Wood banding on granite
Joe shelton
I've attached white oak banding around a small slab of granite, and planed the wood very close to flush. Now I want to bring the wood flush without dulling or scratching the granite. How do I do this?
Joe
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Wood banding on granite
Joe shelton
I've attached white oak banding around a small slab of granite, and planed the wood very close to flush. Now I want to bring the wood flush without dulling or scratching the granite. How do I do this?
Joe
Very Carefully.....
Jesper, Denmark
Sorry, but I couldn't resist.....
Use a block plane set for a fine shaving - rest the heel of the plane sole on the granite and cut at an angle, using your finger as a fence to guide the plane so the blade does not touch the granite.
If you are really fuzzy, you can mask the granite with the thin type precision masking tape.
What I would try
John in NM
Is paring it flush with a wide chisel. Bevel down, working from the granite outwards so that the bevel rides on the granite surface. Steel should not scratch most of the minerals in granite, even as loosely as commercial granite is named, only the mica minerals in an igneous rock are much softer than a chisel. Sandpaper of all types will scratch the granite, even garnet is significantly harder than the quartz and feldspar that make up the stone.
The chisel may mark the granite, leaving tracks of steel on it. I wouldn't expect it on a well polished stone, but you never know. If it does, they should wipe off.
Out of curiosity, what glue did you use?
PL Premium poly
Re: Very Carefully.....
Joe shelton
I usually don't get too fuzzy until 9:30 or 10:00, and after a couple stiff ones.
Re: Wood banding on granite
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Joe,
Never done this, so my advice is worth zip. But what I would do for sure, no matter the tooling approach, is first to mask off the granite. With some cover on the granite, plane close as you have done, until the plane is beginning to skim the masking tape. I think a chisel plane would be best here (really, really sharp) because you can see exactly what's happening, and can adjust very fine to a zero-clearance cut.
When you can no longer keep the plane out of the tape, switch to a flexible, very thin card scraper (LV's is fantastic for this kind of stuff), so you have total control and can see exactly where you're cutting. Flex the scraper, so you can skim right up to the edges of the wood. Take all the time in the world, and do no more than a couple minutes wood removal at a time (I say this cause sometimes I get obsessed with a nit at this stage and risk the whole project to deal with it, when walking around will allow a better solution to come into my head.) When you don't dare go further with the scraper, you're done.
Never done it, so all this with a pound of salt, but that's how I'd approach it.
Wiley
Re: Cop-out
Tom
The normal way this kind of thing is dealt with is by milling a rebate in the granite, or wood, so there is a space between the two, and this groove creates visual interest (horrible dirt trap in a lot of situations). Or the groove can be filled with a contrasting wood. The presence of a groove makes getting in there with a cutter easy, and it visually confuses the eye that is searching to identify mismatches in height. Even if the groove needs to be filled, whether with coloured epoxy, contrasting stringing, etc... The visual break will still make the transition less likely to telegraph problems in the height of the parts, which over time are sure to shift anyway.
There are design implications to this approach, and I have to say that I am not a fan of such spacers having sought to avoid them for 40 years in such product as the grips of knives, and the hardware transitions on gunstocks. But until fairly recently these things were hugely ubiquitous, indicating their utility to those trying to make such products.
Re: Some truth on machining and bamboo fly rods
Tom
So many products are easily cut by other products, like cold rolled steel by HSS. In practice though, one often needs specialized tools like drill presses and milling machines to develop the pressure required to form a chip. When making fly rods out of sections of bamboo, the sections are held in a steel form and a sharpened plane is run over the bamboo, and the steel. The bamboo is cut dead flush, and over time the steel is worried away too, but the point I am getting at is that the wide edge of the blade does not penetrate. It is possible that a wide plane blade would not scratch the granite, not because steel does not scratch granite, but because the width will not allow the down pressure to develop that would allow a chip to form. This would require a mock up to prove before venturing on your piece.
That is exactly right...
John in NM
I would be far more concerned for my blade than the stone 
Might work fine though, with no damage to the blade, I hadn't thought of the similarities to a planing form. Now you've made me want to try it!

