New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

leveling the desk top

Posts

leveling the desk top

#1

leveling the desk top

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I could only find 4500K lamps for the new T5HO fixtures over the bench and they make pictures yellow. The wood is ash and it is really cream colored.

I got the ash border on the veneered field of the desk top's center. Now to level the border to the field. Ash is miserable to plane. Rarely does looking at the slope of the grain offer reliable guidance on what to expect. In this case there were areas of early wood that easily tore regardless of planing direction or cap iron setting, in addition to the more apparent small grain reversals among otherwise straight grained wood. The #5 was nearly useless, the high angle block plane was more useful but the scraper became the weapon of choice. I bought this thing years ago and never found any use for it before. It is slow but reliable.


We had some discussion on string border strategy. I decided to add the mitered frame and then pursue inlaying the string border. Good plan. As can be seen it was not possible, for me at least, to get a crisp joint against the veneered plywood center. Now I have one more opportunity to screw up the top- making the trough for the the string border that defines the frame from the center.

Re: leveling the desk top

#2

Re: leveling the desk top

Sgian Dubh

Did you try planing either directly across the grain Bill, or at least diagonally? As you say, ash is frequently contrary to plane with the grain, even if it's not rippled as yours is. I admit to being a fairly regular cross grain planer of ash followed by scraping and sanding.

The other technique I resort to is to forget all about that tedious and nit-picking hand planing, and just shove the blasted awkward and curmudgeonly panel through something like an oscillating thickness sander. Not very hand tooly orientated I know, but sometimes any port in a storm does it for me, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: leveling the desk top

#3

Re: leveling the desk top

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Did you try planing either directly across the grain Bill, or at least diagonally?" Yes and yes, for that is the only way I could plane at all!

"just shove the blasted awkward and curmudgeonly panel through something like an oscillating thickness sander. " I am not sufficiently experience with the one I recently came to own that I was willing to risk it given that diagonal planing followed by scraping was working....slowly, but reliably.

As more and more labor accumulates in some part like this the tolerance for risk goes way down and reliable become more important than quick.

Re: leveling the desk top

#4

Re: leveling the desk top

Tom

Beautiful!

Re: leveling the desk top

#5

4x24" belt sander

mark hennebury

I would suggest a belt sander , followed by block sanding.

I have a Makita 4" x 24" belt sander and it has served me well for probably more than 25 years.

You can get a pretty good surface if you finish with hand sanding with a flat block and various grits of sandpaper.

Re: leveling the desk top

#6

The 3x24" belt sander- most hazardous tool in the

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Early in my woodworking career I thought the 3 x 24 was the solution to leveling problems. I had more disasters with this machine than the sum of all others. A millisecond of lack of control and the piece is ruined. I do own one, a very good one-gear driven Porter Cable. And in special occasions I use it but vastly less as I have become more experieced at hand planing. But it, and all others, take a higher level of skill and experience to run and not wreck than any other tool I own. Maybe a 4 x 24 would be less risky.?.

The scraper isn't fast, but it won't screw up the top. And that's from a power tool enthusiast!

Re: leveling the desk top

#7

Re: The 2x24" belt sander- most hazardous tool in

Tom

I thought you might mean dangerous, which seemed a little overwraught. I did hurt myself once though. I was in another guys shop, and he had been running his sander when I came in and he must have unplugged it rather than switched it off, not sure how that works. Anyway he was across from me and plugged it back in, and it shot across the table, tore over my hand and centred me at speed.

I'm not sure which one I have I think a Makita 3x21, is that a real size? I've never wrecked anything, but it can go straight down, so one has to be careful, probably not as powerful as yours. Mine has a rear handle, and one has to lift up on that,not just pull back. I don't use it much, but there are situations where it is pretty good. The trick to use is the same as most sanders, learn first how to float it, which is to say have it on the material while running flat out, but hardly cutting. Then get it cutting.

Re: leveling the desk top

#8

"victory favors the bold"

mark hennebury

I would use my 4" x 24" i wouldn't use a narrower one, the 4" with gives you enough stablility.

