We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
So, we just bought a house and we close on July 31st. I had absolutely no say in the house that we bought, but my wife was kind enough to consider a space for the shop. The house has a three car garage, and the third stall has already been finished as a shop. Currently, there is just the cement foundation for a floor, and the garage door is not insulated, but I will be insulating it before winter returns to Minnesota (which I think happens next week or something). I really wanted to put an oak floor in because dropped handplanes and cement floors make tears, but I fear there may be too much moisture in there for wood. What are my options? Could I use Ipe Decking? For those of you with garage-based shops, what do you use?
Mike: I have a cement pad in my shop and it works well, no complaints from me. Used to have a 7' piece of carpet in front of my work bench, more comfortable. My family got me some sort of black pads that interlock with dovetail joint, better than the carpet, easier to clean too.
Myself, I would not go the the trouble about decking the floor with anything, wear comfortable shoes if you like. I don't drop my chiesels or plane irons that much if ever.
Enjoy, designing your new shop and building things.
I do knock stuff off the back of the bench because it can't go right up against the wall. either bring the wall out of put something soft back there. I have dropped things on the floor, but I haven't dropped anything recently. I had two sad Japanese plane blade stories early on in my career, maybe that inoculated me.
Concrete is really cold all year around, which is a mixed blessing. One thing I would do is get something to put under any machines you may have, if you do. They act as giant cooling fins and pull the cold up from the floor. If I had it all to do again, I would install radiant heat. The floor, and shop have never really been comfortable, and I have been there over 16 years. It always seems like it isn't worth the trouble going in, but I find I am always places at least 5 years. and generally a lot longer.
Ipe is typically harder than concrete, so it won't save your planes, or your feet.
Have you considered a moisture barrier between the oak (or more specifically, under the joists underlaying and supporting the oak) and the concrete? I guess you'd call them joists, even though they would by laying directly on the concrete?
If you are only getting one bay, you will probably need to put some of your machinery (assuming you don't have an apprentice for the grunt work) on mobile bases. I have tried to use rubber mats underfoot (They work much better than the bench dog ) around the bench, and other places where I tend to stand a lot, like the lathe. However, they don't work as well as I had hoped, since I find it inconvenient to have to move them to move the mobile machines. Mostly, they get tossed outside, or in a pile in a corner, and don't get put back underfoot, so a hardwood floor is a much better option.
I do knock stuff off the back of the bench because it can't go right up against the wall. either bring the wall out of put something soft back there. I have dropped things on the floor, but I haven't dropped anything recently. I had two sad Japanese plane blade stories early on in my career, maybe that inoculated me.
Concrete is really cold all year around, which is a mixed blessing. One thing I would do is get something to put under any machines you may have, if you do. They act as giant cooling fins and pull the cold up from the floor. If I had it all to do again, I would install radiant heat. The floor, and shop have never really been comfortable, and I have been there over 16 years. It always seems like it isn't worth the trouble going in, but I find I am always places at least 5 years. and generally a lot longer.
How long you planning to be there? I just did my shop and I will only be in it 3 years. Any longer than that and I would definitely put down thick visqueen, 1 x 3 "joists and I would probably use 3/4 inch plywood as floor. I use rubber mats in front of benches now.
Actually I have this stuff a friend gave me that is a roll up floor material that they use in tents, so that people walking around at a weeding in heels won't sink in. I am sceptical about using it on my floor only because I don't have enough of the stuff for it to cover the whole floor, so then I would have an up and down problem at the edges, but it is hard plastic, and creates an air space.
Unless you go south for the winter, or shut down winter work in the garage, you want winter warmth. Will be in super insulated boots and mittens otherwise.
Heat the space. Install 220V. Probably, a couple 20 amp. circuits, too. Drop the thickest hard insulation you dare to use over the concrete (new home should have vapor barrier under concrete). Over that lay 3/4" - 1" T&G plywood decking. Glue perimeter foot of insul./deck interface, and let the rest float. No high-heeled tool legs--use expanded bases. 50-gallon water tanks sit directly on 1" - 2" of rigid insulation. The decking will support your tools, benches.
2. You don't need a wood floor. I know a bunch of woodworkers who don't have wood floors in their shops in MN (you know a couple, Chuck B and me). OTOH, my shop is neither insulated nor heated. However, I also do know a couple woodworkers with heated/insulated shops, and they don't have wood floors, either.
3. Get some of the rubber mats that Bill T and Tom D describe and place them in front of your bench. I have them, and they work exceedingly well.
4. You'll be glad you don't have a wood floor when you need to store your snow blower in the garage/shop.
The house is in Woodbury (extreme opposite side of the twin cities from you). I'll have to weigh out all the flooring options. Cash flow is going to be a big part of what I can do at first anyway. Im trying to picture how the shop is going to look. Im pretty sure the unisaw is going to basically be an assembly table.
I just enclosed the 3rd car stall in my garage so I have a humidity controlled room. I'm glad I did this as it keeps my guitar woods in a very good range of humidity.
For the floor, I did the following:
1) Vapor barrier
2) 3/8" exterior grade plywood subsurface
3) The cheapest bamboo flooring I could find in quantities needed to fill the space.
Bamboo is excellent because it catches the chisel drop-to-death when it rolls off the bench. I don't do heavy planing in my small guitar shop which is good because the slick poly surface causes the bench to slide all over the place if I did. All the heavy planing is on the big cabinet bench that is outside this room (on concrete). But this small shop is now a great cozy place to work and I'm glad I did it.
I installed the 3/8 plywood at a diagonal so that wood movement on the bamboo would open/close the plywood joints along ways that would not be noticable from above. I just spot tacked the bamboo tongue and groove down to it in a few spots with some rubbery external grade glue. The bamboo flooring is glued to it's neighbor with yellow glue, but mostly just floats over the substrate.
I covered my concrete floor with 2"x 4'x8' foil backed roofing panels,laid down 4" strapping every 16" and screwed t&g 3/4" plywood to the strapping.This floor is as solid as any shop floor.---Jack
I agonized over the floor for a while when I recently built my shop. In the end, I ended up just sealing the cement floor and started adding foam mats in strategic places (Harbor Freight has some inexpensive sets).
While I like the look and feel of wood floors, I think I'm less likely to damage concrete and the tools seem to roll around better. I also had a couple inches of foam insulation placed under the floor before they poured it, which should help in the winter.