New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Moisture content from the lumber yard

Posts

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#26

US specification of hardwood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Every kiln I know of dries hardwood lumber to a final target of 7% which typically involves over drying and then steaming back to 7% to relieve stress.

Framing is purposely not dried to this low level. It becomes harder to nail when very dry.

Hardwood and construction lumber is manufactured to meet the needs of large customers. The markets are competitive and any company not satisfying the need and expectation of their high volume customers will soon be gone. This product may, or may not, meet the expectations of hobbyists, amateurs, specialty markets, etc.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#27

Nostalgia, IMHO


Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#28

Re: I don't understand the question

david weaver

I've never had anything side by side to compare, except maybe apple, but you never know what the base tree was for apple.

The apple that I air dried was so much nicer to work than KD apple that there wasn't any comparison.

It wasn't so much planing as it was how the air dried apple responded to tools like chisels, floats and rasps.

I would personally rather have lumber that wasn't dried so hard, if it was dried to 15% or so and allowed to go the rest of the way in my shop, I think it would work better. That's just supposition, though, I've never had anything other than some KD lumber that I suspect wasn't dried the whole way based on how it behaved and how it felt working it.

If I could afford it, I would pretty much exclusively work with air dried fruitwoods.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#29

It might be worth calling...

John in NM

I lumber yard I like down in Roswell. Some of the nicest dimension lumber I've ever used came from that yard, and the manager knows the business well and clearly cares about supplying the best products he can source at a reasonable price. Its a bit of a drive from your place, but not totally unreasonable.

There is a mill on the Mescalero Reservation that runs on and off, the pine coming from that mill would work well for your applications. When we were buying 2x10's for our floor framing I got a bunch that came from that mill and they were a joy to use. That yard manager in Roswell usually knows where each unit came from, and trying to find wood from some of the large desert pines might be well worth your time.

The stuff I'm thinking of tends to be softer and lighter than doug fir, white fir, or the spruce that you find in the big box stores. It's got less load bearing capacity than those woods (but that won't matter for your models), but grain tends to be straight and the knots are large and scattered, having come from big trees. Another big advantage, at least right now, is those poor trees are about as dry as can be and still live :(

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#30

Re: additionally.....

Tom

"Studies at VA Tech have shown that this hysteresis also occurs for KD wood. Wood dried below its equilibrium moisture content will not regain to the original value, which, is one reason why KD wood is more stable."

I'm not too sure what that means. Any wood dried below ambient, and allowed to sit in ambient, will not regain it original wet. It may well be that it will not return to ambient even. Since there is often some efficiency loss in processes. It certainly will return above the pre dry level if you toss it in the lake.

As one paper on hysteresis mentioned, "finishing treatments can reduce strongly the accessibility to the material, and thus the moisture buffering capability of wood". In other words, who cares. In the real world finish trumps the wood, and the effects of different processes on hysteresis are marginal at best. Which is not to say that the effects don't exist. My point is I don't trust these studies because they are meaningful in context and nonsense outside of it. When it comes to tossing wood in the water, epoxy is a really good idea, when it comes to say guitars where the concept is an unfinished interior is better than a finished one, you better practice environmental moisture control.

"Modern kilns in the US always over dry wood and then steam back to a 7% target to relax stress."

That sounds painful...

" In my years of experience selling, lumber dried this way doesn't regain above 10% under typical E. TN conditions in an outdoor shed. The other reason KD wood may be more stable is that often air dried wood has not been dried to its equilibrium moisture content of living conditions to begin with."

Why not? air drying does not mean stacked in flitches out of doors, in means air dried. I have places that probably hit 140. And if I bring the stock into the house it will pop back up to the prevailing conditions.

One of the problems with the science types on this board is you don't have a process in either kiln or air drying that is in any way defined. Or a post drying condition, or use. So why even talk about? It is 100% nonsense.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#31

Re: Unnecessary fretting- unless you are a hack

Tom

Thanks for that SD.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#32

Roswell?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

He probably uses advanced alien technology to season the wood. No wonder it's so good.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#33

If so...

John in NM

They are way more subtle than the Walmart down there...


Whatever it takes to fleece the tourists I guess :D

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#34

Re: The real reason....

Sgian Dubh

"What drying defects are you seeing? I can't think of any defect that will be caused by drying the extra few per cent."

