New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

How does Rockler stay in business?

Posts

How does Rockler stay in business?

#1

Michael Donaldson

How does Rockler stay in business?

Michael Donaldson

Having just finished a small chest (it's really ugly, but I'll post build pictures soon), I went on the hunt for some more wood, hoping that the right piece of wood would tell me what my next project will be. Rockler Woodworking and Hardware is the closest store to me, so I went there. First, I don't like the store too much because they are exclusively power tools, but regardless, the prices were outrageous! One quart of shellac was $21.99, that same quart was $11 at Woodcraft. I was also looking for some wood dye, they had it for $19.99, The exact same dye at Woodcraft was $11.49. Then in the wood room, they were having a clearance event, and had ambrosia maple for 50% off, bringing the price down to $4 per board foot. I left and made the 40 minute drive to Woodcraft, where the ambrosia maple is regularly priced at $3.50 per board foot.

So with everything I looked at, Rockler prices are about DOUBLE Woodcraft prices. How on earth to they stay in business? I've learned my lesson, I will never waste my time there again.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#2

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Mike, I know what you mean, but I've learned to shop both places. Woodcraft has better selection of hand tools, not to mention better prices on those. Rockler makes its living selling stuff that Woodcraft just doesn't seem to carry. It has, e.g., a much better selection of hardware, etc. Rockler is also a fairly big sponsor of WC, so that buys some loyalty from me.

I don't buy wood at either place. Instead, I go to Youngblood Lumber on Central Ave in Mpls, which is only a few blocks from the place that hosted the Lie-Nielsen tool event that we went to last winter. The prices are much better, but they don't typically sell in small quantities. At least I've never gotten a part of a board there - I just get the whole thing with complete confidence that it will get used at some point. That way you also get to develop a little inventory. They will also let you wander around and pick through piles, which is a great deal of fun. Youngblood has a great selection.

For a different selection of tools and stuff, you also need to get acquainted with Seven Corners Hardware in downtown St. Paul. It's a great place just to wander around. They're more oriented toward power tools, though. I took Bill Tindall there a few years back.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

apples and oranges

Jack Guzman from Maine

Michael,

In my experience Rockler and Woodcraft supply different users. Rockler is more hobby oriented. When I want hardware or finishing supplies I go to Rockler. Woodcraft is a better place to look for tools. My local Woodcraft has alot of Veritas stuff and they also carry a good selection of chair building tools.---Jack

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#4

Re: apples and oranges

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I used to make a regular stop at our local Woodcraft store. I get more and more dissapointed with the offerings there. They used to support well known ( American) manufacturers and stock the tools they made. It seems that their Woodriver brand has reverse engineered every decent tool and is now made in China. Maybe decent stuff with good QC but why rip off the companies that pioneered the market? I had no problem paying the going rate for the Home Teams offerings. I have to admit I see Woodcrafts being complicit in seeking out the copycat items. " Here is a nice tool...how much will it cost for you to build it for us??" At least that is what I suspect.

JR

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#5

"Big Box" . . .

steve mackay

I tried dealing with Rockler by catalogue and on-line. They have that "Big Box" attitude. They do such volume that they really don't care if they get YOUR money or not. The three times (I like to make sure before I condem) I tried them, EVERY SINGLE ITEM was back ordered, unavailable or "on order" from a supplier. My only conclusion was that Rockler actually has nothing "on-hand" or ready to go in-house. They receive YOUR order then THEY order from a supplier. Many of my items were the incorrect ones. Leading me toi the conclusuion their communication skills (with their suppliers) are REALLY lacking. And forget about calling Rockler about your order or customer service. The small child at the other end has NO interest (or knowledge) in woodworking, tools or your plight.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#6

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

Mark Nowicki

Rockler, and most companies, stay in business by making a profit.

I tried to check your claim of Rockler prices being DOUBLE that of Woodcraft and was not able to do so.

For example: General Finish Java gel stain 1/2 pint $8.99 vs $8.49.

From a quick glance at both websites similar products appear to have similar prices.

Can you replace a rant with a specific example, please?

Mark

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#7

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

Tom

He did give specific examples. Aren't some of these stores owner operated? If so they may just be making some of the prices up to suit their specific situation.

