New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Posts

Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#1

Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Tony Wilkins

I'm going to add a Plough Plane and a Moving Fillister plane in the future as I can afford. So far I've been using all wooden planes and like them more than the vintage metal planes I've tried. That said, I really like the look of the Veritas versions of both these planes. Wooden ploughs are hard to find and usually expensive for vintage that might have enough original blades. This is less so for moving fillisters.

So, input appreciated...

TIA, Tony

PS. asking this on SMC as well.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#2

One thing about LV....

roger lance

Soon....very soon.....there could be a period of free shipping

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#3

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

I have a wooden plough, and it does the job superbly. I also have the LV Small Plow, and it does just as good a job, just differently.

I built a bridle plough because I fancied one. It feels like a tank mowing its way through any obstacle. Get a head of steam up, and nothing stands in its way ..


The LV Small Plow is like a sports car - fast, nimble and light. It is capable of precision. Just a wonderful, versatile plane.

Recently, LV brought out a set of wider blades and blades for T&G, and these do work well - not a substitute for a fillister, but I have used them for rebating. http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/AccessoryBladesfortheVeritasSmallPlow.html

The one modification (if you can call it that) is to add a deep sub-fence. This makes maintaining vertical very easy.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#4

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Tom

Keeping in mind that the bridle plough that won the contest here, a superb plane, was built by a youth who had not made one before, my vote is to build them in wood as you need them. Standard molding type planes can be built if you have an equipped shop, in about 45 minute. I haven't built a plane with a fence yet, but it doesn't look any more complicated than a marking gage slapped on the side of a molding plane.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#5

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Keeping in mind that the bridle plough that won the contest here, a superb plane, was built by a youth who had not made one before, my vote is to build them in wood as you need them. Standard molding type planes can be built if you have an equipped shop, in about 45 minute. I haven't built a plane with a fence yet, but it doesn't look any more complicated than a marking gage slapped on the side of a molding plane.


Hi Tom

Kyle did an amazing job on this plane. The fact that he was still in high school makes it even more amazing. It just goes to demonstrate how talented he was/is. This is an extremely difficult plane to build. It is a little more complicated than "a marking gauge slapped on the side of a molding plane". :D It was the most complex plane I have built to date.

Build pictorial: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/BridlePloughBuild.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#6

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Patrick Gibbons

I can't speak to wooden plows but I have owned a Stanley 45 (briefly), a Stanley combo plane made in the 1990's (which I still own), and the Veritas small plow. I owned a Record fillester and now own the Veritas fillester. In both cases the Veritas product was better made, more precise, and the design was thought through to correct problem areas of older tools. What I have read most from those who prefer wooden versions is that the wooden tool works better than the metal version. I'm not sure how and wonder if it is more a case of what one is used to. Wood or metal, both of these tools require technique to get good results. I've been well pleased with the precision of my Veritas planes and recommend them without exception.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#7

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Tony Wilkins

Remember that build Derek. I'd love to have the skill to do that (see colourful plan on SMC). Think the LV is my plan for now. With my nerves rotting away, lighter is better for me. Think I'm going with an LV large shoulder plane as well for working on this project.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#8

Re: One thing about LV....

Tony Wilkins

Roger, when will this period be?

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#9

Re: One thing about LV....

roger lance

Tony....only the benevolent gods of the great north land know for sure....but maybe....just maybe....this month.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#10

Re: One thing about LV....

roger lance

I also speculate on horse races and make stock picks....but I wouldn't want to admit to my batting average in either.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#11

@Rob, Nudge, Nudge!

Tony Wilkins

Ya know, Father's day might provide a good excuse to give free shipping. Maybe 10% of all planes ;)

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#12

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

Tom

Yeah, I was not talking about that plane, Derek, I simply said that adding a fence to a plane should not be any more complicated than a marking gage, and simple planes like rebates can be made in minutes, but more complex ones involving milling skates, or complex cutter shapes might add some time to the project. :)

One of the most adjustable beams in my shop is the Japanese marking gage with metal adjustment hardware. This is a set-up that easily adjusts to very fine increments, sometime more readily than gizmos with adjusters built in. They have an ideal amount of sticktion.

Punch two mortices into the plane body, make two beams that have one rounded edge, glue these in, make a fence by starting the mortices with a drill to match the rounded edges, install screws and captured nut and pressure pads, done. Of course far more elaborate solutions are possible if one wants to make a career of it. I would prefer something as described to the metal version that have been sold over the years.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#13

Strong bias for wood

Ron Harper

Really cannot say why. Just me.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#14

Re: let me just tell you then

Tom

"What I have read most from those who prefer wooden versions is that the wooden tool works better than the metal version. I'm not sure how and wonder if it is more a case of what one is used to."

I own the Stanley it is based on mechanical systems that takes backlash to a whole new level. And is made with the the general machining excellence I associate with their products of the period, yet chromed so you can't easily do much about it.

But in general I see your point. One thing that is missing from the usual bun fight on this subject is that they both ride on metal, so you don't get the performance improvements normally associated with having a wood plane. You do get the normal performance improvements from a wedged adjuster, antique blades, warm handles, a real place to put the second hand. The right sticktion for adjustments, the lack of rust, etc...

If the planes are of modern manufacture, then the "performance improvements" probably are just that the maker had to produce a plane that performed better. Like a Hotley doesn't perform better because it is made of metal, but because it is made to a higher standard.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#15

Re: Strong bias for wood

Tony Wilkins

For me it was recommended to try a wooden plane because of the strength deficit due to my injury. So the first plane I tried was an Old Street. Was hooked from there. Of course my only metal experience is a #5 from a company I can't recall just now. It was restored but the post office did a number on it. I haven't had the pleasure of a modern LV or LN.

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#16

It's all about the fence.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What has not been mentioned enough is the fence, and in particular the accuracy of adjusting the fence.

The reason why I built a bridle style wooden plough - rather than, for example, a wedged arm fence - was the search for accuracy. Indeed, this has been the pot of gold for plough plane makers over the centuries. Every wooden plough design - bar a few - suffer from difficulties in keeping the fence parallel to the body and blade. The bridle system is one of the few that works.

Metal ploughs rarely experience this issue. The LV Small plough adjusts easily and accurately.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#17

Re: It's all about the fence.

Tom

Yeah, but it is also all about making the thing fancy. There are simple solution that work better than complex ones. I agree that wedged beams haven't worked... for me. But there are simple solutions that work better. The wedged blade in a Japanese plane being one. People (particularly those who have tried the different options out) can disagree over what system is "best", but it isn't as though the wedged blade doesn't work at the highest level. Fences are not terribly complex to do, and the Biesmeyer fence is a lot simpler than the excaliber, and works pretty much as well. But there are systems that people feel like throwing a ton of ebony, ivory, and brass at, and others they don't. Apparently back when thumb screws were state of the art, they were regarded as scary new tech, like drones today. Because the machined screws were thought of very high tech. Maybe this was also true of the planes that used screws. It may have pleased them to take it that far, but it wasn't necessary.

This isn't how I would do it, but it works, I have a few planes like this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8uLSpEybC4

Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#18

Re: This one really is like a marking gage

Tom


Having the wedge in the middle is a neat tactic.


Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#19

Old Street will spoil you


Re: Fillister and Plough in Veritas or Wood?

#20

Well it did happen this month....just....

roger lance

want to hear any stock picks??.... :D .... :(