Re: Which blade is it? *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Wilbur and all,
I'm curious too. What's Tom got?
A note on Japanese saws. A couple years ago, I ordered a saw from Heiji. This particular saw, I ordered 295mm rip. Few days later, an inquiry came back from the vendor--do you want straight rip or a modified rip that will also cross-cut. I kinda had the feeling that Heiji wouldn't have asked if he didn't want to do the modified, so I took a chance on the modified.
This saw does crosscut and rip well, though not as well as a saw optimized for either one. Nevertheless, it does a creditable job, and I'm glad I have it. The question was, 'how is the filing arranged to enable the saw to do both?'
The best way to describe this saw's toothing is that it is modified crosscut, using the familiar Japanese pattern of an upright tooth with about zero rake, and having front fleam, back fleam, and a third 'over-the-top' facet (edome style). Three facets.
It appears to me from studying the teeth that the saw will rip (without wandering or making an ugly kerf) because of two things--the back fleam is considerably less than the front, and the third facet (over the top) further flattens the top profile of the tooth, when viewed straight down the saw blade. This flattening of the top profile gives the saw the ability to rip, and it is enabled by reduced back fleam and the angle of the top facet.
Modifications similar to this were practiced in the west, too, in the heyday of hand saws. Disston's 'Lumberman's Handbook' of 1907 contains a chapter on saw filing which is most readable and informative. The link below takes one to this chapter, which is found at the Disstonian Institute. In the discussion of crosscut filing, Disston shows the effect on the top profile of the tooth of having a smaller back fleam--top profile is flattened in Disston's drawing, as it must be. Disston states that this is the filing appropriate to a hardwood saw, whereas using the same fleam front and back is better for fast sawing in soft wood. Again, this is in the crosscut section. See discussion around Figures 10, 11, and 12.
If I am recalling correctly, only the 1907 edition of the Lumberman's Handbook has this text. It is not found in the reproduced 1921 edition, for example.
Wiley
Disston on Saw Filing (1907 Lumberman's Handbook)