Re: mortise issues - delayed response
Tom
"Let's check the math. At $0.67 per Mortise AND Tenon - at $10 an hour - you'd need to make 15 mortises and 15 tenons each hour for close to three hours to do 42 M&T joints. That's 2 minutes per mortise and 2 minutes per tenon - including the layout?. If you want to make $20 and hour, cut those times in half - a minute per - and work at that pace for close to three hours. AND - if you make the M&T joints right - NOBODY WILL EVER KNOW - except you."
Of course while it isn't what is being argued here, one can use machines to make real mortises, and easily do it as cheaply as a domino, but without the shortcuts. It is an oddity of american classic work that they just won't cosy up to mortising machines, even in production setting (often), and in places that use many machines.
"It takes about 10 seconds to cut a mortise and move to the next one - so 20 second per pair of mortises. That's 6 per MINUTE as opposed to your 0.25 mortise or tenons per minute. The DOMINO is therefore 24 TIMES faster."
But only because we are arguing on the Domino battle field, whatever the dubious merits of this device, what can't be argued is how limited it is. This is proven alone by the fact there are now two of them. If there were 5 it would only help a little. At some point one should just cut the faffing around and get a real machine.
"Now if you make furniture because you enjoy the making, especially the tedious repetative stuff, and the end result is icing on the cake - and don't make a living making furniture - Neander Away - and more power to you, assuming the power doesn't come from a wall outlet."
That is all fair enough, but the only way that machines compete is by selling junk to peasants. I mean, lets be clear on it. Machines don't make hand made best quality shoes, they make Nikes, and even then only with slavery. It is really astonishing how uneven the quality of US stuff is. There is stuff like 1911s that is really pretty amazingly worked out, or AR15s, but the richest person who doesn't wear a suit looks like a hobo, as he gets out of his 100K car, to go to some giant mall and buy more hobo junk.
"For me, it's the working out HOW and selecting and prepping the wood - that's fun. And once I've learned how to do something by hand and get decent at it, if not pretty good at it, the fun level drops off considerably. That said, I really enjoy grinding shellac, disolving it in alcohol and then french polishing - for hours. And beading and cock beading along with carving and shaping are kind of fun to do - but not for hours on end. But then I don't make furniture for a living - and I have time and enough disposable income to Buy & Try - then write up what I've found and share that info with other woodworkers."
That is the way it should be, we are just enjoying ourselves. Apple pie for apple pie eaters, but there really isn't much point in pretending that is as far as cooking goes.
"No, the exteme examples I provided were inspire by Loose Tenon Joinery - which is what the DOMINO does extremely well. The fact that it LOOKS like a biscuit cutter is probably the biggest obstacle the DOMINO has to overcome."
On the first, it dumbs even that down, on the second, it is totally a hand held cheapy, and it is only relevant as a better biscuit joiner, it isn't some huge step up other than that. And what I have seen isn't even that impressive on tool build quality, they are pocketing as much as they can while they can.
"I'm assuming that you think a 1/2 thick, 1 or inches wide tenon that's 2 1/2" long is a "little tenon". And that you assume that you can't use 2 or even 4 smaller tenons to get the same strength."
It is certainly sounding like a too short a tenon, and obviously there are times when one can't use multiples. Situations where one can, but could use bicuits. It is a narrow niche tool. Best to remember, pulling out a number, that 80% of the stuff can already just be nailed, then some can be screwed, then some can only use trad joinery. You are in that exclusive 3% with the domino. Kidding, but only a little. Think Maloof chair, is a domino stronger, there, I really doubt it. And if people are willing to make all kinds of compromises, what is wrong with a few plugs to cover screws?
"And one of the reasons loose tenon joints aren't used in "traditional" work is because it's very difficult to cut mortises - in END GRAIN - but very easy to do with a plunge router, and even easier and quicker and more accurately with the DOMINO."
Domino is way worse that a router, which in my mind is why they don't hold too tight specs on the joint. The bit swings, so you are getting a facet, little bearing is sought there, and there is an arc in the bottom. Another reason loose tenons aren't cut in trad furniture, is because there is no reason to cut that joint other than the needs of the machine. The machine has a lot of bad habits, and encourages more bad habits. But it's needs are paramount to production. You are dealing with a compromise when the need that was satisfied in the delivered form of the object has zero to do with the "needs" of the object or the end user, but the needs of production, or some other externality.
"What the DOMINO does is flatten the learning curve - and bring loose tenon joinery within the reach of newbies and intermediate woodworkers."
For me, if I got one, I would use it for upgrading, on junk, and the one serious role is when one needs to bring something like it to a workpiece, but the piece won't go to it.
"Even the Quakers adopted some modern technology of their time. I believe the bandsaw idea was a Quaker idea - a Quaker woman in fact. Quaker's had no problem making "traditional" furniture using water power either? "
The thing often overlooked about the Shakers is that they were nuts. As woodworkers we like their work, but overall they were very weird people, and so are we.