New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

Posts

Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#1

Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

Jonathan Wagner

Hi all! I hate that my first post here is to ask for help, but I've been lurking for a while and I recognize the experience available here. So, here goes.

I just received a Stanley No. 7 that I purchased from Walt Q recently and I'm having real trouble getting it to take a shaving. The iron that came with it was a little banana shaped and I thought that was the problem, so I picked up a Hock replacement iron and iron cap from my local Woodcraft on the way home. Long story short, I'm still having issues. I'm suspecting an issue with the frog, but the I'm not sure. With the frog adjusted forward so that the bed of it lines up with the small ramp at rear of the mouth the cap iron runs into the front of the mouth. With the frog adjusted as far back as it will go, by the time the iron protrudes enough to cut, the opening between the iron and front of the mouth is so tight that it chokes.

What am I missing here? I'm really a total newbie at this. I've included a link to an album with some pictures of the frog and plane bed if it helps.


Photo Album

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#2

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

John Horst

Have you flattened the plane base? Make sure it is dead flat. There are articles by Chris Swartz that will give you step by step detatails to have a great plane.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#3

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

Jonathan Wagner

I have not. The sole seems pretty flat when checked with a straightedge though.

I'm not sure how that would affect the mouth opening, though. By the time the iron protrudes far enough to feel the mouth opening is probably only a few thou'–narrower than I set my smoother.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#4

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

ray

I just went through a similar ordeal with my #7 a few weeks ago. The original blade was in very bad shape. LV shipped a Hock and a Veritas blade. I had the same problem that you encountered with both of the thicker blades. Blade wouldn't adjust down far enough with the frog in one position and in the other position it closed up the mouth completely.

LV was very helpful. They then sent a Stanley blade and told me to return any of the blades that didn't work. The Stanley did work. Evidently, other people have not had this problem, so it must be something in my plane. I suspect that there is enough wear on the adjusting wheel/yoke/whatever to make the new thicker irons behave badly.

I will use the $15 Stanley blade until I find a frog with less wear, or a higher quality thin blade.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#5

Mouth opening?

Jonathan Wagner

A worn frog seems like the issue. I just tried the blade that came with it (not the original; probably long gone) and was actually able to get a couple shavings. Still, the mouth opening seems really tight.

So, I guess this goes out to everyone. How tight is the mouth on your jointer?

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#6

File the mouth open

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The problem you are experiencing is a common one when a thicker replacement blade is used. The old banana shaped blade likely acted in the same way, that is, protruded forward a little too much. In both cases there is too little room for the blade. The answer is to open the mouth a snitch with a file.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#7

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In my observation, there is some variability in the Stanley planes as to the mouth opening. I've got a No. 4 that has a mouth that, with a stock blade, has an extremely tight mouth; and other Stanley planes that accept aftermarket blades without fuss. Similarly, when I installed a Lee Valley spokeshave blade in a No. 52 spokeshave - normally a tool on which you can slip a Siamese cat through the mouth opening - I had to file the mouth some to get even a very tight opening.

Check everything out carefully, but then don't be afraid to file the mouth opening. It's a file/test/file/test business; don't get carried away.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#8

Re: File the mouth open

Jonathan Wagner

I was wondering if that was the issue after reading some more about other people with similar problems when upgrading to newer, thicker blades.

This may be a silly question, but it's the front side of the opening that should be filled, right?

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#9

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

Jonathan Wagner

Thanks for the reply. It sounds like a file is what is called for. I was/am just a little timid to go ahead with it without getting some input first. This is the plane I've had to do more than clean and sharpen and this one was very clean coming from Walt.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#10

Re: Mouth opening?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Jonathan and all,

You asked about mouth opening for a jointer....This goes to how people like to work, but for me a jointer is taking pretty fine shavings, whether face jointing or edge jointing. Let's broaden the definition, so that a No. 7 is either a jointer or a try plane. Either way, a fore plane or longish jack has already gone before to do the heavy work. IMO, 5 thousandths is a good shaving aperture for your plane.

