Frame saw and Turbo Cut
Joe shelton
Anyone use frame saws successfully? And does anyone use the Turbo Cut blades with Japanese style teeth?
Thanks
Joe
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Frame saw and Turbo Cut
Joe shelton
Anyone use frame saws successfully? And does anyone use the Turbo Cut blades with Japanese style teeth?
Thanks
Joe
Frank Klausz likes them
Re: Frame saw and Turbo Cut
Tom
I've had those since they came out. I have always thought that there ought to be a japanese pattern blade for a bowsaw, and tried to get LV interested though I didn't expect much since some of their earlier offerings seemed to sit in the remainders bin a long time.
The turbo cut blades are good for what they are, an aggressive pattern softwood crosscut saw. I don't have much use for that, and at the same time there was a reduction in availability of some of the traditional blades that had served well for a long time. This may have just been stocking choices of retailers.
What I would have liked to have seen was very thin blades for small saws around 14 thou Blades like that can be made very cheaply and they will cut joinery nicely, and they don't need all the hand finishing of Japanese saws, because they are under tension. They can be made out of feller gage stock.
I didn't read what FK said about them, I don't know what his experience with Japanese tools is though he gets around a lot and tries lots of stuff at trade shows.
Re: Frame saw and Turbo Cut
Tom
By the way, and admirable thing FK has said he does is adopt tools that are more in line with what his students use. It can be exasperating to see some guy who uses a bunch of unobtaniam execute joinery like a master. FK's approach takes out the all too common supposition that the oddball tools are the reason for his success. But at the end of the day, i don't really know what his choices mean, other than that he can do his routines with anything he chooses in his hand.
Thanks, James and Tom...
Joe shelton
I went and found articles by Frank Klaus and Mike Dunbar that make the bow saw, as a type, sound useful. Frank also endorsed the turbo cut blade enthusiastically. I'm going to try them.
I appreciate your help.
Joe
Re: Thanks, James and Tom...
Tom
Bow saws are great, the german ones have a 6 point rip saw blade which is one of the most useful types, I would try that. The thing about BSs is that the blades are pretty reasonable, so why not try them you aren't dropping 300.
I spoke too soon! 160, not worth it, but by all means try one if it speaks to you. This is the pro choice, if you ask me:
http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/continentalframesawripjoineryblade.aspx
http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/ece-700mm-frame-saw.aspx
Out the door for less than 80, two blades, and there are at least three biggish name, Frid, Klaus, and Guidice, smiling at you. One of these guys, can't remember who, is in favour of using the rip blades for both crosscut and ripping/joinery. And you can reasonably sharpen your own rip blades, while few are the people taking on sharpening the Japanese blades, and less still the induction hardened ones.
I think I bought them here, which worked out for me since the postage is expensive to Canada either way, might not work for you...
http://www.mehr-als-werkzeug.de/category/Gestell--und-Fuchsschwanz-Saegen-3546_3551.htm
Re: Do turbo cuts rip well?
david weaver
Do the turbo cut blades rip well?
Of the various japanese tooth profiled saws that I have, some claim the ability to rip and crosscut well, but in reality, they only crosscut well. It's not hard to look at traditional japanese tools and see that when they wanted to rip, they just used rip teeth.
I'd be wary of the turbocut blades if you want to rip, as a pure rip blade would work very well and be about a sixth of the cost.
I'll admit that for crosscutting, I haven't filed a saw yet that will hang with impulse hardened japanese style teeth. Even the cheap 20 inch plastic handled stanley saw at HD for $11 crosscuts rough stuff at warp speed, though none of the western impulse hardened saws I've seen so far are easy enough on the back side of the cut to make a finish cut.
If you're looking for any of the saws to make long rips, then get a rip dedicated saw for that. The ECE frame saw works fine (and is inexpensive at thebestthings.com), but it'll be easier to steer if the back riser or whatever it's called) is extended to make a long handle. I think Mike Dunbar's saw is that way. If you don't do that, you'll end up with a single extremely tired arm.
In the long run, for straight cuts - especially rips, I didn't find it as convenient as various cutting positions with a western saw
Re: Do turbo cuts rip well?
Winton Applegate
My comment is a little off the topic but figurred I would ask to see what the cool guys (and gals) think.
I've read a lot, some say toooo much, and worked wood a fair amount but I say not enough and anyway . . .
I have read that Tage Frid didn't bother with cross cut saws and just knifed the line and cross cut with a regular filed rip saw. I like the idea of that.
I have no problems filing saws; I'm a metal worker first and a woodworker second so can't remember when I didn't have a metal file in my hand. Was doing all sorts of scary stuff to my bicycle when I was six or so.
Personally , in actual practice, I like cross cut saws, Japanese and Western but figuuured I would ask any way : any body out there doing it the Tage Frid rip only way ?
Re: Do turbo cuts rip well?
William Duffield
That's the way it's done at the Hay Cabinet Shop in Colonial Williamsburg (where they are interpreting mid-Eighteenth Century practice to the best of their knowledge). Their reproduction saws are all filed rip, because they have not been able to find any evidence that any Eighteenth Century saws used in the colonies for cabinetmaking, instrument making, joinery, etc., were ever filed crosscut. My copy of "The Tool Chest of Benjamin Seaton" is not at hand right now, so I cannot verify my recollection, but I believe it indicates that all the saws in the chest (late Eighteenth Century, made by the Englishman John Kenyon) were also filed rip, or at least there is no indication that any of them were filed crosscut.
Re: Do turbo cuts rip well?
Winton Applegate
Ohhhhhhh Aaaaaaauh
I'm getting it now. Thanks. Always some thing new for me to learn.