New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

On learning Woodworking

Posts

On learning Woodworking

#1

Michael Donaldson

On learning Woodworking

Michael Donaldson

I have been at this addiction called woodworking for a few years now. Seeing as how my bedroom is my shop at the moment, I can honestly say that I live woodworking. I've read the anarchist's tool chest, I've read all the blogs and watched all the youtube videos. I've seen every episode of the Woodwright's shop available for streaming at least three or four times each. In the beginning I was trying to learn the right way to work wood. I was searching for the one way that would instantly open the portals of heaven and bestow woodworking mastery on me. I was looking for the one method that worked in every situation all the time.

I have a lot of tools, a lot of books, and a lot of magazines, but I was still really frustrated with my results. Then I learned the great secret to woodworking: There is no right way to do it. There are some key skills you need, but there are a million ways to get to those, too. And no shop or woodworker does it exactly the same. These are three main skill you need:

1. Learn to sharpen

2. Learn to saw a straight line

3. Learn to tune a handplane

That't it, folks. The only way to learn how to cut dovetails is to cut dovetails. With the three aforementioned skills at a satisfactory level (and trending upwards) I can make the things I dream up, and they turn out well. I still enjoy woodworking books, and videos. But I no longer turn to them to figure out the right way, I just do what I have to do in my situation to get my tools to do what I want them to do on my project.

Freeing myself from the fallacy of there being a definitive right way has led me to some interesting discoveries; for example, when I am ripping rough lumber, I stand up, and work my saw perpendicularly to the lumber with both hands on the handle, and I saw towards myself because in my shop, this is the only way I can hold my lumber down while I rip it. I've never seen it in a book or video, but it works in my situation. After my new shop is set up, I might never have to use that method again, but just like how you get to any satisfactory result: it doesn't really matter.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#2

Re: On learning Woodworking

David Bird

I'm following your same path.

I believe there were times and places where there was only one right way; for example, if you were an 18th century apprentice who would be fired for not following the master's way. In other words, the master's way was the "right" way.

Shocking to me, today there are many loud voices on Internet forums who still insist that they know the one right way. Some of them are skilled masters. Perhaps they served 20th century apprenticeships. I'm thankful that they share their ideas freely. Sometimes I learn much from them. Often I ignore them. I know not to attempt any discussion with them. At least they can't fire me.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Perfection

Jack Guzman from Maine

Michael,

I learned woodworking through this forum. I have no mentors.No local old-timers to get tips from. Just the internet and books.

One of the things I learned that was important to me was that perfection is not absolutely necessary. You must shoot for it but don't lose heart if you make mistakes. The makers of fine furniture made mistakes. Once I decided this was true I looked for them in old pieces. They are there.I believe that one desirable skill is the ability to recover from and make the best of mistakes.

Woodworkers are human and humans are imperfect. If you set up a machine to make something and after some trial runs you get all the bugs out you can create perfection but we aren't machines.

I'm sure that there are woodworkers who are pretty close to perfect and who make no mistakes(almost) but I am not one of them. I didn't let that stop me.When I finish a piece I see my mistakes but I am surprised that others don't.

I don't know if I'm the only one who feels this way but it doesn't matter. I love what I do and my flawed work is enjoyed by other people so I keep doing it.---Jack

Re: On learning Woodworking

#4

May not be one right way...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....but on a "discover it yourself path" you will soon discover that there are a multitude of wrong ways when it comes to furniture construction, which will lead to premature failure.

We have a club member that both builds and repairs furniture as a living. He once opined how he learned from repairing. It could be called learning from others mistakes, and not repeating them, unless striving for period accuracy.

There are two issues to be considered in building stuff- speed and reliability. Personally when possible, for learning some new technique I seek out someone that practices this technique professionally. I find the professionals that make stuff, rather than write about making stuff, are more useful for my learning needs. In this way I quickly learn a quick and reliable way to do the task. From this vantage point I can then knowledgeably explore variations if so inclined.

My goal is to make lasting furniture and lots of it. Other may differ and a different approach work for them.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#5

Re: On learning Woodworking

cstanford

Buy the book Good Wood Joints by Jackson and Day and make every hand cut joint in the book (some joints are illustrated as machine cut only, they are indeed, you should ignore them for the moment).

Buy a pile of S4S 1X Poplar (yes, S4S) and start sawing and chiseling. You'll need only a few tools: a marking gauge, a cutting gauge, a mortise gauge, a 4H pencil, pencil sharpener, three or four chisels (maybe), and one 10" backsaw (with which you should be able cut both dovetails and tenons with no problem). Use the Japanese equivalents of these if you want to. It doesn't matter one bit one way or the other. If you already own a fine-toothed dovetail saw then use it in lieu of the tenon saw when sawing dovetails.

