New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT - moisture content in wood floor

Posts

OT - moisture content in wood floor

#1

OT - moisture content in wood floor

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Our Queen Anne cottage, like many around here, has 1x4 tongue-and-groove Douglas fir flooring as its combined subfloor/finish floor. Doug fir is a splintery wood, so we explored putting in a hardwood floor. The contractor came out today and recommended against it, because the floor showed 12-13% moisture, and the hardwood flooring would probably come at 6-8%, and then warp when the moisture equalized between the two materials.

Testing elsewhere in the house got variable readings, down to 10% in spots.

We have no air conditioning (don't need it), nor humidity control, and heat only when temperatures drop in the Fall. For about half the year, we live with windows open much of the time, closing them if the temperature's going to go over 75 degrees.

Is this moisture range a matter of concern, or just an indication that we're just living in sync with the outside world?

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

Dale Lenz

12~13% MC of wood is typical for many areas of outdoor conditions. Would think you could sticker wood flooring material for say 6 weeks and let it condition to the environment it will "live" in. During the winter months, when the cottage is heated, bet the MC drops to near 8%?

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#3

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

Patrick Gibbons

Just curious how the Doug fir looks and how well it held up over the years?

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#4

No advice, but

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'd sure hate to live in sync with our outside world.

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#5

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

Here in Houston engineered hardwood flooring is popular to combat the humidity problem. Also mesquite solid wood flooring is stable enough to be used in a bathroom without any consequences. Mesquite flooring is expensive in Texas. I can only imagine what it might set you back in California. However, it's cost plus shipping. Here's a link I found about engineered flooring.


http://shawfloors.com/tips-trends/natural-hardwood/hardwood-solid-engineered

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,I'm no expert but that don't make alot of sense to me. I would think that if you brought the new flooring into the house to acclimate it would be equal in moisture content to your existing flooring and then installation would be no issue.Place rosin paper or something similar between the layers and leave space around the perimeter for expansion. ---Jack

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#7

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

Here's some info on mesquite stability.


http://www.mesquitefloors.com/hardness-and-stability

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#8

Agree

Frank D. in Montreal

Up here in Montreal, with sub-zero winters and hot, humid summers, solid wood floors are very common. We use run-of-the mill native species (maple, birch, oak) and I've never heard once of anyone having problems due to the wild seasonal humidity swings we have (which is why they've been used for hundreds of years) when the floor has been installed correctly. The only potential problem that I can think of is if your floor is right over a dirt crawlspace, so during prolonged periods of rain (I'm thinking weeks on end), water could wick through the soil from outside and off-gas into the house from below. But this wouldn't be caused by ambient humidity. Even then, a layer of tar paper on the sub-floor would pretty much protect from that.

Re: OT - moisture content in wood floor

#9

Michael Donaldson

Amen to that, Bruce