice bench, so if anyone is on a limited budget, there is that too.

Cutting back to the grinder, that is a tool that requires a lot more skill than using a jig on a stone. So I don't worry about it as a shortcut, where appropriate, because I know I am building skill using that tool over something else. So that is part of it too. Not all power tools are zero skill, and many hand tools are; or are low; or are skills a person may already have. Constantly find new challenges. Also relative to the grinder, it works to support freehand sharpening, since it is easier to build muscle memory for basic sharpening on a hollow ground tool. Also as one is starting out, one will dub edges. Having a grinder on can quickly dig out of a hole with, will embolden one to take on the challenge of free hand sharpening.

Re: mortise issues

#48

Re: Why Domino sucks like a plate joiner

Tom

Got a hankering to look at the Domino XL. so I scooted over to youtube to have a look:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z62c0aMBgss

Around 5:30 you will see him do a second mortise on a rail. It is ridiculously offset from the edge, but it lined up with a detent so it made sense to cut it that way. Maybe he could have made the second mortise deep enough to just act as an index for a third that would have been a better placement for the stop. There are always other methods to use the capabilities of a versatile machine, but it seems significant that he ended up with such a bad placement of the joints. While the joinery illustrated is obviously very strong, it certainly isn't up to the scale of the parts.