New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Mortise chisel recommendation

Posts

Mortise chisel recommendation

#1

Mortise chisel recommendation

Tony Wilkins

My next project (small shaker table) needs a 1/4" mortise chisel. I had planned to get one of the Ray Iles pig stickers, but they seem to always be out of stock. I've thought about Japanese chisels off and on but I'd like to stay all imperial in sizes. Not sure about the steel or my 'restoration skills' with a vintage. So far as I know that leaves me with Lie-nielsen.

It was suggested over on SMC that I could do mortises with out a mortise chisel and that would be ok with me.

Help me think this out more.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#2

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

Tony Wilkins

The only other tool that was used that I don't have a reasonable facsimile for is a shoulder plane. BTW, the project is the shaker table from Christopher Schwarz' new DVD.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#3

Might be of interest.

John Pappas

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_NXq7_TILA

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#4

I might add

John Pappas

A 1/4 inch Buck Bros chisel from Home Depot does not have beveled sides....much like a mortise chisel. And it will surprise you how well the edge holds up if ground to 30 degrees.

I expect to catch some flack here....but that's ok. lol

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#5

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

john sayles

That famous auction site is always loaded with mortise chisels; makers like Ward, Marples, Butcher, Greaves, Cam and Moulson to name just a few. These are some of the "safer" things to buy via auction -- few moving parts.

With the exception of Ray Iles (I love mine) "they (literally) don't make 'em like that anymore."

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#6

Trivial to make a sticker

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Go to a machine shop supply (MSC, Travers, etc.) and pick up a 1/4" cut off tool in an 8" length. It will already be heat treated to some acceptable degree. Grind a tapering point and mount with epoxy in a clam shell" handle.

The two cherries have good steel but I dislike huge handles. I sawed the sides of the handle to render it oval and that was better.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#7

clear choice there

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The LN is an ergonomic disaster. The LV corrected this shortcoming. As little hand tool work that I do I use my shoulder plane surprisingly frequently, even, rarely, for shoulders.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#8

Re: Might be of interest.

Tony Wilkins

Thanks for the link to the Paul Sellers video. So it definitely can be done. Probably go this route until at least I know enough to know which direction I prefer.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

same here

Jack Guzman from Maine

I would recommend holding out for the 1/4" ray iles. It's a nice chisel.Otherwise the bay has old chisels of that style cheap and frequent. I have a 1/4" and 5/16" ray iles. The rest of my mortise chisels are various makers all bought as antique/collectables.---Jack

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#10

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Tony, I recommend getting one of the Narex mortise chisels from Highland Woodworking or Lee Valley. They cost about $13. This will easily get you through the project at hand and you will soon know a lot more about mortising. Antique mortise chisels are rough on those learning to mortise because if there are problems it is hard to sort out if it is you or the chisel. Once you have some success and experience you will be in a much better position to evaluate or work with an old tool or to decide to buy a premium chisel or set.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#11

Making your own sash mortice chisel ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill is correct - it is a simple matter to make a mortice chisel, although I would redefine this to refer to sash mortice chisels, which are lighter versions. Think LN mortice chisels versus Ray Isles.

I have a bunch of vintage oval bolstered mortice chisels (such as Ward) that I rehandled. These have nearly full length steel, and I think they were a steal, even though they came from eBay as they did over the years. If you look out for the ones with bust handles - that no one else wants - you can do very well. I also have two Ray Isles and, frankly, although the edge does last longer, there is no big advantage over the vintage ones unless you are chopping a lot of mortices.

Anyway, I wanted something smaller for delicate work, a mortice chisel with a shorter and lighter blade, and decided to make my own. For this I used tempered HSS, which is very cheap. The advantage of HSS is that you can grind it without fearing it burning and losing its temper.

These two are 1/4" and 5/16". The blades are 2 3/4" long ....


The pictorial is here:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/SquaringChisels.html

They work very well, and for shallower mortices the parallel sides are not a disadvantage (the vintage oval bolstered versions are tapered).

The other alternative is the Narex from Lee Valley, which I have seen but not used. They are cheap but I have heard good reports.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#12

Re: Making your own sash mortice chisel ...

Tom

It is a simple mater, but I bought a handful of Pig Stickers (a previous must have source of enormous general interest) for about the price of the raw metal. It was just a mater of walking the tools of the trade show and picking them up, no special skills required. While it is true that it is easy, and in some cases (plane blades) dramatically cheap to make your own, there are many cases were historic tools are selling for less than scrap prices, let alone what it costs to run paper and gas. I'm in Canada, we have nothing like the US market for second hand tools, last I checked, my pal down there always gets better deals. Most machine shops are going to need a solid reason to even let you through the door, and by the time you put in lost wages and gas (retired for 15 years in my case so less of a problem), and what steel actually costs, it isn't that great a deal. Or really I guess what I am saying is everyone's mileage varies.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#13

Re: Making your own sash mortice chisel ... *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

A Narex 1/4" mortise chisel from Lee Valley is an exact imperial 1/4" and only $12.90. I couldn't make it that cheaply. I haven't used one but have heard good things from people whose opinion I respect. It's inexpensive enough to try it and see and not sweat the consequences. Mortising with a bench chisel is easily done. A mortise chisel has been faster for me but I've done it with a Marples with no problem.


http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=66737&cat=1,41504

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#14

additional details on the "make your own"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

From the picture it appears you used square section metal lathe tool bits for the chisels. BTW, these make dandy wood lathe tools too. If a rectangular cross section mortise chisel is desired then buy "cut-off" bits. 1/4" is a common size. Larger(thicker) isn't.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#16

I am with Warren


Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#17

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Agree, and for the reasons Warren has given. Lee Valley sells the Imperial sizes. They're relieved in the depth which is a good feature.