Bill, I've concluded that there is a slight tendency to see a little more stress in wood kilned in North America than I find in wood kilned in Europe. As I said in my earlier post on the topic, my observations are anecdotal. I haven't made an empirical study. I have formed the impression that the most likely cause of the stress is a stress relieving cycle in the kiln that hasn't gone quite as it should have done.

As I said before, generally speaking the end product from North American kiln drying operations is pretty reliable in my experience, and I really have no significant complaints. Slainte.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#35

Stress relief

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The stress you encounter is little to do with drying to a lower MC. It will have more to do with the air drying or predryer conditions, and the kiln drying rate (which in turn is depending on air circulation, pack configuration in the kiln and drying schedule), or species growing conditions, and additionally will depend on post drying conditioning schedule. At the kilns I am familiar with post conditioning is a day long operation. Does this time differ in England?

I have gotten the impression that the export market is more picky than the domestic market. I would select export packs for our inventory when I was able to, convinced that they were graded more stringently and maybe overall manufactured better.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#36

You are correct

Bob Hackett

I can tell you from personal experience that the planks we cut for wooden boat repair using reclaimed beams as a source of material caused both the beams and the planks to move enough to be noticeable as we worked them. These beams came from old mills and warehouses well south of us and a few of them had more than a century of drying time indoors.

BTW- The beams still smelled strongly like turpentine as we opened them up after more than 100 years. Up here the wood is called "Yellow pine, Hard pine, or Heart pine" by the folks in the boatyards.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#37

Re: Stress relief

Sgian Dubh

Bill, as far as I am aware the methods used for drying in a kiln along with stress relief procedures and any post drying conditioning follow broadly similar stages in Europe and North America. There are no doubt variations between the two areas based upon such factors as wood species and schedules used for those species, the target final moisture content, the size of the wood processing operation along with the commensurate capacity and throughput of the kilns, and so on.

As to whether or not better grade wood is exported from North America to Europe than is retained for domestic consumption, I suspect that's unlikely. The reason I say that is because when I buy North American wood here, certainly at my main supplier, it's sold using the American appearance grading system, eg, FAS and F1F. I never see any North American wood on offer at a lower grade, eg, Selects, No.1Common, etc. I wouldn't say that makes us more "picky", but perhaps the North American exporters have chosen to not export the lower grades, or they know they can't sell the lower grades over here due to the 'pickiness' of us European buyers. Slainte.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#38

Thank you to all who posted!!!

Dave (Arlington, VA)

I appreciated the time each of you took to address my question. I think your posts - in aggregate - have alleviated my concern about the time I might need for any wood I might buy from the lumber yard to fully adjust to the moisture content of my workshop and home (since my workshop is in my basement). I was worried that I'd buy this wood bring it home, start working only to see it warp, cup, twist or whatever. Sounds like I should lay my worries aside and just get started. The key is just to make sure that the wood is kiln dried and has been properly stored out of the elements. I plan to take a trip out to the lumber yard later this week.

For those of you who wondered about the nature of the project, this project would be classified as cabinetry and not carpentry as it involves making something for one of our bathrooms. Though I haven't made a final decision, I think it is likely that I will be looking to use hard maple. I had told my wife - now apparently in error - that I would any wood I purchased for this project would need to acclimate for some time in my workshop and as a result she wanted to look for other ways to fulfill this need. This information may cause her to change her mind.

So, again, I am grateful for all the advice and insights into procuring wood for projects.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#39

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thanks, Wiley. I don't know if you know our area or not, but I saw your mention of Vienna Hardwoods. It made me wonder if you'd done an internet search or if somehow you knew this place. I've been to Vienna Hardwoods and have gotten some wood there in the past, but I found it somewhat difficult to cull through their collection to pick the right pieces. As a result, I am thinking of trying a lumber yard I have not been to before out in Manassas, Virginia.

Dave

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#40

Nah, I was faking it

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Dave,

The tiny point I was trying to make was that I didn't think there was a bargain lumberyard to go to, to get that low MC you needed. The only option (unless you're linked into lumber like Bill T) is to go to a specialty hardwood retail place--I found Vienna Hardwood in Woodfinder, and it looked like the right type of place.

The only VA wood seller I've had deaiings with is Barbara Gill, who was logging her own property in Middlesex Co., but I don't think she is selling lumber any more, from the looks of her website. Real good person though, might be worth a call sometime.

Wiley