New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Downsides of Diamond Plates?

Posts

Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#1

Downsides of Diamond Plates?

Tony Wilkins

I got an Atoma 400grit diamond plate for flattening water stones but made the mistake of running through a lot of Sellers' blogs when I couldn't sleep.

For sharpening, what are the downsides of using a selection of diamond plates? Just wondering after reading his blog, why isn't everyone using them if they cut for a lifetime and are pretty much guaranteed to be dead flat? I'm sure there is something that I'm missing because I see plenty of people who don't use them on their tools.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#2

The big one, other than price...

John in NM

Is that they don't last. Plates where the diamonds are bonded to steel by overplating with nickel are not re-chargeable, so they cut slower as the pointy bits break off the diamonds. They are quite aggressive for a short while, then work well for a long time (length depends on how heavily they are used) then finally they cut slowly.

Best method for diamond sharpening is a bit of cast iron or steel plate machined flat, and some diamond paste or loose grit. You recharge as needed, and a lifetime supply of diamond costs just a few dollars. Only downside to doing that way is contamination of finer grit with a stray coarser grain or two, but that is if you worry obsessively about a little scratch here and there. In lapidary work we do worry about that (and I still use loose grit a lot when I do it), but for sharpening it seems a bit crazy to me to get that hot and bothered over it.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#3

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

Tom

I agree with all that. I bought my first one for sharpening and flattening stones, and it was big hit back in the day, in the early 80s. Rubbish within a few weeks. The stuff that bonds the diamonds is soft compared to the swarf from the stones, so it disappears in very low use. I have never had a diamond stone that lasted long for sharpening, other than machine tools. On machine tools they are mostly used on carbide as legend has it that the stones are ruined on HSS.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#4

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

L Robins

I had some diamond stones years ago, and they weren't very good, but they have improved a lot since then. I just did a check on the internet and most people that use them seem to feel that they last for a longer time than waterstones at less cost and less mess. Mr. Sellers is quite experienced, and he seems to like them. Even people who use waterstones now tend to use them for flattening. I tried diamond paste on a kataba, and was not pleased with the results, but I do like my diamond stones (all at less cost than 1 Shapton 15,000 grit). Oilstones are another long lasting alternative, but slower, and they do need to be occasionally freshened up with guess what - a diamond stone. Everyone seems to say that EZE-Lap and DMT are the two best brands. Most systems work and can be made to work well (scary sharp, waterstones, oilstones, diamonds), so you just decide what cost you are willing to pay in time, mess, or cost. Just some random thoughts.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#5

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

roger lance

Tony....you would be well advised to use your Atoma to flatten your waterstones only (don't use it to flatten tools).....and don't use it to flatten coarse waterstones (400....320 grit or less)....diamond plates don't last forever.....some wear out faster than others.....and some things wear them out prematurely.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#6

About stone flattening...

John in NM

I would not use loose grit for flattening a waterstone, that would be a great opportunity to get the stone contaminated with diamond grit. Flattening a waterstone is about the one time I'd use a piece of wet sandpaper glued to a plate. Cheap and easy.

Bonded diamond plates will work well for this. As soft as waterstones are, I don't think the plate would wear out as fast as when cutting steel, but I don't know, never tried it.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#7

Re: About stone flattening...

david weaver

Medium and fine stones (like 700 grit or higher) don't cause much trouble on a quality diamond hone in my experience. Coarser stones that have larger abrasive particles rolling around when flattening them do seem to wear the nickel plate a lot faster.

The old stones (kings, etc) were very agreeable with sandpaper, but some of the new ones are not (shaptons, etc). I don't know what happens with shapton fine stones with sandpaper, and you can use them passably with it, but they load faster after using sandpaper. I don't know if particles get embedded in the stone surface or if the stone surface is clinging on to some of the bonding agent in the sandpaper, but what happens isn't lovely.

For those hard and coarse stones, loose grit is almost unavoidable. Unfortunately.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#8

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

Patrick Gibbons

Some believe one type of sharpening media works better on their particular needs than all others. Others have continued to use what they learned on and still others already own what they use, are satisfied with it and are not inclined to spend money on something new. Diamond plates work well. I've owned mine over 10 years. I have, and do still, use oil stones so my diamonds stones have not been used continuously the whole time. They settle in as oil stones do also but have not worn out yet. Sharpening is one of those subjects that has been heavily covered. I've been swayed in the past to spend dinero on different approaches. We all know what I am, and what I was parted from in a rapid fashion. It all has to do with obtaining a more intense shade of forage on the opposite end of the partition.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#9

I'm not talking about nickel bonded plates...

John in NM

I'm talking about loose diamond grit (bort) applied to a metal plate with oil and used with or without rolling in (rolling in is done on copper laps, not iron).

Even though the OP did not ask about using either nickel bonded plates or loose grit for flattening (he asked about sharpening), enough other people mentioned flattening that I thought I should clarify that loose grit on steel or iron should probably be reserved for sharpening.

The use of loose grit diamond is so fantastically cheap and indefinitely renewable that I remain amazed that discussion always veers back towards bonded laps that are hardly inexpensive and do wear out fairly quickly.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#10

Re: I'm not talking about nickel bonded plates...

david weaver

For coarse and very fine work, I agree.

Ezelap's stuff for the inbetween seems to be pretty nice and inexpensive, too.

I have super fine loose, and 100 grit loose diamonds. There's not a lot of chance of cross contamination that way because I don't use one right after the other (actually, I only ever use the 100 grit for rehabilitation work).

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#11

I see now...

John in NM

You do use 100 grit loose for flattening waterstones? Good to know it works with no problems. My concern was that a 100 grit diamond or two might get stuck to the waterstone and then put a nice scratch in the next blade to be honed. The big advantage of nickel bonded plates is the lack of possible contamination.

Bear in mind of course, I don't use waterstones myself, so the question is fairly theoretical to me.

Re: Downsides of Diamond Plates?

#12

Re: I see now...

david weaver

Sorry, I wasn't that clear about that. I use 100 grit for removing pitting of hardened tools and flattening tools that are way out. It's so cheap and on a reinforced kanaban (which in my case is just a kanaban mounted to a piece of 8/4 hardwood) it can take unlimited pressure. I haven't used $10 worth of 100 grit diamonds in 6 years, and I have rehabilitated a lot of irons and chisels that I put aside before I had them.

I don't use any coarse stones below 800 grit, except for a pink aluminum oxide sloppy waterstone and a medium carborundum stone (and don't care so much if either of those are flatter than flatness you achieve by using the high spots on purpose), and use an atoma 400 to flatten my stones.