New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Moisture content from the lumber yard

Posts

Moisture content from the lumber yard

#1

Moisture content from the lumber yard

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi All -

Do lumber yards ever sell wood that has been dried to 6-8 percent moisture content so you could take the wood home and pretty much start working it without waiting much for it to dry any further before working?

I am interested in building something but the desired due date is "yesterday." Some of this wood would need to be 8/4 or perhaps a smidgen more. If I can't figure out a reasonable way to get started on this project without having to wait weeks or months for the wood to acclimate to the indoors before working, we may be forced to look for other "solutions" to our problem.

I lack enough experience around lumber yards to know if its even feasible to try to search for such a situation. Can anyone tell me, is this a pipe dream or should I start searching?

Thank you -

Impatient Dave

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#2

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Keep in mind that the moisture content of lumber that's been sitting anywhere for long will be affected by the ambient humidity. If things are still dry around there, that's one thing; but if you're into the summer humidity, you might have trouble finding lumber that dry.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#3

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

John in NM

If it is kiln dried, it should be or have been at one time, down to 8% or so. The equilibrium MC will vary with the climate, so even kiln dried wood can at times meter over 10%.

I don't worry about it much, but then I also live in a dry climate, which helps a lot. To some degree, I just accept the inevitable changes of wood with climate as the nature of the material. While I wouldn't build with 30% MC wood and expect reasonable results, I also don't expect doors to always stay perfectly flat.

The most stable woods I've ever used had been air dried for years. I suspect the stability came from the "years" more than the "air dried". The practice of letting wood acclimate to your shop strikes me as naive, unless you're willing to park it for a decade or so. Over the time frame of years it seems to make a difference, but not over the time frame of weeks or months.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#4

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Dave,

Finding bargain wood of that MC would be tough. Like going to an outdoor yard looking to high-grade their stacks.

On the other hand, if you go to a local hardwood place there in the greater MD/DC/No. VA area(maybe Vienna Hardwood?), you could use their lumber pretty much as-is. That's assuming your home climate is a lot like their indoor climate.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#5

that all depends on

Bruce, a MN Galoot

what are you making?

If you're talking dimension lumber for a carpentry project, I wouldn't worry about it. You'll rarely see a carpenter waiting for that equilibrium point before starting work on a project. One caveat here is for pressure-treated lumber. That stuff can be literally dripping when you get it. I made a huge mistake by using PT lumber for support beams for an addition to my house. Those 2X12's shrank more than 1/2" and now I have problems. I should have looked for drier stock.

However, if you're talking furniture grade wood, then I'd recommend getting yourself a moisture meter to see what you're working with.

I get my hardwood from two sources, neither of which is a local lumber yard. One is a local sawmill, whose owner/operator claims he dries wood to 8%, but when I ask him about his conditioning protocol (as Bill T describes), he looks at me like I'm speaking Swahili. His wood is cheap, but I always let it sit for a long time before using it because it moves like crazy. The other is a very large, reputable wholesaler an hour away whose wood sits in covered buildings but open to the outside. That wood is always stable, and I use it immediately.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#6

Or are we talking construction lumber?


Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#7

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We sold thousands of bdft of lumber from our inventory that went straight into cabinetry. It is common practice. Ditto for every other yard that I know of. If you are buying from a reliable supplier there is nothing to worry about. Buy it an use it.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#8

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

Tom

Well of course that is a special case. If the mill that Bill often refers to has dried it correctly in the first place, and then it goes immediately to a climate controlled shop (or some natural climates, like where I live, are pretty forgiving), then that is a perfect situation, but there isn't a lumber yard in that situation.

But that mill could send out it's truck to a half dozen retailers, and shops, and the wood would normalize to all those local conditions, and within a short period of time be in vastly different conditions.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#9

Re: Testing

Tom

There are many things you can do to get a sense of the wood you are using and testing is always the best way to find things out. Often one can tell while handling the wood. One saws a pieces in half and touches the surface, it is warm and dry from the saw, but a few moments later when one touches it it is cold and while not obviously wet one gets the feeling it might be. Or sometimes the sawing will create and aroma, as it heats up the wood, this is usually a sight of even more moisture than the first case.