It takes a bit of practice, but once you are used to it you will use it like a handplane, back and forth, side to side , diagonally, straight line, on a skew; keep it moving and change the direction to minimize and uneveness.

You develop a feel for the belt sander just the same as a plane , you have to feel the surface of your table.

Its fast and wont cause any tearout.

Leave yourself the flat block sanding to refine your surface.

Don't use a random orbit sander the bases are too soft and will not give you a flat surface .

Don't take a nap while sanding with a belt sander; it requires your full attention!

A few minutes of white knuckle sanding with the belt sander and your ready for handsanding with a block.

Piece of cake Bill,

C'mon get a 4' x 24" beltsander and do a bit of practice then give it a go.

Well worth the cost of the sander and the time spent learning.

It is a very useful tool; (and this from a Surpersurfacer and handplane guy)

Re: leveling the desk top

#9

caution will prevail (well, has at this point)...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As I get ever more labor invested in some part that shows I become very cautious. There will be no machine sanding on the top. I am not a stranger to the belt sander and I know how difficult it would be to level the 1 1/2" mitered frame from its position proud of the center field to bring it level with the center field. If I had more confidence with my fairly new drum sander that would be the choice. But machine sanders can made wood disappear in an instant and I don't want any disappearing from where it needs to remain.

Re: leveling the desk top

#10

plane sailing, steady as she goes

mark hennebury

The handplane is the most precise and controllable and probably the best bet then.

Good luck and keep us updated.

Re: leveling the desk top

#11

Re: leveling the desk top

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

"Did you try planing either directly across the grain Bill, or at least diagonally?" Yes and yes, for that is the only way I could plane at all!

Hi Bill

I have never used a belt sander, and would be too afraid to do so, having read about its pitfalls, aside from the obvious dust problem it creates and which I want to avoid.

In addition to traversing across the grain and scraping, both of which I do frequently to control interlocked grain, there is a third strategy that has worked for me. This is to use a toothed blade. There one for the LV and LN BU planes.

These blades are different from the toothed blade used for preparing veneered substratums. Instead, where large amounts of waste need to be removed, they can flatten a surface safely, preparing it for a scraper.

From the LV website:


And a video by LN on its use ...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gl8Tj1lUha4

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: leveling the desk top

#12

Re: leveling the desk top

Kees

You probably tried this allready, but how about the chipbreaker trick we discussed so much last year? I was haveing trouble with an ash table too, about two years ago. With tearout in unexpected spots all the time. I still have quite a few leftovers from that project and use the all the time for shopprojects. With the chipbreaker close to the edge I have no trouble with tearout anymore.

Re: leveling the desk top

#13

Re: leveling the desk top

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Thanks for tip.

The problem with ash is not interlocked grain. The curly stuff planes predictably. Rather, the spring wood tears easily in some places and ash is prone to have small areas of grain swirls embedded in otherwise straight sections. Each leads to surprises while removing shavings.

Ash typically power planes just fine except for the occasional embedded swirl that will pick out. Occasionally there will be a board that will pick out throughout.

Re: leveling the desk top

#14

Re: leveling the desk top

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I need to further explore the chip breaker. I had it set close but not extremely close. You know what I say...If Keys can plane ash I can :) Well, not so far.

Re: leveling the desk top

#15

Re: leveling the desk top

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is something not quite right with the plane, curly ash is not really difficult. However the problems could be pretty subtle, hard to discern from several states away.

Re: leveling the desk top

#16

the curl is not the problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The problem with ash is not interlocked grain. The curly stuff planes predictably. Rather, the spring wood tears easily in some places and ash is prone to have small areas of grain swirls embedded in otherwise straight sections. Each leads to surprises while removing shavings."

As reported above the curly part is not a problem and it planes predictably. However, it has already been smoothed before adding the frame.

The problem at hand is leveling the mitered border to the center field. The mitered frame is quarter sawed. Frequently I have problems planing domestic quarter sawed surfaces, surface planer or hand plane. Certain growth rings of the spring wood are prone to tearing unpredictably. These growth areas must be weaker toward the planing forces lifting the shaving.