If a company goes out of business and it's prices were too high that may tell you something. If they stay in business with high prices the message is different entirely.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#8

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

Mark Nowicki

By specific I meant the actual brands and quantities so I can check the veracity of the facts. A link would be fine

I checked the price both of shellac and dye and found them to be $15.99 vs. $15.99, and $19.99 vs. $20.99, respectively.

In this situation, I would be surprised is the Woodcraft store remained in business.

Mark

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#9

Michael Donaldson

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

Michael Donaldson

I thought I was being specific. But here is the list of what I was looking for yesterday:

Zinsser Bulls eye Shellac, clear, 1 qt. $21.99 at Rockler, $11.99 at Woodcraft

Transfast Powdered wood dye, 1oz. $19.99 at Rockler, $11.49 at Woodcraft

Ambrosia Maple, 4/4, rough cut. $8.00/BF at Rockler (on clearance for $4.00/BF), $3.50/BF regular price at Woodcraft.

I don't know if the catalog prices for each are different, this is just what they were priced at in the stores I went to. I am willing to spend a little extra to support a specialty store (This is why I don't buy from big box stores), but the differences in price on the items I was looking for were simply too big.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#10

I've had good service from Rockler

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

All online. Tormek accessories and denatured alcohol (the 95% ethanol kind) and hinges come to mind.

I checked online to see what Woodcraft and Rockler were charging for a quart of Zinsser Bullseye shellac. Each were advertising it for $15.99. I suppose the local walk-in stores set their own prices.

Looks like you got a good deal from your local Woodcraft!

Wiley

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#11

Michael Donaldson

Woodriver Planes *LINK*

Michael Donaldson

There was a falling out between Tom Lie-Nielsen and Woodcraft over how his tools would be sold. Tom wanted the tools out where they could be handled and experienced, Woodcraft wanted to keep them in a locked case to protect their inventory. I fully understand both of their points, and am not taking sides on this one. In the end, Lie-Nielsen stopped selling through Woodcraft (with the exception of one or two independent Woodcraft stores), and Woodcraft tried to find a way to sell bedrock style planes in their stores, and thus began the Woodriver planes. I have two Woodriver planes, and seven Lie-Nielsen planes (the rest are a mix of vintage Stanley, Veritas, and really old woodies) they both work well and are well made, but I like the LN better. My 10 year old daughter uses the Woodriver planes, which is great because she can still use a quality tool, but if it hits the garage floor, nobody is going to cry.


http://www.finewoodworking.com/item/22352/lie-nielsen-toolworks-and-woodcraft-part-ways

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#12

Michael Donaldson

It seems this is a local problem

Michael Donaldson

After reading all the responses and checking online, it seems like the massive disparity in pricing is, in fact, a local phenomenon for me. I'm guessing that local stores set their own pricing, and set them to where it works for them. The Rockler is moving into a larger store front next month, so they are obviously doing well. The Woodcraft was very busy when I was there, and there was a line at the checkout, so they must be doing well, too. I'm grateful to have two woodworking stores so close. Thanks for all the feedback.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#13

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

Mark Nowicki

Thank you.

Rockler website shows the dye at $12.29. The shellac could have been old stock, apparently there is, or was, a large increase. The current Woodcraft web price is $15.99.

Ultimately, how and where we spend our money is our business.

Mark

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#14

Re: Woodriver Planes

Tom

LV is about 10 minutes from me, and I can't tell you how often I go in there and some tool or book has gone walkies off the floor. And they are good about keeping the store stocked up. And as nice as mostly middle aged middle income patrons seem to be... So I am with woodcraft on this...

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#15

Your description is but part of the story

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Lots of things changed with LN marketing in addition to their arrangement with Woodcraft. On a personal note my business was cut off from wholesale purchase. I believe the real story behind all that happened was that LN chose a new marketing strategy that left them selling more product retail and less wholesale. Instead of getting 50% of a plane purchase they get 100%, at the expense of more marketing cost.

As far as company XX copying company YY it is well to remember that LN copies more or less Stanley products. Copying is an accepted business practice and should not be condemned. The patent system was developed to temporarily discourage copying and spur innovation, while not depriving the public right to an innovation forever.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#16

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

david weaver

Your woodcraft is a lot more reasonable than mine. Rockler is close to me here, woodcraft used to be. Rockler has changed enough in the last 6 years such that if you don't want festool or wood screws, there's not much reason to go there. Everything else is FAR too expensive, even with a coupon.

Woodcraft was always expensive. I still see a lot of things in the woodcraft catalog that make me wonder who buys them. Things like DMT items that are above what amazon says the retail is. I just don't get it.