Wood can seem unusually heavy. One can also do tests like cut a small block, put it in the oven and compare before and after weights. Or take a piece and put it in the microwave and see if moisture bubbles out.

One can glue an end cut to a thin piece of ply, then put it in the oven or some hot place and see how badly it curves.

I live right on the great lakes, and have pretty much learned to ignore conventional wisdom about wood. This is a really forgiving climate. For the most part I don't have trouble with my wood. But I am also reasonably slow getting my wood to it's final use. I have a lot of it, and I almost always bring wood into the house to take on the conditions it will live in, as part of the process.

Certain cuts of wood and dimensions will give greater difficulty. So in some situations it is possible to work with even wet wood, and to get away with it, while in some other situations minor changes as the task proceeds will have big effects.

There is also the question of where the final project will live. Sending stuff from the desert to the pacific northwest is always questionable. But the same could happen with a damp outdoor shop, with the furniture going to a hot room under the roof of the house.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#10

Unnecessary fretting- lumber acclimation facts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was late, well after Chicago won the cup (for the hockey crazed), and I was more interested in sleep than an in depth answer. Here are more details. The following is based on many years experience selling hardwood lumber and hanging around places that manufacture , distribute it and use it. To save critics the trouble of pointing out the obvious there could always be an exception to this generally true situation. Don't buy lumber from these exceptions.

Summary- Buy KD lumber. Use it as soon as you wish to.

Facts:

1. KD lumber is more stable than air dried lumber. It may be that fretting over acclimation among hobbyists stems from their use of lumber they have dried, more or less.

2. The product of mills with 1,000,000 bdft kiln capacity is not mostly bought by your local Woodcraft stores. Lumber is manufactured to meet the needs of large customers. If they can use the typically manufactured product, to make furniture for example, you can too.

PIC

3. After drying, lumber inventory is commonly stored in open sheds, protected from rain but not ambient air conditions. Shown is an example of such a shed. (there is another in my Article on hardwood lumber production in the Articles section) It is normal for lumber to be sold, shipped and used without any additional treatment from such storage. For example, our typical small shop customers would typically begin working lumber they day we delivered it.

4. Experienced users of hardwood lumber expect that the wood may change moisture conditions a small amount during working of the lumber and/or after it is made into something. They build and store parts and finished product to account for this fact.

Where you may get into trouble:

Once a furniture part is made store in a way that does not cause one surface to gain or loose moisture more or less than others. Don't expose parts or product to sudden large changes in temperature or humidity.

Story: I was finishing a walnut top outside one sunny summer day. After spraying it I left it in the sun to dry. It split on one edge. The surface was almost to hot to touch. Black walnut gets very hot in direct summer sunlight and therefore changes moisture content quickly.

I will be delivering a chest of drawers over the 4th. It will not loaded into the van until I am ready to roll, and it will not be left in the van to bake in route. Upon arrival it will go indoors immediately. All prudent precautions.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#11

Helpful tip for parts storage

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Thin polymer films are typically the equivalent of a screen door to the passage of small molecules like water vapor. However, the stuff that plastic film (HandiWrap and the like) is made from is a good barrier. If I have small parts, a home made veneer flitch for example, that I need to store and keep from gaining or loosing moisture, I wrap it in this plastic film. Works good for door parts too.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#12

Conclusion : . . .

steve mackay

I came to the conclusion a few years ago that, now days, 90% of the lumber available to the common human was A TREE YESTERDAY. Drying time ? ON THE TRUCK from the mill to the store. If the truck drove south through Arizona and Nevada (to El Paso) it is only "damp". If the truck drove east it probably needs a wringer.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#13

Re: Unnecessary fretting- unless you are a hack

Tom

That's what I am talking about exactly, straight from the kiln to the assembly line. If everyone know what they are doing, should work out fine.