Question: When you use the blade that Walt Q sent, and with the frog moved back, and with the cap iron up a little, say 1/8" back from the blade edge, can you slide a piece of Post-It note downward through the shaving aperture? If so, can you double a Post-It note and slide that through? A Post-It is about 4 thou thick.

Nothing against filing, but you can always file. You can't unfile. Right now, you have some other options, and you should know whether the plane works or not with stock parts in it. If you can't make it work with stock parts, make a call to Walt and have a discussion. He's knowledgeable and reputable and will make things right for you. Later, once you get the plane working as it was originally designed, you can decide whether you want to buy a 0.095" aftermarket iron and file the the mouth to suit. Or whether you want to buy a 5/64" Tsunesaburo blue steel #1 laminated iron, and use it with an unfiled mouth. For right now, get the plane right with correct original parts, and then go from there.

Wiley

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#11

Advice:  don't file yet (see earlier post)


Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#12

Re: Mouth opening?

Jonathan Wagner

The unfiling problem is what made me hesitate. To answer your question, a single post-it can fit (with some resistance), but a folded one will not. This is with the frog all the way back and the cap iron about 3/16ths back. Any closer and the top of the cap iron hits the front of the mouth before the iron protrudes from the mouth. I can actually get the cap iron closer to an 1/8th from the Hock iron, and get similar results. I think this is because of the slight convex shape of the Stanley iron. I should mention that the Stanley iron is a replacement iron which was noted by Walt when I bought it.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#13

Re: File the mouth open

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This may be a silly question, but it's the front side of the opening that should be filled, right?

Hi Jonathan

Not a silly question at all. The answer is "it depends".

One can file either end. If the sole of the plane at the front of the mouth is flat and clean, then I would first look to file the rear of the mouth since this will not prevent you returning the plane to use with an original blade. Filing the rear of the mouth depends on whether the frog can be pulled back enough and that any reinforcements there do no interfere with the path of the blade. Generally the back of the mouth is the section blocking the path of the blade, and if this is the case then you can file a little away here.

More commonly one file the front of the mouth since the sole is chipped or worn in that area. Score a fine line across the sole a fraction in front of the mouth and remove with a file file. Rather take off too little than too much. Watch how you angle the file. It must either be perfectly vertical or tipped slightly towards the rear of the sole (as if you were looking down at the sole facing up at you when clamped in a vice).

No doubt others here will chip in with their views.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#14

craigd

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

craigd

Nice plane, it looks to be in excellant shape.

It seems a little strange to me that a Stanley iron is too tight, as I haven't ever seen this (I have several that don't close up but not vice versa). Have you tried just sliding the iron along the frog without the breaker? Also, I'm seen the frog too far back such that the bevel rides the sole and is pushed forward.

The majority of my Stanley blades are banana shaped from trying to conform to the chip breaker, completely ignorable, the cap iron will press the blade flat enough against the frog.

I don't think sole flatness is an issue here.

Even though I've filed several mouths (and it is easy), but as others have said, I'd think three or four times before filing it, as I find it hard to imagine that a 100+ year old plane hasn't worked in all that time (even though the sole looks exceptional). I personally don't find much difference between 1/8" thick blades and stock (on Stanleys, I have a Sargent that did benefit), another reason to make stock work before "fixing" it with a thicker blade.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#15

Agree

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Craig said "...I'd think three or four times before filing it, as I find it hard to imagine that a 100+ year old plane hasn't worked in all that time..."

That's the problem I see, too. That plane looks to be in really nice shape, and you know it works with stock Stanley vintage parts, when set up correctly. The problem with filing before you get it working on a stock basis, is that there is something amiss in the setup. Filing now will mask the actual problem, while changing the integrity of the plane.

Craig's suggestion to take the blade and slide it down the frog (w/o the chipbreaker attached) is the way to go. Is the blade hitting and riding up on the sole? Set the frog so that its leading edge lines up vertically with the back edge of the mouth opening. Slide the blade down the frog and see whether the blade clears--how could it not? Now, which chipbreaker works best? When you get this question answered, you have defined the problem, and can decide whether to file and where, following Derek's advice.