I've never had bad service from woodcraft, but the stuff there is so expensive that I've really not had much to have service from them, and like a lot of other places, our retail store disappeared.

But in terms of rockler, what keeps them in business, I'd suspect, is a dose of festool at local stores, overpriced lumber, and a lot of people who go to the store once or twice a year and don't mind buying a few pieces of aluminum and plastic manufactured overseas for cheap and sold here as a "got to have it" for a pretty high price.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#17

Re: I think LN....

david weaver

...tells that story in a way that is flattering to them.

I remember back then being in contact with folks at woodcraft from time to time, and remember them saying they'd like to get guaranteed stock from LN and they couldn't get it.

I also don't think it was necessarily all about service from LN, I think a lot of it had to do with their frustration of not being able to generate business from their website. Well, no kidding, you could pretty much universally get 10% off from several retailers and free shipping.

Once they banned selling below retail, then all of the sudden it's better to go to their retail site, and though I have no clue what the difference between wholesale and retail was, it was probably around 30% because I never saw a woodcraft employee jump at 20% off back then when WC had those sales at the end of the argument.

At any rate, there may have been some of WC having a desire about how their tools are presented, and there may have also been some "hey, thanks for putting our stuff in different markets brick and mortar when we didn't have the means to, but now we want to sell the planes ourselves and keep the $$$, so take a hike".

Just my opinion.

I don't carry water for LN or WC, but the no discount policy effectively ended my purchasing of LN tools, not because I can't afford the extra $$, but because of the message it sends to the customer. (from the company to the customer) "no thanks pal, we'll tell you how you buy, your discretion has been revoked".

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#18

Re:Discounts

Tom

I like to pay as little as I can but discounts aren't really an advantage unless they are so common they are a floor price. If they are an on again off again thing, then they just muddy the waters. The discount price becomes the real price in customer's minds, and the company is only in business a few days of the year. I think LV has it right, at least as far as how it works around here. US distribution I am not familiar with.

I am also a little at a loss as to why people who want cheap planes don't just make them. I get that some people feel all the bells and whistles are added value, but then why not pay for then. A caddy isn't as good if it costs as little as a Corolla. Isn't that how that works?

If you just want to remove wood cheaply make a wooden plane, it is faster, cheaper, and works at least as well. Then in addition you can convince yourself it is better because you made it to boot. Which is true up to a point. It doesn't mater how good any of these people are at designing planes, and in general I would say not very good. But they don't know how I want mine. That is a large part of the reason I am in this game in the first place. I can make what I want.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#19

Re:Discounts

david weaver

Yeah, I do make them, too.

You hit it precisely on the head, though, for anyone with sense, the price for a LN tool had become 10 percent off or so and free shipping. By their changes, they raised my price by 10 percent with an "our way or the highway" type policy.

So I chose the highway. I still have some LN tools, the ones I like the most. I probably wouldn't buy them again on a second go around because there's nothing really necessary about any of them.

I don't know, maybe it's like being told what to do that I don't like, or maybe it's the issue of there being expectations and they change for the negative. If they'd have only ever been available direct (effectively for us in the US) like the LV tools, maybe I'd have little thought about it. I'd, for sure, have fewer of their tools, though, too.

I don't order so much from LV anymore, either, but that's mostly due to already having what I want from them.

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#20

I never mentioned L N in my post

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

And I have to admit hand planes were part of my thoughts but in truth there are many many Woodriver tools that are direct copy's of other offerings beside hand planes.

Joe

Re: How does Rockler stay in business?

#21

Re: I never mentioned L N in my post

david weaver

You're right, it's not just LN planes. It's all kinds of stuff, like the "deluxe scraper" set and other odds and ends. I thought at one point they sold the glenn drake hammer, and then sold a knock-off version of it not long after.

You can go out to alibaba and find a lot of what woodcraft sells.

That said, they do at least carry some respectable carving tools and other hand tool things. Rockler doesn't really carry much other than the flavor of the day mediocre chisel and maybe some bulky two cherries carving tools for really high prices.

It's just the direction all of the ww retailers have gone. They're catalogs with a few quality items and a lot of stuff that looks like it was shopped off of ali baba (which is always going to include copies or near copied things).

Still, I believe that if LN issue was more about control and supply, and WC would still be selling LN planes if LN let them.