New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Chisel Handle Sizes

Posts

Chisel Handle Sizes

#1

Chisel Handle Sizes

CJ in MPLS

Over the years I've collected a number of socket chisels ranging from 1/8" to 2". They are all Zenith brand from Marshall Wells Hardware and the users I have I enjoy very much. It is time to put handles on the entire set and I envision something like the 750 style handles, though perhaps a bit longer.

In any case, the tenons on the end will be turned/shaped to fit the sockets, but does anyone have any suggestions on differently sized handles for the series? Perhaps a linear or Fibonacci series? I'll be making the handles from the same hard maple from which my bench is made.

Cheers,

CJ

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#2

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Not sure about you but I only have one size hand so I make all my chisel handles the same size. the design I use has a taper that meets the ferrule or socket and I can change that taper to suit the chisel without changing the overall size of the handle.

Robin

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#3

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

I've wondered the same. At one time all chisels were made with different sized handles to suit the size of the metal. There are so many variables to consider; handle design, hand size, chisel size, chisel use, etc. I don't think there are hard and fast rules that were traditionally followed. Lee Valley sells some nice boxwood handles in a London pattern. They are graduated in size and can perhaps suggest a place to start. In the end, I don't think you can get it wrong.


http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=30020&cat=1,41504,30020

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#4

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Over the years I've collected a number of socket chisels ranging from 1/8" to 2". They are all Zenith brand from Marshall Wells Hardware and the users I have I enjoy very much. It is time to put handles on the entire set and I envision something like the 750 style handles, though perhaps a bit longer.

In any case, the tenons on the end will be turned/shaped to fit the sockets, but does anyone have any suggestions on differently sized handles for the series? Perhaps a linear or Fibonacci series? I'll be making the handles from the same hard maple from which my bench is made.

Hi CJ

I searched ebay and came up with this picture of a Zenith chisel and handle ...


Based on this I doubt that you would like the standard Stanley/LN #750 handle as it looks shorter and more squat than this. Something slighty longer would be handles along the lines of the Blue Spruce and Veritas/LV.

Blue Spruce ..


Veritas and LN 750 ..


I had the same idea as you to built "longer" #750 handles. In She-oak ...


Some ideas.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#5

Interesting

CJ in MPLS

Derek:

I was looking at your site for some inspiration last night.

One of the Zenith chisels I have has the same rather chunky handle as appeared in your post. Two others have a 750 style handle that feels a bit too short and slim. The rest have nothing.

I'll post some examples I'm working up in scrap pine for all of you to comment on in the next day or two.

Cheers,

CJ

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#6

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Tom

I think all those chisel handles have bad ergonomics, though obviously this is determined by what the rational is. Back in the 70s when I was building a lot of fly rods, I came up with my own handle design. I was attracted to handles like those shown by Derek, which in the fly game are called half wells. Mainly I liked the aesthetic. I was at the time Reading Charles Ritz's biography (that Ritz,yes). He had his own grip which was an inverted carrot, the reason for that being that it fills the thumb index area more naturally, but his grip was straight tapered. I built a grip like that and really liked it, so I came up with my own design which combined the Ritz taper, the half wells contour, and a swell to incorporate the uplocking reel seat.

Anyway, on chisels. The handles shown are the poorly designed half wells, the Japanese handles (though oddly not their push chisels) are the ritz, and a hybrid does not seem to exist, though given all the options someone probably has it.

The design points are: Design the grip so it does not cramp the hand; so that pushing the chisel is will supported, and in that mode follows the contours of the hand; and so that hammering does not cause an energy transfer into the hand. (or however you wish based on real world factors and not just the fact that someone else has the design).

Another big design point is that while commercial sellers need to make sexy looking grips, and in particular, grips that feel good in the store, you don't have to follow that nonsense. This thing can be identified in many other products where the product is designed for a test drive, or a feel when taking it off the rack. Those are moments in time, but all important ones to retailers trying to make a sale. I'm not knocking it, they have to get those products in your hands long enough for you to buy them, but unfortunately what serves that purpose is not what serves the longer term purpose of making the tool work in use.

A couple of examples of that are the gear ratios on touring bicycles, almost everyone takes those bikes on a test drive where the bike is not loaded up with the backpacking gear it will carry on tour. So the ratios are set to make the bike drive fast. Same with the steering. But the bike will be terrible once the load is added.

