New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

Posts

Re: Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

#26

Re: Possibly silly question

Darren Brewster

So in the picture I uploaded, it would be the blue groove, as it is completely contained within the tail, and nearest to the bottom? That makes sense.

Do you mark and cut the dovetails first, then plough the groove, or plough the groove first then cut the dovetails? These are some pretty elementary questions, but I haven't made any furniture with a drawer in it yet (well, one piece did, but they were made to match something else and didn't have dovetails for the drawers).

Re: Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

#27

Re: Possibly silly question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Darren, I always do the dovetailing of a drawer first and then make the grooves. I am sorry to say that it has been so long that I have been doing it this way that I do not remember the original considerations. I do know that many make the grooves first. Often the order in which we do things is important, but perhaps not in this case.

Re: Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

#28

Thanks Warren.


Re: Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

#29

Speculation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It seems like "dammit!" moments would be more likely with paring all that fairly short grain on the tails than plowing a groove; maybe you're just maintaining strength in the tails during the strenuous work.

Re: Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

#30

Re: Possibly silly question

William Duffield

Reasons often sited by those who plow the grooves first include:

- Immediate visual indication of which is the inside and outside, top and bottom. (You still have to mark the drawer back.)

- It shows you where to make the kerf for the bottom half pin (assuming you prefer cutting pins first),

Re: Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

#31

Re: Possibly silly question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

When sawing dovetails first, it becomes important to ensure that the first few are positioned the same distance from the edge of the board. This ensures that the groove will run through all the tails if they are to be hidden in the pins ( e.g. when making a drawer with half blind dovetails at the front).

My practice is to saw the dovetails first. The layout - spacing, size and slope of the pin - is determined by the type of drawer or whether it is a carcase. Where the tails are large, as with a carcase, there is more freedom, however with slim dovetails for drawers there is little margin for error. In this case I may lightly run the plough plane over the board for a visual reminder of where the groove will go.

There is more freedom still if one omits the lower half pin. I wonder why this layout is not more commonly used? I assume it is for the added strength of the double half pin drawer front. Any comment?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Roubo bouvet, 10th tool

#32

Re: Possibly silly question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Perhaps because it's a lot easier to split out a half tail than a half pin?

Frank Klausz says you have to cut your pins first, :>) and you shouldn't do English dovetails because they are much too fragile. For maximum strength, it's best to make your pins and your tails about the same size.

Wilbur and I both attended a very entertaining and informative seminar presented by Frank Klausz last Saturday (the 13th). Really, he said he always cuts pins first, but you can do it either way. Some day, I may get good enough to cut mine by eye with reasonably consistent layout and just use a pencil to mark my tails from my pins, like Frank does, but I doubt it. I'll continue to use a ruler (or maybe two pairs of dividers) and a gauge and a marking knife and other "crutches".