Gauge and cut the joints EXACTLY AS ILLUSTRATED AND IN THE SAME SEQUENCE AS ARRANGED BY THE AUTHORS. NO DEVIATION. UNLEARN WHAT YOU THINK YOU'VE LEARNED AND DO THE WORK AS ILLUSTRATED.

You should easily be able to do this in a bedroom workshop and create small messes that are very easy to clean up.

Good luck.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#6

Re: On learning Woodworking

david weaver

Used hardbound copies for 15 cents!

Re: On learning Woodworking

#7

I should add..

cstanford

...you will need a bevel gauge and a No. 4 to cut a couple of joints, hopper dovetails come immediately to mind.

Otherwise, all other joints should be gauged and cut to finish as flush as you can make them off saw and chisel. If they are a touch out-of-flush, don't worry about it. Move on.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#8

Re: On learning Woodworking

cstanford

Best book there is!

Re: On learning Woodworking

#9

Re: I should add..

david weaver

I took one of the 15 cent copies. Thanks for the suggestion. Have several joint books, but they focus too much on TS/BS and Router joints.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#10

You said it better

John in NM

That's what I was just trying to say in the ever growing chisel monogamy thread :D You said it better though :D

My mom is always amused that I mutter and curse at stuff as I try to fix it. A habit of my dads that she was well acquainted with. I think the other habit of his that I learned was to try different methods when the first one doesn't work.

Apply things learned from other tasks to the current one and see if that works. Go back to the first after all other known methods are exhausted. The other thing about dad, he never gave up. Kept his hands busy cycling through iterations of different ways of loosening a stuck bolt (for example) while his mind worked on new wrinkles of what hadn't worked.

After a few years of this, one usually knows the one most likely to yield results on the first try. The other thing you know is that there is no single way that will always work.

I have little doubt that he learned this by watching others who did the same :D

Re: On learning Woodworking

#11

Re: I should add..

cstanford

I think you'll enjoy it.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#12

Re: On learning Woodworking

Ron Harper

Yes... You have reached a major milestone... I agree that there can be many right ways to do a task. Some will depend on your tool kit. Some will depend on your acquired skills, and some will depend on what you like to do.

Again, consult the gurus, just do not let them get in the way of your woodworking.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#13

Michael Donaldson

Re: On learning Woodworking

Michael Donaldson

I hope my post did not appear to diminish the value of learning from other's experience. I have learned a lot from this forum, and I still come here often to get assistance and input on problems I am trying to solve. There is a huge value in learning what others do. Perhaps a more pure way of conveying my sentiment is to say that I realized that my woodworking is mine, and that I need to own it completely. There are always universal rules that must be followed, like when dealing with wood movement, joint strength, etc. if I want my work to last (which I do). Ron Harper said it well when he advised us to consult the gurus, but to not let them get in the way of our woodworking.

Re: On learning Woodworking

#14

Re: On learning Woodworking

CStanford

There is no particular secret or set of secrets to hand tool woodworking. One always marks the wood, always, and removes wood to the mark. If you've ever worked on a framing crew you know that the lead carpenter can snap the lines and lay out the plates and walk away while the $8/hour monkeys frame the walls. He's done the hard part - the thinking part. Marking joinery is no different. Lay out workpieces so that any reasonably competent woodworker could immediately understand the layout and cut the joints. And then lay out and mark every joint, every time, to the same standard even if you're the one doing the cutting. Clean, professional, uncompromising, lay out and gauging. Every. Single. Time. Without fail.

Shortcuts make for long days. Write it or print it out in BIG LETTERS and hang it over your workbench.

You need to understand 'working in pair,' unrolling a drawer to mark sides, how to mark multiple workpieces, how to mark multiple workpieces that are slightly out-of-truth and have them finish the same length, shoulders match up, etc.. Until you learn all of this you will be confounded by small errors and joints that don't quite fit that you thought would fit, frames that knock together a little out of square or twisted, etc. Your work will take longer and you'll spend more time tweaking and scratching your head.

If you aren't reading Hayward, Joyce, Kingshott, Kirby, and the rest of the British gang on all of these topics you simply aren't doing your homework IMO.

In essence, if you can mark and gauge workpieces the way it's supposed to be done (and at a point without having to look it up in a book) you really can't do $hit. Took me years and a ton of angst before I realized it.

The keys to it all are: 1)your brain; 2)a pencil; 3)a marking gauge; 4)a cutting gauge; 5)a mortise gauge 6)a bevel gauge