I would still talk with Walt.

Wiley

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#16

I agree as well

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Craig's suggestion to take the blade and slide it down the frog (w/o the chipbreaker attached) is the way to go. Is the blade hitting and riding up on the sole? Set the frog so that its leading edge lines up vertically with the back edge of the mouth opening. Slide the blade down the frog and see whether the blade clears--how could it not? Now, which chipbreaker works best? When you get this question answered, you have defined the problem, and can decide whether to file and where, following Derek's advice.

I would still talk with Walt.

I agree that filing the mouth lies third in line. First check the frog, then speak with Walt.

The few bits of information offered indicate that the blade is to thick and that you will need to open the mouth. I suspect that the plane has not been used for a while, as a result of the bent blade. The bent blade effectively acts as a thicker blade - hence it would not work. I imagine someone must have replaced the blade with this one, found the plane could not work, but did not know enough to trouble-shoot, and put it aside.

Simple test: try another Stanley blade. If this fits, you have your answer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#17

missing data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We can take as a given that Stanley#7's work and that likely this one also worked at one time. So either it is set up wrong or there is a bastard part crept into the picture.

I measured the opening on my #7 and it is 0.152" (measured by sticking a number drill into it). Does yours match this value?

With the frog ramp aligned with the sole ramp and everything else adjusted typical there is ample clearance for shavings, but the remaining opening is smaller than on any of my other Stanley planes.

So, it would not take much equivalent thickening of the blade to close up this opening. A plane blade that bent away from the frog ramp could easily increase the apparent thickness of the blade to close the mouth on my plane. A blade that for any other reason that didn't sit flat on the frog ramp would also increase the apparent thickness. This is the place to look for a cause of the problem.

As far as not picking up a shaving I would suspect that the sole is not flat and that the mouth area is in a higher plane than the "heel and toe". Test with straightedge. If this is the case take it to a machine shop and have it surface ground flat again. It is a whole lot easier to make a sole worse doing it yourself than getting it flat. Several in the club confirmed this fact and provided the machine shop some welcome business during the recession. .

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#18

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

CStanford

There is virtually no way that the mouth of your plane is too narrow. Do not file it. The problem lies elsewhere.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#19

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue

CStanford

I have a Hock in a Record No. 7 (with a Clifton Stay-Set cap iron to boot) whose mouth is tighter than the one in your photos. There is puh-lenty of of room to pass even a thickish shaving.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#20

Chipbreaker Problem??

david charlesworth

This sounds like a chipbreaker issue to me. They were not all the same length and can get swapped around over time. (Length being distance from front edge to slot).

If a fine shaving can be taken with original blade, it should be possible to set c/b as close as you wish without causing shaving trap. (Close can be as close as 0.004"). If shaving trap exists it is the front edge of c/b which is the wrong shape, or possible front edge of throat.

A plane tuning article of mine can be found on the second page of www.rexmill.com

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#21

Send it back for a refund

Woodburnbob

You bought a plane from a dealer. It doesn't work. What keeps you from sending it back for a refund? One reason to buy from a dealer is the tool should work, unless you are told otherwise ahead of time. The other reason is to be able to expect a return/refund if you are dissatisfied. Surely you are dissatisfied.

Your #7 appears to have a Type 6A frog and a Type 5 bed, if it is a Stanley Bailey. Regardless, the limited mating surface between frog and bed makes the frog, and what ever is attached to it, act like a swimming pool diving board (chatter) because of the absence of a machined and fitted surface right at the back of the mouth. If you are a beginner, you definitely don't need the hassles, frustrations and disappointments of this type/model, and should get a type 10 or later. Better yet save your coin for a Bedrock.

If you can't even get the blade edge through the mouth to even experience that maddening diving board effect and chatter, something is very wrong.

Or, perhaps blade diving from an unsupported, flexible frog assembly is precisely what you are describing by saying the mouth/throat "choke" when you have the frog pushed back to the limit and the blade advanced to only take a very thin shaving.