Grips on bows are another chronic example, they have permanent, or interchangeable grips that are essentially impossible to shoot well, but they feel good to the newbie shooter who is taking the bow off the rack. A target bow that can't be shot well is a pretty serious flaw...

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#7

Re:Admission of failure

Tom

If you look at those handles they are an admission of failure. There is a shoulder ahead of the fingers to prevent the hand sliding up onto the blade (maybe there is even a lawyerly reason for that, like a guard). Or if you prefer to allow the forward edges of two fingers to transfer the hand's energy. But this is basically an admission that the hand is not stable, why does the whole grip not contain the hand. We are lucky in chiselling that the flow is mostly one way, we aren't sword fighting, we need a grip that isn't clunky, but allows the hand to transfer the body's energy to the tool.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#8

Re:Admission of failure

barryvabeach

CJ, I like larger handles than most manufacturers, and so I end up making my own. I tend to make the handles larger for chisels 1 inch and over. For chisels 3/4 or less, I usually make the handles the same size. I find the larger handle works well with 1 to 1 1/2 chisel - it just feels better to me.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#9

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

Bob Hackett

When making handles for tools the things I consider are 1-my hands, 2- the type of work being done.

Many of the factory handles are meant to sell tools to a wide variety of people and don`t come close to fitting my over large hands. Likewise a hooped handle for a chisel is made to be driven rather than pushed so a paring chisel will have a completely different handle than a chisel that I`m going to take a mallet to.

One of the things I like most about socket chisels is that it is so easy to change handles. A couple of taps on a piece of scrap sideways to the blade and you`re ready to change out the handle.

I pick impact resistant local wood with straight grain (usually riven) for my chisels that will be doing chopping work. I used pretty wood scaps regardless of grain direction for my paring handles. The paring handles are also much shorter and larger in diameter than most so they fill my palm and are easily pushed. I patterned many of my handles after things like shift knobs, the ends of tiller arms, walking sticks, etc that still felt comfortable in my hands after hours of use .

I also find that making the handles all slightly different (either different wood, different embellishments such as texturing the handle for better grip or slightly different variations on the same shape makes it much easier for me to pick up the one I really need without having to look at the blade.

I make sets of handles for other people. For myself I make what feels right at the time. When it stops feeling exactly right I can quickly change it out for a new one that feels better.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#10

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

CJ in MPLS

I'm not a great turner (haven't really turned much of anything in 25 years), but I'm having some fun with this project. The image below is of two original Zenith handles and two samples I've made so far.


The first handle (loose) was a bit too slender at its waist and the small stop section adjacent the socket of the chisel is the wrong angle, i.e. it doesn't reflect the angle of the socket itself. On the second sample handle (on the chisel) I've had the same problem with the stop portion, but the proportions seem to be better. The overall size is a bit too large though (please disregard the fact that I've not yet cut off the waste at the top of the handle). It fits my hand quite well, but then so does the handle of a baseball bat. My hands are large, but this might be a bit too much. I'm going to work the next sample back towards the size of the original handles to see what that looks like.

Cheers,

CJ

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#11

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think all those chisel handles have bad ergonomics, though obviously this is determined by what the rational is. Back in the 70s when I was building a lot of fly rods, I came up with my own handle design. I was attracted to handles like those shown by Derek, which in the fly game are called half wells. Mainly I liked the aesthetic. I was at the time Reading Charles Ritz's biography (that Ritz,yes). He had his own grip which was an inverted carrot, the reason for that being that it fills the thumb index area more naturally, but his grip was straight tapered. I built a grip like that and really liked it, so I came up with my own design which combined the Ritz taper, the half wells contour, and a swell to incorporate the uplocking reel seat.

Anyway, on chisels. The handles shown are the poorly designed half wells, the Japanese handles (though oddly not their push chisels) are the ritz, and a hybrid does not seem to exist, though given all the options someone probably has it.

The design points are: Design the grip so it does not cramp the hand; so that pushing the chisel is will supported, and in that mode follows the contours of the hand; and so that hammering does not cause an energy transfer into the hand. (or however you wish based on real world factors and not just the fact that someone else has the design).