I don't know of any scientific evidence that I would trust that says that kiln dried wood is more stable. Though since it fixes the lignin it might be the case in some cases, it sure messes with bending. I don't know of any evidence that old wood is more stable either though there is plenty of experience that claims the fact, and that can't be countered scientifically since the cost of investigation would not tend to make the endeavour profitable.

But there is no one answer. Musical instrument makers, normally have moisture controlled rooms or boxes where they store instruments during manufacture. This applies to home builders or the largest makers. Even despite considerable efforts to engineer these problems away, these products require this care for the life of the product. And the same issues are probably there for piston fit drawers.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#14

Re: Conclusion : . . .

Tom

Certainly the structural stuff which is serious stuff, it's graded for one thing, it may have been kiln dried, probably saves them money on shipping, but what happens to it afterwords who knows. You can see the stuff sitting outside the door in banded lifts, getting rained or snowed on.

I would be curious in a poll how many of you actually use lumber you just bought in fine woodwork. I have stuff sitting around for decades. I have been refusing to buy any lumber for 20 years, but some creeps in (like my beech), and other stuff finds it's way in. People are always trimming trees and stuff. A current job is to haul some of this off to the dump.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#15

Data to support your conclusion?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I live in the midst of the main hardwood lumber production area of the world. I recently posted about a field trip to a 125,000 bd ft per day production facility and in the Articles is another discussion of hardwood lumber production at a different 125,000 bd ft capacity facility. Shown in the recent post is the 1,000,000 bd ft kiln capacity at the site.

Having been associated with hardwood production since the 1970's, from my perspective the drying of lumber is better controlled than it has ever been before (probably in response to the more stringent demands of the export market), resulting in a better product with fewer drying defects and better visual appeal.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#16

Re: Unnecessary fretting- unless you are a hack

Sgian Dubh

"I don't know of any evidence that old wood is more stable either though there is plenty of experience that claims the fact, and that can't be countered scientifically since the cost of investigation would not tend to make the endeavour profitable.

There is Tom. Here's a link to an abstract of one study on the subject: http://www.afs-journal.org/index.php?option=com_article&access=doi&doi=10.1051/forest:2005020&Itemid=129

I have developed a text from that and other research I've undertaken that reads in slightly paraphrased form as follows:

"There is a long held belief amongst woodworkers that timber salvaged from old buildings and furniture is more stable than newly felled and seasoned wood. The argument frequently put forward is that the wood has been around for centuries and therefore it must have done all the conditioning and acclimatising that it’s possible to do. Whilst the reasoning is not fully correct there is some truth in the belief that old wood is often more stable than new wood. Research into this phenomenon is limited, an example is the paper by Esteban et al (2004, pp 275 -- 284) in which they describe experiments undertaken to better understand it. The authors discuss the changes that take place within wood as it undergoes cycles of gaining and losing moisture. They describe changes in wood’s microstructure, essentially chemical in nature leading to “hygroscopic and dimensional ageing of wood ... [resulting in a] loss of response of wood in relation to hygrothermal changes” (p 276). In other words, old dry wood that has been through many seasonal cycles of adsorbing and desorbing moisture becomes less hygroscopic with time, and less responsive to variations in temperature and relative humidity. In certain circumstances old wood is likely to be very slightly more stable than freshly felled and properly seasoned material because of this hysteresis loop." Slainte.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#17

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

Sgian Dubh

"Do lumber yards ever sell wood that has been dried to 6-8 percent moisture content so you could take the wood home and pretty much start working it without waiting much for it to dry any further before working?"

Dave, I think you are worrying somewhat needlessly. If the wood has been kiln dried in North America it will have been dried to a target MC of about 7%. I buy a lot of North American kiln dried wood from our local timber yard (aka lumber yard in North America). It's travelled four to five thousand miles to get to the UK, and it's been close stacked and wrapped in plastic all the way, and remains close stacked in sheds for me to buy that experience typical cool and damp United Kingdom climate conditions. Close or dead stacking helps delay moisture uptake significantly.

I buy it. chuck it in the van, get it in the workshop and just get on with making furniture. American cherry, American walnut, hard maple, American white oak, etc, all just get hacked up and turned into bits of furniture immediately. I don't bother with letting the wood acclimatise to my workshop conditions, which are not, by the way, the same as the conditions found inside habitable buildings.

