New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

A drawer for the kist

Posts

A drawer for the kist

#1

A drawer for the kist

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

When we left off last time the base had been constructed in preparation for the drawer. The question I asked was whether there would be any reason why one wide drawer was a bad idea (since it would look better - be easier to hide in the base - than two drawers). I decided to go ahead with one drawer. This is where it will be fitted ...


The base looks like this ...


... and the plan was to use these stretchers as a guide for the drawer ...


I have since sawn them to about half that width and added a rebate to create a 1/4" tongue along the inside length at each side. The idea is to groove the side of the drawer and run the drawer along the tongues.

What I would like to get opinion on is whether there is a better way, such as a mechanical (extension) slide. Again, the concern is to minimise any potential racking in a wide drawer.

I have completed the drawer, done today. The design of the drawer takes it out of the traditional as I have used plywood for the base. The reason for this is was the need to maximise the internal space in this shallow drawer (about 2" high) by screwing the base into a lower rebate rather than floating a panel in a groove (which would have to be situated higher). My reasoning was that ply would be stable and not need to deal with the expansion issue of solid wood. Your thoughts? Would you have designed the drawer differently?

Here is the drawer resting on the side stretchers. The drawer has not yet been grooved to slide on the tongues. I can change the design if there is a convincing argument for something else.



This is the tongue (that the drawer is resting upon).


Two features here: the first is the drawer features through dovetails at the front and a cross piece that is attached with sliding dovetails. A section from the base will be attached to the front of the drawer (and blend in with the remainder of the base). The drawer does not extend to the rear, although the sides do (to support it when extended).


This is the ply base screwed into a rebate that runs fully around the drawer. The 1/4" ply is very stiff and there was no need for a munton. No glue. I considered expansion slots, but believe that there is no need.



The wide breadboard ends on the top have been cut down (by more than half). Inside there is a 3/4" tenon. The underside has been given a small moulding (to pick up the theme of the base). This is a dry fit.



That's it for now. I am away (visiting parents in Cape Town) for 10 days. No building in this time. I look forward to any comments.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A drawer for the kist

#2

Re: A drawer for the kist

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Interesting design, and, of course, secret drawers are always really cool. This one is sized perfectly to hold maps to where the treasure is buried.

One structural question: will the front corners of the base be fastened firmly to the carcase so that they don't spread? If not, you probably need some kind of connection between the two front corners.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#3

Re: A drawer for the kist

roger lance

Derek....I think you have made some good decisions on the drawer....I like one drawer over two.....the plywood bottom works in its rebate and the bottom of the drawer should not be seen again after installation....I vote no on any metal runners to prevent racking (you used up all your allowed deviation from mythological standards with the plywood.... :))....however, I'm wondering if there might be a way to create a wood guide attached to the bottom of the kist that the top of the drawer ran along....that might prevent racking and also prevent the drawer from being pulled all the way out.

I like the shortening of the side overhangs....that looks much better....and I like the matching of the type of wood with the type used in the base (jarrah I assume).....but I guess I'm more of a traditionalist and would like to see a "hand hold "in the front of the chest to open the top....to open the top from the side is a little counter intuitive for me.


an example from a blanket chest I did that has a piece of trim around three sides of the chest with a hand hold centered in front....but I'm still listening to The Four Tops....not vary open to new ideas I guess.

Hope you have a wonderful visit with your parents.....don't go hand feeding any lions or great whites while there.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#4

Re: A drawer for the kist

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Thanks.

Regarding the attachment at the front, in the 4th and 5th photo you can (just) make out the steel L-brackets that I am using to ensure that area does not move.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A drawer for the kist

#5

an alternative choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never been fond of grooved drawer sides. Especially in this case I would have made a thin sided drawer and captured it between two side guides attached to the stretchers.

Some like a center guided drawer. They are more work to make but work well. In this case the shallow drawer precludes this option.

