New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Help me with LN and LV order

Posts

Help me with LN and LV order

#1

Help me with LN and LV order

Tony Wilkins

Got a gift and so now I have a good chunk to put down on some tools. Been moving things around in my head and here's what I have:

A) From LV

1) low angle smoother with pm-v11 blade

2) #6 fore with pm-v11 blade

3) dx60 block with pm-v11 blade

4) maybe a small plow plane

B) from LN

1) a bench chisel since I like my LN mortise chisel so well

2) a large router plane

Whatdya think? Should I get an extra blade for the LV Fore if I want to use it as a jack and a shortish jointer/try? I'm caught between the cheaper LV low angle smoother and an LN #3 or #4 - thoughts please? I'd also like an LV small plow but I'd have to drop something (maybe the LV block or the smooth plane).

Plane wise I have an old street jack and coffin smoother but after using a very poor example of a bailey #5 I like the feel of it better. Guess for that matter I could get either an LV or LN #5 and two extra blades to use it as a 'jack' in the full sense.

So, lots of thoughts that I keep rolling over in my mind.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#2

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

Tony Wilkins

Have a parallel conversation going on over on SMC. I probably should have just asked what to get with a grand ($1000 US)?

Current tools: fixed for saws with 26" Disston rip and cross, Wenzloff pannel Rip, and a 12" Bad Axe hybrid DT/carcasse.

Planes: Old Street Jack, Old Street Smoother

Chisels: 1/4" LN Mortise, 1/4" and 3/4" Blue Spruce Bench, Slight over 1/4" Pig Sticker vintage (which I can barley wield)

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#3

Michael Donaldson

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

Michael Donaldson

I prefer the large router plane from LV simply because the irons are compatible with the old Stanley 71. So you can get new irons for it anywhere. The LN router plane, although of excellent quality, used proprietary irons. This might not be of concern to you, but since I own both an old Stanley 71 and the LV router, it makes sense to me.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#4

Michael Donaldson

Planes

Michael Donaldson

I have yet to find a need for a low angle smoother. I have a LN #3 and #4, and sometimes I wish I had the 55 degree frog to help in tougher grain, but as long as I keep the iron really, really, sharp I can make it work. So I would suggest getting a regular smoother (if I had to do it over I'd just get a 4 1/2 and be done with it).

For the jack plane, I have two stanley #5's. One is set up with a straight iron and is a really nice plane. I use this as a short jointer, and also on my shooting board. This is really my go-to plane. My other #5 is a $15 ebay special. It's rusty, and rough. I have an 8" radius on the iron and the frog all the way back. But for rough stock removal, it gets the job done, and is cheaper than a replacement blade for a nice Jack Plane.

What do you have for sharpening? I would suggest taking some of that money and investing in a nice sharpening system (millions of options, just pick one that you will actually use often). Hand tools are only nice to use when they are sharp.

Honestly, my LN dovetail saw, LN block plane, old Stanley #5, and an old 1" bench chisel are the tools I use about 90% of the time (for what I build). Just my two cents.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#5

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A) From LV

1) low angle smoother with pm-v11 blade

2) #6 fore with pm-v11 blade

3) dx60 block with pm-v11 blade

4) maybe a small plow plane

B) from LN

1) a bench chisel since I like my LN mortise chisel so well

2) a large router plane

Hi Tony

Since you are interested in a BU smoother, let me point you in the direction of the LV Small BU Smoother. This has a 1 3/4" wide blade (get the PM-V11 steel), the same as a LN #3. If possible, try these planes alongside one another - ensure that they are both set up with the same cutting angle. Which do you prefer? Ultimately, only you can decide.

I enjoy using both. The LN has a 55 degree frog - same as the bed on your Old Street

coffin smoother. The LV is generally set up with a 62 degree cutting angle (50 degree secondary bevel). This little LV BUS is a gem. The LN #3 can leave a fine finish on hard, interlocked wood (using the chip breaker), but it is harder to push.


Another plane I would advise you to consider is the LV Large Router Plane over the LN. Until the LV acquired a new depth stop I would have said that the old was a deal breaker and the LN was to be preferred because of that .... and inspite of the LV having the better blade selection and ease of blade change (both by far). Now that the LV has a similar depth stop to the LN, it is overall the better choice for large router planes.

