New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

card scraper sharpening again

Posts

card scraper sharpening again

#1

card scraper sharpening again

Jerry Gibbs

Just watched a Scott Phillips video. Phillips re-established the burr by holding the card freehand and running a mill file over the edge a few times. None of this using a stone and then a burnisher. What am I missing? Jerry

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#2

Re: card scraper sharpening again

roger lance

I saw the same show.....you aren't missing anything.....that was Scott Phillips.....and that was an example of why he is held in such low regard.

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#3

Re: card scraper sharpening again

Don Stephan

There are many different ways to prepare a scraper and turn a burr. His method is only one of many, and very quick. Many will suggest his method will result in a burr with the equivalent of many tiny nicks in it.

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#4

Re: card scraper sharpening again

roger lance

His method for turning a burr????....spare me, please.

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#5

Re: card scraper sharpening again

Bruce McCrory

I grabbed a "new, in the ruff" card from a delivery by a cottage saw plate maker that had two "scratchy" cut corners and used it on pine with great results. It would have worked better on maple.

I think the "experts" get carried away with their instructions--and marketing. Witness the phobic need to polish a mirror gloss on the back of chisels and plane irons. My thought is: 'how did thousands of craftsmen get anything done before Diamond flattened Shaptons, and Torm[ent]ks? Not to mention Eastern "caved in back" tools.

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#6

I've not seen the video...

John in NM

But I know an older guy from Sonora who does that too. It works for him, and his work is top notch, so I don't question the methods. I remember trying it too, years ago, but without much luck. Could be useful to revisit, because it is fast! My impression is that a burnished burr lasts better though.

I'm such a weenie when it comes to burnishing that I use the Veritas tool to do it. Works quite well, better than I can seem to do freehand.

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#7

Re: card scraper sharpening again

Winton Applegate

'how did thousands of craftsmen get anything done before Diamond flattened Shaptons, and Torm[ent]ks? Not to mention Eastern "caved in back" tools.

That is a very good question.

I think when you research it in a serious manner you may be quite surprised at the truth of the matter.

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#8

Re: It all depends....

Edward in Vancouver

While I don't consider myself a "real" woodworker, I do have some experience with the lowly card scraper. Files work great for making burs to remove course shavings, for scraping old finishes, and general futzing around.

However........once you stain a piece, the scratches show up like pigeon crap on a black car. Even if you go back to 120 grit and work up to 320, you still might not get rid of them.

I've found that if you work the scraper up to a 4000 stone, the odds of scratches dissapear

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#9

Interesting...

John in NM

As I recall, he mostly used the scraper as an intermediate finishing tool, removing tool marks before the finishers got hold of a piece and sanded it.

I've noticed a similar tendency for rasps to leave marks that pop out later. The most noticeable time was when I was treating the piece with some vinegar+iron - the solution raised the grain and all these rasp marks that I hadn't noticed before popped right up!

Re: card scraper sharpening again

#10

Re: card scraper sharpening again

Charles Stanford

Scott Phillips vs. the likes of Tage Frid, Frank Klausz, Alan Peters, Ian Kirby and countless others.

Really? Scott Phillips?