You were all right
Jonathan Wagner
So, thanks to all of you, I'm finally taking good shavings with the Stanley iron and a Hock chipbreaker/cap-iron.
Let's see if I can keep this straight. I had suspected something wrong with the way the iron mated with the frog, which lead to me figuring out that the iron was bent. I figured, no problem, I'll pick up a replacement on the way home from work on Friday. While I was at it, I went ahead and picked up a Hock chipbreaker as well. I knew the chipbreaker was thicker, but I didn't realize the Hock iron was thicker than the Stanley iron iron. Once I got home, I went ahead and swapped out the Stanley pair for the Hock pair and watched the cap iron run into the front of the mouth immediately.
After playing with the frog position and the chipbreaker position, I was finally able to get dust like shavings, but the mouth quickly clogged. Extending the iron enough to get an actual shaving barely let any light through when sighting down the cap iron towards the mouth. The Stanley combo was even worse still.
This morning, after several messages from Willey and Derek about the replacement iron being thicker than the original and the bent iron acting like a thicker iron itself, and suggestions to try another Stanley iron, I tried an experiment. This is the only #7 I have and the only other Stanley plane I have is a #4 with a narrower iron. Well, narrower should fit, right? And it does. It took some finagling to get the iron centered in the plane, but it worked. I was able to get decent shavings, though there wasn't any side to side support and the iron had a tendency to rock to one side and gouge the wood. The point was, though, the mouth opening and frog was fine. My iron/chipbreaker setup was what was amiss.
After reading a couple more posts from Derek and David about the chipbreaker being a potential problem and that the curve in the iron could be affected by it, I decided to try one more setup. I thought that the thicker Hock chipbreaker might be better at straightening the Stanley iron iron allowing clearance with the thinner Stanley blade. That was the ticket! It's still a pretty tight mouth, but I'm actually able to move the new chipbreaker to within a 1/16th of the cutting edge and take a decent shaving.
So, now I have an extra Hock iron in case I ever get a #4-1/2 or a #6 that needs one or I decide to file this one. Thanks for everyone's help. I probably would not have looked so closely at the chipbreaker without your advice.