The third plane you should consider does not have any competition among new planes: the LV Small Plow Plane. Add a wide sub-fence and it is foolproof ...


Now, do you have a shoulder plane .... :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#6

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

Tom

I also prefer the LV router.

I'm not sure where were are on the BU planes these days, since the great breaker wars? Are BUs still the go to plane for folks buying all new? Or are they yesterday's news. I have an LV BU, and an LN the jointer and the jack. They are good but so are many other planes. There is a lot lot less magic out there than all the chat would imply. I was just reviewing an old thread, by accident, in which some guy got dropped from delivery of a custom tool he badly wanted. He sounded like a jilted lover. The level of expectation was so out the world it was sad.

I prefer to have all one type of plane and particularly all one type of steel. Each steel or even variant in the same steel will end up with a better or worse sharpening combo, and I don't like having to reach for a bunch of different stones just to keep the same set of tools in the game. Of course some people don't have that many stones, in which case, all the more reason to get one steel and work towards a great set-up for that steel.

I also prefer having tools of a given brand. It's sad to spend a grand and end up with a set that still looks like it came from a garage sale, though that is a purely aesthetic preference.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#7

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

I agree with you that reducing the number of variables in a set of tools makes for a simpler, more predictable, and thereby easier-to-use experience. I could have said more about the reasoning behind the LV Small BU Smoother.

As Tony has pointed out, he is experiencing difficulty with hand strength. For this reason, the plane needs to be easy to push (or pull - but I know little about Japanese planes). BU planes are easier to push than the equivalent BD plane - lower centre of effort aids with control and maximises where the power goes. A narrower blade (1 3/4" vs 2" and greater) reduces resistance. Wax the sole to further reduce friction.

PM-V11 steel hones with the same level of effort as A2 but has great advantages of durability = less sharpening and less tax on the hands. Versus the fine edge of O1? PM-V11 and O1 edges are similar, but I give the nod to the PM steel. Durability? No competition, even more than A2. Why settle for less.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#8

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

Tony Wilkins

Derek, thanks for all the insight; I'll definitely look at those (and have some of them).

Tom, hadn't thought of the sharpening constancy issue. I'm not as concerned about my tools matching; to be honest, if I chose based on appearance alone the LN tools would wind hands down for me. At the point in my life I have to be a lot more pragmatic ;)

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#9

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

Patrick Gibbons

I have the regular LV low angle block plane. Buying that instead of your choice will save you $46. I also have the LN apron block ( the 102?). The smaller block is much easier to hold and use than a regular block. The LV apron plane wasn't available when I bought mine otherwise I would have gotten it. That purchase would save you almost enough to get the plow which I also recommend.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#10

This isn't the answer you're looking for

John in NM

But I have to say it.

Buy some wood. Quantity and quality will depend on what you wish to make, but it is a great thing to have your wood on hand. Same goes for high quality hardware, hinges, latches, etc. Of course you may have done this already, but I like to say it since our discussions are often very tool centered and not as materials centered as they could be.

As to the tools, I don't have much of an opinion. I have a few LN tools, and a few older LV tools. I don't much care for either company's planes, LV for aesthetic reasons (probably the worst reason to not favor a particular brand :D ) and LN's because I have yet to find one that is a good fit for my hands - everything seems to be too small. My preference is for old Stanleys and Hock blades. I believe I could easily form a preference for old Stanleys and LV blades :D

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#11

Agree Stanley and Hock and buy wood


Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#12

Re: This isn't the answer you're looking for

Tony Wilkins

Have wood for a Few projects (walnut, cherry, poplar) but will probably pick up some more cherry and maybe some maple. One area that I haven't got into is sharpening; I have 1000 and 6000 grit water stones I got from Hida when I started. Know I'll have to get some way to grind soon.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#13

Re: This isn't the answer you're looking for

John in NM

My bench grinder gets a bit of use, but not as much as you might think.

