Re: Fore planes
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Warren and all,
Thank you for the quotation from Moxon's House Carpentry book. My own citation of Moxon was deficient in that I referred only to the Joinery book. Note that Moxon doesn't provide a length of either the joiner's fore plane or the carpenter's jack plane, except possibly through his plate of illustrations (which is actually Felibien's of 1676)--more on this point below.
In speaking of 'fore planes', my notion is that roughing planes--through all the countries and all the centuries--fall into a continuum from short/narrow/deep cutting to moderately long/shallower cutting, with the blade widths tending to get wider as the camber decreases. From the Stanley/LN No. 40 and the German shropphobel to the 14-17" jack to the 18"+ fore plane (pre-1700). From a really deep bite at the short/narrow end to maximize wood removal, to a shallower bite but accurate straightening at the longer end--and all combinations in between.
I was saying that I really like the longer/shallower-cambered end of the spectrum, and was asking about others' preferences.
On your 16" jack/fore plane, what is the blade width? And camber? Just curious. (I like cambers in the 1/32" to 3/64" range.)
Wiley
_________
A couple references for those interested....Josef Greber, a German author of The History of Woodworking Planes, looked at Felibien's 1676 engraving and other engravings, and says based on these graphics, that the early fore plane was "then as now one-seventh to one-ninth shorter than the jointer" (he said the two planes were typically shown in pairs). He scaled the Felibien (Moxon) planes, calculating the fore plane in Moxon's plate to be 2-1/4 times the length of the smooth plane, and the jointer, 2-1/2 times the smooth plane. However, Greber also states that over time what was called a fore plane changed function from a roughing plane to a short, straight bladed jointer.
John Whelan, in The Wooden Plane, notes the change in form of the fore/jack plane, from the close-toted plane shown in Moxon's plate and in John Jennion's shop sign, to the open-toted jack occurring in the late-18th/early 19th century.
American catalogs from Chapin (1859), Greenfield (1872), and Sandusky (1877) show close-toted 'fore planes' from 21-22" long with 2-3/8 to 2-1/2" irons, and open-toted 'jack planes' of unstated length with blades of 2" to 2-1/4". Of course, the owners would camber them (or not) as they pleased. The width of irons on the fore planes falls naturally in the progression from jack to jointer, and give no indication that there is an intended restriction to roughing use--quite the opposite.
__________________