Yes, you can mortise with any chisel. When I only had Japanese dovetail chisels, I used them. But I'd rather not. My hat is off to Paul Sellers, but his decades of experience are making it look easier than it really is (when you're starting out) to keep the mortise straight with a bench chisel. For $13 + shipping, you can test the Narex against what you already have, and decide for yourself.

Wiley

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#18

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

Tony Wilkins

Found where my chisels were packed when we moved - there's just two of them a 6mm Massahige oire-nomi and a 3/4" Blue Spruce. Over on SMC, I mentioned how the nomi wasn't comfortable and Derek mentioned that a correctly tuned one should be. I looked at the job I did preparing it and you could tell I was sick :/ I'm going to give it another go and see how it works out this time.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#19

Re: Making your own sash mortice chisel ...

Tom

And then there is Jim Cummings video in which he shows how to harden the cheapos so they are Blue Spruces, Barrs, or LVs, and they didn't cost anything to get there. Most cheap chisels are soft by design, they can easily be made better. I gather Jim was a part of this site, maybe some of his work is on here?

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#20

D2 steel in Ray Iles pig sticker

Tony Wilkins

Probably won't get on immediately but I just noticed that the Ray Iles mortise chisels are made out of D2 steel. Will that present a problem sharpening? Especially since I use King (1000) and Hida (6000) water stones? Just how much of a bear is it to sharpen these?

Bonus question: I've read they are pretty hefty; is that a bad thing or a good thing for someone with strength impaired hands?

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#21

Re: D2 steel in Ray Iles pig sticker

Bruce McCrory

If you are like me, it will simply fall out of your hand sooner than a lighter one. :\

I think more mass is no advantage in this case. A twenty-eight-ounce hammer moves bigger nails faster, but I need an iron constitution for when it slides from my grip; and, sturdy shoes.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#22

Re: D2 steel in Ray Iles pig sticker

Patrick Gibbons

Tony, I have a Ray Iles mortise chisel and find it sharpens about like A2. I don't use the same medium you do but think your experience would be comparable.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#23

Re: D2 steel in Ray Iles pig sticker

david weaver

The RI chisels are no problem to sharpen on decent waterstones.

The bigger chisels are more massive, but the small ones (like the 1/4" and 5/16") are not that bulky like some of the older pigstickers you'll find, and the business end of them is delicate enough that you can cut cabinet mortises without half of the chisel taking up a mortise.

Either the 1/4" or 5/16" chisel would be nice to have.

If you're averse to narex and you want a quick fix, there is a sheffield sash mortise chisel on ebay - 1/4", branded "woodworker supply" for $15 shipped. \

I've been through a fair number of mortise chisels, old and new, and the RI chisels are the best mortise chisels I've used, maybe tied with the little miyanaga japanese mortise chisels (but those are expensive if you don't find someone unloading used ones, as i did). The LN chisels hold an edge a long time, but I didn't find as much favor with them in use (they were still good, though).

The rest of the stuff that's a quarter of the cost of the LN's and RIs would be fine, you'll just be sharpening more, but it won't be a big deal if you're not trying to mortise ebony.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#24

Re: D2 steel in Ray Iles pig sticker

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Controlling and pounding a mortise chisel will require more hand strength than lifting it so the chisel weight will not be a limiting factor. The mallet gets lifted and driven; the chisel doesn't.

D2 will be highly abrasion resistant, not an important attribute for a mortise chisel. Makes no sense to me to make a mortise chisel from D2.

A mortise chisel does not have to have a highly refined edge. After all it is being driven into the wood with a mallet. Grind it, touch up with oil stone or equivalent and go to work.

Re: Mortise chisel recommendation

#25

Re: Academic and reality don't line up..

david weaver

... the RI mortise chisel I have holds its edge much longer than the carbon steel mortise chisels I have, and if you choose to abuse it, it takes nearly no damage in situations where you're sure it would.

mortises in cabinet work are not an act of bludgeoning, so a sharp mortise chisel is still far better than one that's dull.

How do I know that the RI chisel holds its edge better? I can keep it in shape indefinitely just with a half dozen swipes on a polishing stone between mortises in hardwood.

This is one case where hypothesizing about the properties of a certain type of steel falls way short of the only test that really counts - how well the tool works when you use it to make stuff.