New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Small router plane......

Posts

Small router plane......

#1

Small router plane......

roger lance

Awhile ago, Derek Cohen posted about a small wooden router plane that he had made. I had an idea then of how I might make a small plane that would also use the router blades that come with the large LV router. Surprisingly, LV has failed to make a small router that can use these blades.....instead they have decided to use a round shafted blade in their small router which is offered in only one size.

So the goal was a small wooden router that could use all of the router blades made by LV for their large router and also have a way of securing the blades in the router that had more bearing than that shown by Derek in his design....

This is my prototype with a template of Derek's plane body.....


And a look at how pinned that blade shaft is to the body of the plane.....it is very secure.....there will be no rotating of the blade shaft....


The blade can also be used out the back for those rare occasions when that might be desired.....


Now, if I could just figure out a way to make a better shooting board plane than LV or LN.....

Re: Small router plane......

#2

Re: Small router plane......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Nice Roger. How is the blade tightened down? And what about a depth stop - that is most important.

Now, if I could just figure out a way to make a better shooting board plane than LV or LN.....

Ooooooo .... you couldn't resist. :)

Wait until the plane is released on Tuesday, then I shall post my review. I promise it will include some interesting data.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Small router plane......

#3

Re: Small router plane......

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Good idea! Both the LN and LV small routers have only the 1/4" iron, as I recall. Very limiting and counterintuitive. This solves it.

I like the expression on its face--last photo :) . Like 'duh-h-h'.

Wiley

Re: Small router plane......

#4

Re: Small router plane......

roger lance

Derek.....Its difficult to photograph but when the "blade keeper" first contacts the blade there is a gap of 1/64" or so between the keeper and the plane body.....so as you tighten down those screws, the keeper is actually bent around the blade in a small arc and a goodly amount of pressure is created holding that blade in place.....


As far as depth control (adjustment and depth stop), that is a weakness of all these small routers (excluding yours.....and possibly LN who may offer a depth stop soon).....its a matter of loosing the screws a little .....tapping the blade down to a new depth.....retightening the screws.....and continuing with the work.

No, you're right, I couldn't resist.

Re: Small router plane......

#5

Re: Small router plane......

roger lance

Thanks Wiley.....a design choice like that made by LV on their small router does make a person wonder why people as smart as they are would choose to make a product that doesn't allow the use of their own blades.....so maybe they have a Homer Simpson moment also from time to time....duh-h-h.

Re: Small router plane......

#6

Re: Small router plane......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

I can't help but make a suggestion that would make blade adjustment easier for the blade holding system you have designed. It's the compulsive tweaker in me!

Replace the screws with bolts. I would use hex/Allen head types. To adjust, you only have to open/close one side - think of a twin screw vise or a Moxon vise.

A depth stop is nothing more than a brass sleeve threaded for a screw. Here's mine ...


Incidentally, I did recommend to LV a while ago that a small router plane be developed around the large blades. It would not be possible to machine the current small router plane to be used since the Large blades are too long in the head.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Small router plane......

#7

Re: Small router plane......

roger lance

Derek....

Like a moxon??.....maybe I could get the guys over at BenchCrafted to make me up a couple of small wheels that I could spin shut.... :D

Yours wins the beauty contest.....mines a distant second at best....does look a bit like a face with a dumb expression....

Tuesday is coming my friend.....looking forward to reading your assessment.

Re: Small router plane......

#8

Re: Small router plane......Don't sell it short

James Watriss

The round shank allows for a lot more versatility than you think. I have a Stanley 271, which also has a round hole, but allows for the use of home- made irons made out of re-ground hex keys, key for inlay. Point against the L-N, which doesn't use the full size irons, AND doesn't accept hex shanks.

As with everything else, there's always a work-around. But Don't sell the LV version short.

Re: Small router plane......

#9

Re: Small router plane......Don't sell it short

roger lance

James.....If anyone has sold the small router plane short, it is LV themselves. Why produce a product for which you not only do not make a selection of blades but also make it so that the goodly number of blades that you already make can't be used either?? To then operate under the assumption that your customers will find items in their shops like hex keys that your customer can then turn into the blades you should be offering is not a good business model....never was....never will be. LV dropped the ball here and a couple of simple design changes would remedy the flaws.....cost, at this point, is another story (would a re-design pay for itself?).

Re: Small router plane......

#10

Hogwash

James Watriss

Woodworking is about making things and solving problems. Tool making is part of that, as evidenced by this thread... And by Derek's ongoing threads on making and modifying... As well as work done by others. Finding ways to use things in a new or better way, and not being limited by what's been provided, is the hallmark of a creative mind.

The round shank clamp is more versatile, and allows for more creativity on the part of the end user. It's a viable way to make the tool... And to keep the manufacturing simple enough to keep the tool affordable, which is just as important. I'm sure if there was sufficient demand for other, smaller blades, Veritas would make them. Failing that, they've provided the versatility to the motivated few, to use the tool in a way that isn't easily done with their competitor's.

Whine all you like about what you perceive its shortcomings to be. If I didn't already have the Stanley 271 (which also uses a round shank) I'd buy the Veritas.

Re: Small router plane......

#11

I'm not trying to wash any hogs here...

roger lance

We just have a difference of opinion....and lets leave it at that.