When fit well drawers don't rack. I just delivered to daughters new home a chest of drawers 42" wide. My metric for the approx. 40" wide drawer fitting was that they should readily close by pushing on one side, and they all did. Your arrangement is not different from a small desk with a drawer in the apron. Prepare the drawer tight and plane it till it closes easily.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#6

Re: A drawer for the kist

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would be nice to see some more of that chest.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#7

Re: A drawer for the kist

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

I have stayed away from a front lift as it would change the line of the kist. Yours looks great - I like it - and I agree with Bill ... let's see some more of your chest (the wooden one .... :) ).

I am going to explore sliding metal brackets before I go further, but the case work is so solid .. and everything is square ... that I believe I could get away with my first plan.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A drawer for the kist

#8

Re: an alternative choice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Bill. As I have just mentioned in my reply to Roger, I will explore the possibility of metal slides .... I have 10 days away from the shop to do a little research.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A drawer for the kist

#9

Re: an alternative choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I do not understand the consideration of metal slides. They certainly are not required to ensure a drawer that works. For someone that can plane making a drawer that works is not difficult.

A drawer with shellaced and waxed sides glides more smoothly than a ball bearing drawer glide. This is not an idle statement. I have Accuride slides in kitchen and elsewhere and just wood in my furniture.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#10

Re: an alternative choice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I think I'm getting a mixed message here, or perhaps misunderstood your first message ...

I have never been fond of grooved drawer sides. Especially in this case I would have made a thin sided drawer and captured it between two side guides attached to the stretchers.

Since I cannot now build the drawer this way, I took away that your first comment (about the drawer grooves).

My first preference is to continue down the line of a drawer groove (I cannot see why it should not work). However I will look into a drawer slide, the provisor being that it is slim and unobtrusive.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A drawer for the kist

#11

Re: an alternative choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In picture #5, couldn't you simply capture the drawer between two guide strips fastened to each stretcher? Fit the strips tight and than plane drawer to be smooth gliding.

And, yes, I have no material objection to your original plan. I am just prejudiced against drawers with grooved sides.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#12

Re: an alternative choice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I shall have to see if that can be done. The fit is not what you may think you see.

The drawer front is 1/4" in total less in height than the face/base, intending to fit 1/8" from each side (the false front is to be attached to the drawer). The lower side of the stretcher lies directly behind the base and flush with it. This is the picture to which I think you were referring ...


Are you suggesting that I create a tongue/tenon 1/8" from the bottom edge of the stretcher upon which the drawer can rest and run? I am not sure if that would be strong enough.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A drawer for the kist

#13

Re: an alternative choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

that fact there is confusion suggests I don' t understand the situation.


The drawer appears to be sitting on what you are calling stretchers, that I might call runners. If red strips under the drawer are not runners then I am lost. If they are, adding a strip of wood down the runner will capture the drawer and provide guidance to its action.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#14

Re: I vote for door #3...

Bruce McCrory

Derek, you obviously are getting sick of this project ... ummm, to suggest metal kitchen drawer glides.

Everyone knows those metal things belong on utility drawers utilizing MDF, and worse. Besides, metal glides always jam and pinch, then break something; usually the drawer. However, in your case (pun) the feet will collapse.

And, down will fall Kist, and All. Onto tabletop runners.

Take Door #3, the least opened, and have a break from this twisted mess--beautiful twists--and let sub-C ruminate for awhile. Ten days is not long enough.

Just my penny's worth...

Re: A drawer for the kist

#15

Re: an alternative choice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

OK Bill, I get it now. I think my tired brain earlier wanted to hang the drawer 1/8" above the edge of the runner, and what you suggested did not do so. BUT ... if I plane a rebate 1/8" deep (and say 1" wide), I can attach a wooden strip in the rebate, extend it out about a further 2", and that will enable the drawer to run at the desired height.

Regards (now) from sunny Cape Town

Derek

Re: A drawer for the kist

#16

Isn't it remarkable.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What would have taken seconds had we been standing at the piece took considerable written communication as well as pictures. We didn't even get the right picture at first. And that's between two people experienced with the topic and reasonably skilled in communication. In many ways the Internet has helped communication, but it is still difficult.

To supplement my daughters formal classes in English I would have them write for me directions for how to do something, which I would critique. Don't know if it ever helped them in their careers or not.

Re: A drawer for the kist

#17

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I once had a shallow drawer to contend with and solved it just as you did with a thin plywood bottom.