Tony, have you tried a Krenov plane?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I was wondering what style or shape grip would suit you best, with your reduced hand strength.
Wooden planes have an advantage for you in that they are light and naturally slick on wood (although metal planes become slick if you squiggle wax on them).
A low centre of gravity plane should also be easier to push. For example, a low slung Krenov-styled smoother should be less effort to push than a high sided coffin smoother.
Combine this with a custom hand hold (Krenov was well known for doing this), which places the effort on the palm rather than the fingers.
For example, a while ago I built two smoothers, both bevel down with a 55 degree bed, and both with a 1 3/4" wide 3/8" thick blade. The Krenov used a double iron by Hock and the coffin used a single tapered iron. They are essentially the same length, around 7".
The coffin is pretty traditional (one piece construction) ..

You are used to using one of these. It is very similar to your Old Street.
The Krenov has a low slung hand hold ...

Here is a Jim Krenov-made Krenov. You can see how he shaped the body to fit his hand ...

When I use these two smoothers alongside one another, it is evident that the Krenov is the more comfortable ... for me. I do not assume that this preference will extend to others. It requires more pushing forward than pushing down. The coffin does require more concentration and effort to keep it flat.
Have you tried a Krenov smoother or trying plane in this style?
Regards from Perth
Derek