New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Thin plate back saws

Posts

Thin plate back saws

#1

Thin plate back saws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Am curious whether anyone has tried the new thin-plate back saws being offered by Lie Nielsen:

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?sku=1-SAW-Tapered

They're advertising them as 'tapered', which they are, but what catches my eye is the 0.015" plate on the two shallow saws (not the tenon, which is still at 20 thousandths).

I'm used to thin plates on Japanese saws (12 thousandths for dozukis, for example), but they're used in tension. Here's a push saw that's at 15 thousandths--how does it handle? If the toothing is the same, should require less force.

Wiley

Re: Thin plate back saws

#2

Re: Thin plate back saws

L Robins

Mine work great. I really like the tapered crosscut saw. Its hang seems perfect for me when working with a bench hook. I was using the 14" tenon crosscut, but this one cuts more quickly and with less effort and it just seems to work better. I tend to trade tools and look for the perfect fit. This one has a permanent home. I like the other two also, but I have not had as much opportunity to work with them. I guess that it is time to work on a project.

Re: Thin plate back saws

#3

Re: Thin plate back saws

Michael Brady

I have the the original (not tapered) thin-plate tenon saw from Lie-Nielsen. I consider myself to be an average sawyer, and am comfortable with saw sharpening. In other words I think I understand how saws work.

I have trouble with this particular saw wandering off-line on deeper tenon cuts. I believe that the thin plate flexes as it get into the cut, and once that happens there is no getting it back. There is probably a condition of unequal set on this particular saw that is pulling one side of the plate off line; or a flaw in my sawing stroke. For me, the standard plate thickness would have been a better choice, I think, since I have no similar problems with any other of my panel or back saws.