New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Fore planes

Posts

Fore planes

#1

Fore planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Who has a copy of Roubo? Does Roubo talk about, or show, foreplanes or the French equivalent?

Moxon on bench planes, describes fore plane, jointer, and smoother (and strike block for mitering). Fore plane is the only roughing plane.

Do you folks use fore planes? Not a No. 6 with a straight blade. But a No. 6, woodie, or other 18-20" plane with cambered blade?

I really, really like fore planes. Takes the hard out of work, straightens as it scrubs, and saves your try plane edge for final passes.

Wiley

Re: Fore planes

#2

Re: Fore planes

david weaver

I use a #6 with a cambered blade. it's not set up like a try plane, but instead more like a jack with less camber. If I get a nice board that is flat and only has coarse saw marks or something, I use it and skip the jack.

The #6 that I have is a cheap ($15) very heavy casting ww2 or thereabouts stanley with all stock parts in it. It's a pleasure to use.

I love the new irons for smoothing, but I can't really find much virtue in them for that kind of coarse work. I think I like the stock irons better for that.

Re: Fore planes

#3

I don't know why P. Leach

Bruce, a MN Galoot

disses them, but I have a #6, same vintage as yours, that I absolutely love, for the same reason. It just works really well, the weight is just right, it's all good.

Re: Fore planes

#4

Re: Fore planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am not sure just what you are asking here, Wiley. Are you comparing a fore plane to a scrub plane or to a "jack plane". I have used a 16 inch wooden plane for many years and have referred to it as both jack and fore. I think it is less tiring than a scrub plane because your hands are farther apart, so you have more leverage, less effort to keep the angle you want. Here is what Moxon said about jack and fore planes:


Randall Holme, a rough contemporary of Moxon echoes Moxon's words, but I think the term fore plane sort of died out by around 1800.

The French term riflard is used by Felibien, Diderot and Roubo for this type of plane; Diderot mentions some variation in dimensions. The term varlope is used for Trying and jointing planes, also several types.

Re: Fore planes

#5

Re: I don't know why P. Leach

david weaver

I kind of like that he doesn't like them, though it hasn't always made them cheap - but often enough. I've had 5 #6s at various times just because I came across them so cheap I couldn't turn them down. 2 millers falls and 2 stanleys. All in great shape. The current one was $15, and the others averaged about $25, and I eventually sold all of them for one reason or another, except the current one.

That 6 (that I still have) is so much more pleasant to use than any jack that I have, and enough more precise that it's easy to go to almost any plane after it.

Re: Fore planes

#7

Re: Fore planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Warren and all,

Thank you for the quotation from Moxon's House Carpentry book. My own citation of Moxon was deficient in that I referred only to the Joinery book. Note that Moxon doesn't provide a length of either the joiner's fore plane or the carpenter's jack plane, except possibly through his plate of illustrations (which is actually Felibien's of 1676)--more on this point below.

In speaking of 'fore planes', my notion is that roughing planes--through all the countries and all the centuries--fall into a continuum from short/narrow/deep cutting to moderately long/shallower cutting, with the blade widths tending to get wider as the camber decreases. From the Stanley/LN No. 40 and the German shropphobel to the 14-17" jack to the 18"+ fore plane (pre-1700). From a really deep bite at the short/narrow end to maximize wood removal, to a shallower bite but accurate straightening at the longer end--and all combinations in between.

I was saying that I really like the longer/shallower-cambered end of the spectrum, and was asking about others' preferences.

On your 16" jack/fore plane, what is the blade width? And camber? Just curious. (I like cambers in the 1/32" to 3/64" range.)

Wiley

_________

A couple references for those interested....Josef Greber, a German author of The History of Woodworking Planes, looked at Felibien's 1676 engraving and other engravings, and says based on these graphics, that the early fore plane was "then as now one-seventh to one-ninth shorter than the jointer" (he said the two planes were typically shown in pairs). He scaled the Felibien (Moxon) planes, calculating the fore plane in Moxon's plate to be 2-1/4 times the length of the smooth plane, and the jointer, 2-1/2 times the smooth plane. However, Greber also states that over time what was called a fore plane changed function from a roughing plane to a short, straight bladed jointer.

John Whelan, in The Wooden Plane, notes the change in form of the fore/jack plane, from the close-toted plane shown in Moxon's plate and in John Jennion's shop sign, to the open-toted jack occurring in the late-18th/early 19th century.

American catalogs from Chapin (1859), Greenfield (1872), and Sandusky (1877) show close-toted 'fore planes' from 21-22" long with 2-3/8 to 2-1/2" irons, and open-toted 'jack planes' of unstated length with blades of 2" to 2-1/4". Of course, the owners would camber them (or not) as they pleased. The width of irons on the fore planes falls naturally in the progression from jack to jointer, and give no indication that there is an intended restriction to roughing use--quite the opposite.

