New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Bench Slave or Deadman....

Posts

Bench Slave or Deadman....

#1

Bench Slave or Deadman....

roger lance

Since things are so slow on the board, I thought I'd take a few photos of the bench slave I showed below in Phil's thread and discuss its use and build.

The following two photos show a couple of ways to use the bench slave which can also be used away from (independent of) the bench. Note that the slave has support holes on two sides that are centered on each other to give more choices for adjusting the support height when needed.....



These two photos show the base which is just a tight fit and removable....



Its a handy device to have for stock support.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#2

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

Phil

My first choice would have been some cleverly designed sliding deadman. But that bench slave is so nice, I might just abandon the sliding approach altogether. I assume a dimensioned shop drawing and video is available for that design? :)

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#3

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

roger lance

Phil.....actually, that bench slave is my design (undoubtedly there is a similar one somewhere, someplace).....I was inspired by the bench slave shown in Scott Landis' The Workbench Book with Frank Klausz's bench. I used 1" actual thick stock....so the shaft is 3" x 3".....and the height was determined by my bench height.....you should be able to work one out from there.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#4

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

William Duffield

Very nice, Roger, and ingenious, to boot! I never thought of clamping the deadman in a tail vise, but that's probably because the only tail vise I've used was on a bench with front legs flush with the front of the bench top. Yours would even work on a bench with an Adjust-a-Bench base, whereas a sliding board jack would not.

With the rear support and the thickness of yours, it looks like you could also use it with a holdfast. I never tried that with my board jack (I just use pegs), because it is made from 4/4 material, too thin for a holdfast to hold.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#5

A lesser approach

Alex Y

Nice job on that deadman, Roger. Here is my lesser approach to the same problem.

I wanted a way to hold boards for edge planing on my semi-Klausz style bench. The two jigs shown below meet my very occasional need and stow away nicely against the front stretcher. the two pieces resting on the top have blocks of wood (two on the larger one) that register in dog holes. I thought I was going to be bothered that the wood was not against the face of the bench between these two supports, but so far, it hasn't been an issue. I usually supplement this with a spring clamp holding the board to the fixture on the right end.


Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#6

A very valid approach.....

roger lance

Alex.....I like your thinking.....and you have presented a most interesting possibility for creative problem solving by making use of the dog holes themselves....thats a topic which, to my memory, has not been explored here.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#7

Re: A lesser approach

William Duffield

I like the way you solved that problem. Your approach would have solved the problem I had with one of my benches. Like yours and Pete's, my rails are set back from the front edge of the bench. Worse, the rear chop on my face vise is proud of the front edge of the bench top. That's not clear in this picture. I came up with a different solution, which relies on the fact that the bench has both an upper and a lower rail.


The jack is the same thickness as the vise chop, and it has two hooks on the back: One hooks over the upper rail; the other sits on the top and front of the lower rail.

The next pic shows the vise chop a bit clearer.


I found I don't need that many holes. Fine height adjustment is not necessary.

This photo shows the structure of the jack a bit better. Top of the jack is to the right.


Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#8

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

roger lance

William.....yes, the bench slave used by Frank Klausz in The Workbench Book used a stock support that went all around the slave and could not be clamped in the tail vise except when set at a lower height.....that was one of the factors that lead me to go as I did.....so far, with 15 choices for stock support height, this design has worked....thought of some ways to go more modern but wanted to keep the old school look.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#9

Stephen Shepherd

Another version

Stephen Shepherd

Here is my take on the silent apprentice. Also called a dummy.

Stephen


img

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#10

Deadman....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

Your design is excellent. The joinery is very clever. And I like the versatility - reversability - that your bench slave and bench tail vise has to offer.

Nevertheless, for someone starting out to build a bench, with the choices available, a sliding deadman offers more. You asked the question.


Not only is it compact and out of the way, but it offers a hgher level of stability and rigid support since a hold down can push a work piece against the side of a benchtop or leg. With a bench slave you only rest a board on a support - I think that you could use a hold down in yours, but not in others I have seen.

I don't have a picture of this, but here is one of a hold down (actually, a Veritas Surface Clamp - since replaced by the Veritas hold down) in the deadman ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#11

Re: Another version

roger lance

Stephen.....that's a good example of a design with continuous adjustability....and a bench built for a left hander!!

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#12

Re: Deadman....

roger lance

Derek.....I was inspired by the Shaker style benches back when I built mine and, although those benches had a sliding deadman, I decided that a built-in deadman on such a small base could potentially interfere with those drawers.....so decisions....decisions....and I went with the bench slave.

I do supplement the slave at times with a clamp similar to the following photo....


just another workaround.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#13

Clamp works great, but...

GolfSteve in Calgary

Roger, I do the same as you, using a clamp to hold one end - works great.

The downside is that you only need the clamp when you're planeing a really long heavy board, and you need four hands and a strong back to hold the long heavy board while clamping it at the same time.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#14

Re: Clamp works great, but...

roger lance

Steve (who built a beautiful bench)....but thats were the slave or sliding deadman come into play.....they give you that resting place while you place your clamp.

Re: Bench Slave or Deadman....

#15

Re: A lesser approach

William Duffield

It has been a while since I stuck my nose into The Workbench Book. Roger's comments on the problem with Frank Klausz' deadman (shown on page 51) aroused my curiosity. On page 103, I found another bench with basically the same board jack as mine, except that one has an ingenious escapement, instead of rows of holes for dogs. It even dealt with the problem of the proud rear chop. I guess that's what inspired me, perhaps subconsciously. The vise jaws on that one even have the tilting auxiliary jaw that I borrowed from Steve Latta. I'm sure I didn't notice that detail when I was studying the book.