Hi Tom

I Googled and found a Charles of the Ritz chisel handle. I must argue that it does not look very comfortable, and indeed a little fragile ..


The topic of chisel handle ergonomics could probably fill a few books. It certainly would make a great discussion, if not because all here have used a chisel, have a favourite one, and can pass an opinion.

Let's say that we want to design a handle for someone that experiences difficulty with hand strength. The tasks they want to use it for include dovetailing and general bench work. What would you advise?

In a case such as this I would immediately recommend a Japanese dovetail chisel, such as the Koyamaichi ...


These are fairly short chisels with short blades and handles.

Here is one alongside a standard Stanley (=LN) #750 and another long-handled version ..


The advantage of the Koyamaichi is that it does not require hand strength at all for tasks where it may be tapped with a gennou. The gennou imparts control and downforce.

That short handle on the 750 should work in the same way.

By contrast, I would not enjoy either of these chisels for paring work. While they facilitate pushing with the heel of the hand - and in the case of the 750, that finger grip offers additional leverage - their short length makes it harder to judge angles.

For paring work I prefer a longer chisel. This is the reason for the extended 750 handle - and that is my hybrid handle for paring and hammer work. What is interesting for me is that the Veritas handle is very similar (if you include the ferrule), both in length and girth.

Veritas and LN, again ...


Does it matter whether the extension is in the handle or the blade?


My preference is for a longer handle, as in the Japanese slick here. I just feel that I am working closer, and this creates more feedback. Is this the same for you? What is your preference?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#12

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

Patrick Gibbons

Many chisel handles made up to about 1830 or so were octagonal in shape and tapering towards the blade. I made such a handle for a shaving brush of all things. Every morning I'm reminded how comfortable it is to hold and to orient without looking. I remember using Adam Cherubini's chisels to make a practice dovetail at a Woodworking in America conference. They were handled in this same way and were quite comfortable. I've always found Marples blue chip chisels to have a good handle that holds up well for long use. Registered mortise chisel handles feel great in the hand but would be greatly improved with a rounded butt. I own some Ashley Isles chisels that had the larger handles. I cut off the back third of these and this improved balance on sizes 3/4" and smaller. The thicker girth of these handles feels great. I have a Defiance chisel (Stanley's lower-priced option) with a larger 750-style handle. It's a good handle. The typical 750-style handle one finds on a LN chisel is fine for balance if one holds the blade but isn't very good for how I use a chisel 90% of the time. It seems that a lot of shapes work. It's the shapes that don't work that tell me more about what makes a good handle.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#13

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Tom

I would choose the Japanese ones myself. The push and they hit very well. I am a little surprised at their paring chisel handles and the only thing that makes sense is either balance or the need to push hard on the pommel, but they work great, and are even copied over here.

When one talks about people with hand problems, I have spent my whole life with a lot of older people and have some idea of their problems. I grew up around WWI vets some of whom were woodworkers, and one who was a fantastic machinist (never saw him work). I also sold lawn bowling gear to the aged, at one point, which was eye opening.

At 54 a week from today, I am starting to get pretty creaky myself. But not to any critical degree. So far I am still falling back on sharp edges, proper holding (no pinching), and hammer that baby. But if people have advanced arthritis or leprosy (I guess) the requirements get really specific.

Here is AP as a youth, gotta be easier to hold your chisel like this when you are backed into the "O" lawn bowls, with hands like claws.


Here is a Ritz Grip for a flyrod:


If this were a chisel, the edge would be to the left.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#14

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

The "inverted carrot", as you referred to it earlier, is an interesting handle ..


I have reservations about Alan Peter, in the picture below, using it, at least in the way you may envisage ..


First off note that Alan is using a palmar grip to essentially balance and control the chisel. The downforce comes via the mallet blows.

I have built a few handles with this "inverted carrot" as well ..


This is a heavy duty marking knife I made a few years ago, for example, when marking deep lines for tenon shoulders. The ergonomics of the handle force one to direct the energy downward, with the handle held in the horizontal or diagonal, using the thumb on top. This grip seems to maximise thumb strength.

For interest, the opposite of this may be using a marking knife for detail, such as dovetails, where the line is shallow. Here the grip you want is like a pencil. The handle I came up with is another carrot, but it runs the other way so as to mould into the correct dynamic tripod pencil grip ...