__________________

Re: Fore planes

#8

My fore plane's blade is sharpened

Chuck Nickerson

to a 16" radius, my jack to an 8", 5-1/4 to 5", and scrub to 3".

(Yes, I like buying planes.)

Which one I use depends on how much material there is to remove.

Re: Fore planes

#9

Re: Fore planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wiley, I have about 3/64 camber on my 16 inch plane, 2 1/8 iron. It has had more or less camber at various times over the last 35 years. I occasionally have thought to have two planes with different camber, but I would not go longer because I like the light weight. My trying plane is 22 inches.

Here is Felibien's plate showing Riflard and Varlope.


Felibien lists Riflart, Galere, grande Varlope, petite Varlope, and demie Varlope. Some authors seem to suggest galere is another name for Riflard. I would not get too excited about the the relative lengths in the illustration. Felibien also lists and illustrates Varlope a onglet [strike block] and Rabot [smoother].

Old inventories and illustrations suggest four maybe five bench planes for a worker. I don't think you want eight, but it is reasonable that two workers with different specialties would have slightly different kits. With regard to fore plane and jack plane, I think that at various times and places, one term has been used for two slightly different planes or one plane has had two different names.

Re: Fore planes

#10

Re: Fore planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Warren,

Thanks for the detail, and for the Felibien engraving.

I agree with you about the relative lengths of the riflard and varlope shown by Felibien. Felibien was an art historian and court historian to the French king, and perhaps paid less attention to precisely scaling these objects than Josef Greber gave him credit for (though Greber cited other engravings as well, in making his estimate).

Roubo, though, was a cabinetmaker, and it would be interesting to know whether he provided data or graphics on these tools--his scaling would be credible, I imagine. I realize we're no longer in the 17th century, but still find these historical details of great interest :) .

Wiley

Re: Fore planes

#12

Re: Office québécois de la langue française

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks, Denis. Most of the times I have seen the word galere it was in the context "riflard ou galere" which made me think they were the same or similar. Here is a paragraph from Felibien (17th century) which touches on usage. You can probably translate better than I.


Re: Fore planes

#13

Re: Office québécois de la langue française

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

After this we straighten them with a jack then the jointer plane. Sometimes we use the Riflard or the Galère when the wood is crooked; then we put it square in width and thickness with the marking gauge.

This suggests that the Demi-varlope might not be the same tool as the Riflard or Galère...

Funny (at least for me) how the spelling has changed in ~400 years, wherever you see an f, s is now used. And that "funny f" at the beginning of sentences has no equivalent today...

DC

Re: Fore planes

#14

Re: Office québécois de la langue française

Patrick Gibbons

The French and English emphasize different points, the English defining the English language jack plane and comparing it to a smooth plane and the French relates that the varlope and riflard are for dressing long boards. To my mind they describe different planes.

Re: Fore planes

#15

Re: Office québécois de la langue française

Patrick Gibbons

That funny f was a printer's attempt to duplicate a hand written s as it was written in many different cursive hands. This type of s was usually used as a lower case letter. Letters have a certain number of minims, or strokes. An s has three. Due to the nature of what was written on, vellum, etc, strokes were mostly down. For this, and other reasons, this s developed early. f has the cross stroke through the upright. S has the cross stroke more as a tail. It does not go through the upright. It represents the third minim that is the lower curve stroke of the S. With ballpoints, felt tips and smooth paper we don't worry about which direction is easiest to follow. With a quill on vellum it's a different story. One wants down strokes as much as possible.

Re: Fore planes

#16

Re: Fore planes

Marc Waldbillig

Hi Wiley,

I use a #6 with an 3/64" camber and after this an #8 with an 1/64" camber, followed by a #7 established as a smoothing plane iron. This team of 3 revealed to me to be fast and gentle to the wood at the same time. No additional work because of heavy tear-out by a scrub plane.

Günther Heine, in Das Werkzeug des Schreiners und Drechslers (The Tools of the Joiner and the Turner) states that until the invention of the cap iron the fore plane (long roughing plane) was used with a scrup iron to flatten accurately big surfaces. A second long plane was the jointer, it had a straight blade. There are pictures of fore planes in the range from 60 to 70 cm and one of a jointer measuring 82 cm, 58 mm iron. Since the invention of the cap iron (double iron) fore planes with single iron and with cap iron became prevalent for jointing and flattening, the longer jointer fell into disuse. Heine refers to Greber too.

Furthermore Heine points out that originally fore planes had no totes at all, next step were turned pegs either in front or at the rear. The Alps region knew leather clews nailed to the body. Then there were cross breakthroughs at the back of the plane body, roman style like in France, Germany... The last step in this evolution was a tote, first open and later on closed, installed immediately behind the iron.

