New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Fore planes

Posts

Re: Fore planes

#26

Re: Fore planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Well, there's always the in-between of 47.5 degrees! Tearout always bothers me, just because it's uncontrolled. It goes as deep as it wants to, esp. in high-figure wood.

Incidentally, my C&W jack plane is also 50 degrees, with a camber of 1/8", 5.5 inch radius (I know because Bill said he used an 11" diam. coffee can to mark with).

Might actually be worth an email to Larry to get his thinking. He has unbounded interest in talking plane-making.

You raised a point earlier about 'how quartered does the wood need to be'? I don't know (again, a point for Larry perhaps), but I do notice that Japanese dais are rarely dead quartered. I've only seen one truly quartered dai, out of a bunch of Mosakus, one by Funatsu, and some others. Good dais, too. Mostly they are rift, with the grain on one diagonal and the rays on the other diagonal. Maybe someone here knows why--you see it so much that it has to be intentional.

Wiley

Re: Fore planes

#27

Re: Fore planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have made planes that were both quarter sawn and not and I have bought some moulding planes that are more like rift sawn. It is not the end of the world. My roughing plane (16 inch, call it fore or jack) is not quarter sawn and is the only one I have used since 1978. The reason quarter sawn is preferred is that dimensional change in the vertical direction affects the wedge fitting so you want the radial figure on the sides to the extent possible. However if you are making a plane, you have to learn to adjust a wedge anyway, so making a small adjustment later, if needed, is trivial.

If you have a 3x3 blank, you want to orient it with the radial surfaces on the sides if possible. If you start with a 4x4 blank, you have enough waste to adjust the grain orientation quite a bit. Even a 3X5 blank will probably have one part that is more favorable than the other because the rings curve.

You asked about weight earlier. I like a light plane for ease of working. If the plane cannot be controlled on bad grain, the remedies are sharper iron, less depth of cut. As Wiley mentioned beech has a long history. If it were desirable, a craftsman could add weight to a plane easily, but historically this has bot been done.

Re: Fore planes

#28

Re: Fore planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

how quartered does the wood need to be'?

Hi Wiley

I have made plane with grain both ways. Rift sawn works fine, however there is an issue around the mouth and back of the mouth where the edges can be more fragile and break away. This is less of a problem with quarter sawn stock. Of course it depends on the wood used.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fore planes

#29

Re: Fore planes

wilbur

"The Japanese planes probably vary substantially less in length without loss of function."

True. You can flatten a face of a board with a set of three Japanese planes where the main difference is in the degree of camber, how open the mouth is, and the thickness of the shaving the plane is set up to take. The length of the planes in this set would be identical for all intents and purposes, about 11-1/2" or so.

Re: Fore planes

#30

Re: Fore planes

Marc Waldbillig

Looking closer at the double-iron in the picture, one sees that the chip breaker hasn't the same width as the iron. It confirms the suspicions that the iron isn't the first one. You are right, irons in old planes aren't often enough reliable sources.

Marc