Re: leveling the desk top

#17

Re: the curl is not the problem

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Many woods tear more easily on a quarter sawn surface because the wood splits easily on a radial plane.

Re: leveling the desk top

#18

Re: Dusty

Tom

Obviously they produce dust or they wouldn't work, but it is one of the less dusty sanders that actually gets anything done. And they are one of the earlier sanders with semi effective extraction on all models. I don't think they are difficult to use. It is sorta a 10 minute learning curve vs a ten year one for planes, though either is so easy when you know how. It falls on the production side of the ledger. So unless one needs to make money and has the shop to accommodate that, I rarely switch one on. It would be an outdoor tool for me. When would you use it? Well other than to make money, probably if there were nails in there, or other stuff that eats planes or metal to level with the work. That doesn't describe much of my stuff. Epoxy does though, and epoxy can be hand planed, depending.

Re: leveling the desk top

#19

Re: the curl is not the problem

Tom

I don't know what will work in this situation, but one option you have doubtless heard of, and that works in some situations is wetting the wood. It is more something I would do to make a final pass which isn't going to help you waste the wood up to that point. Another is to scrape that final pass.

One option getting to the point of a final pass is a trim router. Set a base on it with a groove to take the raised spline. Set a straight flute bit short of the surface. You can even use a fence in your application. Now you are planing side grain again.

Re: leveling the desk top

#20

Re: leveling the desk top

Kees

Yes you can! :)

I'm just a rookie.

Re: leveling the desk top

#21

If Keys can do it.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I must Mr Keys has been inspirational. I reset the blade tip to where it was just detectable past the cap iron, half to a third of its previous projection and less than I ever experimented with before. Damn, it was had to push, but it sliced over the problem grain areas with zero defects. I was beat by the time I finished and wishing I needed to sharped for a break part way through. Again, I am only planing the mitered border. (note the nice tight miters, a result of extreme(for me) patience in fitting. )

A test piece of string border is shown on the front edge. I am learning that if I think I need 1/4 I will in fact need 1/8. Actually I think 3/32 is going to look best. Some how it is wider on the piece than in my mind.

Re: leveling the desk top

#22

Will the real Bill Tindall please stand up

mark hennebury

You can't be the same guy that went through all of the exhaustive discussion on hand plane setup last year, and then posted this thread about grain tearout without having setup your handplane first?

please tell me its not you.

You already had the solution to this before posting.

I wouldn't for a moment have ever questioned your handplane setup.

I have to say Bill you caught me by surprise this time.

Re: leveling the desk top

#23

how close is close enough-very close apparently?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I keep one plane with the cap iron "close". For what it has encountered (walnut with average grain problems) it has been successful. This setting was not adequate for the greater challenge of ash.

The lesson learned here is that the benefit from the cap iron apparently increases significantly up to the point that one can just detect that the blade tip is extending beyond the cap iron edge. All I could see of the blade was a shiny line in bright light.

Later......I planed a near identical (taken from same board as used for frame) piece of ash with a plane set up with the cap iron 1/16" back from the blade tip. It ripped out impressive strings of wood fiber from the quarter grain leaving divots 1/32" deep or more. Resetting cap iron to a barely detectable extension beyond blade tip then resulted in a defect free surface once the divots were planed away.

Re: leveling the desk top

#24

Re: how close is close enough-very close apparentl

Kees

I love it when this happens. It's so predictable. Everytime someone tries out setting the chipbreaker closer then they ever would have thought neccessary, they are amazed at how good it works. :)

I set it now mostly not so close to the edge, because often you just don't need it. But sometimes I amaze myself with how effective the chipbreaker can be.

Re: leveling the desk top

#25

Re: how close is close enough-very close apparentl

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Perhaps you can start to see why I declined to give a distance for the cap iron last year. Not only is it difficult to measure, but the ideal distance "depends altogether on the nature of the stuff".