I remember a story in a FWW eulogizing Tage Frid, a long time student/employee of his was relating how the boss had these stubby chisels like none he'd ever seen before. Turns out they got dressed on the shop belt sander frequently and used straight off the sander, thus they were pretty short :D

Although I like my sharpening routines as much as anyone else, that story always stuck with me as evidence that, as a group, we make waaaayyy too big a deal about sharpening.

You might look for a coarse synthetic stone as a first step in honing. I got one at Woodcraft, back when we had a Woodcraft around here. Raise a burr with that and then move to the fancy stones. Almost as good as a grinder and a lot more forgiving and cheap.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#14

Grindy water stone

Tony Wilkins

sent a message to Stu. I like the idea of a low grit water stone instead of a grinding wheel. Any suggestions from y'all?

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#15

Don't know about a water stone...

John in NM

They one I was referring to is a coarse SiC stone. They may be used with water or oil, or dry probably. But they behave more like an oilstone, you don't get a slurry of abrasive and use of the stone does not continually expose new abrasive.

Come to think of it, you don't even need a stone for a coarse first step - you could use wet/dry sandpaper on a polished floor tile just as well. The main thing is to make the first step one coarse enough that this doesn't take long.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#16

Remove obstacles

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Coarse water stones are cheap and no reason you shouldn't have one. The one I am familiar with (Shapton) dishes quickly. So you need a flat concrete block or something to undish it on. Stu could advise on this.

More generally, the ability to sharpen quickly is pretty much ballgame. Buying a load of planes and irons, and three water stones to deal with it all, and nothing to flatten them with, immediately establishes sharpening as a big issue--at least as soon as all the irons are dull (they come usably sharp from LV) and stones begin to dish. Yeah, you can defer stone dishing once you become really skilled and experienced, but there will be some bad road up to that point.

Your life will be a lot better if you have a way of maintaining the hollow grind that your blades will come with. Otherwise, you are building up obstacles in your path by having the three water stones to do all your grinding and flat-bevel honing. With hollow grinding, you'll still have to flatten stones, but they won't wear and dish nearly as fast. And it takes extraordinary skill to maintain flat bevels doing hand-held sharpening--if you go this route, you should plan on using a sharpening jig IMO.

If you're going to be at this hobby for a long time, you would be better off IMO, spending most of the gift money on a Tormek setup (the high end one), and the balance on a couple of planes.

Why Tormek? It's low speed and wet stone. Yeah, kinda slow. But it's not going to blue any irons, and it's forgiving of any slippage in dexterity. Will work with chisels and planes, and your current water stones are fine for final hone, though you'd probably pick up one superfine grit. (Makoto Imai won the kezourou-kai planing competition years ago, honing with a 6000g stone, so it's possible. But most of us want a 10K to 15K stone at some point.)

Wiley

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#17

Re: Remove obstacles

Tony Wilkins

I'll look into the Tormek Wiley. Was planning on getting either an iWood or Atoma diamond plate to flatten the stones. I've been eyeing those higher grit stones just as you say.

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#18

Good plan!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

on the diamond plate for flattening.

Wiley

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#19

Tormek Question

Tony Wilkins

Wiley, when you suggested the higher end Tormek you are referring to the T7 as opposed to the T3 correct?

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#20

Re: Tormek Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Yes, the T-7. Mostly, folks offer it at $639 with free shipping. Lot of money, but it's pretty bulletproof. I recall Jet offering a cheaper alternative, but then people said they could stop the Jet wheel just by pressing the blade down on it. Tormek is very sturdy, and will do you from now on.

Wiley

Re: Help me with LN and LV order

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Old Fuddy-Duddy's take on the question.....

Jesper, Denmark

As a matter of principle, I never buy stuff in sets. You end up with a bunch of stuff you never use, when all you need was one - take your pick - router bit, drill bit etc.

Making up your list of "wanna-haves" is like a set.

Put the money in your tool investment account. When you need a tool for something - go buy it.

The discussion between LN, LV or old Stanley for that matter is really irrelevant. Different people have different preferences for their own reasons. Their reason is not necessarily relevant for you. Whatever you prefer is the only thing that matters to you. I might like something different, but that is best for me - not necessarily for anyone else.

I'm getting off the soapbox now........