Re: another flyrod, or shoji approach
Tom
There are planes used in fly rod, and shoji manufacture, that have a groove in the sole so that the blade can extend enough to take a chip, yet not cut into the surface of the work. In fly rods these are used to cut flush to the forms without damaging them, something that is useful when working on Al forms. A simple version of this can be made with a strip of tape to either side of a block plane, the tape does not run over the blade, there is a gap in the tape for the blade, or you would need a cutter made to cut only between the tape. The best tape I have used is the slick teflon tape that LV sells. I also have a plane with the center milled to do this.
Anyway, you need a second tool, and for this I think it is easiest to speak of a power router, I am not sure a hand tool version of this exists, or that many of us would have it.
Imagine you use a flush trim router bit to flush up the wood to the granite. Many such bits have a significant gap between the bearing and the cutter. If properly set, this would remove wood, everywhere but along the edge. There would be a raised section of wood at the edge. The plane mentioned above would then straddle that edge and cut the wood away until it was flush to the granite and the wooden edging. Of course something similar can be arranged in many ways, but most people are familiar with the working of a trim bit, and that is the easiest to visualize.
Another technique that works pretty well is a file with the end that bears on the granite, wrapped with one or two layers of tape.
Re: File this
Tom
Another technique that works pretty well is a file with the end that bears on the granite, wrapped with one or two layers of tape. This will allow you to approach the edge very precisely, and the method also magically fills any hairline cracks, which can be useful. Of course, in doing this the edging will get slightly bevelled away from the granite. This can be a good look, and useful in a number of ways, if you want to go that route. This approach, tape and angling, can also be used with cutting tools, allowing them to work down to the edge, if you like. Obviously, ones patience for filling will be limited, so if you framing is 3 inches wide, the file will not work, but if that is the case, I have other ideas.
Re: Wood banding on granite
wilbur
I'd vote for paring as well, but use a gooseneck chisel.


This way you can rest the flat of the chisel on the granite for reference and pare outwards. This should be a more stable operation than the bevel down suggestion. The same cautions about the steel marking the granite would apply.
The pictures are just for reference. You don't have to use a Japanese gooseneck chisel.
Re: The promised other ideas...
Tom
So similar to the file, if you had a finishing plane with a cambered blade, it would essentially cut a gutter in a wide piece of framing, while resting on the granite and the wood.. This gutter, could be moved towards the edge of the granite by careful control of a fence. You would essentially plane the frame flat to the granite, but for the last pass or so. Then you mount your fence, and work your cambered blade cut over until it is cutting at the edge of the granite. You now have a perfect cut to the edge, but a several thou gutter adjacent to it. You use a free hand finishing plane to blend that out.
Something similar could be worked with a rebate plane that has a fence. you run it off the edge, and use the cutter to cut flush to the edge of the granite, then you just level up the rest of the frame with finishing planes. This approach is a bit like the stand-off groove approach I first mentioned, but in this case, you are making your own groove, and it is flush to the granite, allowing you room to bring in a finishing plane.
I can keep coming up with stuff pretty much indefinitely, but your final approach will depend on your exact piece and tools.
Re: Wood banding on granite
John Veerkamp
After planing close with masking tape, use a well tuned cabinet scraper to get the last bit. Angle it about 45 degrees to the edge of the granite.
I am surprised no one has sugjested
Winton Applegate
this little gem
The tape on the file is a good idea.
Really though . . . if you want to take off some wood rather than polish it up with a file (or tear it up with a rssp) . . .
I am surprised no one has mentioned . . . are you ready ? The tool made for the job is . . .
TA DAAAA !
[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/IMG_2294_zps543537c7.jpg.html]
[/URL]
[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/IMG_2293_zpse3ab72b3.jpg.html]
[/URL]
I can cut a candle wax spot off my table and not touch the surface with this little jewel.
Good stuff !
http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1232
Router plane
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
You need a router plane with a sharp blade (obviously), preferably the pointed one, as this is designed for finish work.