I swear, if I can do it, with accepted necessary allowances made for some dimensional changes in the wood in service here in the UK, you ought to be able to do so too in North America, which I strongly suspect happens to be the same continent that your kiln dried wood comes from! Slainte.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#18

Re: Data to support your conclusion?

Sgian Dubh

"the drying of lumber is better controlled than it has ever been before (probably in response to the more stringent demands of the export market), resulting in a better product with fewer drying defects and better visual appeal."

The quality control is generally very good Bill, I must agree. However, as a slight negative, I do seem (anecdotally) to find a slightly greater proportion of drying faults in kiln dried North American woods than I do in kiln dried European timbers.

I've reached the conclusion that the reason for this is the lower target MC for North American kiln operators compared to European practice. Here in the UK for example the target kilned MC is 11% ±2% which seems to lead to less stress on the wood in that 4% zone between 11% MC and 7% MC.

As I said, my observations should be taken as anecdotal, and I have to say that the overwhelming majority all the North American sourced wood we buy is in good shape when we get it. Slainte.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#19

additionally.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Studies at VA Tech have shown that this hysteresis also occurs for KD wood. Wood dried below its equilibrium moisture content will not regain to the original value, which, is one reason why KD wood is more stable. Modern kilns in the US always over dry wood and then steam back to a 7% target to relax stress. In my years of experience selling, lumber dried this way doesn't regain above 10% under typical E. TN conditions in an outdoor shed. The other reason KD wood may be more stable is that often air dried wood has not been dried to its equilibrium moisture content of living conditions to begin with.

The bottom line of it all is that KD wood may change moisture content a small amount once brought into a typical shop. One could let the wood sit for days to achieve equilibrium. However, most experienced woodworkers anticipate small changes and deal with them during construction by properly storing prepared parts and in fitting to current conditions.

Who ever invented "piston fit drawers" likely didn't anticipate selling stuff with such drawers. An experienced woodworker will fit loose in the winter and tight in the summer, anticipating seasonal movement.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#20

The real reason....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What you get will include the poorest lumber the bulk importer will tolerate buying. Any sort of defects will be included up to the tolerated amount. And occasionally there are grading screw ups and your supplier may be inclined to stick some customers with them.

As an example, the edger at Bailey is computer controlled. If they are sawing for NHLA grading the edger is programmed for the NHLA tolerance of wane in a piece. It will purposely leave this amount of wane when a piece is trimmed. Every piece that is trimmed will have this minimum value, where as with manual edging most pieces will be less to none.

What drying defects are you seeing? I can't think of any defect that will be caused by drying the extra few per cent. Residual stress is related to the growth conditions of the tree, or failure to relax stress after drying and will have something to do with rate but not final value. Shrinkage defects mainly occur in the predrier at around 20% MC when the lumber first experiences shrinkage. Ditto case hardening.

My guess is that your tiny kilns simply are able to have more control over the overall drying conditions- uniformity of air flow, uniformity of original MC, heating rate, etc. and if you predry outdoors your summer temperatures are not 90 degrees F, not favorable for oak. Additionally, your local grading standards may be more stringent. The defects you see in US wood may be put in a lower grade which you don't buy.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#21

Handtools

Kees

But, wasn't air dried easier for handtools, especially planes?

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#22

Re: additionally.....

Patrick Gibbons

Salvaged old-growth long leaf pine beams that may be over 100 years old will still move after they are recut. I have no experience with this but have read this as a caution on web sites of a few suppliers.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#24

Demensional SYP kd'ed to 19%

Patrick Gibbons

Not the 10% of cabinet woods. There is no comparison.

Re: Moisture content from the lumber yard

#25

Re: I don't understand the question

Kees

You always hear that airdried wood is somehow softer and easier to plane. Killn dried wood always has some degree of case hardening, making it harder to plane. But I don't know if it is just nostalgia, or if it is a real phenomen.

I just use the wood crossing my path. So I have no clear idea which ones were airdried or killn dried.