Marc

Re: Fore planes

#17

Re: Fore planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Marc and all,

Great to hear from you! As you have read, I am still getting good use from the Greber books.

That is very interesting data from Heine. Does he provide any date ranges for the 60-70cm fore planes with scrub irons?--I understand it was before the double-iron came into use. So maybe 18th century and earlier?

Greber also writes about the double-iron bringing large changes, with the long roughing fore plane morphing into a straight-bladed plane and the really long jointer falling into disuse. Do you understand the logic of how the double-iron caused this?--I don't get it. Maybe Warren gets it.

I like your solution, starting at No. 6 with 3/64" camber, then the long planes--all to avoid deepening the low places. I am using a woodie fore plane--20" closed tote with 3/64" camber--followed by a 22" try plane or 26" jointer (or smoother, depending). Sometimes an 18" woodie fore plane with 1/32" camber, where the board is in decent shape to start with.

Best wishes,

Wiley

Re: Fore planes

#18

Re: Fore planes

Marc Waldbillig

Wiley and all,

Great to read you too, Wiley!

"Does he provide any date ranges for the 60-70cm fore planes with scrub irons?--I understand it was before the double-iron came into use. So maybe 18th century and earlier?"

Heine says these fore planes were in use from the late Middle Age to the invention of the double-iron. He states that the invention of the latter was first documented 1787 in Sheffield, but it exists an earlier illustration of this type of iron in a catalogue of 1816 by Joseph Smith of Sheffield. He found this information in a book by William L. Goodman: The History of Woodworking Tools, p. 88. So the date range would extend from the mid 13th to the 19th century.

"Greber also writes about the double-iron bringing large changes, with the long roughing fore plane morphing into a straight-bladed plane and the really long jointer falling into disuse. Do you understand the logic of how the double-iron caused this?--I don't get it. Maybe Warren gets it."

Heine specifies that the longer jointer plane bodies (range 800 to 850 mm) disappeared and the joiners used the long fore plane bodies (range 600 to 650 mm) with both single-iron and double-iron. He doesn't mention the scrub iron anymore, but this doesn't mean that the camber on the iron disappeared. So far he agrees with Greber, but doesn't establish a cause between the appearing of the double-iron and the disappearing of the long jointers. I don't think the double-iron caused the fade-out of the really long jointer. In the German book of Greber, one sees an 80.3 cm long plane with a double-iron dating 1667 (p.240, Abb. 116, f). The long jointers coexisted with the double-iron. Maybe... beginning industrialization brought along standard sizes. Beforehand craftsmen customized the tools to their needs, now they bought their planes. But that is my guesswork.

Best regards,

Marc

Re: Fore planes

#19

1667 double-iron jointer (Germany) *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Marc and all,

Marc, you have a good eye, to find that double-iron jointer from 1667 in Greber!

This book is hard to come by, so I scanned the rather soft b/w photo in Greber, so people could see what we are talking about. The double-iron jointer that Marc spoke of is 'f', on the far right. For purposes of scale, that jointer is approx. 31-5/8" long.

Quite amazing, how the artisans carved their planes.

Wiley


Double-iron jointer, 1667 [from book by J. Greber]

Re: Fore planes

#20

Re: Fore planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wiley spoke earlier of a continuum from short/narrow/deep cutting to moderately long/shallower cutting, with the blade widths tending to get wider as the camber decreases. Of these two variables, camber and length, camber is much more important in determining function. One could more easily do roughing with a long plane with deep camber than a short plane with shallow camber. And one could more easily do trying or jointing with a short plane with small camber than a long plane with great camber. The Japanese planes probably vary substantially less in length without loss of function.

It could be that in German areas the double iron plane emerged during the same era as the longer fore plane disappeared, but like you Marc, I cannot imagine a rationale. Absent a good rationale the idea that the double iron caused the length change seems to be a post hoc argument.

We have to be skeptical of any photograph of a very old plane with double iron. There is just too much chance that the plane was altered and a new iron substituted in 300 years. I do think the use of the double iron preceded our 1767 earliest documentation by quite a while, perhaps even centuries, but was possibly very limited in number of practitioners.

Re: Fore planes

#21

Re: Fore planes

Steve Voigt

Hi folks, this is my first time posting here. I'm planning a fore plane build soon, so I wanted to make a couple observations and ask a couple of questions.

Like many people, my experience has been that a #5 is the right weight for a fore, but it's too short for initial flattening of large boards. When I switched to #6, I noticed that it made initial flattening much easier. But the #6 is exhausting for me when used for long sessions.

The other thing is that the chip breaker just gets in the way, and slows me down for sharpening.