Back now to the inverted carrot grip for a chisel: while I think it works for a levering action, I just do not see how it can work for paring, that is, when pushing forward towards a bevel edge. What is to stop the hand sliding down onto the blade the way Alan is working? That is why there is usually a rest/stop for a finger (which you referred to as "an admission of failure"), or palm, as in Alan's case. Even the straight handles of a Japanese slick off more support for a non-slip grip.

Your thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#15

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Old Baleine

Very astute, Derek.

In fact, when fishing a fly rod, the position of the thumb is analogous to that the forefinger when using most hand tools: it points the way. The thumb is generally placed on top of the grip, and at the conclusion of the forward cast, one uses the thumb in conjunction with a snap of the wrist to apply a downward force that drives the fly line forward.

It was a delight to read your analysis of the inverted carrot design. It seems to me you really "pegged it".

While I don't expend much effort thinking about ergonomics, I have not been very enthusiastic about LV's plane totes. However, the first time I picked up my LV-PMV chisels, the unarticulated neural spark that flashed across the blank space between my ears said, "This fits my hand as if it were made for me," and the words that eventually came to mind were "modern classic."

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#16

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

While I don't expend much effort thinking about ergonomics, I have not been very enthusiastic about LV's plane totes. However, the first time I picked up my LV-PMV chisels, the unarticulated neural spark that flashed across the blank space between my ears said, "This fits my hand as if it were made for me," and the words that eventually came to mind were "modern classic."

Thanks OB

I agree with your opinion about the LV chisel handles, but then it is hard not to be biased in this regard. I was involved from the outset in testing the chisel steels for consideration, and then the chisel handle shape. My bias comes not simply from the fact that I was so involved, but especially from the eerie experience in discovering that these handles ended up so very close in shape and length to the ones I had made for my Stanley 750s. I had one criticism of the prototype handles, and this was that they had a significant flat on each side, and that these tended to dictate how one held the handle. In the production chisels this was reduced considerably, to the extent that they no longer dominated but just lent a subtle influence. Later, when the PM-V11 versions came out, Rob Lee recalled my preference, and had a set of chisels made for me without any flats at all (they are the only set like this). I think that these are just wonderful.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#17

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Darren Brewster

"Back now to the inverted carrot grip for a chisel: while I think it works for a levering action, I just do not see how it can work for paring, that is, when pushing forward towards a bevel edge. What is to stop the hand sliding down onto the blade the way Alan is working?"

I'm pretty sure you are imagining the handle the opposite the way Tom explained it. It gets thicker towards the blade, no? He said the edge would be to the left of the fly rod.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#18

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm pretty sure you are imagining the handle the opposite the way Tom explained it. It gets thicker towards the blade, no? He said the edge would be to the left of the fly rod.

Quite possible. Tom referred to an "inverted carrot", which to me suggests that the thin end is at the top.

Where are you, Tom?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#19

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes - Ritzy

Tom

Yeah Darren nailed it. I guess I wasn't clear.


Bugs is holding the carrot in the normal eating position, the edge is where the carrot greens are. The result is that when one pushes there is plenty of support. In the picture though, Bugs has it in the hammering position, the advantage there is that the handle when hit with the hammer is not easily retained by the hand, and that reduces fatigue from the hammer. The hand guides and presses down, which plays well with the carrot grip.

Fly rods are not manipulated in a similar way to chisels, but some of the ergonomics are still there. The Ritz grip is not that well known (maybe this has changed with Google), but it does capture some of the lessons of good handle design, including the fact that what looks good to the eye is often not that good in use.

The carrot grip is good for chisel pinching also, as it keeps the weight toward the edge, which reduces fatigue.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#20

Re: Knife fighting

Tom

With knives the two most common grips are sabre and reverse. The former is the thumb on top edge to the enemy, and the latter is the point emerging from the weak end of the hand. These are roughly the single handed paring, and the hammering grips. There is probably a slight bias towards ritzieness in these handles. That is to say the thickest part of the grip being between the thumb and the index finger. But there are lots of designs. And knives tend to have very well defined flats for what that is worth. The image of sabre and reverse grips might be helpful in describing the different chisel gripping positions.

Re: Chisel Handle Sizes

#22

Re: "You call that a knife?"

Tom

I figured there had to be a few small ones in Australia....