The router plane is designed to work with levels, and it enables the user to set the level to the depth one wants. Think of the way you level a hinge mortice or tenon cheek.
You can run the body along the granite and use a fence to prevent the blade encroaching onto the granite, itself.
Having said all this, I am not sure there is much point in being obsessive about this since wood moves and it will not remain flush at all times.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Router plane
Winton Applegate
The chisel plane has the advantage of being able to align the cutting edge exactly parallel with the base of the plane and have the majority of the base on the granite.
Hey at the vary least , if you don't already have these planes you have a great "reason" to buy both.
You simply MUST test both and let us know which works best.
Tell SWMBO that you own it to the guys (and dolls (I know bad choice of words but I am on a Frank Sinatra thing from the other thread)) to do this research.
Another option
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Do this when you're scared to plane or scrape any more....
Keep the granite masked off. Clamp straight wooden sticks on the granite, on either side of the wood inlay, forming a channel with only the wood showing. Make yourself a third length of wood, whose width will barely slide in the channel you've made. Stick PSA sandpaper--220g, say--to the bottom of the 'slider'. Stick the paper on, and trim it exact with a diamond marking knife. Sand flush by trial and check.
Wiley
I have never been THAT scared
Winton Applegate
Sand paper ?
Sand paper !
SAND PAPER ! ! ! !
"Blasphemy !" he cried making the sign of the cross with his fingers and hissing as he backed toward the door, the day light and his last chance for escape from the hellish specter before him.
Yet another idea (this is fun ) ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Everyone so far (including my earlier post) assumes that one must flush the top in line with the granite. INSTEAD, flush the underside where you will not be concerned with any scratches. You can use an old and cheap block plane for that ..
Plane the top of the banding flat and smooth, then attach it to the granite so that it is flushed with the top of the granite. Leave the lower edge for later trimming. To get the upper side flush, clamp a flat board to the granite as a stop.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Rules are RULES
Winton Applegate
Derek,
For this particular project you were right the first time. As the OP said
I've attached
white oak banding around a small slab of granite, and planed the wood very close to flush.
Now
I want to bring the wood flush without dulling or scratching the granite. How do I do this?
I was kind of assuming he had set the granite in a rabet.
I wonder how he attached it ?
Joe,
How did you attach the banding ?
Thanks, and what I did...
Joe shelton
Many responses, some of which pointed up my own lack of clarity:
I glued white oak banding, or edging, around a (slightly irregular) slab of granite. The cut edges of the granite were unsightly, and I wanted to finish them and to continue them as flat as the granite surface. This is to be the top of a small (19" x 27") sharpening bench.
I acted mostly on the advice from Tom, who suggested a rebate plane. Several other responses arrived while I worked; thanks for all the suggestions. The plane I used is a fenced 140, and I kept the side plate attached, though this was just a mental crutch, I guess. Anyway, it worked splendidly, and went quickly. I'm embarrassed that I needed to ask y'all how to do this. All I had to do was to pick up the plane, set the fence and trim it up. Maybe next time I'll think on my own.
Joe
Some times asking....
Dale Lenz
is just a reassurance or your thoughts...Got the job done and done well...Good Job, Joe!
Re: Now that you're done,
William Duffield
and successfully, I can't help but wonder if a different approach might have worked as well, and without as much trepidation regarding possible tearout, chipping granite, etc.
What I was considering is that someone efficiently and effectively polished the granite before it came to you, so you should be able to polish it again if you scratch it up. Why couldn't you sand the oak flush, seal the pores and then repolish the granite with successively finer grits of wet/dry sandpaper? I realize that an excuse to buy some new abrasives does not have nearly the sense of satisfaction that buying a new hand tool does, but…
Re: Now that you're done,
Joe shelton
Well, you're right. I studied granite polishing a lot more than than I did flush fitment of oak to stone. I was intimidated by that slurry. And I thought, up to the final 32d inch, that trimming flush would be easy. Turns out, it was, once I screwed my commitment to the startin' pint.
Joe