So, I recently obtained a very nice, 2" vintage single iron, .195 thick at the business end. I plan on making the fore 18", same as a #6.

Here's my questions. First, has anyone found a traditional beech fore plane to be too lightweight? Does the plane tend to skitter when hitting resistance (like knots)? I can source a beech blank, but a beech plane of this size will weigh roughly 3.5-4 pounds. For comparison, a #5 is about 4.75 pounds. Would I be better off with something a little heavier? Of the half dozen woodies I've built, the only one that's a definite failure is made of maple; I've been happier with the ones made of heavy exotic woods.

Second, how important is it to orient the grain so that the quartersawn is on the sides? I can see how it would be essential in a moulding plane, but I'm not sure about the fore. If it's not essential, it would be cheaper to laminate 2 pieces of 8/4 than to get a single 12/4 or 16/4 blank.

Thanks in advance,

Steve

Re: Fore planes

#22

Re: Fore planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Steve,

First off, welcome! We'd like to follow the progress of your build.

...So, I recently obtained a very nice, 2" vintage single iron, .195 thick at the business end. I plan on making the fore 18", same as a #6.

Here are a couple of beech examples, please excuse the photo quality, the planes deserve better:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/sets/72157635030917606

The open tote plane is 18" long, 1/32" camber, 2-1/4" iron. The closed tote plane is 20" long, 3/64" camber, 2" iron. The beech is quartered, with the grain sweeping upward gradually from rear to front.

First, has anyone found a traditional beech fore plane to be too lightweight? Does the plane tend to skitter when hitting resistance (like knots)? I can source a beech blank, but a beech plane of this size will weigh roughly 3.5-4 pounds. For comparison, a #5 is about 4.75 pounds. Would I be better off with something a little heavier? Of the half dozen woodies I've built, the only one that's a definite failure is made of maple; I've been happier with the ones made of heavy exotic woods.

I have not found beech to be lightweight. It's been the trade choice for centuries. I've used these two planes on many temperate zone hardwoods--quartered white oak, sugar maple and soft maple, cherry, birch--and Ceylon satinwood. The planes pull into the wood--the camber accentuates this, and I keep mine sharp as a smooth plane as well. Nothing wrong with heavy exotics either, just more weight.

Let us know how it goes!

Wiley

Re: Fore planes

#23

Re: Fore planes

Steve Voigt

Hi Wiley,

Thanks for the kind words and especially the photos of your planes! The Old Street fore is definitely the model of what I'm aiming for.

I wonder if I could impose upon you for one measurement…on the 18" plane, what is the distance, on the sole, from the toe to the blade?

I will definitely update this when the plane is done…though it will be a while, as I haven't procured the wood yet.

Thanks again,

Steve

Re: Fore planes

#24

Re: Fore planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Steve and all,

The current Old Street fore plane shown on the website uses the closed tote, and is 18" long, with 2" iron:

http://www.planemaker.com/products.html

On my 18" plane, which is open tote, measuring on the sole, it is 6-3/4" from the toe to the rear of the mouth, i.e., to the bedding plane of the iron. Other bits of geometry for this plane:

Bedding angle...........50 degrees

Height of the block.... 2-3/4 inches

Width of block.......... 2-7/8" [however, this accommodates a 2-1/4" iron; my other fore plane with the 2" iron is 2-5/8" wide].

Tote offset.....Purely optional, but following their own research, Old Street at that time offset the tote from the centerline of the plane. The offset places the tote slightly on the far side of the pushing hand--so for me, being left-handed, the tote is shifted slightly to the left of the centerline. The idea is that the balancing hand in front will be on the near side of the plane stock, so the two hands being offset will tend to balance the plane, for example, if it's on an edge.

Grain....Quartered; horizontal grain lines, with rays vertical; grain running slightly upward from rear to front (this is explained on the Old Street site in an article). In the tote, grain running downhill, lined up with the horn (so as not to end up with short grain in the horn, or in the thin section at the top of a closed tote, I would imagine.)

Good sailing!

Wiley

Re: Fore planes

#25

Re: Fore planes

Steve Voigt

Hi Wiley,

Thanks so much for your trouble--those measurements are really helpful! I've read all of Larry's articles before, but I never had the actual dimensions, so this is great.

I confess I am slightly puzzled by 50* for a fore plane. I've made two planes--a coffin smoother and a jointer--that are bedded at 50*. Compared to 45*, I find the slightly increased difficulty of pushing is more than offset by the improved control of tear -out. But for a fore, I'm not too worried about tear-out, and I want the plane to be as easy to push as possible, so I'm tempted to bed the plane at 45*. Hmm, I'll have to mull this over. Anyway, thanks again for all your help!

-Steve