I have "shimmed" this unsupported area below the front of this type frog with various materials in the past, and it can improve rigidity. But really, it is a bad design, which obviously caused Stanley to machine and fit the front of the frog to the body in later "types", if they wanted to sell more planes.

You can see that filing the mouth of your plane more open would not help.

Here's a the relevant page on type 6a from Walter's book (a wise $40 splurge when it first came out).


img

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#22

You were all right

Jonathan Wagner

So, thanks to all of you, I'm finally taking good shavings with the Stanley iron and a Hock chipbreaker/cap-iron.

Let's see if I can keep this straight. I had suspected something wrong with the way the iron mated with the frog, which lead to me figuring out that the iron was bent. I figured, no problem, I'll pick up a replacement on the way home from work on Friday. While I was at it, I went ahead and picked up a Hock chipbreaker as well. I knew the chipbreaker was thicker, but I didn't realize the Hock iron was thicker than the Stanley iron iron. Once I got home, I went ahead and swapped out the Stanley pair for the Hock pair and watched the cap iron run into the front of the mouth immediately.

After playing with the frog position and the chipbreaker position, I was finally able to get dust like shavings, but the mouth quickly clogged. Extending the iron enough to get an actual shaving barely let any light through when sighting down the cap iron towards the mouth. The Stanley combo was even worse still.

This morning, after several messages from Willey and Derek about the replacement iron being thicker than the original and the bent iron acting like a thicker iron itself, and suggestions to try another Stanley iron, I tried an experiment. This is the only #7 I have and the only other Stanley plane I have is a #4 with a narrower iron. Well, narrower should fit, right? And it does. It took some finagling to get the iron centered in the plane, but it worked. I was able to get decent shavings, though there wasn't any side to side support and the iron had a tendency to rock to one side and gouge the wood. The point was, though, the mouth opening and frog was fine. My iron/chipbreaker setup was what was amiss.

After reading a couple more posts from Derek and David about the chipbreaker being a potential problem and that the curve in the iron could be affected by it, I decided to try one more setup. I thought that the thicker Hock chipbreaker might be better at straightening the Stanley iron iron allowing clearance with the thinner Stanley blade. That was the ticket! It's still a pretty tight mouth, but I'm actually able to move the new chipbreaker to within a 1/16th of the cutting edge and take a decent shaving.

So, now I have an extra Hock iron in case I ever get a #4-1/2 or a #6 that needs one or I decide to file this one. Thanks for everyone's help. I probably would not have looked so closely at the chipbreaker without your advice.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#23

Chipbreaker solved it. See above. 


Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#24

Re: You were all right

david weaver

Filing may still be beneficial at some point if it's that tight.

There is virtually no virtue to a super tight mouth once you've learned to use the cap iron properly, and 1/16th from the edge will get you no benefit from it.

Use it as you wish for a while, but don't be afraid to file a hundredth or so out of the mouth at a time (I haven't viewed others' tutorials, but a metal scribe, marker and a good square will go miles toward making that a twaddle) and get yourself room to work.

In the balance of things, using the chipbreaker to control what's happening on the wood will be far more useful than having a restricted mouth size.

Re: Stanley no. 7 issue *LINK*

#25

Re: Send it back for a refund

Jonathan Wagner

Well, I just received it Thursday night and honestly I'm still new enough at this to not know what I don't know. You're right; I bought from a dealer so I could see what a clean example of the tool looked and worked like. Because I am so new to this, I figured it must be me, not the plane. Then, once I figured out that it was the plane (or rather the iron /chipbreaker combo), I decided to use it as a learning experience. Walt wouldn't be in until Monday anyway and I could call him if I needed to then. That was part of my aversion to filing the mouth. If I did have to ask for a return or refund, I wanted to be able to return it in the condition received.

I really can't complain about Walt though. The plane was well described and very clean and priced appropriately for the flaws he pointed out. If I do run into chatter because of the frog issue, then it's my fault for not doing enough research on the frog. He did mention that it was a type 7,which seems plausible from the page you posted.

Thanks for the advice and information,

Jonathan